िनबंधन सं या पी0ट0-40
बहार गजट
बहार गजट
बहार गजट
बहार गजट
असाधारण अंक
असाधारण अंक
असाधारण अंक
असाधारण अंक
बहार सरकार ारा ूकािशत
बहार सरकार ारा ूकािशत
बहार सरकार ारा ूकािशत
बहार सरकार ारा ूकािशत
26
26
26
26 फा! गु
फा! गु
फा! गु
फा! गुन 1931
1931
1931
1931 (श0)
(सं
सं
सं
सं0 पटना
टना
टना
टना 181
181
181
181)
)
)
)
पटना
टना
टना
टना,
,
,
, बुध
बुध
बुध
बुधवार
वार
वार
वार, 17 माच.
माच.
माच.
माच. 20
20
20
2010
10
10
10
la‚&,e-4&20@2007&1459fo0¼2½]
———
foÙk foHkkx
ladYi
11 Qjojh 2010
fo"k;%& tu&futh Hkkxhnkjh ¼Public Private Partnership½ ds ek/;e ls vk/kkjHkwr lajpuk ifj;kstukvksa
gsrq izLrko rS;kj djus ds fy, leO;ogkj lykgdkj ¼Transaction Advisor½ dh fu;qfDr A
tu futh Hkkxhnkjh vk/kkjHkwr lajpuk fodkl gsrq jkT; ds fy, ,d egRoiw.kZ lalk/ku lzksr gks
ldrk gSA Hkkjr ljdkj }kjk bu ifj;kstukvksa ds dk;kZUo;u esa futh Hkkxhnkjh dks c<+kok nsus ds
mís'; ls Viability Gap Funding dh ;kstuk izkjEHk dh x;h gS ftlds fy, ifj;kstuk dh vkfFkZd
lEHkkO;rk lqfuf'pr djus gsrq futh Hkkxhnkjh ifj;kstuk dh ykxr dks 40 izfr'kr rd vuqnku
miyC/k djk;k tk ldrk gS ftlesa 50 izfr'kr va'k jkT; ljdkj dk gksxk A
2- ,slh ifj;kstukvksa ds fy, loZizFke ,d foLr`r ifj;kstuk fjiksVZ rS;kj djus dh
vko';drk gksrh gSA bl izfrosnu dks rS;kj djus dh {kerk foHkkxksa esa ugha jgus ds dkj.k blds fy,
lykgdkj dh fu;qfDr djuh gksrh gSA pWawfd lykgdkjksa dh fu;qfDr dh izfdz;k yEch gksrh gS] vr%
LokHkkfod :i ls ,slh ifj;kstukvksa dk p;u] foLr`r ifj;kstuk fjiksVZ rS;kj djuk] futh Hkkxhnkj dk
p;u djuk rFkk dk;kZUo;u esa foyEc dh lEHkkouk jgrh gSA bu dkj.kksa ls foRr foHkkx ds ladYi
la[;k 4308 fo0¼2½] fnukad 22 twu 2007 }kjk foHkkxksa dks ;g 'kfDr nh x;h Fkh fd os tu
futh Hkkxhnkjh ds ek/;e ls vk/kkjHkwr lajpuk fodkl ls tqM+h ifj;kstukvksa ds vfHkdYi ls ysdj
futh Hkkxhnkj ds p;u rd dh dk;Zokgh ds fy, bUQzkLVªDpj MsoyiesaV QkbZukal daiuh
2
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
(Infrastructure Development Finance Company) vFkok IL&FS dks lh/ks lykgdkj fu;qfDr dj
ldrs gSaA
3- bl laca/k esa foRr ea=ky;] Hkkjr ljdkj }kjk i=kad OM No.-2/4/2007 fnukad 22 vxLr
2007 ds }kjk leO;ogkj lykgdkjksa dh lwph rFkk OM No.-2/4/2007 fnukad 25.10.2007 ds }kjk
ekxZfunsZf'kdk fuxZr dh xbZ gS] ftlds vuqlkj muds }kjk fof/kor p;fur 11 lykgdkjksa esa
de&ls&de 5 ls foRrh; fufonk izkIr dj tu&futh Hkkxhnkjh ¼Public Private Partnership½ ds
ek/;e ls vk/kkjHkwr lajpuk ifj;kstukvksa gsrq izLrko rS;kj djus ds fy, leO;ogkj lykgdkj
¼Transaction Advisor½ dh fu;qfDr dh tkuh gS ¼vuqyXud&1 layXu½A
4- lE;d fopkjksijkUr jkT; ljdkj us fu.kZ; fy;k gS fd Hkfo"; esa tu&futh Hkkxhnkj ds
ek/;e ls vk/kkjHkwr lajpuk ifj;kstukvksa gsrq izLrko rS;kj djus ds fy, laO;ogkj lykgdkj dh
fu;qfDr foRr ea=ky;] Hkkjr ljdkj }kjk fuxZr ifji= ,oa fn'kk&funsZ'k ds vkyksd esa dh tk,xh A
iwoZ ds ifji= ds vk/kkj ij ftu ekeyksa esa laO;ogkj lykgdkj dh fu;qfDr gks pqdh gS] os bl fu.kZ;
ls izHkkfor ugha gksaxsA
vkns'k %
vkns'k %
vkns'k %
vkns'k % vkns'k fn;k tkrk gS fd
vkns'k fn;k tkrk gS fd
vkns'k fn;k tkrk gS fd
vkns'k fn;k tkrk gS fd bl ladYi dks fcgkj jkti= ds vxys vlk/kkj.k vad esa izdkf'kr
bl ladYi dks fcgkj jkti= ds vxys vlk/kkj.k vad esa izdkf'kr
bl ladYi dks fcgkj jkti= ds vxys vlk/kkj.k vad esa izdkf'kr
bl ladYi dks fcgkj jkti= ds vxys vlk/kkj.k vad esa izdkf'kr
fd;k tk; A
fd;k tk; A
fd;k tk; A
fd;k tk; A
fcgkj&jkT;iky ds vkns'k ls]
fefgj dqekj flag]
lfpo ¼O;;½A
3
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
vuqyXud&1
vuqyXud&1
vuqyXud&1
vuqyXud&1
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Economic Affairs
Panel of Transaction Advisers for PPP projects: A guide for use of the Panel
1 Introduction
1.1 The Government of India has announced its intention to create an enabling
environment for private investment in infrastructure. The Government of India has
established the Committee on Infrastructure under the chairmanship of the Prime Minister of
India to support this policy. The Government has also established a scheme for financial
support to Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) where there is a gap between revenues which
can be raised from user charges and the funds required.
1.2 Implementation of this policy will require that the agencies concerned at central,
state and municipal government level have access to appropriate advisory support for the
implementation of PPP transactions.
1.3 There has been a demand from some of the State Governments and its agencies
raised in different fora for assistance in short-listing transaction advisers/consultants to
eliminate delays in creation of shelf of projects and to prevent hiring of transaction
advisors/consultants on nomination basis.
1.4 In response to this demand, the Government of India has established a panel of
pre-qualified Transaction Advisers, hereinafter referred to as Panel. The Panel has the
following characteristics:
• The Government has pre-qualified those firms who it has assessed are the
most suitable for providing this advice, rather than pre-qualifying all firms
who pass a minimum threshold.
• This Panel is available to all central, state and municipal governments who
are undertaking or intending to undertake PPP transactions However, it is
advisable to procure financial, legal and technical expertise separately in the
case of large projects such as port development or airport development
projects where the project cost is very high.
• Panel
members
have
skills
and
experience
to
provide
both
commercial/financial and legal services in support of PPP transactions. The
possible scope of such services is described in section 3. Where specialist
technical advice related to the sector concerned is required, this should be
separately procured.
• Panel applicants have already been assessed as capable of providing
transaction management services. Subsequent appointment by the central,
state and municipal government agencies should be on the basis of a financial
proposal, against a defined scope of work.
• Firms/ Consortia on the Panel will contract directly with the Sponsoring
Authorities concerned for provision of transaction management services.
DEA should however be kept informed on the use being made of the Panel,
and the performance of Panel members.
• The transactions may arise in urban waste management, water, public
transport, highways, education and health. However, use of the Panel is not
restricted to these sectors
1.5 This Users’ guide describes the processes and the tasks involved in appointing a
transaction adviser for a PPP transaction using the Panel. Projects may be implemented
4
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
Government Departments, project units, or agencies. These are collectively referred to as
Sponsoring Authorities in this document.
2 Role of the Panel
2.1 The Panel is intended to:
• Streamline the tendering process for the engagement of transaction advisers for
PPPs;
•
Enable fast access to firms that have been pre-qualified against relevant criteria;
and
• Ensure transparency and accountability through clear definition of the processes
and the role and responsibilities of the agencies and the private sector.
2.2 All Central, State and municipal government agencies may access the Panel for
the purpose of procuring transaction advisers for PPP projects.
2.3 Where Sponsoring Authorities are seeking a quote from a Panel member, the
Sponsoring Authority concerned should directly approach those members. A full listing of
Panel members and their contact details is provided in section 4.
2.4 The Panel is valid for a period of two years. During this period Department of
Economic Affairs (DEA) may remove firms from the panel if it concludes that they have not
demonstrated adequate capability of providing the required services in a professional manner
or add new firms, after due diligence. Any information on change to panel membership will
be made available through DEA’s website- www.pppinindia.com.
3 Step-by-step guide
3.1 Figure 1 provides a summary of the steps that Sponsoring Authorities need to take
in determining whether the panel is applicable to their requirements, and (if it is applicable)
in appointing panel members to act as transaction adviser.
Figure 1: Summary of steps in using panel consultants:
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
Confirm proposed project is eligible
Develop specific terms of reference for the assignment
Determine which panel members to approach
Seek financial quote from panel members
Evaluate proposals from panel members
Sign contract for provision of transaction services withselected panel member
Service commences
Evaluate and report performance to DEA on performance of selected panel member
5
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
3.2 These steps are detailed below.
Step 1
3.3 Ensure the project meets the eligibility criteria
3.3.1 The Panel has been developed to provide pre-qualified transaction advisers for
small to medium size PPP projects. The first step is to confirm that the project under
consideration is a small to medium size PPP project.
3.3.2 The panel should not generally be used for projects with a capital cost
exceeding around Rs. 250 crore (Rs. 2.5 billion). If the projected capital costs exceed that
level, the panel is unlikely to be appropriate. The panel has sought integrated offers to
provide both commercial/financial and legal advice. Larger projects will often use separate
commercial/financial and legal advisers.
3.3.3 The Panel should be used for PPP projects. Broadly defined, a Project is based
on a contract or concession agreement between a Government or statutory entity and a
private sector company for delivering a service on payment of user charges.
3.3.4 Prior to using the Panel, the agency should confirm that the project under
consideration meets the following conditions:
• A substantial capital investment (but not exceeding around Rs. 250 crore) in
infrastructure will be required, to provide the services required under the project;
• Government facilitation is required, whether in purchasing the output, other direct
financial support to the project’s viability, or supporting inputs (such as land acquisition); and
• The concessionaire will be required to finance the project, and recover the capital
costs over time, through user charges/annuities. Typical concession period is likely to be 15
to 30 years, and in some cases longer. A contract where the contractor receives payment for
the capital cost at an earlier stage (such as on successful commissioning) and not based on
life-cycle costs that include maintenance for the period, is not eligible.
The reason for limiting the Panel to projects of this kind is that they raise distinctive
problems in their execution. The Panel of advisers has been selected on the basis of their
capability to advise on projects of this kind, and their experience in doing so.
Step 2
3.4 Develop specific terms of reference for the assignment
3.4.1 The panel is intended as a source of advisers to assist with implementation of a
transaction. The panel is not intended for use for preliminary analysis, for instance to
determine whether the project is viable, and to determine whether it should be procured
through a PPP contract or some other means.
3.4.2 The terms of reference for the assignment should relate to the successful
execution of a PPP transaction.
3.4.3 There are many different stages at which the transaction adviser could become
involved, and many different ways of allocating the tasks between the Sponsoring Authority
and the transaction adviser. The transaction adviser needs to understand clearly what tasks
they will undertake and what resources they will require, in order to provide a financial offer
for undertaking the transaction. The terms of reference should therefore set out both what
needs to be done, and the supporting inputs that will be provided by the Sponsoring Authority
(or other advisers) and the role that the transaction adviser needs to play.
3.4.4 An indicative list of tasks that could be considered in developing the terms of
reference includes:
• Interaction with the market, or conduct of formal market soundings, to confirm
decisions on scope, timing and packaging of the transaction;
6
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
• Preparation of bid documents including but not limited to the Request for
Proposals and the Contract for Services (Concession Agreement);
• Preparation of supporting information to assist bidders in preparation of their
bid, and where relevant creation of a data base and management of access to
the data base;
• Support to communication with the market and interaction with the market,
including managing and responding to requests for clarification;
• Preparation of an evaluation plan, assistance with evaluation and preparation
of evaluation reports;
• Assistance in negotiation with one or more parties prior to contract award;
• Monitoring and advice on bidder performance against any conditions
precedent to financial close; and
• Management of other advisory inputs, and overall management of the
transaction team, to ensure a successful conclusion.
3.4.5 Panel members have been selected on the basis of their capability and
experience in discharging a lead role in transactions and providing commercial, financial and
legal advice. They are unlikely to have detailed technical or engineering expertise. Where
further technical advice is required, the technical advisers should be procured separately. The
terms of reference should not include any tasks (such as detailed design of the technical
specifications) which need to be undertaken by technical specialists. Generally this task is left
to the contracted private party.
Step 3
3.5 Determine which panel member to approach
3.5.1 The firms/consortia on the Panel have been selected on the basis of their ability
to provide transaction services. This is a skill which is applicable across all sectors. Where
specialist technical expertise is required, this should be separately procured.
3.5.2 There may however be advantageous to use transaction advisers who have
previously worked in the sector concerned. These advisers may bring a close familiarity with
typical contract arrangements, the potential bidders and other knowledge which assists with
undertaking the transaction.
3.5.3 The Panel has therefore sought an indication from panel members of the sectors
in which they have previous experience in undertaking transactions. Each panel member has
indicated whether they have experience in, - i.e., Urban waste management, Water, Public
transport, Ports, Airports, Highways, Education and Health.
3.5.4 These sectors have been selected as ones in which PPP projects are likely to
proceed. However, it is also intended that the panel can be used for other sectors as PPP
projects develop in those sectors.
3.5.5 Before approaching Panel members, the Sponsoring Authority should carefully
consider whether it wishes to seek advisers with previous expertise in the sector applicable to
the project. This will reduce the number of eligible panel members, and therefore, reduce the
number of competitors.
Step 4
3.6 Seek a proposal and financial quote from the selected panel members
3.6.1 Having identified the project for PPP structuring, the Sponsoring Authority
should request a proposal (RFP) from all or atleast five members of the Panel. The RFP
should clearly define the tasks to be undertaken by the transaction adviser, the key
deliverables, the timelines and the evaluation criteria. The RFP should also provide
background on the project, how it is currently being managed, and (where relevant) the role
of other advisers.
3.6.2 It is possible to structure the fee in two parts. The first part would be the
lumpsum fee to be quoted by the Transaction Adviser as the financial bid (the bidding
7
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
parameter), and would be released against pre-determined milestones. The second part, as an
incentive, could be a predetermined success fee, payable on the project reaching technical
close, i.e. on signing of the Concession Agreement by the prospective concessionaire for the
PPP project. The quantum of the success fee, to be recovered from the Concessionaire, could
be 50-100 percent higher than the cost of transaction actually incurred by the Transaction
Adviser, excluding outsourced work, expenses incurred by the Sponsoring Authority and
similar such costs. The percentage of return on the actual cost of transaction (say 50-100 per
cent) should be specified in the RFP to enable the Transaction Adviser to determine his most
competitive financial bid.
3.6.3 The proposal from the selected panel member should provide a detailed
description of the resources that will be applied to the assignment, especially adequately
experienced personnel, capable of and devoted to the successful accomplishment of work to
be performed under the contract. The panel member must agree to assign specific individuals
to the key positions and that, once assigned to work under this contract, key personnel shall
not be removed or replaced without written notice to the Authority. If key personnel are not
available for work under this contract for a continuous period exceeding thirty (30) calendar
days, or are expected to devote substantially less effort to the work than initially anticipated,
the panel member shall immediately notify the Sponsoring Authority, and shall, subject to the
concurrence of the Sponsoring Authority, replace such personnel with personnel of
substantially equal ability and qualifications.
3.6.4 The panel member should confirm that there is no conflict of interest in taking
up this Transaction Advisory assignment. Sponsoring Authority should take an undertaking
from the tendering Panel member or consortia, that they/ their affiliates will not bid for/ rate
the same projects.
3.6.5 In case the Panel member is a Consortium, change in composition of the
Consortium shall not be permitted by the Sponsoring Authority.
3.6.6 In short the RFP should contain the following:
(i) A letter of invitation
(ii) Information to Consultants regarding the procedure for submission of
proposal
(iii) Terms of Reference (TOR)
(iv) List of key position whose CV and experience would be evaluated
(v) Standard formats for financial proposal.
(vi) Proposed contract terms
(vii) Procedure proposed to be followed for midterm review of the progress of the
work and review of the final draft report.
Step 5
3.7 Evaluate proposals from panel members
3.7.1 The panel members have already been pre-qualified as capable of providing
transaction services. A further technical offer and evaluation is not required. It is expected
that appointment will be on the basis of a financial evaluation. However, the Sponsoring
Authority, while evaluating should ensure that :
(i) The panel member has confirmed its acceptance of the deliverables, has confirmed
its capability and resources to meet the deliverables within the timeline set out in the RFP;
(ii) The panel member has confirmed that they face no conflict of interest in
undertaking the assignment. A conflict of interest will arise if the panel member, or its parent
company, is advising potential bidders for the PPP project, or if the panel member or its
parent company is considering a debt or equity involvement in the project or is required to
rate the proposed PPP project. It is, therefore, recommended that the Sponsoring Authority
8
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
appointing the transaction advisors should ensure that such a conflict of interest does not
exist or arise.
Step 6
3.8 Sign a contract with the successful panel member
3.8.1 Sponsoring Authorities using the Panel should note that they will be the party
contracting with the Panel member. DEA has established the Panel, but will not be involved
in any contracts between Sponsoring Authorities and Panel members.
3.8.2 After the completion of evaluation process and the selection of the preferred -
panel member the Sponsoring Authorities must send a letter of appointment together with a
contract of engagement.
3.8.3 The Sponsoring Authority will rely on the transaction adviser for managing the
transaction up to the award of the PPP contract. It is of great importance that the contract
clearly sets out:
• The role and functions of the transaction adviser and of other parties, key
deliverables, timelines, and accountabilities;
• The basis on which the transaction adviser will be paid.;
• The reporting requirements to ensure the Sponsoring Authority is well informed
on progress on the PPP transaction, and on any issues arising; and
• Probity requirements, including the need to actively monitor any possible
conflicts of interest, and the need to maintain project confidentiality, supported by
a Deed of Confidentiality.
3.8.4 DEA is separately providing advice on standard terms and conditions in a
contract with a transaction adviser.
Step 7
3.9 Commencement of service
3.9.1 After signature of the contract, the transaction adviser can start work.
3.9.2 The Sponsoring Authority should ensure that a full and comprehensive briefing
is provided to the transaction adviser, to assist an early and effective start on the assignment.
3.9.3 The Sponsoring Authority should also ensure that all relevant parties, including
project staff within the Sponsoring Authority itself, other institutions involved in the project,
and other advisers working on the project are informed of the appointment of the transaction
adviser.
Step 8
3.10 Report performance to the DEA contract manager
3.10.1 The Panel has been established by DEA to assist agencies in identifying and
retaining transaction advisers. It is of importance that DEA receives feedback on the
performance of Panel members to ensure the ongoing quality, and the effectiveness of the
Panel arrangement.
3.10.2 Sponsoring Authorities should inform DEA when a Panel member is
appointed to provide transaction services and provide a report on performance after
completion of the transaction adviser’s assignment.
9
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
4 List of Panel of Transaction Advisers (Panel members )
Sl.
No.
Name of the Transaction
Adviser
Address
Contact No.s/
Contact person
1
2
3
4
5
1
Abacus Legal Group, India
Consortium partner: Clayton
Utz., Australia
B-226, 1st Floor,
Greater Kailash-1,
New Delhi-110 048
+91(011) 2923 4030/
2923 4092/2923 6522
net.in
Mr. Akshoy Rekhi
+9198110 43477
2
CRISIL Infrastructure Advisory,
India;
Consortium partners: Verulam
Consultants Private Limited,
India; Amarchand & Mangaldas
and Suresh A. Shroff & Co., India
and Devesh K Shah & Co., India
CRISIL Limited,
121-122,
CRISIL House,
Andheri-Kurla Road,
Andheri (East),
Mumbai-400093
+91(011) 52405194
Mr. Sameer Gupta,
Head- CRISIL
Infrastructure
Advisory
+91 9350491051
3
Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India
Private Limited, India;
Consortium partners: Deloitte &
Touche LLP, UK and Hemant
Sahai Associates, India
Hansalya, 4th Flour
4E, Barakhamba
Road, New Delhi-
110 001
+91011 2331 5256
2331 3543
2331 5437
kamleshmittal@deloitt
e.com
Mr. Kamlesh Mittal
+919811156820
4
Ernst & Young Private Limited,
India
Consortium partners:
Amarchand & Mangaldas and
Suresh A. Shroff & Co
Ernst & Young
Private Limited 205,
Ashoka Bhoopal
Chambers, Sardar
patel Road,
Hyderabad, Andhra
Pradesh 50003
+91406627 4111/6627
4000
+91 40 2789 8851
(Fax)
+91 9849040801
m
Mr. Utkarsh
Palnitkaar, Partner &
Leader, Advisory
Services,
Infrastructure, Real
Estate & Government
5
Feedback Ventures Private
Limited, India;
Consortium partners:
Delhi Metro Rail Corporation
(DMRC), India. Bankworld Inc.,
USA and Hemant Sahai
Associates, India
Feedback House, 7,
Local
Shopping Centre,
Panchsheel Park,
New Delhi-110 017
91(011) 42007508
akhileshwar@feedbac
kventures.com
Mr. Akhileshwar
Sahay,
President, Government
& Multilateral
Advisory Services
(GMAS)
6
Grant Thornton UK LLP, London,
Consortium partners: U.K.
Grant Thornton India Private
Limited, India and Amarchand
Mangaldas & Suresh A Shroff &
Co., India.
Grant Thornton
House, Melton Street,
Euston Square,
London, NW1 2EP,
United Kingdom
0044(0)870 324 2282
(Telefax)
Glenn.stone@gtuk.
com
Mr. Glenn Stone
0870 324 2282 Mr.
Amit Jain, Senior Vice
President, Government
and Infrastructure
Advisory, Grant
Thornton, India
+9198717 44 226
7
Infrastructure Development
Finance Company (IDFC)
Limited, India;
Consortium partners:
Infrastructure Development
ITC Centre, 3rd
Floor, 760,
Anna Salai,
Chennai-600 002
+91044 2855 9440
044 2854 7597(F)
Mr. Cherian Thomas,
Senior
Director – Advisory
Services
10
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
Sl.
No.
Name of the Transaction
Adviser
Address
Contact No.s/
Contact person
1
2
3
4
5
Corporation (Karnataka) Limited
(iDeCK), India and Singhania &
Partners, India
+91(011) 46006111
+919818101115
8
Infrastructure Leasing and
Financial Services (IL&FS), India;
Consortium partners: IL&FS
Infrastructure Development
Corporation, India; IL&FS
Education and Technology
Services, India; Amarchand and
Mangaldas & Suresh A. Shroff &
Co. and Junnarkar & Associates,
India
Infrastructure
Leasing and
Financial Services
Limited, Regd
Office: IL&FS
Financial Centre, C-
22, G Block, Bandra
Kurla Complex,
Bandra East,
Mumbai-400051
+91011 4130 6726/27
prasanna.srinivasan@i
lfsind ia.com
Mr. Prasanna
Srinivasan,
Sr. Vice President,
+9198110 66728
9
International Finance Corporation
50M, Niti Marg
(Gate No.3)
Chankyapuri, New
Delhi-110021
+91(011) 4111 1018/
1000
+91011) 4111 1001/
02 (Fax)
Mr. Vipul Bhagat,
Manager,
Infrastructure
Advisory, South Asia
10
Pricewaterhouse Coopers Private
Limited, India;
Consortium partners:
A.Y.Chitale & Associates, India
and Singhania & Partners, India
Price water house
Coopers Private
Limited, Building 8,
7t h & 8th Floor,
Tower B, DLF
Cybercity,
Gurgaon-122 002.
Regd office: Plot
No.Y-14, Block
EP, Sector V, Salt
Lake Electronics
Complex,
Bidhannagar,
Kolkata-700 091
+910124 4620557
+9101244620000
(Board)
+910124 4620620
(fax)
vishwas.udgirkar@in.
pwc.com
Mr. Vishwas Udgirkar,
Executive
Director
11
RITES Limited, India
Consortium partner: Suri &
Company Law Firm, India
Regd Office: New
Delhi House,
27, Barakhama Road,
New Delhi
Corporate Office:
Plot No.1, Sector 29,
Gurgaon 122001
+910124 2571666/
0124 2818170
+910124 2571630 /
+910124 2571660 (F)
Mr. S.K. Seth, Group
General
Manager (Privatisation
and
Concession)
NOTE:—1. There may be potential conflict of interest in case of panel members such as
IL&FS and IDFC Limited are selected as the Transaction Adviser for a project
for which they could be potential bidders. It is, therefore, recommended that the
state governments/ local governments appointing the transaction advisors should
take an undertaking from the selected consortia that they/ their affiliates will not
bid for the same projects.
11
बहार गजट (असाधारण)] 17 माच. 2010
2. There may be potential conflict of interest in case the agencies with CRISIL
consortia are selected as the Transaction Adviser for a project, where CRISIL is
also required to rate the proposed PPP project.
————
अधी/क, सिचवालय मुिणालय,
बहार, पटना ारा ूकािशत एवं मु3ित।
बहार गजट (असाधारण) 181-571+500-ड0ट0पी0।
Website: http://egazette.bih.nic.in