ँध्र् ी "{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न्ध्॰ीं्रय्ध्र््िध्ूर्अिग.ूर्अ्रिण्" "प्रष्ँॉर् ीैन् ऽह्मई्रय्ई त्र्र्न्ी र्५ीीं} ्र॰ झ्ीं्रर्ईी ;प्रर्ष्ी त्र्र्न्ी प्रन्न्द्ध ऽर्ह्यी २न्ईीं ऽींईण् र् ी ँध्ण् ू.ूू.{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ्रँन्न्ध्गद्व प्रॉण् ॉण् प्रझ्र्९ी"य्ए प्रर्॰ी गर्.्रि.ूर्र्अििण्" {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँी
र्ीर्प्रीन् ॉर् ीप्रर्५ीई
र्ी गर् ि, र्न्ीींन्ए र्र्५ीींीन्ए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न्न् ूर्अिर्र्द्वीीर्ह्यी ्रए र्५ी अ्लर्ि
प्रऽॉट्टध्
र्झ्ी्र गण्;अद्ध प्रर्र्क्कीी र्ऽीभन् प्रप्र ॉर्ट्टीए ;ूद्धर् ॉीप्रऊध्
ॉर्ट्टीण्
र्झ्ी्र अण्;अद्ध र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉ र्ऽी॰र्५ीए ;ूद्ध प्रर्झ्ी्रर् ींीञ र्ऽी॰र्५ीए ;गद्ध न्ट्ठ र्र्ह्मीी९ र्ऽी॰र्५ी र्ऽीभन् ऽप्रॉर्ट्टीए ;लद्ध र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉ ॉ}ए ;्रद्ध र्झ्ीन्ई र्र्५ीीॉ र्ऽी॰र्५ी र्ऽीभन् ऽप्रॉर्ट्टीए ;क्ष्द्ध र्प्रीय् र्र्ऽीी्रए र्झ्ीन्ई ध् ऽप्रॉर्ट्टीए ;द्यद्ध र्९ी.र्झ्ीर्ऽी प्रन्प्रर्५ीब्ड्ढन्ण्
र्झ्ी्र लण्;द्ध ;अद्ध {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् प्रए ;ूद्ध न् ॉप्रप्रई प्रई॰ए ;गद्ध ॉॉ॰ ञ ींन्र्—ैीप्रई प्रए ;द्ध ;अद्ध ऽर्क्ती॰र्५ीए ;ूद्ध {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ऽप्रप्रए ;गद्ध ॉॉ॰ड्ढ ऽप्रप्रए ;्रद्ध ;अद्धर् ीड प्रए ;ूद्ध ऽप्रई प्रण् र्झ्ी्र ूर्ण्ैीध् र्प्री ध् ऽप्रॉर्ट्टीण्
र्झ्ी्र 1
र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ र्ऽी॰र्५ी
ॉर्र्ीीह्म र्र्५ीीॉ प्रर्झ्ी्र
र्र्ीी९ए २र्न्ी॰ध् झ्एर् ी र्न्ीींन्
र्ी र्न्ीींन्ए प्रर्॰ी ूग ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ ्र.अलध्ूर्अिद्यध्अ ;द्धण्र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰ड्ढर्उीर्न्ी र्ीध् र्ह्मीट्टप्रईय् Shri Thottathil B. Radhakrishnan ींऊ र्र्ह्मीीप्रप्रईए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् न्ट्ठ र्र्ह्मीी९ प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्र् ी प्रर्॰ी र्द्यि.र््र.िूर्अिद्व ॉ ूग.र््र.िूर्अिद्व ;अद्य प्र॰द्धर् ी ट्टर्ह्यीय् ई र्र्झ्ीीञ ॉप्र२न्ई ९र्र्ीिंींट्ठई र्ऽीर्५ीर् ी र्९ीझ् ९ ध् ैध्ट्ठप्रई र्॰ी न्र्ईी २भन्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्झ्ी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
"य्प्र९ ९त्र्र्न्ीए प्रर्५ीऽ ॉप्रण्
अद्वद्वग
ॉर्ी९ए ीं]र्ह्यी र्ईी ९र् ॉी्रध्ए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्उीर्न्ी र्र्५ीीॉध्र्र् ीीध् ीं]र्र्ह्यीी९ए र्र्न्ीँी॰र््री ॉ ींप्र]ई र्ईीर् ीप्रर्५ीईूर्अिद्वण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1884
र्र्ऽीीॉ ञर् ीय्न्र्ह्यी प्रर्झ्ी्र
र्र्ीी९ए २र्न्ी॰ध् झ्एर् ी र्न्ीींन्
र्ी र्न्ीींन्ए प्रर्॰ी अअ ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्५ीींप्रीर्न्ी
र्ीञ द्य.अूध्ूर्अिद्वध्गूण्"न्ॉ प्रर्झ्ी्र ध् ॉॉञऊ ऽप्रर्क्तीॉर्ट्टी प्रर्॰ीञ ूद्व.्र.ूर्अिद्व र्उीर्न्ी ष्र्९ीभर्॰ीर्र्ष्ीँीन् प्रँ९ ऽञई्रय्ई र्न्ीन् प्रर्५ीर्र् ीीर् ी ्रन् न्ई २ींन् न्ॉध् ॉर्ध्ीञ प्रर्र्क्तीीय्प्रन्ई न् ॉञष्ञर्क्तीध् २भन्ए ॰र्प्रीर्ह्यीध् ॉर्ध्ी ञ र््री "झ्र्र्]ीी९न्" र् ैी न् र््री "झ्र्र्]ीी९ध्न्" ३र्न्ीर् ँीण्
र्ी र्न्ीींन्ए प्रर्॰ी अक्ष् ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्५ीींप्रीर्न्ी
र्ीञ द्य.अर्ध्ूिर्अिद्वध्गूण्"न्ॉ प्रर्झ्ी्र ध् ॉॉञऊ ऽप्रर्क्तीॉर्ट्टी प्रर्॰ीञ ूद्व.्र.ूर्अिद्व र्उीर्न्ी ष्र्९ीभर्॰ीर्र्ष्ीँीन् प्रँ९ ऽञई्रय्ई र्न्ीत्र्न्ध्२न् प्रर्५ीर्र् ीीर् ी ्रन् न्ई २ींन् न्ॉध् ॉर्ध्ीञ प्रर्र्क्तीीय्प्रन्ई न् ॉञष्ञर्क्तीध् २भन्ए ॰र्प्रीर्ह्यीध् ॉर्ध्ी ञ र््री "प्रर्न्ीत्र्न्ध्२न्" र् ैी न् र््री "र्न्ीत्र्न्ध्२न्" ३र्न्ीर् ँीण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्झ्ी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
श्न्ँर्ध्ी र्न्ीर्०ीए ऽन्.ॉप्रण् LAW AND LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Naya Raipur
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6917/2228/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Shri Nilesh Jagdalla S/o Shri Makar Dhawaj Jagdalla (Category-S.C. Merit No. 13) on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090-920- 40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date he assumes charge of his office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Com- mission by the appointee during his selection process as well as the information given by appointee in his affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab-initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event his service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by him on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6919/2508/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Shri Vaibhav Ghritlahre S/o Shri Jagat Ram Ghritlahre (Category-S.C. Merit No. 14) on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090-920- 40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of theर्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1885 Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date he assumes charge of his office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during his selection process as well as the information given by appointee in his affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event his service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by him on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6921/2291/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Shri Prateek Tembhurkar S/o Shri Puran Nath Tembhurkar (Category-Unreserved Merit No. 08) on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090- 920-40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date he assumes charge of his office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during his selection process as well as the information given by appointee in his affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event his service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by him on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6923/2211/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Ku. Ankita Tigga D/o Shri Anand Prakash Tigga [Category-S. T. (F-E) Merit No. 25] on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090- 920-40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date she assumes charge of her office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during her selection process as well as the information given by appointee in her affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event her service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by her on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6925/2210/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Shri Vivek Kerketta S/o Shri Manshuk Kerketta (Category-S. T. Merit No. 16) on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090-920- 40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date he assumes charge of his office.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1886This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during his selection process as well as the information given by appointee in his affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event his service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by him on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6927/2261/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Ku. Ranju Vaishnav D/o Shri Lakhan Das Vaishnav [Category-Unreserved (F) Merit No. 04] on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770- 33,090-920-40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date she assumes charge of her office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during her selection process as well as the information given by appointee in her affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event her service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by her on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6929/2512/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Ku. Yogita Jangade D/o Late Shri Ganga Ram Jangade [Category-S.C. (F) Merit No. 20] on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090- 920-40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date she assumes charge of her office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during her selection process as well as the information given by appointee in her affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event her service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by her on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6931/2294/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Shri Kranti Kumar Singh S/o Shri Jagadev Prasad (Category-S.T. Merit No. 24] on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090-920- 40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date he assumes charge of his office.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1887This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during his selection process as well as the information given by appointee in his affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event his service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by him on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6933/2209/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Shri Prashant Kumar Dewangan S/o Shri Ram Kumar Dewangan (Category-OBC Merit No. 11) on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770- 33,090-920-40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date he assumes charge of his office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during his selection process as well as the information given by appointee in his affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event his service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by him on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6935/2201/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Shri Manoj Kumar Kushwaha S/o Shri Ramswarup Kushwaha (Category-OBC Merit No. 12) on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770- 33,090-920-40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date he assumes charge of his office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during his selection process as well as the information given by appointee in his affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event his service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by him on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6937/2333/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Shri Rajat Kumar Nirala S/o Shri G. R. Nirala (Category-S.T. Merit No. 21) on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090-920- 40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date he assumes charge of his office.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1888This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during his selection process as well as the information given by appointee in his affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event his service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by him on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6939/2212/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Ku. Kiran Panna D/o Shri Pascal Panna [Category- S.T. (F) Merit No. 18] on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090-920-40,450- 1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date she assumes charge of her office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during her selection process as well as the information given by appointee in her affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event her service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by her on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6941/2329/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Smt. Kalpana Bhagat W/o Shri Amit Kumar Tirkey [Category-Unreserved (F) Merit No. 01] on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770- 33,090-920-40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date she assumes charge of her office.
This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during her selection process as well as the information given by appointee in her affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event her service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by her on the strength of this appointment order.
Raipur, the 12th July 2018
No. 6943/2279/XXI-B/2018.—In exercise of the powers conferred by Article 234 of the Constitution of India read with sub-rule (1) of Rule 5 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006 the State Government, hereby appoints Shri Ashish Bhagat S/o Shri Amarjeet Bhagat (Category-S.T. Merit No. 19) on the Post of Civil Judge (Entry Level) in the Pay Scale of 27,700-770-33,090-920- 40,450-1,080-44,770 (Corresponding 7th C.P.C. Pay Matrix-10) under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 3 of the Chhattisgarh Lower Judicial Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2006, temporarily on probation for a period of two years or till further order, from the date he assumes charge of his office.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1889This order is being issued on the basis of the documents and information furnished to Public Service Commission by the appointee during his selection process as well as the information given by appointee in his affidavit, considering them to be correct, bonafide and true. This appointment order shall be deemed to be void ab- initio in case any information so furnished by the appointee is subsequently found to be concealed, false, fabricated, untrue, concocted of misleading and in such event his service shall be terminated without any enquiry or assigning any reason or cause and also no right or claim shall accrue on account of services rendered by him on the strength of this appointment order.
By order and in the name of the Governor of Chhattisgarh,
RAVISHANKAR SHARMA, Principal Secretary,
र्ञीई ञ र््रीध्र्ह्यी र्प्रीॉ प्रर्झ्ी्र
र्र्ीी९ए २र्न्ी॰ध् झ्एर् ी र्न्ीींन्
र्ी र्न्ीींन्ए प्रर्॰ी ूक्ष् ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञध्ञण्ध्ञर््रीप्रप्रध्ूूध्ूर्अिद्वध्अूूद्यण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् प्रर्र्५ीी ;ञण्द्ध ॉञ्रय् र्;ॉी ध्र्र् ॉीीह्म र्५ीईय्द्ध प्रए ूर्अिद्वर् ी प्रट्टप्र९प्रई र्ीडए प्रँॉ र्न्ीद्द ॉर्न्ीन्ए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्ञीई र्न्ीँ ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए अ््ग र्;ीञ अ ॉ अ््लद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ््र ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध ॉ२न्प्रन्ई र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी द्यर् िध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध र्ईी र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ्रग ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध र्उीर्न्ी र्॰ी र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र ञ र्९ीई २ींन् र्र्ष्ीी ैर्ईीप्रई न्ईध् २भन्ए न्घई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ््र ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;गद्ध र्उीर्न्ी ऽर्प्रीई प्र ्र र्ऽींॉीन्ए न् ॉैई प्रघर्ईीञए प्रँ प्र न्ॉॉ र्झ्ीप्रई २र्न्ी ध् ॉञर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ए ध् ँर्र्ीीन्ध् प्र९ ई॰र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्५ीई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन् र्ईी ई॰र्उीर्न्ी २न् ॉट्टप्रई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन् प्र न्घईर् ीड न् "न्ॉ ऽप्रर्क्तीॉर्ट्टी र्र्न्ीँी ञ र्ीर्५ी ध् र्ईीन्ध् ॉ ञ]२न् प्र॰ॉ र्ऽॉी र्५ीई र्प्रीन् र्प्रीर् ँीर््रीण्
र्ी"य् र्ऽीर्प्रीर् ीर्र् ॉींीीएर् ँी न्घईर् ीड ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ प्रॉध् प्रघई ॉ प्रप्रप्र॰य्ब्न्र् ीर्९ीप्रर्क्ती ट्टय्ए ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्ञीई ञ र््रीध्र्ह्यी र्प्रीॉ प्रर्झ्ी्रए र्;ी ण् ॉ र्.िूलद्धए २र्न्ी॰ध् झ्एर् ी र्न्ीींन् र्र् ीीय्९ ञर्र् ीीय्९ध् ॉ ञर् ी०ई २र्न्ीए न् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉ र्उीर्न्ी र्प्रीन् र्प्रीर् ँीर््रीण्
प्रर् ीड
अण् ॉञर्प्री०ईर् ी र्ईीर् ीञन्झ्ण्
;अद्ध प्र {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३ प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय् र्;ॉी ध्र्र् ॉीीह्म र्५ीर्ईद्ध प्रए ूर्अिद्व २न्र्९ीञ्रण्
;ूद्ध प्र र्र्न्ीँी ञ "न्र् ीर्५ी ध् र्ईीन्ध् ॉ र्ट्ठी २र्न्ीञ्रण्
ूण् प्रन्र्झ्ीर्ऽीञण् "न् र्प्रीञ ञए ँष् ई प्र ॉञ॰झ्य् ॉ ऽर्ह्मी ऽर्प्रीई २र्न्ीए
;द्ध "ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र" ॉ ऽप्रझ्ई २न्भ {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्ञीई र्न्ीँ ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए अ््ग ;ण् अ ॉ अ््लद्धय ;द्ध प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय् ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ "प्रींप्रघईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्" ॉ ऽप्रझ्ई २भन्र् ॉीर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्एर् ँी ऽींॉट्टध् र्ी९ ;्रद्ध ञ प्रप्रप्र॰य्ब्न् २भन्य
;्रद्ध "र्र्५ीीॉ" ॉ ऽप्रझ्ई २भन् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉय ;र्र्ीिंद्ध "र्ञीई" ॉ ऽप्रझ्ई २भन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ऽर्क्तीध् ्रप्रन्ईएर् ीप्रैप्रईए प्रँर्९ी र्ञीईए ँ॰ र्ञीईर् ी र््री र्ञीईय
;द्रद्ध "ऽींॉट्टध्" ॉ ऽप्रझ्ई २भन् "न् र्प्रीञ ञ ॉ ॉञ९ िंऽींॉट्टध्य ;द्ध "प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय्" ॉ ऽप्रझ्ई २भन्र् ीप्रैप्रईए प्रँर्९ी र्ञीईर् ी ँ॰ र्ञीई प्रर्ञीर्र्ह्यीीर्क्तीध् प्रर्सीर्९ीञ ञ ३र्न्ी प्र९ प्रींघई प्रघईय
;ूद्ध र्५ीन्न॰ र्ईी ऽप्रझ्प्रघर्ईीएर् ँी "न् र्प्रीञ ञ ींघई २भञन्ए प्रह्मईीं प्रन्र्झ्ीप्रऽई २न्ध्ञ २भन्ए २न्ध्ञ ऽय् २र्न्ीञ्रएर् ँी {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्ञीई र्न्ीँ ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए अ््ग ;ण् अ ॉ अ््लद्ध ञ न् प्र९ ॉीं॰प्रर्५ीई २भन्ण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1890 गण् प्रैर्ईीन् र्ईी र्९ी्रट्ट २र्र्न्ीीण् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् प्रॉप्र९र् ॉी र्;ॉी ध्र्र् ॉीीह्म र्५ीर्ईद्ध प्रए अ्क्ष्अ ञ ऽह्मईप्रय्ब्न्र् ीर्र्र्क्तीीीञ ध्र् ीर्ईी न् प्रईट्ट९ र्झ्ी त्र्र्न्ी९ प्रर्ष्ीए प्रर् ॉी ह्न ॉ॰ै न् र्९ी्रट्ट २र्न्ीञ्रण्
लण् ॉर्ीर् ी ्रन्र्ण्ॉी ञ प्रट्टप्र९प्रई प्रघई ॉप्रट्टप्र९ई २र्न्ीञ्रए र्ऽीय्ई —
;अद्ध प्रघईएर् ँी "न् र्प्रीञ र् ीञन्झ् ॉए ऽींॉट्टध् ञ प्रप्रप्र॰य्ब्न् र्॰ीञर् ी ट्ट९ई—र् ीर्र् ैीीह्म २भन्प्रॉई ॉ र्र्क्तीीन्र्ह्यी न् न्२न् २र्न्ीञय
;ूद्ध प्रघईएर् ँी "न् र्प्रीञ र् ीञन्झ् २र्न्ी ट्टय्र् ॉी ञ झ्ईध्य् प्र ्र २र्न्ीञण्
्रण् ्रध्य्न्र्ह्यी र्ईी र्ईीण्र् ॉीर् ी ्रध्य्न्र्ह्यी र्ईी न्ॉॉ ॉञ९ िंर्ईीए ऽींॉट्टध् ञ ऽञईप्रय्ब्न्र् ीर्र्र्क्तीीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् २र्न्ीञ्रण् क्ष्ण् ॉञप्रप्र९ण् ँभॉ २न्ध् प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय् र्य्ीन्ध् र्ऽीन् ऽय् ध्र् ॉी ट्टर्ह्यीय् न्ई २भञन्ए भॉ २न्ध् र्न्ी ैट्ट९ प्रर्र्र्५ीीी प्रर्झ्ी्र ऽर्क्तीध् र्र्५ीीॉध् प्रर्र्५ीी ड ञ ॉञप्रप्र९ र्प्रीर् ँीर््रीण्
द्यण् ऽींर्ञी प्रींप्रघईण् प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय् ध् न्र् ॉी र्॰ीभर्न्ी ट्ठह्नीं २र्न्ीर् ँी न्ए न्र्र् ीी र्ऽीर्प्रीईर् ी ॉ२र्न्ी प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ड ञर्र् ीीर्ईीर् ी॰ह्यत्र्न् ट्टर्ह्यीय् न् न्ए ऽींर्ञी प्रींप्रघई ॰ध्र् ँी्रध्—
ञन्ईीं २न् प्र ॉध् प्रींप्रघई ध्र् ीञ्र न्र् ी९ र्ऽीर्प्रीई र्उीर्न्ीए ॉ२र्न्ी प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॰ न् ऽींर्ञी प्रींप्रघई २न्ईींए २र्न्ीन् ॉह्यत्र्न्न्ध्ए त्र्न्ध्ण्त्र्न्ण्ध्ष्ध्ण्९ण्त्र्न्ण् ञ प्रर्र्५ीी र्र् ीीर्ईी न्र्र्ध्ीी ;न्ध्ण्"य्न्ण्न्ध्ण्द्ध र्न्ीध्र्ह्यीय् र्न्ी ऽर्प्रीय् २भन्ण्
द्वण् प्रन्र्र्ध्ीीण्
;अद्ध ॉ र्य्ीन्ध्ए प्रँध् प्रींप्रघई "न् र्प्रीञ र्प्रीह्म ट्टय् प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय् ॰ न् २ींन्"य्न् २भन् र्ऽीभन् प्रँध् प्रन्र्र्ध्ीी ध्र् ीर्९ीप्रर्क्तीर् ॉी०ई २न्ध्ञ २ींन्"य्न् २भन्ए र्॰ी ऽय् ध्र् ीर्९ीप्रर्क्ती प्र९ प्रन्र्र्ध्ीी न् न्२ञन््रए प्रँॉर् ीञ ऽय् ध्र् ीर्९ीप्रर्क्ती ई ष्३र्र्न्ीीर् ँी ॉर््रीण् प्रींप्रघईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ह्न ऽय् ऽञई ञ प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय् र्य्ीन्ध् र् ीय्र् ी र्ऽीञ९ श्न्र््रीण्
;ूद्ध र्॰ी ऽय् ध् प्रन्र्र्ध्ीी ध्र् ीर्९ीप्रर्क्ती र्५ीई र्ञीईए प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय् र्य्ीन्ध् र्ऽीन्र्ह्यी ञ न्र्र्र् ीी र्ऽीर्र्क्तीीन् न्ए प्रन्र्र्ध्ीी ध्र् ीर्९ीप्रर्क्तीर् ॉी०ई न् ॉ्रध्ण् प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय् र्य्ीन्ध्र् ीर् ीय् ॉञर्ईीऽँ २न्ध्ञर् ीर् ँी ध् प्रैप्रई ञ प्रन्र्र्ध्ीी ध्र् ीर्९ीप्रर्क्ती ॉ ईध् ऽय् ई ष्३र्न्ी"य्न्र् ँी ॉ्रध्ण् "न्ॉ र्५ीई ॉध् ष्३र्न्ी"य्न् ्र"य्न् र्ीर्९ीप्रर्क्ती ऽञई ञ न्र् ीय्र् ी र्ऽीञ९ र्प्रीर् ँीर््री र्ऽीभन् प्र॰ प्रन् झ्ध् न्र् ीय् ॉञर्ईीऽँ २न्ध्ञर् ीर् ँीई २भञन्ए र्ईी न्ध्र् ॉीञर् ॉी०ई न् ॰ध्र् ँीञ्रध्ण्
्ण् ऽींर्र्५ीीॉ ञ प्रर्ञीर्ह्यीण् प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय्एर् ीप्रैप्रईए प्रँर्९ी र्ञीईर् ी ँ॰ र्ञीई र्र्५ीीॉध् प्रर्ञीर्र्ह्यीीर्क्तीध् २र्न्ीञ्रण् ॰ध्र्र्ीिंय् र्र्५ीीप्रैई प्र९ए प्रँर्९ी र्ञीईर् ी ँ॰ र्ञीई ध्र्र् ॉीीह्म र्र्५ीीॉ ॉप्रप्रई र्ईी ९र्र्ीिंीं र्र्५ीीप्रैई प्र९ए ॉञष्प्रर्क्तीई र्ञीई ींऊर् ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ध्ऽप्रईप्रन्घई ींऊर् ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ऽींर्र्५ीीॉप्रर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् २र्न्ीञ्रण्
अर्ण्ि ॉर्ी ध्र् ॉीप्र०ईण् प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ॉञ्रय् र्य्ीन्ध् ध्र् ॉीञएर् ी र्ईी प्रींप्रघईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् र्उीर्न्ी र्य्ीन्ध्र् ीय र्ऽी र्य्ीन्ध् र्उीर्न्ी प्रींप्रघईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी प्र९प्रई ञ र् ीॉ ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰न्यर् ी र्य्ीन्ध् र्उीर्न्ी र् ीॉ ईर् ी झ्ीं्रर्ईी न् र्५ीई प्रॉध् झ्ध् ॉर् ॉी०ई ध्र् ँी ॉञ्रध्ण्
अअण् ॉर्ी ध्र्र् ॉीीह्म र्५ीर्ईण् "न् र्प्रीञ ञ न्}९प्रई ॉ प्रझ्ह्मर् ॉी ध् र्५ीर्ई २न्ध्ञ २र्न्ीञ्रध्र् ँी प्रर् ीप्रैप्रईए प्रँर्९ी र्ञीई र्ऽी ँ॰ र्ञीई ऽह्म र्य्ीप्रर्न्ीञर् ी र्९ी्रट्ट २भन्ण्
अूण् ऽध्९ण् "न् र्प्रीञ ऽर्क्तीध्र् ीप्रन्ई प्रॉध् र्ऽी॰र्५ी प्रस्ीन् ऽध्९ए ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् २र्न्ी्रध्ण्
अगण् प्रय्ण् प्र॰ "न् र्प्रीञ प्रय् ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञर् ी"य्न् ५ न्॰झ्ट्टई २र्न्ीर्ईी २र्न्ीए र्ईी न्ॉ र्र्५ीीॉर् ी प्रप्र॰य्ब्न् र्प्रीर् ँीर््रीए प्रँॉ न् र्न्ॉी प्रप्रप्र५ ऽञप्रई २र्न्ीर््रीण्र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1891 अलण् प्रर्५ीप्र९ध्न्र्ह्यीण् "न् र्प्रीञ ञ ॰ध् ्र"य्न् प्रॉध् र्ष्ीईर् ी २न् ऽय् २न्ध्ञ ९र्र््रीीर् ँीर््री प्र २न् ॉ प्रघई र् ी९ ञए र्प्रँॉी प्र र्९ी्रट्ट २र्न्ीई २भञन्ए ॉध् न्ध्प्रई ॉर् ीर्य्ी२न्ध् न् ध् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ ध् र्५ीप्रघईर् ीएर् ँी न्ॉ न्प्रई र्ऽीभन् र्ह्मीॉञ्रई ईध्ई २र्न्ीए ॉध्प्रईर् ी न्ईध् २भन्—
न्ह्मईींर् ी"य्र् ीर्९ी ॉध् न्ध्प्रई ॉ २न्ध्ञ प्रर्र्न्ीीर् ँीर््रीएर् ँी प्र "न् र्प्रीञ ञ न्ष्ञप्रर्क्तीई न्ध्प्रई ध् र्र्ऽीी न्ॉ प्र९ ऽींट्ट९ २र्न्ीण्
अ्रण् प्रन्ॉ र्ऽीभन्र् ीट्ठर्प्रीण्"न् र्प्रीञ ईर्ह्नैीध् र्ऽीभन् "न् र्प्रीञ र् ीञन्झ् २र्न्ी न्ध् ट्टय् र्ट्ठी ॉैई प्रए "न् र्प्रीञ ऽञई्रय्ई र्ऽीर् ी९ प्रर्ऽीञ ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी प्रन्प्रॉई प्रर् ँीई २भञन्—
न्ह्मईीं "न्ॉर् ीन् प्रन्प्रॉई र्प्रीञ ऽर्क्तीध् र्प्री र््रीर् ी"य्न् झ्ध् र्ऽी॰र्५ीर् ी ध् ्र"य्न्र् ीर्य्ी२न्ध्ए "न् र्प्रीञ ईर्ह्नैीध् न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ ऽर्क्तीध् प्रर्॰ी र््री र्ऽी॰र्५ीर् ी ध् ्र"य्न्र् ीर्य्ी२न्ध्र् ॉीध्र् ँी्रध्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्झ्ी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
र्ईीन्र् ीर्५ी प्रॉह्म२र्न्ीए न्.ॉप्रण्
ऽींॉट्टध् ख् प्र ू ;द्ध ञ ्र ॰प्र ,
ॉण् ण् प्रर्र्५ीी ;ञण्द्ध ॉञ्रय् र्ईी
प्रींप्रघईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्
द्य ऽय् ईध् ध्र् ॉी ऽप्रर्क्ती द्य ॉ द्व ऽय् ष्ध्र् ॉी र्ीर्९ीञर् ी र्ईी ऽप्रर्क्तीर् ीर्९ीञर् ी र्ईी
;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध अण् र्ीर्ऊीर्ईी ;र्ञीईद्ध ्रगर्र्.ििअ्रर्.िद्वगर्र्िि द्यर्र्र्.िििूर्र्.ििगर्र्र्ऱ्ल्रििििर्र्िि प्रँर्९ी र्ञीई ध्र्र् ॉीीह्म
ऽर्क्ती र्र्झ्ीीण् र्र्५ीीॉ ॉप्रप्रईण् ूण् प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध ल्रर्र्.ििअू्र.द्यर्र्र्ििि क्ष्र्र्र्.िििअद्य्र.ू्रर्र्ऱ्ग्रिििर्र्िि प्रँर्९ी र्ञीई ध्र्र् ॉीीह्म
ऽर्क्ती र्र्झ्ीीण् र्र्५ीीॉ ॉप्रप्रईण् गण् ॉ२र्न्ी प्रर्र्५ीी ;र्ञीईद्ध गद्वर्र्.ििअर्र्.्रििद्वर्र्िि ्रर्र्र्.िििअ्रर्.िूर्र्र्ऱ्ू्रििििर्र्िि ँ॰ र्ञीई ध्र्र् ॉीीह्म
ऽर्क्ती र्र्झ्ीीण् र्र्५ीीॉ ॉप्रप्रईण्
र्ी र्न्ीींन्ए प्रर्॰ी ूक्ष् ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञध्ञण्ध्ञर््रीप्रप्रध्ूूध्ूर्अिद्वध्अूूद्वण्र्झ्ीन्ई ॉञप्रर्र्क्तीी ऽींट्ठ{न्॰ गलद्व ञत्र्न् ;गद्ध ऽींॉन्र्ह्यी ञ "न्ॉ प्रर्झ्ी्र ध् ऽप्रर्क्तीॉर्ट्टी र्ीञध्ञण्ध्ञर््रीप्रप्रध्ूूध्ूर्अिद्वध्अूूद्यए प्रर्॰ीञ ूक्ष्.र्द्यि.ूर्अिद्वर् ी ऽञ्रँध् र्ऽींी॰ र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्५ीई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्झ्ी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
र्ईीन्र् ीर्५ी प्रॉह्म२र्न्ीए न्.ॉप्रण्
Naya Raipur, the 26 July 2018
No./P./PGVV/22/2018/1227/The following draft of the Chhattisgarh Teacher (Panchayat) Cadre (General Conditions of Service) Rules, 2018, which the State Government proposes to make in exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 95 read with sub-section (1) of Section 70 and sub-section (1) of section 53 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993 (No.1 of 1994), is hereby, published as required by sub-section (3) of Section 95 of the said Adhiniyam, for the information of all persons likely to be affected thereby and notice is{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1892 hereby given that the said draft shall be taken into consideration after the expiry of fifteen days from the date of publication of this notification in the Official Gazette.
Any objection or suggestions regarding the said draft received from any person, before the specified period, in office hours by the office of the Secretary, Government of Chhattisgarh, Department of Panchayat & Rural Devel- opment, (Room No. S0-24), Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya, Naya Raipur shall be considered by the Government of Chhattisgarh.
DRAFT RULES
1. Short Title and Commencement.—
(1) These rules may be called the Chhattisgarh Teacher [Panchayat] Cadre [General Conditions of service] Rules, 2018.
(2) These rules shall come into force from the date of its publication in the Official Gazette.
2. Definitions.— In these rules, unless the context otherwise requires;
(a) "Act" means the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993 (No. 1 of 1994); (b) "Appointing Authority" in respect of Teacher [Panchayat] Cadre means such authority as specified in column (5) of Schedule;
(c) "Government" means the Government of Chhattisgarh; (d) "Panchayat" means Zila Panchayat, Janpad Panchayat or Gram Panchayat, as the case may be, constituted under the Act;
(e) "Schedule" means a Schedule appended to these rules; (f) "Teacher [Panchayat] Cadre" means person appointed for teaching in schools under con- trol of Zila Panchayat or Janpad Panchayat, as the case may be.
(2) The words and expressions used but not defined in these rules shall have the same meaning as assigned to them in the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993 (No. 1 of 1994).
3. Scope and application -Without prejudice to the generality of the provisions contained in the Chhattisgarh Civil Service (General Conditions of Service) Rules, 1961, these rules shall apply to every member of the Service.
4. Constitution of the service.— The service shall consist of the following persons, namely:—
(1) Persons, who at the commencement of these rules are holding substantively or in officiating capac- ity the posts specified in Schedule;
(2) Persons, recruited to the service before the commencement of these rules.
5. Classification and scale of pay.— The classification of the service and the scale of pay attached thereto shall be in accordance with the provisions contained in the Schedule.
6. Absorption.— As and when an employee of the teacher (Panchayat) cadre completes eight years of the service, he/she will be absorbed as government teachers under the School Education Department. 7. Compassionate Appointment.— On the death of the teacher (Panchayat) cadre during his/her services, eligible dependent will be given compassionate appointment, as Assistant Teacher (Panchayat) on fulfilling the eligibility criteria:
Provided that, for compassionate appointment to the post of Assistant Teacher (Panchayat); Higher Secondary, D.Ed./B.EL.ED and Teacher Eligibility (TET) must have been passed by the dependent seeking such appointment.
8. Probation.—
(1) The employee who were appointed to the post of teacher (Panchayat) cadre before the implementation of this rule, and whose probation period has not expired, will remain in probation for a period of two years, which may be extended to a five years. The Appointing Authority will assess the work of the employees of the teacher (Panchayat) cadre at the end of each year.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1893(2) After the probation period of two years, on the basis of conduct and work of the employee of the Teacher (Panchayat) cadre, the Panchayat may terminate the probation period. In case the work of the employee of the Teacher (Panchayat) cadre is not found to be satisfactory, the probation period may be extended from one the three years. Thereafter, their work shall be assessed at the end of the such extended period and if their works are not found to be satisfactory, then their services shall be terminated.
9. Discipline and Control.— The Teacher (Panchayat) cadre shall be under the administrative control of Zila Panchayat or Janpad panchayat, as the case may be. For major punishment, the General Administrative Committee of Zila panchayat or Janpad panchayat and for minor punishment, the Chief Executive Officer/ Additional Chief Executive Officer of concerned Panchayat shall be the disciplinary authority.
10. Termination Of Service.— Services of the employee of the Teacher (Panchayat) cadre may be terminated at any time by giving one month notice in writing either by the Appointing Authority to the employee; or by employee to the Appointing Authority; or after the depositing one month salary by the employee.
11. General Conditions of Service.— Conditions of service other than mentioned in this rules shall be the same, as applicable to other employee of Zila Panchayat or Janpad Panchayat, as the case may be.
12. Appeal.— An appeal against any order passed under these rules shall be in accordance with the provisions of the Act.
13. Interpretation.— If any question arises relating to the interpretation of these rules, the same shall be referred to the Government, whose decision thereon shall be final.
14. Relaxation.—Nothing in these rules shall be construed to limit or abridge the powers of the Governor to deal with the case of any person to whom these rules apply in such manner as may appear to him to be just and proper:
Provided that any case shall not be dealt with in any manner less favorable to him, than those provided in these rules.
15. Repeal and Saving.-—All rules corresponding to these rules and in force immediately before the com- mencement of these rules are hereby repealed in respect of matters covered by these rules:
Provided that any order made or any action taken under the rules so repealed shall be deemed to have been made or taken under the corresponding provisions of these rules.
By order and in the name of the Governor of Chhattisgarh,
TARAN PARKASH SINHA, Deputy Secretary.
SECHEDULE
[ See rules 2 (b) and 5 ]
S. No. Teacher (Panchayat) Pay Scale Appointing Authority cadre Pay scale of service Pay scale of service period
period up to 7 years between 7 to 8 years
(1) (2)
(3)
(4)
(5) 1. Lecturer (Panchayat) 5300-150-8300 7000-200-30000+4500 The general adminis-
Teaching Allowance trative committee of
Zila Panchayat.
2. Teacher (Panchayat) 4500-125-7000 6000-175-25000+3500 The general adminis-
Teaching Allowance trative committee of
Zila Panchayat.
3. Assistant Teacher 3800-100-5800 5000-150-20000+2500 The general adminis- (Panchayat)
Teaching Allowance trative committee of
Janpad Panchayat.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1894र्न्ीैँ प्रर्झ्ी्र र्र्ीीय्९ए ९घन्न्ए प्रँर्९ीर् ीन्र्ष्ीए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ॰ न्.ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र
र्ीन्र्ष्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ग ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीड.
;प्र अअ ॰प्रद्ध
र्ीञध्अअलअ्रध्ध्झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ध्र्गि ऽध्द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्झ्ट्टप्र.ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ ञ ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ईीर् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईी र्ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ल ॉ२न्प्रन्ई प्र द्य ऽञई्रय्ई ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ञ न्}९प्रई झ्ट्टप्रर् ी ऽँय् र्९ीर् ीँ २न्ईीं र्न्ीद्द ॉर्न्ीन् र्उीर्न्ी र्ऽीर्५ीप्रई २भन्ए र्ऽीय्ई —
प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ र््रीध््रन् र्र्ीी९ र्९ीर् ीँर् ी प्रन्र्ह्यी ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध
र्ीन्र्ष्ी न्ईर्९ी न्२न्न्ींर्त्र्ी र्ण्र््रद्यिि २न्ण् प्रर्ध्ीर्ईी ;२न्ॉ॰द्ध र्ष्ीञर््री प्रर्र्न्ीँी न्२न्न्ींर्त्र्ी न् ई२न्ण् ष्र्न्ी९ध्
र् ी"न् २न्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यीण्
न्र्न्ीघई न्}९प्रई झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय् २न्ईींर्र् ॉीीप्रँर् ॉीर्र्र्ीिंीई प्रर्र्क्तीीय्न्र्ह्यी ऽक्त २न्ईीं ँर् ॉींी"य्न् प्रर्॰ीञ ूद्य.र्द्यि.ूर्अिद्वर् ी ॉ अूण्र्र् ििष्ँ ॉर् ैी र््री न्२न्न्ींर्त्र्ी प्रई ध् ्र"य्न् २भन्ण् ैर्ईीप्रई झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्र् ी ऽह्म प्रन्र्ह्यी प्रर्र्ट्टीींॉीन् २भन् —
अण् र्९ीर् ीँर् ी ॉञर्प्री०ई प्रन्र्ह्यी प्रर्ध्ीर्ईी ;२न्ॉ॰द्ध र्ष्ीञर््री प्रर्र्न्ीँी न्२न्न्ींर्त्र्ी
र्ी"न्न् २न्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यीण्
ूण् र्ह्नी ड ॉ र्झ्ीप्रई प्रर्न्ीर्न्ीञ ध् ॉञर्ऊी र्अि
गण् ऽर्ह्नी ड ॉ र्झ्ीप्रई प्रर्न्ीर्न्ीञ ध् ॉञर्ऊी प्रञन्
लण् र्झ्ीप्रईर्र् ीी ञ प्रँध्र्र् ीीञ र्ईी ऽह्म प्रन्ॉट्टर्र्प्रीीञ प्रञन्
ध् र्ऽींीप्रई ॉञर्ऊीण्
्रण् र्झ्ीप्रईर्र् ीी ञ र्र्५ीीॉध्र्र् ीीञ र्ईी ऽह्म प्रञन्
प्रन्ॉट्टर्र्प्रीीञ ध् र्ऽींीप्रई ॉञर्ऊीण्
क्ष्ण् र्घी ैर्ईीप्रई ऽँय् ह्मट्टई २भन् घ् २र्न्ीञ
द्यण् र्घी ॉञझ् प्रर्}ीञ र्ऽीभन् "न्ॉध्र् ॉीक्तर्ईी न् र्प्रीन् २र्न्ीञ
न् प्रर्९ी र््री २भन् घ्
द्वण् प्रर्र्न्ीँी ध् ीं९ र्९ी्रई ल्ूण्गअ र्९ी
्ण् प्रर्र्न्ीँी ॉ २र्न्ीर् ीर्९ी र्९ीझ् प्रॉर्ञी"य्न् २न्ईीं
अर्ण्ि ैर्ईीप्रईर्र् ॉीीप्रँर् ॉीर्र्र्ीिंीई ध् प्रईट्टप्रईय् प्र९ ैर्ईीप्रई र्र् ॉीीप्रँ र् ॉीर्र्र्ीिंीई ध् प्रईट्टप्रईय् प्र९ र्न्ी ई न्ॉ न् २र्न्ीर् ीर्९ी ॉञर्झ्ीप्रई ण् ॉञर्झ्ीप्रई र्न्ी प्रर् ँी न्२न् २भञन्ण् "न्ॉ २न्ईींर् ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए २न्ॉ॰ २न्न् ँ९ ष्ञर्क्ती ॉञर्झ्ी्रर् ँीञँ्रध्न् र्उीर्न्ी र्न्ीप्रर्५ी ्रण्र्र् िि र्९ीर् ी झ्ीं्रर्ईी र् ीञ ूक्ष्अ्द्य्र प्रर्॰ीञ अ्र.र्क्ष्.िूर्अिद्व र् ीक्त ॉर् ँी र्प्री र््री २भन्ण् अअन् प्रर्र्न्ीँी र्उीर्न्ी र्झ्ीप्रई २र्न्ीर् ी९ ऽह्म र्र्ीिंन् प्रञन्
न्र्न्ीघई झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय् ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ प्रॉध् प्रघईध्ॉर्ञैीर् ी ऽह्म प्रॉध् प्रघईर् ीर् ी"य्न्र्र् ँीीन्ध्र्र्ध्ॉींीी र्॰ी २र्न्ीए र्ईी प्रप्र२न्ई प्रईप्रध्ॉ ञर् ैी न् ॰ध्र् ँी ॉ्रध्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
र्ीण् भॉन् ऽन्न॰ीं९ २न्ए ९घन्न् ञ ॰ न्.ॉप्रण्र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1895 र्र्ीीय्९ए ९घन्न्ए प्रँर्९ी प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ॰ न्.ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र
प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूग ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीड.
;प्र अअ ॰प्रद्ध
र्ीञध्ू्रद्यध्झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ध्ऽण्प्रण्ऽण्ध्ूर्अिद्वण्झ्ट्टप्र.ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ ञ ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ईीर् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ल ॉ२न्प्रन्ई प्र द्य ऽञई्रय्ई ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ञ न्}९प्रई झ्ट्टप्रर् ी ऽँय् र्९ीर् ीँ २न्ईीं र्न्ीद्द ॉर्न्ीन् र्उीर्न्ी र्ऽीर्५ीप्रई २भन्ए र्ऽीय्ई —
प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ र््रीध््रन् र्र्ीी९ र्९ीर् ीँर् ी प्रन्र्ह्यी ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध
प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् र्ीर्न्ीन् ञर््रीन्ध् र्ण्र्क्ष्र्ििि न्ईींन्र्.ीर्न्ी.र्९ीन्ध्र् ी्रय्र् ी न्ह्म ञ ींप्रर्य्ीर्ह्यी
र्ीय् २न्ईींण्
न्र्न्ीघई न्}९प्रई झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय् २न्ईींर्र् ॉीीप्रँर् ॉीर्र्र्ीिंीई प्रर्र्क्तीीय्न्र्ह्यी ऽक्त २न्ईीं ँर् ॉींी"य्न् ;प्रर्॰ीञद्ध गर्.िर्द्यि.ूर्अिद्वर् ी ;ॉद्ध अअण्र्र् ििष्ँ र्;ैीद्ध र््री र्ञीई झ्ए ञर््रीन्ध् न् प्रई ध् ्र"य्न् २भन्ण् ैर्ईीप्रई झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्र् ी ऽह्म प्रन्र्ह्यी प्रर्र्ट्टीींॉीन् २भन् —
;द्ध र्९ीर् ीँर् ी ॉञर्प्री०ई प्रन्र्ह्यी न्ईींन्र्.ीर्न्ी.र्९ीन्ध्र् ी्रय्र् ी न्ह्म ञ ींप्रर्य्ीर्ह्यीण् ;र्॰ीद्ध र्ह्नी ड ॉ र्झ्ीप्रई प्रर्न्ीर्न्ीञ ध् ॉञर्ऊी र्ूि
;ईध्द्ध ऽर्ह्नी ड ॉ र्झ्ीप्रई प्रर्न्ीर्न्ीञ ध् ॉञर्ऊी
र्;ीन्द्ध र्झ्ीप्रईर्र् ीी ञ प्रँध्र्र् ीीञ र्ईी ऽह्म प्रन्ॉट्टर्र्प्रीीञ प्रञन्
ध् र्ऽींीप्रई ॉञर्ऊीण्
र्;ीञद्ध र्झ्ीप्रईर्र् ीी ञ र्र्५ीीॉध्र्र् ीीञ र्ईी ऽह्म प्रञन्
प्रन्ॉट्टर्र्प्रीीञ ध् र्ऽींीप्रई ॉञर्ऊीण्
;{न्—द्ध र्घी ैर्ईीप्रई ऽँय् ह्मट्टई २भन् घ् २र्न्ीञ
र्;ॉीईद्ध र्घी ॉञझ् प्रर्}ीञ र्ऽीभन् "न्ॉध्र् ॉीक्तर्ईी न् र्प्रीन् २र्न्ीञ.न्}९प्रई झ्ट्टप्र न्र् ी्रय्र् ी न्ह्म ञ ींप्रर्य्ीर्ह्यी न् प्रर्९ी र््री २भन् घ्
र्ीय् २न्ईीं ैर्ईीप्रई २भन्ण्
;र्ऽीन्द्ध प्रर्र्न्ीँी ध् ीं९ र्९ी्रई अूद्वण्क्ष्् र्न्ीत्र्
र्;ीभद्ध प्रर्र्न्ीँी ॉ २र्न्ीर् ीर्९ी र्९ीझ्
;॰ॉद्ध ैर्ईीप्रईर्र् ॉीीप्रँर् ॉीर्र्र्ीिंीई ध् प्रईट्टप्रईय् प्र९ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ईीर् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र. र्न्ी ई न्ॉ न् २र्न्ीर् ीर्९ी ॉञर्झ्ीप्रई ण् ूर्अिग र्उीर्न्ी ॰र्र्५ीीय्ध् ्र"य्न् र्ईी ॉ.ॉ न् {न्ण््रण् र्र्५ीीॉ र्उीर्न्ी ष्र्र्ईीी र््रीन् र्न्ीर् ी र्ऽींी९ र्प्रीर् ँीर््री र्ईी ॉञर्झ्ीप्रई स्ण्र् ीञ र्९ीर् ीर् ीैईप्र र् ँी झ्ध् ऽप्रर्क्ती २र्न्ीण्
र्;ीिंन्२न्द्ध प्रर्र्न्ीँी र्उीर्न्ी र्झ्ीप्रई २र्न्ीर् ी९ ऽह्म र्र्ीिंन् प्रञन्
न्र्न्ीघई झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय् ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ प्रॉध् प्रघईध्ॉर्ञैीर् ी ऽह्म प्रॉध् प्रघईर् ीर् ी"य्न्र्र् ँीीन्ध्र्र्ध्ॉींीी र्॰ी २र्न्ीए र्ईी प्रप्र२न्ई प्रईप्रध्ॉ ञर् ैी न् ॰ध्र् ँी ॉ्रध्ण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1896 प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूग ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीड.
;प्र अअ ॰प्रद्ध
र्ीञध्ू्रद्वध्झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ध्ऽण्प्रण्ऽण्ध्ूर्अिद्वण्झ्ट्टप्र.ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ ञ ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ईीर् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ल ॉ२न्प्रन्ई प्र द्य ऽञई्रय्ई ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ञ न्}९प्रई झ्ट्टप्रर् ी ऽँय् र्९ीर् ीँ २न्ईीं र्न्ीद्द ॉर्न्ीन् र्उीर्न्ी र्ऽीर्५ीप्रई २भन्ए र्ऽीय्ई —
प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ र््रीध््रन् र्र्ीी९ र्९ीर् ीँर् ी प्रन्र्ह्यी ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध
प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् र्ीर्न्ीन् र्ीर्न्ी अण्द्वर््ि न्ईींन्र्.ीर्न्ी.र्९ीन्ध्र् ी्रय्र् ी न्ह्म ञ ींप्रर्य्ीर्ह्यी
र्ीय् २न्ईींण्
न्र्न्ीघई न्}९प्रई झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय् २न्ईींर्र् ॉीीप्रँर् ॉीर्र्र्ीिंीई प्रर्र्क्तीीय्न्र्ह्यी ऽक्त प्र९ ँर् ॉींी"य्न् ;प्रर्॰ीञद्ध द्व.द्व.ूर्अिद्वर् ी ;ॉद्ध अअण्र्र् ििष्ँ र्;ैीद्ध ह्यत्र्न्ध्र् ीञ्रर्ह्यीर् ीर्न्ी न् प्रई ध् ्र"य्न् २भन्ण् ैर्ईीप्रई झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्र् ी ऽह्म प्रन्र्ह्यी प्रर्र्ट्टीींॉीन् २भन् —
;द्ध र्९ीर् ीँर् ी ॉञर्प्री०ई प्रन्र्ह्यी न्ईींन्र्.ीर्न्ी.र्९ीन्ध्र् ी्रय्र् ी न्ह्म ञ ींप्रर्य्ीर्ह्यीण् ;र्॰ीद्ध र्ह्नी ड ॉ र्झ्ीप्रई प्रर्न्ीर्न्ीञ ध् ॉञर्ऊी अल
;ईध्द्ध ऽर्ह्नी ड ॉ र्झ्ीप्रई प्रर्न्ीर्न्ीञ ध् ॉञर्ऊी प्रञन्
र्;ीन्द्ध र्झ्ीप्रईर्र् ीी ञ प्रँध्र्र् ीीञ र्ईी ऽह्म प्रन्ॉट्टर्र्प्रीीञ प्रञन्
ध् र्ऽींीप्रई ॉञर्ऊीण्
र्;ीञद्ध र्झ्ीप्रईर्र् ीी ञ र्र्५ीीॉध्र्र् ीीञ र्ईी ऽह्म प्रञन्
प्रन्ॉट्टर्र्प्रीीञ ध् र्ऽींीप्रई ॉञर्ऊीण्
;{न्—द्ध र्घी ैर्ईीप्रई ऽँय् ह्मट्टई २भन् घ् २र्न्ीञ
र्;ॉीईद्ध र्घी ॉञझ् प्रर्}ीञ र्ऽीभन् "न्ॉध्र् ॉीक्तर्ईी न् र्प्रीन् २र्न्ीञ न्}९प्रई झ्ट्टप्र न्र् ी्रय्र् ी न्ह्म ञ ींप्रर्य्ीर्ह्यी न् प्रर्९ी र््री २भन् घ्
र्ीय् २न्ईीं ैर्ईीप्रई २भन्ण्
;र्ऽीन्द्ध प्रर्र्न्ीँी ध् ीं९ र्९ी्रई अूद्वण्क्ष्् र्न्ीत्र्
र्;ीभद्ध प्रर्र्न्ीँी ॉ २र्न्ीर् ीर्९ी र्९ीझ्
;॰ॉद्ध ैर्ईीप्रईर्र् ॉीीप्रँर् ॉीर्र्र्ीिंीई ध् प्रईट्टप्रईय् प्र९ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ईीर् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र. र्न्ी ई न्ॉ न् २र्न्ीर् ीर्९ी ॉञर्झ्ीप्रई ण् ूर्अिग र्उीर्न्ी ॰र्र्५ीीय्ध् ्र"य्न् र्ईी ॉ.ॉ न् {न्ण््रण् र्र्५ीीॉ र्उीर्न्ी ष्र्र्ईीी र््रीन् र्न्ीर् ी र्ऽींी९ र्प्रीर् ँीर््री र्ईी ॉञर्झ्ीप्रई स्ण्र् ीञ र्९ीर् ीर् ीैईप्र र् ँी झ्ध् ऽप्रर्क्ती २र्न्ीण्
र्;ीिंन्२न्द्ध प्रर्र्न्ीँी र्उीर्न्ी र्झ्ीप्रई २र्न्ीर् ी९ ऽह्म र्र्ीिंन् प्रञन्
न्र्न्ीघई झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय् ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ प्रॉध् प्रघईध्ॉर्ञैीर् ी ऽह्म प्रॉध् प्रघईर् ीर् ी"य्न्र्र् ँीीन्ध्र्र्ध्ॉींीी र्॰ी २र्न्ीए र्ईी प्रप्र२न्ई प्रईप्रध्ॉ ञर् ैी न् ॰ध्र् ँी ॉ्रध्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
ध्ण् र्॰ीञ॰ए ९घन्न् ञ ॰ न्.ॉप्रण्र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1897 र्र्ीीय्९ए ९घन्न्ए प्रँर्९ी ष्ईर्न्ीएन् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ॰ न्.ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र
ष्ईर्न्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ू् ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञध्र्अिध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिक्ष्.अद्यण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध् ँर्ीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध ष्ईर्न्ी ष्न्र्९ीन् ९र्ञँीर्न्ी र्ण्र्क्ष््िि ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ;र्न्ीण्द्ध ९र्ञँीर्न्ी . र्ईीर्न्ी९ध् .
ण्२न्ण्ञण् अक्ष् ञ झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ष्न्र्९ी ष्न्र्९ीर् ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यीण्
;{न्ण््रण्द्धण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ष्न्र्९ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
ष्ईर्न्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ू् ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञध्र््रध्ऽि.द्वूध्ूर्अिक्ष्.अद्यण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध् ँर्ीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध ष्ईर्न्ी ष्न्र्९ीन् ट्ट२न्प्रर्न्ी र्ण्र््र्िि ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ;र्न्ीण्द्ध ॉर्ी३न् .श्न् . ॰न्ष्र्ध्ँी ण्२न्ण्ञण् र्गि ञ झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ष्न्र्९ी र्ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यीण् ;{न्ण््रण्द्धण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ष्न्र्९ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1898 ष्ईर्न्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ू् ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व र्ीञध्र्क्ष्ध्ऽि.द्वूध्ूर्अिक्ष्.अद्यण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध् ँर्ीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध ष्ईर्न्ी ष्न्र्९ीन् ॰न्ष्र्ध्ँी र्ण्ग्रिल ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ;र्न्ीण्द्ध ॉर्ी३न् .श्न् . ॰न्ष्र्ध्ँी ण्२न्ण्ञण् र्अि ञ झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ष्न्र्९ी र्ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यीण् ;{न्ण््रण्द्धण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ष्न्र्९ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
ष्ईर्न्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ू् ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञध्र्द्यिध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिक्ष्.अद्यण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध् ँर्ीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध ष्ईर्न्ी ष्न्र्९ीन् श्न् र्ण्र्द्वििद्य ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ;र्न्ीण्द्ध ॉर्ी३न् .श्न् . ॰न्ष्र्ध्ँी ण्२न्ण्ञण् र््ि ञ झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ष्न्र्९ी र्ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यीण् ;{न्ण््रण्द्धण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ष्न्र्९ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1899 ष्ईर्न्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ू् ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व र्ीञध्र्द्विध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिक्ष्.अद्यण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध् ँर्ीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध ष्ईर्न्ी ष्न्र्९ीन् प्रॉर्न्ॉी र्ण्गिद्वू ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ;र्न्ीण्द्ध ॉर्ी३न् .श्न् . ॰न्ष्र्ध्ँी ण्२न्ण्ञण् अर्ि ञ झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ष्न्र्९ी र्ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यीण् ;{न्ण््रण्द्धण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ष्न्र्९ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
ष्ईर्न्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ू् ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञध्अर्ध्ऽि.द्वूध्ूर्अिक्ष्.अद्यण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध् ँर्ीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध ष्ईर्न्ी ष्न्र्९ीन् प्रॉञर्र्र्ीिंीभन्ध् र्ण्गिअर्ि ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ;र्न्ीण्द्ध ॉर्ी३न् .श्न् . ॰न्ष्र्ध्ँी ण्२न्ण्ञण् अर्ि ञ झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ष्न्र्९ी र्ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यीण् ;{न्ण््रण्द्धण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ष्न्र्९ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1900 ष्ईर्न्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ू् ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व र्ीञध्अअध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिक्ष्.अद्यण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध् ँर्ीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध ष्ईर्न्ी ष्न्र्९ीन् ॉर्ी३न् र्ण्क्ष्अिल ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ;र्न्ीण्द्ध ॉर्ी३न् .श्न् . ॰न्ष्र्ध्ँी ण्२न्ण्ञण् अल ञ झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्ए ष्न्र्९ी र्ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यीण् ;{न्ण््रण्द्धण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ष्न्र्९ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
२र्न्ी॰र् ीश्न्ए ९घन्न् ञ ॰ न्.ॉप्रण् र्र्ीीय्९ए ९घन्न्ए प्रँर्९ी र्क्तीईन्ध्एन् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ॰ ॉञींघई ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र
र्क्तीईन्ध्न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अ्र ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व
न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ ूद्वध््रग्रलध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्क्तीईन्ध् ींड॰न् र्झ्ीर्न्ी ूण्गल र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए र्९ी र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी र्झ्ीर्न्ी र्र्ष्ीीॉ र् ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण् ण्२न्ण्ञण् अद्य ॉट्टर्झ्ी्रए र्क्तीईन्ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ींड॰न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1901
र्क्तीईन्ध्न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अ्र ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व
न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ ू्ध््रग्र्रध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्क्तीईन्ध् ींड॰न् प्रॉ२र्न्ी॰ लण्अर्ि र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए र्९ी र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी र्झ्ीर्न्ी र्र्ष्ीीॉ र् ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण् ण्२न्ण्ञण् अ् ॉट्टर्झ्ी्रए र्क्तीईन्ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ींड॰न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
ॉध्ण् र्ऽीन्ण् ॉर्ह्मीए ९घन्न् ञ ॰ ॉञींघई ॉप्रण् र्र्ीीय्९ए ९घन्न्ए प्रँर्९ी र्न्ी्र३न्एन् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ॰ न्.ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र
र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अअ ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ ूअध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्न्ी्र३न् र्ईीन् र्ीभ२र्र्न्ीी९ध् र्ण््िक्ष्क्ष् ऽन् २र्न्ीष्ञर्क्तीए ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् श्न्९ र्९ी"य्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण्
प्रईर्९ी"य्र्न्ी९ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्ध ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् र्न्ीैँए र्र्ीिंन्र्र्र्ीिंीर्त्र्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्॰ीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1902 र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अअ ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ ूूध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्न्ी्र३न् र्ईीन् र्र्न्ीी९ अण्क्ष््रग ऽन् २र्न्ीष्ञर्क्तीए ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् श्न्९ र्९ी"य्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण्
प्रईर्९ी"य्र्न्ी९ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्ध ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् र्न्ीैँए र्र्ीिंन्र्र्र्ीिंीर्त्र्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्॰ीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अअ ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ ूगध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्न्ी्र३न् र्ईीन् ट्ट॰न्२र्न्ी ूण््र्ल ऽन् २र्न्ीष्ञर्क्तीए ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् श्न्९ र्९ी"य्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण्
प्रईर्९ी"य्र्न्ी९ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्ध ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् र्न्ीैँए र्र्ीिंन्र्र्र्ीिंीर्त्र्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्॰ीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1903 र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अअ ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ ूलध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्न्ी्र३न् र्ईीन् र्ष्ी"य्न् र्ण्अिलग ऽन् २र्न्ीष्ञर्क्तीए ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् श्न्९ र्९ी"य्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण्
प्रईर्९ी"य्र्न्ी९ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्ध ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् र्न्ीैँए र्र्ीिंन्र्र्र्ीिंीर्त्र्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्॰ीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अअ ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ लअध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्न्ी्र३न् र्ईीन् त्र्र्न्ी९ॉर्न्ी अण्अद्यू ऽन् २र्न्ीष्ञर्क्तीए ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् श्न्९ र्९ी"य्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण्
प्रईर्९ी"य्र्न्ी९ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्ध ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् र्न्ीैँए र्र्ीिंन्र्र्र्ीिंीर्त्र्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्॰ीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1904 र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अअ ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ लूध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्न्ी्र३न् र्ईीन् र्न्ीर्न्ी अण्द्वक्ष्र्ि ऽन् २र्न्ीष्ञर्क्तीए ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् श्न्९ र्९ी"य्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण्
प्रईर्९ी"य्र्न्ी९ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्ध ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् र्न्ीैँए र्र्ीिंन्र्र्र्ीिंीर्त्र्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्॰ीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अअ ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ लगध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्न्ी्र३न् र्ईीन् ँश्न्र्९ी ूण्लद्वक्ष् ऽन् २र्न्ीष्ञर्क्तीए ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् श्न्९ र्९ी"य्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण्
प्रईर्९ी"य्र्न्ी९ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्ध ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् र्न्ीैँए र्र्ीिंन्र्र्र्ीिंीर्त्र्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्॰ीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1905 र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अअ ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् न्र्ह्यीर् ीञ ल्रध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध र्न्ी्र३न् र्ईीन् ईर्र्न्ीी९ध् र्ण्गि्अ ऽन् २र्न्ीष्ञर्क्तीए ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् ण्न्ध्ण्ध्ण्ॉध्ण् श्न्९ र्९ी"य्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईीं झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ण्
प्रईर्९ी"य्र्न्ी९ध्ण्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्ध ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् र्न्ीैँए र्र्ीिंन्र्र्र्ीिंीर्त्र्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्॰ीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
र्५ीट्टध् र्ऽीप्रष्॰ध्ए ९घन्न् ञ ॰ न्.ॉप्रण् र्र्ीीय्९ए ९घन्न्ए प्रँर्९ीर् ँीञँ्रध्न्र्.ीर्ञीएन् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ॰ न्.ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र
ँर्ीञँ्रध्न्र्.ीर्ञीए प्रर्॰ीञ ूर् िँट्ट ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ र्ूिध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिल.अ्रध्््रूलण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध ँर्ीञँ्रध्न्र्.ीर्ञी ँर्ीञँ्रध्न् ईह्म॰ट्टर्झ्ीर्न्ी र्ण्र्लििर्ि र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईी ;प्रॉञद्धए झ्ट्ट. ू-्रर्र् ििञर्र््रीीन् र्त्र्ी. ण्२न्ण्ञण् लग ऽँय् ॉञर्झ्ी्र ू-्रर्र् ििर्ण्ीण्र्ईीण् ईह्म॰ट्टर्झ्ीर्न्ी र्ईी प्रसींई प्रण्प्रन्ण् र्त्र्ी.ईह्म॰ट्टर्झ्ीर्न्ी ;{न्ण््रण्द्ध प्रर्र्न्ीँी ऽञई्रय्ई र्न्ीत्र् र् ी"य्न् र्९ी"य्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण् झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धएर् ँीञँ्रध्न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
ध्न्ँर् ींीन् र्ष्ॉीत्र्ए ९घन्न् ञ ॰ न्.ॉप्रण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1906 र्र्ीीय्९ए ९घन्न्ए प्रँर्९ी प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्एन् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ॰ न्.ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र
प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूर् ि"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ ूर्गिध्अूध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्व.अ्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ींत्र्"य्न् र्ण््रूि् र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए र्९ी र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी ह्यत्र्र्न्ी र्र्ष्ीीॉ र् ी्रय् ण्२न्ण्ञण् ग प्रर्झ्ी्र ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ॉञर्झ्ी्रए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
प्रँण् प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ;{न्ण््रण्द्ध
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न्न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूर् ि"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ ूर्लिध्अलध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्व.अ्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ह्यत्र्र्न्ी झ्र्॰ीभर्न्ी गण्र्क्ष्गि र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए र्९ी र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी ह्यत्र्र्न्ी र्र्ष्ीीॉ र् ी्रय् ण्२न्ण्ञण् ूअ प्रर्झ्ी्र ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ॉञर्झ्ी्रए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
प्रँण् प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ;{न्ण््रण्द्ध
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1907 प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूर् ि"य्न् ूर्अिद्व र्ीञ ूर््रध्अ्रिध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्व.अ्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ह्यत्र्र्न्ी अद्यण्अगद्व र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए र्९ी र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी ह्यत्र्र्न्ी र्र्ष्ीीॉ र् ी्रय्
ण्२न्ण्ञण् अ प्रर्झ्ी्र ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ॉञर्झ्ी्रए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
प्रँण् प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ;{न्ण््रण्द्ध
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न्न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूर् ि"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ ूर्क्ष्ध्अिर्ध्ऽि.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्व.अ्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ऽत्र्र्झ्ीन् द्यण्द्वद्वअ र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए र्९ी र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी ह्यत्र्र्न्ी र्र्ष्ीीॉ र् ी्रय्
ण्२न्ण्ञण् ग प्रर्झ्ी्र ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ॉञर्झ्ी्रए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
प्रँण् प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ;{न्ण््रण्द्ध
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1908 प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूर् ि"य्न् ूर्अिद्व र्ीञ ूर्द्यिध्द्वध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्व.अ्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ॉर्न्ी अण्र्द्यिर्ि र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए र्९ी र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी ह्यत्र्र्न्ी र्र्ष्ीीॉ र् ी्रय् ण्२न्ण्ञण् ूअ प्रर्झ्ी्र ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ॉञर्झ्ी्रए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
प्रँण् प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ;{न्ण््रण्द्ध
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूर् ि"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ ूर्द्विध्अगध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्व.अ्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ष्ञर्क्तीध् गण्द्यद्वू र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए र्९ी र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी ह्यत्र्र्न्ी र्र्ष्ीीॉ र् ी्रय् ण्२न्ण्ञण् अअ प्रर्झ्ी्र ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ॉञर्झ्ी्रए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
प्रँण् प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ;{न्ण््रण्द्ध
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न्न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1909 प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अअ ँट्ट ूर्अिद्व र्ीञ ूूद्वध्अअध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्व.अ्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी २न् ईध्ई २र्न्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र "ॉॉ ॉ९ िंऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;अद्ध ॉ ;लद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;क्ष्द्ध ञ न्ॉर् ॉी प्र॰ ्रर् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् र्ऽी र्ऽी५र्ईी त्र्न् ध् ॉर्र्झ्ीी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अअ ध् न्.र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ;अद्ध न्ष्ञर्र्क्तीीञ र्ऽींॉीन् ॉझ्ध् ॉञष्ञप्रर्क्तीई प्रर्फीञर् ी "न्ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ध् ॉर्ट्टी ॰ध्र् ँीईध् २भन् प्र र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ ई॰र्उीर्न्ी ऽींॉट्टध् र् ी ;्रद्ध ञ न्}९प्रईर् ीप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध्र् ी न्घई झ्ट्टप्र ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू ऽञई्रय्ई ॰ध् ्रध् र्५ीप्रघर्ईीञर् ीर् ी्र न् प्र९र् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई न्र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय् र् ीर्न्ी अू र्उीर्न्ीर् ीप्रर्क्तीट्ठई र् ॉीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँर्९ी ई२न्ॉध्९ ्रन्ध्र््री ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९ ऽर्प्रीन्ध् र् ी र्ह्यीय्
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ;गद्ध ;लद्ध ;्रद्ध ;क्ष्द्ध प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ऽन्ींन् द्यण््रद्वद्व र्ीर्य्ी९ ऽप्रझ्ञर्ईीए र्९ी र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी ह्यत्र्र्न्ी र्र्ष्ीीॉ र् ी्रय्
ण्२न्ण्ञण् अअ प्रर्झ्ी्र ह्यत्र्र्न्ी ॉञर्झ्ी्रए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण् प्रँण् प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् ;{न्ण््रण्द्ध
झ्ट्टप्रर् ी घर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए ह्यत्र्र्न्ीर्न्ीत्र्न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
र्र्ीीय्९ए ९घन्न्ए प्रँर्९ीर् ीन्र्ष्ीन्ए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ॰ न् ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र र्ीन्र्ष्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ग ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञध्अअलअद्वध्झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ध्र््र िऽ द्वूध्ूर्अ्रि.अक्ष्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी "ॉ र्ष्ीईर् ीर्र् ॉीी २र्न्ी र््री २भन् प्र ध् ॰ध् ्र"य् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;अद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;ूद्ध ञ न्}९प्रई ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्ए ींर्ीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अ् ऽह्मई्रय्ई "ॉ र्उीर्न्ी २न् र्र्र्ीिंीप्रऽई र्प्री ँर्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र न्फ झ्ट्टप्र ध् न्फर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
;अद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय्.
;द्ध प्रँर्९ीर्.ीन्र्ष्ी ;द्ध ई२न्ॉध्९.न्ईर्९ी ;्रद्ध ्रन्ध्र््री.र्न्ीध् ;र्र्ीिंद्ध ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९.र्ण्र्द्वििर् ि२न्घन्न् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
ध्ण् र्॰ीञ॰ए ९घन्न् ञ ॰ न्.ॉप्रण् ॉर्न्ी ट्टष्न् न्र्ष्ी
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
्रर्गि र्ण्र्ूििल ्रर्लि र्ण्र्ूििर्ि ्रर््रध्अि र्ण्र्र्लििि ्रर््रध्ूि र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ्रर््रध्गि र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ्रअअध्अ र्ण्र्अििक्ष् र् ी्र क्ष् र्ण्र्द्वििर्ि ;ूद्ध ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्रँॉ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्. र्ष्ी९ींन्. न्ध्र्र्ञीीन्.र्न्ीध्र्.ॉी२र्न्ी्रींन्र् ी्रय् न्र् ॉी ॰ध् न् न्र्ड्डी ैईन्ध् ॉईीं २ींञन्र् ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
;गद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ीघर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धएर् ीन्र्ष्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1910 ऽींॉट्टध् र्ीन्र्ष्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ल ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व र्ीञध्अअ्रर्गिध्झ्ट्ट.ऽँय्ध्र््ि ऽ द्वूध्ूर्अ्रि.अक्ष्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी "ॉ र्ष्ीईर् ीर्र् ॉीी २र्न्ी र््री २भन् प्र ध् ॰ध् ्र"य् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;अद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;ूद्ध ञ न्}९प्रई ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्ए ींर्ीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अ् ऽह्मई्रय्ई "ॉ र्उीर्न्ी २न् र्र्र्ीिंीप्रऽई र्प्री ँर्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र न्फ झ्ट्टप्र ध् न्फर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
;अद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय्.
;द्ध प्रँर्९ीर्.ीन्र्ष्ी ;द्ध ई२न्ॉध्९.न्ईर्९ी ;्रद्ध ्रन्ध्र््री.ॉन्"य्र्न्ी९ध् ;र्र्ीिंद्ध ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९.र्ण्र्ूििद्व २न्घन्न् ॉर्न्ी ट्टष्न् न्र्ष्ी
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
;अद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय्.
;द्ध प्रँर्९ीर्.ीन्र्ष्ी ;द्ध ई२न्ॉध्९.न्ईर्९ी ;्रद्ध ्रन्ध्र््री.॰र्न्ीय्र्झ्ीञर्न्ी ;र्र्ीिंद्ध ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९.र्ण्गिक्ष् त्र्
ॉर्न्ी ट्टष्न् न्र्ष्ी
;त्र् ञद्ध ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
अ्र्र र्ण्र्क्ष्अििध्ू अक्ष्द्य र्ण्र्गििअध्ू अ्रक्ष् र्ण्र्द्यििअध्ू अ्रद्वध्अ र्ण्र्गिि अ्रद्वध्ू र्ण्र्गिि अ्र् र्ण्र्ूििअध्ू अक्ष्र्ि र्ण्र्गिि अक्ष्द्वध्अ र्ण्र्ूिि अक्ष्द्वध्ू र्ण्र्अिि अक्ष्द्वध्ग र्ण्र्ूिि अक्ष्द्वध्ल र्ण्र्ूिि
र् ी्र अअ र्ण्गिक्ष्
गक्ष्क्ष् र्ण्र्ूििद्व र् ी्र अ र्ण्र्ूििद्व ;ूद्ध ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्रँॉ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्. र्ष्ी९ींन्. न्ध्र्र्ञीीन् ;॰र्न्ीय्र्झ्ीञर्न्ीद्ध ॉन्"य्र्न्ी९ध्.र्न्ीध्र् ी्रय् न्र् ॉी ॰ध् न् ॉईीं २ींञन्र् ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
;गद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ीघर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धएर् ीन्र्ष्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण् र्ीन्र्ष्ीए प्रर्॰ीञ ल ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञध्अअ्रर्क्ष्ध्झ्ट्टि.ऽँय्ध्अर् िऽ द्वूध्ूर्अ्रि.अक्ष्ण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी "ॉ र्ष्ीईर् ीर्र् ॉीी २र्न्ी र््री २भन् प्र ध् ॰ध् ्र"य् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;अद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;ूद्ध ञ न्}९प्रई ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्ए ींर्ीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन्र् ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईीर् ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अ् ऽह्मई्रय्ई "ॉ र्उीर्न्ी २न् र्र्र्ीिंीप्रऽई र्प्री ँर्ीर्ईी २भन् प्र न्फ झ्ट्टप्र ध् न्फर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् —
;ूद्ध ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्रँॉ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्. र्ष्ी९ींन्. न्ध्र्र्ञीीन् ;॰र्न्ीय्र्झ्ीञर्न्ीद्ध ॉन्"य्र्न्ी९ध्.र्न्ीध्र् ी्रय् न्र् ॉी ॰ध् न् ॉईीं २ींञन्र् ी्रय् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
;गद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ीघर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धएर् ीन्र्ष्ी र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए र्ीण् भॉन् ऽन्न॰ीं९ २न्ए ९घन्न् ञ ॰ न्.ॉप्रण् र्र्ीीय्९ए ९घन्न्ए प्रँर्९ी र्न्ी्र३न्ए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् ॰ न् ॉप्रए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अर् िँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ र््िध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी "ॉ र्ष्ीईर् ीर्र् ॉीी २र्न्ी र््री २भन् प्र ध् ॰ध् ्र"य् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;अद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;ूद्ध ञ न्}९प्रई ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन् र्ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईी र्ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अ् ऽह्मई्रय्ई "ॉ र्उीर्न्ी २न् र्र्र्ीिंीप्रऽई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन् प्र न्फ झ्ट्टप्र ध् न्फर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् —
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1911;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ऽींॉट्टध्
;अद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय्.
;द्ध प्रँर्९ी.र्न्ी्र३न् ;द्ध ई२न्ॉध्९र्.ींॉीभन् ;्रद्ध ्रन्ध्र््री.र्ऽीत्र्न्र्न्ी ;र्र्ीिंद्ध ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९.्रण््द्वग २न्घन्न्
ॉर्न्ी ट्टष्न् न्र्ष्ी
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध
;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
ूअअध्अ र्ण्र्ल्रिि ूअू र्ण्र्द्वििर्ि ूग्ध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष््रिि ूक्ष्लध्अ र्ण्र्द्यििू गअद्यध्ग र्ण्र्द्व्रिि गअद्यध्ग र्ण्र्लििल ूद्वद्वध्अए ूद्वद्वध्अ र्ण्ूिअू गअ्रए गअक्ष्ए गअद्यध्अए गअद्यध्द्य र्ण्र्ूििल लर््रध्अि र्ण्र्अििू ल्ूध्अ र्ण्र्द्वििद्व अगूध्अ र्ण्र्द्वििअ ्रअर्ध्लि र्ण्र्ू्रिि ूद्वद्यध्ू र्ण्र्ूििद्व ्रअलध्अ र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि ्रअद्यध्ू र्ण्र्अििग ्रग्रध्ू र्ण्र्द्वििर्ि ू्रक्ष् र्ण्र्ूििल ूक्ष्लध््र र्ण्र्क्ष््िि अू् र्ण्अिर््रि अलद्वध्अ र्ण्र्लििल अ्रर्ध्अि र्ण्र्र्लििि अगगध्ू र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि द्यर्ि र्ण्र्र्द्वििि द्यद्वध्ू र्ण्र्ूिि् द्व् र्ण्र्द्यििग ूअअध्ग र्ण्र्लििद्व ूअद्वध्ू र्ण्र््ििू ूगद्वध्ू र्ण्अिर्अि ूक्ष्लध्क्ष् र्ण्र्द्विि् लर््रध्ूिए लर््रध्गि र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि लर््रध्ूिए लर््रध्गि र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि ूद्वद्वध्ू र्ण्र्लििअ लक्ष्ूध्अए लक्ष्ूध्ग र्ण्र्र््ििि लर्लिध्ू र्ण्र्द्वििअ लर्द्विध्ू र्ण्र््रगिि ल्लध्द्व र्ण्र्क्ष्अिि ्रअूध्ल र्ण्र्लििद्व
गअद्यध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष्द्विि ्रअ्रध्अ र्ण्र््रगिि ्रअक्ष्ध्ग र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ू्र्र र्ण्र्द्वििद्व ्रग्रध्क्ष् र्ण्र्द्यििग ्रगक्ष्ध्ल र्ण्अिू्र अलग र्ण्र्र्लििि अ्रर्ध्लि र्ण्र्क्ष््रिि अगअ र्ण्र्द्यििू अगलध्अ र्ण्र्र््ििि द्यद्य र्ण्र्द्यििग द्वगध्अ र्ण्र््रगिि ्र्ध्गि र्ण्अिर््रि ूअअध्ल र्ण्र्गििग ूअद्वध्ल र्ण्अिर््ि ूग्ध्ग र्ण्र्अििग ूक्ष्लध्ग र्ण्र्गििग ूक्ष्लध्ग्र र्ण्र्क्ष््रिि ल्अध्लर्र्ीिं र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि लर्लिध्अ र्ण्र्र््ििि ल्ूध्ू र्ण्अिअक्ष् लर्द्विध्अ र्ण्र्द्वििल ्रअगध्ू र्ण्र्लिि् ्रअर्ध्अि र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि ्रअगध्ग र्ण्र्ूिि् ्रअअध्अ र्ण्र्लिि् ्रअक्ष्ध्अ र्ण्र््रगिि ्रअक्ष्ध्ल र्ण्र्क्ष््रिि ूर््िध्अ र्ण्र्क्ष्र्ििि ्रग्रध्द्य र्ण्र्द्वििल द्वक्ष्ध्ू र्ण्अिूअ अलक्ष् र्ण्र्अििक्ष् अल् र्ण्र्लििअ ्र्ध्ूि र्ण्र्गििू ल्ध्अध्अ र्ण्अिअग द्य्रध्अ र्ण्र्अििक्ष् द्व्र र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि ्ूध्अ र्ण्र्ू्रिि ूगद्वध्अ र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि ूअ्ध्अ र्ण्र्अििक्ष् ूलर्ध्गि र्ण्र्अििग ूद्वद्वध्अ्रए ूद्वद्वध्अद्र र्ण्र्ूििअ ूद्वद्यध्अ र्ण्अिगू ्रअगध्अ र्ण्र्ू्रिि ल्अध्द्य र्ण्र्द्वििअ गूर्ि र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि ग्ू र्ण्अिर््ि ल्लध्गए ल्लध्ल र्ण्र्क्ष््िि{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1912 ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
;अद्ध ;ूद्ध अगूध्ू र्ण्र्लििर्ि लर््रध्ूिर्र्ीिंए लर््रध्गिर्र्ीिं र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि ्रअअध्द्य र्ण्र््ििअ ्रअद्यध्अ र्ण्र्क्ष्अिि ्रअद्वध्अ्र र्ण्र्गििू ूअर्ध्अि र्ण्र््रूिि ्रगक्ष्ध्् र्ण्अिगग अूद्व र्ण्र््ििद्य अलद्य र्ण्र्लििल अलद्वध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष्द्विि अगूध्ग र्ण्र्ू्रिि ल्ध्अद्र र्ण्अिअू द्यक्ष्ध्अ र्ण्अिद्वअ द्वद्यध्अए द्वद्यध्ू र्ण्र्ूिि्
र् ी्र ्् ्रण््द्वग
;ूद्ध ॉर्ीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँॉ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्.र्९ी प्रर्र्न्ीँी र्ऽीत्र्र्न्ीए ईींञन्र््री ञ ९ध्र् ी"न्न् २न्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
;गद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ीघर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए र्न्ी्र३न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अर् िँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ अर्ध्ऽि.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी "ॉ र्ष्ीईर् ीर्र् ॉीी २र्न्ी र््री २भन् प्र ध् ॰ध् ्र"य् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;अद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;ूद्ध ञ न्}९प्रई ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन् र्ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईी र्ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अ् ऽह्मई्रय्ई "ॉ र्उीर्न्ी २न् र्र्र्ीिंीप्रऽई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन् प्र न्फ झ्ट्टप्र ध् न्फर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
;अद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय्.
;द्ध प्रँर्९ी.र्न्ी्र३न् ;द्ध ई२न्ॉध्९र्.ींॉीभन् ;्रद्ध ्रन्ध्र््रीर्.ीॉञर्॰ी ;र्र्ीिंद्ध ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९.ूण्ूद्वद्व २न्घन्न्
ॉर्न्ी ट्टष्न् न्र्ष्ी
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध
;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
क्ष् र्ण्र्गििू द्यध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष््रिि अद्वध्अ र्ण्अिूअ अद्वध्ल र्ण्अिअग ूगूध्अ र्ण्र्ूििद्व अक्ष्द्यध्अ र्ण्र्ूििर्ि ूअद्व र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अक्ष्लध्अ र्ण्र्ूििर्ि ूू्रध्ू र्ण्र्ूििल अ्र्ध्अ र्ण्र्अििू ूूूध््रद्वू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अक्ष्अध्अ र्ण्र्ूििग अ्रक्ष्ध्अ र्ण्र्गििक्ष् ूूद्यध्अ र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूूूध््रद्वअध्ू र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अक्ष्लध्द्व र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अद्वध््र र्ण्र्द्व्रिि द्यध्अ र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूगअध््र र्ण्र्लििर्ि ूगक्ष्ध््र र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूूद्वध्ग र्ण्र्ूििर्ि ूगूध्ग र्ण्र््रगिि ूअ्ध्अ र्ण्र्अििक्ष् ूअद्य र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अ्रर्ध्लि र्ण्र्अििू ूूद्यध्ू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अक्ष्ूध्ू र्ण्र्अििू ूूू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूूर्ध्क्ष्ि र्ण्र्अििू ूअल र्ण्र्ूििद्व अलध्ू र्ण्अिू्र अ्रर्ध्ूि र्ण्र्ूििल अ्रर्ध्क्ष्ि र्ण्र्अििू ूगक्ष्ध्ू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूगूध्ू र्ण्र््रलिि ूगूध्ल र्ण्र्अििल अद्वध्ू र्ण्अिू्र ूगल र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूू् र्ण्र्अििक्ष् ूूगध्अ र्ण्र्र्लििि अ्रलध्अ र्ण्र्अििू ूगगध्ू र्ण्र्ूििू ूगगध्अ र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अ्रद्वध्ग र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अ्रर्ध्अि र्ण्र्ग्रिि अध्गए ूध्ग र्ण्र्द्यििगर्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1913 ॉर्न्ी ट्टष्न् न्र्ष्ी ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध
;अद्ध ;ूद्ध ूूर्ध्अि र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अल्ध्अ र्ण्अिद्वू ूअगध्अ र्ण्र््रगिि अ्रर्ध्गि र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अ्रर्ध्द्यि र्ण्र्अििू अलद्वए अल्ध्ू र्ण्अिद्व्र द्वलध्क्ष् र्ण्र्अििर्ि अक्ष्र्ध््रि र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अद्वध्ग र्ण्अिअग ूअ्ध्ू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूूगध्ू र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अक्ष्क्ष् र्ण्र्ूििद्व ूअक्ष् र्ण्र्ूििद्व अ्रद्यध्अ र्ण्र्ूििल अ्रर्ध््रि र्ण्र्अििू ूूअध्अ र्ण्र्ूििर्ि ूूअध्ू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अ्र्र र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूगर्ध्अि र्ण्र्ूििल ूूूध््रद्वर्ध्अि र्ण्र्अििू अ्रर्ध््ि र्ण्र्लिि् अक्ष्लध्द्य र्ण्र्र्द्वििि
र् ी्र क्ष्द्व ूण्ूद्वद्व
;ूद्ध ॉर्ीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँॉ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्.र्९ी प्रर्र्न्ीँी
ऽञई्रय्ई र्ष्ीर्र्र्ीिंीत्र्र्न्ीर्९ीर् ी"न्न् २न्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
;गद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ीघर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए र्न्ी्र३न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अर् िँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ अअध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी "ॉ र्ष्ीईर् ीर्र् ॉीी २र्न्ी र््री २भन् प्र ध् ॰ध् ्र"य् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;अद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;ूद्ध ञ न्}९प्रई ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन् र्ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईी र्ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अ् ऽह्मई्रय्ई "ॉ र्उीर्न्ी २न् र्र्र्ीिंीप्रऽई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन् प्र न्फ झ्ट्टप्र ध् न्फर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
;अद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय्.
अअद्वद्यध्अ र्ण्अिलद्व अूू्ध्ू र्ण्र्द्वििद्व अूलअध्ल र्ण्र्अििू अूलद्वध्अ र्ण्र्अििू अू्क्ष् र्ण्र्गििक्ष् अू्ू र्ण्र्ूििल अू्र्ि र्ण्र्अििू अल्रर्ध्ूि र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अ्रूलध्ू र्ण्र्लििर्ि अल्रअध्ू र्ण्र्अििक्ष् अूल्रध्ल र्ण्र्ूििल अ्रूअ र्ण्र्लििर्ि अ्रूक्ष्ध्अ र्ण्र्क्ष्र्ििि अअद्व्ध्अ र्ण्र्अििक्ष् अअद्वद्यध्ू र्ण्अिर्द्वि अूू्ध्ल र्ण्र्क्ष्द्विि अूल्रध्ग र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अूद्यगध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि अूद्य्रध्अ र्ण्र््रद्यिि अूद्वअध्ू र्ण्र्ूििल अूद्व्रध्ू र्ण्र्अििू अल्रूध्अ र्ण्र्द्वििर्ि अ्रूक्ष्ध्ू र्ण्र््रूिि अूू्ध्ग र्ण्र्ूििद्व अ्रूलध्अ र्ण्र्लििर्ि अूललध्अ र्ण्र्अििू अ्रअ् र्ण्र्ूििद्व अअ्र्रध्अ र्ण्र््ििग अअद्वद्वध्अ र्ण्र््रूिि अूलूध्अ र्ण्र्अििू अूलद्वध्ग र्ण्र्द्यििू अूद्यगध्ग र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अूद्य्रध्ू र्ण्र्अििू अूद्व्रध्अ र्ण्र्अििू अूद्वद्व र्ण्अिर्द्वि अ्रूर्ध्ूि र्ण्र्अििक्ष् अ्रूद्यध्अ र्ण्र्गििक्ष् अूलअध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि अ्रूू र्ण्र्लििल अूद्वलध्ू र्ण्अिक्ष्र्ि अललअध्अ र्ण्र्गििू अअ्र्रध्ग र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि अअ्द्यध्अ र्ण्र्अििू अूलअध्ग र्ण्र्लििल अूलद्वध्ल र्ण्अिद्वद्व अूद्यगध्अ र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि ;द्ध प्रँर्९ी.र्न्ी्र३न् ;द्ध ई२न्ॉध्९र्.ींॉीभन् ;्रद्ध ्रन्ध्र््रीर्.ींॉीभन् ;र्र्ीिंद्ध ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९.ूण्लद्वक्ष् २न्घन्न्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1914 ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
;अद्ध ;ूद्ध अूद्वू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अूद्व् र्ण्र्गििक्ष् अल्रर्ध्अि र्ण्र्अििक्ष् अ्रूद्वध्अ र्ण्र्लििल अल्रअध्अ र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अूल्रध्ू र्ण्र््ििू अल्रर्ध्गि र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अललद्वध्ग र्ण्र्गििू अलगूध्ू र्ण्र्अििू
र् ी्र ्र्र ूण्लद्वक्ष्
;ूद्ध ॉर्ीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँॉ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्.र्९ी प्रर्र्न्ीँी ई९र्ध्ी९ध् प्रईन् २न्न् ञर् ींॉीभन्र् ी"न्न्.ू २न्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
;गद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ीघर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए र्न्ी्र३न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अर् िँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ अूध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी "ॉ र्ष्ीईर् ीर्र् ॉीी २र्न्ी र््री २भन् प्र ध् ॰ध् ्र"य् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;अद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;ूद्ध ञ न्}९प्रई ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन् र्ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईी र्ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अ् ऽह्मई्रय्ई "ॉ र्उीर्न्ी २न् र्र्र्ीिंीप्रऽई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन् प्र न्फ झ्ट्टप्र ध् न्फर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
;अद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय्.
;द्ध प्रँर्९ी.र्न्ी्र३न् ;द्ध ई२न्ॉध्९र्.ींॉीभन् ;्रद्ध ्रन्ध्र््री.॰न्ध्र्य्ी९ध् ;र्र्ीिंद्ध ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९.ूण्क्ष्अक्ष् २न्घन्न्
ॉर्न्ी ट्टष्न् न्र्ष्ी
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध
;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
अ्क्ष् र्ण्अि्ू अल्रध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि अलग र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अ्रलध्अ र्ण्र्लििद्व ललक्ष् र्ण्र्अििक्ष् लल्रध्ू र्ण्र्गििक्ष् लअू र्ण्र्क्ष्र्ििि लग्रध्अ र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अद्य्ध्अ र्ण्र्ूििर्ि लगलध्अ र्ण्र्अििक्ष् लूअध्ू र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि अर्अि र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अ््रध्ू र्ण्र्ूििद्व ्द्य र्ण्अि्ू ूर्गिध्अ र्ण्र््रद्यिि ूर्ूि र्ण्र्लििल ूद्यगध्ू र्ण्र्ूििल अलद्य र्ण्र्ूििर्ि अद्व्र र्ण्र््रूिि लललध्अ र्ण्र्ूििल ललअ र्ण्अिूर्ि लूर्ध्ूि र्ण्र्लििद्व ूद्यगध्ू र्ण्र्ूििल अद्यद्वध्ू र्ण्र्ूििल लगलध्ू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि लूूध्ू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अ्रद्यध्ू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि लग्रध्ू र्ण्र्अििक्ष् ्द्वध्अ र्ण्अिूर्ि ूर्गिध्अर्र्ीिं र्ण्र्र्द्वििि लअग र्ण्र्क्ष्द्विि अल्रध्अ र्ण्र्द्वििल ूर्गिध्अद्र र्ण्र्क्ष्अिि अद्वर्ध्ूि र्ण्र्अििू लललध्ू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि लअद्य र्ण्र्क्ष्र्ििि अद्वक्ष्ध्ग र्ण्र््ििग अद्वक्ष्ध्अ र्ण्र्अििक्ष् ूद्यगध्ू्र र्ण्र्ूििद्व लूअध्अ र्ण्र्ूििल लग्रध्अ र्ण्र्ूििद्व अ्रद्वध्ल र्ण्र्अििू अ््रध्ग र्ण्र्ूििद्व ््ध्अ र्ण्र्द्यििू अद्य्र र्ण्र्गििक्ष् लअक्ष् र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अलल र्ण्र्अििू अ्रअ र्ण्र्ूििद्व अद्यक्ष् र्ण्र्द्वििल अर्र्िि र्ण्र्द्वििद्व अ्रद्वध्ग र्ण्र्ूििल ूद्यल र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अद्यद्वध्अ र्ण्र्ूििर्िर्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1915 ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
;अद्ध ;ूद्ध लल्रध्अ र्ण्र्लििर्ि लूूध्अ र्ण्र्र्द्वििि अ््रध्अ र्ण्र्ूििद्व अ्रद्यध्अ र्ण्र्ूिि् लअ्ध्अ र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि अद्यद्य र्ण्अिक्ष्र्ि लूअध्ग र्ण्र्गििक्ष्
र् ी्र क्ष्र्ि ूण्क्ष्अक्ष्
;ूद्ध ॉर्ीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँॉ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्.र्९ी प्रर्र्न्ीँी
॰न्ध्र्य्ी९ध्र् ी"न्न् २न्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
;गद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ीघर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए र्न्ी्र३न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
र्न्ी्र३न्ए प्रर्॰ीञ अर् िँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ अगध्ऽ.द्वूध्ूर्अिद्य.अद्वण्ट्टप्र र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉर् ी "ॉ र्ष्ीईर् ीर्र् ॉीी २र्न्ी र््री २भन् प्र ध् ॰ध् ्र"य् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;अद्ध ञ प्रर्ह्यीय्ई झ्ट्टप्र ध् ऽींॉट्टध् ॰ ;ूद्ध ञ न्}९प्रई ॉर्ीय्ँप्र र्ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्ण् ऽई— झ्ट्टप्र ऽँय्एर् ींीय्ॉ र्ऽीभन् ींर्य्ैी ञ न्प्रई प्रईन् र्ऽीभन् र्ीन्॰प्रर्५ीय्र्ईी र्ी ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन् ऽप्रप्रए ूर्अिग ;प्रँॉ ई॰ र्५ीई ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र ूर्अिग २र्न्ीर् ँीर््रीद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अ् ऽह्मई्रय्ई "ॉ र्उीर्न्ी २न् र्र्र्ीिंीप्रऽई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन् प्र न्फ झ्ट्टप्र ध् न्फर् ीँ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन् —
ऽींॉट्टध्
;अद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ी र्ह्यीय्.
;द्ध प्रँर्९ी.र्न्ी्र३न् ;द्ध ई२न्ॉध्९र्.ींॉीभन् ;्रद्ध ्रन्ध्र््री.ॉर्न्ी"य्र्न्ी९ध् ;र्र्ीिंद्ध ९्रझ््रर्र् ीी९.ूण्द्यलर् ि२न्घन्न्
ॉर्न्ी ट्टष्न् न्र्ष्ी
;२न्घन्न् ञद्ध
लद्वध्ग र्ण्अिूद्व ल्रद्यध्ल र्ण्र्लििर्ि अूक्ष्ध्ल र्ण्र्द्वििल ल्रद्वध्ू र्ण्र्लििद्व ्रूध्ग र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि अू्रध्अ र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि ल्ध्अ र्ण्ूिअू लक्ष् र्ण्अिर्र्िि ूर्गि र्ण्र्क्ष्द्विि अद्वद्वध्ग र्ण्अिर्र्िि अद्वद्वध्क्ष् र्ण्र्क्ष्र्ििि अूद्यध््र र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि लद्यध्अ र्ण्र्ूििर्ि ्रगध्ग र्ण्र््रूिि अद्वद्वध््र र्ण्र्ूििल ल्रद्वध्ल र्ण्र्गििू अूक्ष्ध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष्र्ििि अूक्ष्ध्क्ष् र्ण्र्अििू ूर्र्िि र्ण्र्लििर्ि अूद्यध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष्द्विि ूर्ूिध्अ र्ण्र््रक्ष्िि अद्वद्वध्द्य र्ण्र्अििू अद्वद्वध्द्व र्ण्र्लििद्व ्र्ध्अ र्ण्र्द्यििू अद्वद्यध्अ र्ण्र्अििक्ष् लद्यध्ग र्ण्अिर्र्िि ल्रद्यध्ू र्ण्र्गििक्ष् क्ष्ल र्ण्र्लििर्ि ्रूध्ल र्ण्र्लििल ्रूध््र र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूर्अिध्ू र्ण्र्र्द्वििि ूर््रि र्ण्र्अििू ल्रक्ष्ध्ल र्ण्र्ूििल अद्वद्वध्् र्ण्र्ूििद्व क्ष्द्य र्ण्र््रूिि ्रगध्अ र्ण्र्क्ष्लिि अ््ध्ू र्ण्र्गििू क्ष्क्ष्ध्ू र्ण्र्अििू ल्रद्यध््र र्ण्र्अििू ;अद्ध ;ूद्ध
र् ी्र लद्य ूण्द्यलर्ि
;ूद्ध ॉर्ीय्ँप्रर् ीँ प्रँॉ प्र९ र्ऽी५र्ईी २भन्.र्९ी प्रर्र्न्ीँी र् ींॉीभन्र् ी"न्न्.ग ञ ९ध्र् ी"न्न् २न्न् र्प्रीय्र्ह्यी २न्ईींण्
;गद्ध झ्ट्टप्रर् ीघर्र्५ीी ;०र्९ीद्धर् ी प्रन्र्ध्ीर्ह्यी ऽींप्रर्झ्ी्रध् ऽप्रर्र्क्तीीन्ध् ;र्न्ीैँद्धए र्न्ी्र३न् र्र् ीीय्९ ञ र्प्रीर् ँी ॉर्ईी २भन्ण्
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्न्ीर्द्दी९ र् ी ॉ र्ईी र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए ्रक्ष्ध्अ र्ण्ूिर्द्वि ्रअध्ू र्ण्र्अििक्ष् ्रअध्ग र्ण्र्गििू ल्रद्वध्अ र्ण्अिक्ष्द्व क्ष्द्व र्ण्र््ििक्ष् ूर्अिध्अ र्ण्अिर्र्िि अद्वद्वध्ू र्ण्र्क्ष्र्ििि क्ष्क्ष्ध्अ र्ण्र्क्ष्र्ििि
र्५ीट्टध् र्ऽीप्रष्॰ध्ए ९घन्न् ञ ॰ न्.ॉप्रण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1916
प्रर्झ्ी्रर् ींीञ र्ऽी॰र्५ी
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् प्रँध् प्र५प्रर्सी९ए प्रर्प्री र्र्ऽीी्र
र्क्तीीं प्र}९र् ीभए र्न्ी ञप्र॰न् र् ॉी र्र्५ीीञप्रई ्रन्ए र्न्ीींन् ;{न्ण््रण्द्ध
र्न्ीींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूर् िँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ द्यद्य्रध्ध्ण्ट्टण्ध्प्रन्प्रध्ूर्अ्रिण्{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए न्र्ड्डी प्रर्र्र्५ीीी प्रर्झ्ी्र र्ी र्ीञ अ्र.गध्ूर्अिक्ष्ध्ूद्व.ू प्रर्॰ीञ र्द्वि.र्ूि.ूर्अिद्व प्रर्न्ी९ ञ र्ऽीण्ध्ण्प्रँञ॰९ प्र५प्रर्सी९ र्उीर्न्ी {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् प्रँध् प्र५प्रर्सी९ र्र्;ैीी ञ ॉर्ञी९द्ध ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र.ूर्र््रिि ध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ूद्व ध् न्र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ल र् ीर्र्क्तीी ऽञई्रय्ई ऽर्क्ती॰र्५ी र्र्न्ीँी ञर् ीर्५ी ट्टय् ष्ध्ण्न्ण् र्ऽीभन् ण्न्ण् र् ीन्र् ॉी ूर्अ्रि.अक्ष् ञर् ीञन्झ् प्र ्र ण् "न्र् ीर्न्ीञ ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ प्रट्टप्र९प्रई र्५ीर्र्ईी ऽर्क्तीध् प्र५प्रर्सी९र् ी र्ऽीर््रीध् र्ऽी५र् ीर्य्ी२न्ध् न् २न्ईीं र्ऽी॰प्रर्५ीई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन् —
अण् र्न्ीद्द र्र्५ीीॉ र्उीर्न्ीर् ीर् ीञ अ्र.गध्ूर्अिक्ष्ध्गद्व.ू प्रर्॰ीञ अल.र््ि.ूर्अिद्य र् ीक्त ॉ {र्र्न्ीी.प्र२न्ईर् ी र्क्ती ञ न्न् र्ऽीण्ध्ण् प्रँञ॰९ प्र५प्रर्सी९र् ी ष्ध्ण्न्ण् र्ऽीभन् ण्न्ण् ञर् ॉी ूर्अ्रि.अक्ष् ञ प्रर्५ीई {र्र्र्न्ीीीञर् ी र्ष्ीन् ;One Timeद्ध झ्ट्टईर्९ीध् र्झ्ी ॉर्र् ीीर्य्ीन् ैध्ट्ठप्रई ॰ध् ्र"य्न् २भन्ण्
ूण् {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए न्र्ड्डी प्रर्र्र्५ीीी प्रर्झ्ी्र ध् ऽप्रर्क्तीॉर्ट्टीर् ीञ क्ष्र्र्लििध्ू््रद्यध्ूर्अ्रिध्गद्व.ू प्रर्॰ीञ ूद्व.र््ि.ूर्अिक्ष् र्उीर्न्ी र्ऽीण्ध्ण् प्रँञ॰९ प्र५प्रर्सी९ ष्ध्ण्न्ण् र्ऽीभन् ण्न्ण् ऽर्क्ती॰र्५ी र्र्न्ीँी ञ {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् प्रँध् प्र५प्रर्सी९ र्र्;ैीी ञ ॉर्ञी९द्ध ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र.ूर्र््र ििध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी ूद्व ऽञई्रय्ईर् ीप्रर्५ीई २र्न्ी ीं २भञन्ण्
गण् र्ऽीण्ध्ण् प्रँञ॰९ प्र५प्रर्सी९ प्रन् प्रर्॰ी २भन् प्रर् ॉी ूर्अ्रि.अक्ष् ञर् ीञन्झ् ष्ध्ण्न्ण् र्ऽीभन् ण्न्ण्र् ीन् ध् ॉञर्न्ी र्ऽीभन् न्र्र्ध्ीी ध्र्र् ीँी र्र्न्ीँी ञर् ीप्रर्५ीई ऽर्क्ती॰र्५ी ऽींड २भन्ण्
लण् र्ऽीण् ध्ण् प्रँञ॰९ प्र५प्रर्सी९ ॉट्टध् ैईींई ध् २भन्ए प्रँॉञ {र्र्र्न्ीीीञ र् ीए प्रर्ईीर् ीर् ीए ँह्म प्रईप्रएर् ीन् ञ र्५ी ध् प्रईप्र र्ी प्रन्र्ह्यी २भन्ण् ;ॉट्टध् ॉञ९.िंअ ड ञ ॉञ९ िं२भन्द्धण्
्रण् र्ऽीण् ध्ण् प्रँञ॰९ प्र५प्रर्सी९ र्उीर्न्ी {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् प्रँध् प्र५प्रर्सी९ र्र्;ैीी ञ ॉर्ञी९द्ध ऽप्रर्क्तीप्र.ूर्र््र ििध् र्र्क्तीीर्न्ी अू;द्ध र्ी९ ञ प्रर्र्क्तीीय्प्रन्ई र्५ीीं} र्न्ीप्रर्५ीए प्रर्प्री र्र्ऽीी्र र् ीॉ "न्ॉ र्ऽी॰र्५ी र् ीर्५ी ध् प्रईप्र ईध् ॉ०र्ईी२न् ऽञ॰न्र् ँी र्न्ी ॉींप्रप्र५ई श्न्र््रीण्
क्ष्ण् र्ऽीण् ध्ण् प्रँञ॰९ प्र५प्रर्सी९ र्उीर्न्ी ॉ {र्र्र्न्ीीीञ ध् ॉट्टध्ए प्रँह्म२ञन् र्न्ीप्रर्क्ती र्॰ी ध्र् ँीध् २भन्एर् ीन् ट्टर्ह्यीय् २र्न्ी र् ी२न् ऽह्म॰न् र्र्ऽीी्रर् ी ैईींई श्न्र््रीण्
द्यण् र्ऽीण् ध्ण् प्रँञ॰९ प्र५प्रर्सी९ प्रन् प्रर्॰ी २भन् प्र प्रप्रझ्ह्म ऽप्रझ्न्र्र्ह्यीीञ र्उीर्न्ीर् ँीन्ध् प्र॰र्र्५ीी.प्र॰य्र्र्५ीीञर् ीर् ी९ र्प्री र््री २भन्ण् २न् र्ऽी॰र्५ी {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् प्रँध् प्र५प्रर्सी९ प्रर्प्री ध् ष्भन्र् ीञ अर्अिध्ूर्अिद्व प्रर्॰ीञ ू्.र्क्ष्.िूर्अिद्व ञ प्र९ ्र प्रर्ह्यीय् प्रर्न्ी९ ञर् ँीन्ध् र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन्ण्
त्र्र्न्ीण् ष्ध्ण् त्र्न्ध्ण् ॰र्९ीध्ए
ॉप्रण्
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1917 {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1918 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1919 {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1920 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1921 {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1922 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1923h
r a g s i t t
a h h C
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1924 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1925 {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1926 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1927 {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1928 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1929र्र्ीीय्९ ींऊ र्प्रीय् र्॰ीर्प्रीन्ध्ए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्र्५ीीैीध्र् ीभए ींर्र्न्ीीन्र्र् ीी९ प्रन्ॉन्ए र्न्ीींन्
र्न्ीींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूर्र् िीय् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीण्.अद्वध्र्गिध्र्प्रीय्र् ीर्प्रीध्ूर्अिद्वध््अगण्र्झ्ीन्ई र्प्रीय् र्र्ऽीी्रए "य् प्र॰}९ध् र्उीर्न्ीर् ँीन्ध् ऽप्रॉर्ट्टी ॉर्ऊी द्वूध्{न्ण््रण्.प्रण्ॉण्ध् ;अक्ष्ध्ूर्अिलद्धध्ूर्अिद्व प्रर्॰ी अग.र्गि.ूर्अिद्व— र्९ी प्रईप्रप्रह्न ऽप्रप्रए अ््रअ ;अ््रअर् ी लगद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अर्क्ष् ि;द्ध ऽींॉन्र्ह्यी ञ र्प्रीय् र्र्ऽीी्र ई॰ड्ढ र्उीर्न्ी र्प्रीय् ऽँध्य् ॉर्ऊी.अक्ष्ध्ूर्अिल ञ प्र॰ ्र न्र्ड्डी र्र्ह्मीी९ए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् र्ईीन्ध् र्द्वि प्र॰ॉट्टष्न्ए ूर्अिद्व र्ऽी॰र्५ी र्ी र्न्ीझ् र्र्५ीीॉध् र्र्न्ीँी ञ ॉर्र्य्ॉीीन्र्ह्यी ध्र्र् ँीीन्ध् २न्ईींर् ीप्रर्५ीई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन्ण्
;ॉींष्ईर् ॉी२ट्टन्द्ध ींऊ र्प्रीय् र्॰ीर्प्रीन्ध्ण्
र्झ्ीन्ई र्प्रीय् र्र्ऽीी्र
र्प्रीय् ॉ॰ए ऽर्र्५ीी र्न्ीत्र्न्ए "य् प्र॰}९ध्.अअर्र्र्अििि
"य् प्र॰}९ध्ए र्ईीन्ध् अगर् ीय्ए ूर्अिद्वूूर् ी}्रींए अ्ग् ;र्५ीद्ध
ॉण् द्वूध्{न्ण््रण्.प्रण्ॉण्ध्;अक्ष्ध्ूर्अिलद्धध्ूर्अिद्वण्र्९ी प्रईप्रप्रह्न ऽप्रप्रए अ््रअ ;अ््रअर् ी लगद्ध ध्र् ीर्न्ी अर्क्ष् ि;द्ध ऽींॉन्र्ह्यी ञए र्प्रीय् र्र्ऽीी्र ई॰ड्ढर्उीर्न्ी र्प्रीय् ऽँध्य् ॉण् अक्ष्ध्ूर्अिल ञ प्र॰ ्र न्र्ड्डी र्र्ह्मीी९ए {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न्ए प्रष्र्९ीॉींन् र्ईीन्ध् र्द्वि प्र॰ॉट्टष्न्ए ूर्अिद्य र्ऽी॰र्५ीर् ीर् ीप्रर्५ीई न्र्ईी २भन्ण्
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR
EP No. 16 of 2014
PETITIONER : Rupdhar Pudo S/o Jalluram Pudo Aged About 30 years R/o Village-Dargarh, P.O. Sadhu-Michgaon, Tah Durgukondal, P.S. Kodeknurse, Distt. Kanker C.G., Pin- 494669.
VERSUS
RESPONDENTS : 1. Bhojraj Nag S/o Laxminath Nag Aged About 42 Yeas R/o Village-Himoda, P.O.
P.S. & Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker, C.G.
2. Manturam Pawar S/o Subran Singh Pawar Aged About 47 years R/o Pakhanjur
P.O. And P.S. Pakhanjur, Tah. Pakhanjur, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 3. Jaiprakash Padmakar Padda S/o M.R. Padmakar Padda Aged About 30 Years R/o Gawdepara, Ward No. 15, P.O. & P.S. Bhanupratappur, Tah. Bhanupratappur, Distt. Uttar Bastar, Kanker C.G.
4. Anil Netam S/o Daniram Netam Aged About 38 Yeas R/o Chikhli, P.O. Useli,
Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar, Kanker C.G.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 19305. Bhim Singh Usendi S/o Mayaram Usendi Aged Acbout 36 years R/o Bade Jaitpur, Post Office-Kamta, P.S. And Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 6. Devnath Hidko S/o Sunher Hidko Aged About 27 years R/o Pufgaon, P.O. & P.S. Antagarh, Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar, Kanker C.G.
7. Mahadev Mandavi S/o Vishalram Mandavi Aged about 27 Years R/o Koilibeda Chandni Chowk, P.O. And P.S. Koilibeda, Tah. Pakhanjur Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G.
8. Parsuram Pawar S/o Jagoram Pawar Aged About 44 Years R/o Belgal Sitlapara, P.O. Tekameta, P.S. Bande, Tah. Pakhanjur, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 9. Raghunath Kumeti S/o Late Samrath Kumeti Aged About 42 Years R/o Tenkal Patelpara, House No. 26 P.O. And P.S. Antagarh, Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G.
10. Savita Pawar W/o Manturam Pawar Aged About 35 Years R/o Pakhanjur P.O. And P.S. Pakhanjur, Tah. Pakhanjur, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 11. Shankarlal Netam S/o Late Sukhlal Netam Aged About 25 Years R/o imlipadar, P.O. and P.S. Antagarh, Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 12. Virendra Kumar Hidami S/o Sagruram Hidami Aged About 25 Years R/o Sarandi Uparpara, P.O. Sarandi, P.S. And Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. For the Petitoner : Mr. Sudeep Verma Advocate For the Respondent No. 1 : Mr. Ramakant Mishra, Advocate For the intervener : Mr. Himanshu Kr. Sharma, Adv.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Goutam Bhaduri
C. A. V. JUDGMENT
Judgment reserved on 15.11.2017
Judgment delivered on 08.12.2017
1. The primary relief sought in this petition is to declare the election of returned candidate Bhojraj Nag who was declared elected in the by-election of Chhattisgarh State Legislative Assembly Area No. 79 of Antagarh Constituency as held on 13.09.2014.
2. The instant petition is under Sections 80 & 80-A read with section 81 of the Representation of the People Act., 1951 (hereinafter referred to as the Act of 1951). The grounds which are urged in this petition are that respondent No. 1 has resorted to corrupt practice thereby the result of election is liable to be set aside.
3. The brief facts of the case are that initially in the year 2013, the general election to the Antagarh Legislative Assembly was conducted by the Election Commission. The present election petition is concerned with the result of by-election of Legislative Assembly Area no. 79 of Antagarh Constituency held on 13.09.2014. After the initial election of 2013, the returned candidate who was elected in the year 2013 had vacated the seat therefore new notification for election was issued. The election Commission thereafter issued notifica- tion on 20.08.2014 to conduct by-election for the Antagarh Constituency and the following dates were fixed for conducting the election.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1931S. No. Event
Date
1. Issue of notification
20-08-2014
2. Last date for filling nominations 27-08-2014 3. Scrutiny of nominations 28-08-2014 4. Last date for withdrawal of candidatures 30-08-2014
13-09-2014 5. Date of Polling 6. Counting of votes 16-09-2014 7. Date before which the election shall be completed 19-09-2014
4. After the result of polling, respondent no. 1 was declared as returned candidate.
5. (i) Mr. Sudeep Verma, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner would submit that as per the election programme, the last date of withdrawal of candidature was on 30-08-2014 and out of 13 candidates who had filled their nominations, 11 had withdrawn their candidature. The petitoner belongs to ambedkarite Party of India and the repondent returned candidat belongs to Bhartiya Janta Party. It is stated that in order to pressurize withdrawal of the candidates who were 11 in number undue influence and pressure tactics were adopted by the respondent returned candidate. It is stated that the petitioner was also approached and request was made to him for withdrawal of his candidature through mobile of one Omprakash Gupta and money was offered but the petitioner did not accept the same.
(ii) It is further stated that during such conversation it was also disclosed that the candidature of Indian National Congress has withdrawn his candidature by use of undue influence and by payment of money, therefore, the corrupt practice was adopted by the respondent it is furhter submitted that the petitioner had visited various polling booths on the date of polling on 13.09.2014 and it was found that different voters were carried to the polling booths in different vehicles, It was stated that having enquired, it was revealed that the voters were being brought to the polling stations at the behest of respondent no. 1 and in lieu of thereof amount was paid by respondent no. 1 therefore the same also amounts to corrupt practice. Further, it is submitted that free supply of fruits was made to the voters apart from various means of conveyance used to carry the voters to the polling booths.
(iii) Referring to the pleadings and statements, learned counsel would submit that the oral evidence in this respect has been adduced before the Court and the petitioner has examined as many as 4 witnesses including the petitioner and all have equivocally supported the fact that during the poll- ing, the voters were being carried on payment of money and the work was delegated to few per- sons. He went through to the statements of petitioner Rupdhar Pudo and 3 witnesses namely Arjun Singh Thakur (P.W.2), Santosh Yadav(P.W.3) and Rajesh Kumar Pudo (P.W.4) and submitted that all the videos were also recorded and the complaint was also made to the Election Commission. Therefore, the petitioner has placed all the evidence on record to show that corrupt practice was adopted by respondent No. 1 Bhojraj Nag by payment of money and by other allurements to the voters. Therefore it would be termed as corrupt practice and the election of respondent no. 1 be set aside.
6. Per contra, Shri Ramakant Mishra, learned counsel appearing for repondent No. 1 would submit that the pleadings in the petition are completely vague and no primary evidence has been adduced by the respondent it is further submitted that though the reference of one O.P. Gupta, has been made but no efforts were made to call and examine him as a witness. He further submitted that mere pleading of fact that the other candi- dates who were contesting the election have withdrawn their candidatures, will not prove the fact that money was paid by the returned candidate. He further submitted that no pleading has been made and despite the fact that it is stated that occurrence of incidents was captured in camera, no evidence has been led in this behalf. Therefore, the petition is devoid of merits and deserves to be dismissed at the threshold.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 19327. On the basis of pleadings of the parties, this Court has framed the following issues on 19.02.2016.
S. No. Issues
Findings
1. Whether the respondent No. 1, (returned candidate) exercised "Not proved"
undue influence, threat and Pressure and if so whether it amounts to commission of corrupt practices ?
2. Whether the respondent No. 1 (returned candidate) had offe- "Not proved"
red free food and other articles to the electors to influence the electors to vote for him, therefore, it amounts to corrupt Practices ?
3. Whether the election of Respondent No. 1 (returned candi- No
date is liable to be set aside) ?
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have also perused the record and documents filed along- with the petition as well as the evidence adduced during the counsel of trial.
9. After closure of the trial, on the last day of closure of arguments of respondents, an applicant has been filed by one Shri Pankaj Mahawar u/s 151 of CPC read with Order 1 Rule 10(2) to implead the applicant Pankaj Mahawar as a party in the case Along-with the petition certain documents have also been placed and the allegations have been made that the petitioner was not able to bring evidence properly before the Court and therefore he may be allowed to be impleaded as a party. The said argument was vehemently opposed by the petitioner and the respondent and submits that the applicant Pankaj Mahawar has neither any locus-standi nor has any interest instead he is trying to protract the trial and the effort is to keep this petition pending. The counsel for the petitioner further refutes the allegation that the case was not contested properly. It is contended that the like nautre of allegation at the closure of case casts a stigma on the petitioner, therefore the application be dismissed with heavy cost.
10. Section 81 of the Representation of People's Act 1951 says that the election petition may be presented on the grounds enumerated u/ss 100 and 101 by any candidate on the elector of concerned constituency within 45 days. The document which has been filed along-with the application by the applicant Pankaj Mahawar would show that the applicant is resident of Gujrati Colony, Dhamtari, Tahsil and District Dhamtari there- fore, apparently as appears he is not an elector/voter of the Antagarh constituency. Along-with the appliaction, the order sheets of 2015 have been placed on record which would show that the applicant was also in know of the fact that the election petition is pending before this Court. The word elector has been defined in the Act of 1951 that person to vote at the election to which the election petition relates. The election petition is of Antagarh constituencey therefore, applicant even remotely can be considered within the definition of elector. The documents e. order sheets of this petition suggest that the applicant was aware of the fact that the case was pending since 2015. At the fag end when the final argument of the respondents were in con- cluding stage, the said application has been filed with an averment that the petitioner was unable to place the evidence which was existing in the case.
11. I an afraid that if such like nature of third party's application is allowed to intervene in such a manner then the entire object of section 81 of the R.P. Act 1951 would be defeated. At the same time the applicant cannot claim himself to be the repository of the entire wisdom and casts stigma on the petitioner especially when the petitioner was also a candidate who contested the election and having lost the election, has filed the election petition before the High Court to set aside the election of the returned candidate on the grounds of undue infulence and corrupt practice. As such the said application appears to have been filed with an oblique motive and to protract the trail of election petition or to keep it alive for some reason or the other. In the result, on overall evaluating the facts, I am of the opinion that the said application is devoid of merits and is liable to be rejected.
12. The record would show that the petitioner has examined himself as P.W. 1 and one Arjun Singh Thakur has been examined as P.W. 2, Santosh Yadav has been examined as P.W. 3, Rajesh Kumar Pudo has been examined as P.W. 4 whereas the respondent no. 1 has examined himself alone.
13. Section 100 (1) (b) lays down that the /commission of corrupt Practice is a ground for declaring the election veid in this context, Section 100 (1) (b) (d) is relevant here and quoted below.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1933Section 100 of the R.P Act. 1951.
100 Grounds for delcaring election to be void -(1) Subject to the provisions of such sub-section (2) if the High Court is of the opinion:— 1. (a) xxx xxx xxx
(b) that any corrupt practice has been committed by a returned candidate or his election agent or by any other person with the consent of a returned candidate or his election agent; or (c) xxx xxx xxx
(d) that the result of the election, in so far as it concerns a returned candidate, has been materally effected— (i) xxx xxx
(ii) by any corrupt practice committed in the interests of the returned candidate by
an agent other than his election agent or.
(iii) xxx xxx
(iv) by any non-compliance with the provisions of the Constitution or of this Act or
of any rules or orders made under this Act,
The High Court shall declare the election of the returned candidate to be void."
14. Further coming back to the point of pleading, reading of Section 83 would show that where an election petition alleges commission of corrupt practice by a candidate, the pleading must contain (a) direct and detailed nature of corrupt practice as defined in 1951 Act; (b) the details of every important particulars giving the time, place, names of persons, use of words and expressions, etc. it must also clearly appear from the allegations that the corrupt practice was indulged with either express or implied consent of the candidate or his election agent.
15. In the present case, with respect to issue no. 1 whether the retrned candidate has exercised undue influence threat and pressure to pressurize the withdrawal of his opponent candidates, the respective pleadings made by the petitioner was perused. At Para 8.8 of the petition, the pleading has been made that one Om Prakash Gupta had given a call to him by his mobile number and offered money for withdawal of candidature and tried to allure, influence and pressurize the petitioner, in the pleading and avidence of the pititoner it is stated that on Mobile No. 9406466221 he had received the call from one Om Prakash Gupta. In the pleading though it has been stated that apart from allurement, influence pressure was exerted, but in the statement nothing particulars have been described. Only omni-bus averments have been made and in the evidence it is stated that in lieu of withdrawal of his candidature, he was offered whatever he would have asked that would be fulfilled. It has also not been made clear that how much amount was offered and what sort of pressure was exerted. Though a particular mobile phone number has been stated, but no evidence is adduced or on record to show that to whom the said number belonged. The evidence is furhter absent to show that whether the phone number which received the call, whether it was of the petitioner or any of the other persons. It is also not clear that what was the identity of the alleged caller O.P.Gupta. If the petitioner who was also a contesting candidate had received such phone call, the best evidence to prove the call details could have been placed on record along-with the identity of the caller. Nothing has been placed on record to show that when it was called, what was the timing, who was the caller and his identity.
16. The petitioner though claimed that the receiving number belonged to him but that too has not been estab- lished. Only paid oral staement has been adduced about the call. The official records to prove the identity of receiver and caller could have been proved by evidence, but the same was withheld by the petitioner. Despite the best evidence available to the petitioner, the petitioner has chosen not to place it on record. Only by mere submission that the petitioner was offered money and allured for withdrawal of candidatures, no inference can be drawn in absence of proof beyond doubt. Further more, the statement of petitioner in this regard would show that it was the opinion and inference of the petitioner that the other candidates barring respondents have received the money for withdrawal. If the petitioner was so sanguine of the fact that the money was offered to other 11 candidates then in order to prove the facts and denial any one could have been summoned as a witness. Therefore, the opinion of the petitioner cannot take place of evidence to prove the facts.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 193417. Further in evidence the petitioner had given a specific date of call, it was stated by the petitioner that on 29.08.2014 one Johan Gawade, who was the ex-president of Durg kondal and one Narendra Besre, who was one of the worker of the Bjp, contacted the petitioner on his mobile and asked the petitoner to meet and thereafter it was suggested to the petitioner to take back his name as condidate. It is further stated that in lieu of withdrawal of names of Jagannath Sahu, Anil Chandel and Narendra Besre offer was made to pay heavy amounts. Subsequently, the petitioner came to know that one Manturam Pawar who was authorised candidate of Congress Party, had also taken back his name.
18. So again inference has been made that respondent had paid different amounts to the contesting candidates and the other candidates have withdrawn their names to contest the election after acceptance of such money. However, except the inference nothings on record to come to a definite finding. Despite the fact that specific date has been given that on 29.08.2014 the petitioner had received the phone call from Johan Gawade and Narendra Besare, the call details which could have been placed on record as a proof of a positive call on a particular date has not been produced. Therefore, even if the conversation was not recorded in order to draw a little inference, the petitoner could have produced the call details along with the identity of caller and phone number to show that he received certain phonecalls from a particular person on a particular date, So the minimum evidence too is completely absent. There is no reason assigned by the petitioner that why such evidence was withheld, which would have been otherwise available so as to climb even the first ladder of evidence.
19. The statement would further show that the petitoner has stated that on 30.08.2014 while he was with Arjun Singh Thakur at his residence, he received a phone call on his mobile number. The Mobile number is again stated to be 9406466221. There is no evidence on record to show that the said mobile number belonges to the petitioner,. Furhter the statement is made that similar phone call was received by Arjun Singh Thakur and Narendra Bansod, who were the post holders in the party from which the petitioner was contesting. Arjun Singh Thakur has been exmined as PW-2. He has stated that he was holding the mobile no. 9406371295. it is stated that the Secretary of Chief Minister, Raman Singh had called him disclosing his identity as Om Prakash and he was aksed to advice Rupdhar Pudo to take back the name and in lieu thereof money was offered. Neither the evidence thereof has been produced nor any document has been placed to show with reference to the phone number that it belongs to him. Similar analogy also applied here that when the details of particular date and the mobile number was given by the witness of the petitioner, then in such case, the petitioner could have placed on record the minimum fact that the said number belongs to Arjun Singh. Thakur (PW 2), who had recevied the alleged phone call. The caller identity could have been proved by the record, but nothing has been placed on record. In the cross-examination the witness has referred the hearsay conversation with Rupdhar Pudo about receipt of the phone call, which too is not admissible in evidence.
20. Arjun Singh Thakur (PW-2) has further stated the petitioner had made complaint to the Chief Election Officer but the same fact is not stated by the petitioner. No document is also placed on record to show that the offer was made to the petitioner Rupdhar Pudo and party workers have complained to the Election Officer. In the statement, the furhter reference is also made to one Narendra Bansod, who was shown as National Secretary of Ambedkarite Party. It was stated that he also received phone call, whereby the offer was made to take back the candidature in lieu of the money. The said Narendra Bansod has not been examined before the Court, it is not clear that why his evidence was withheld when he was also availabel as a primary witness and could have disclosed the facts with respect to the allegations made by the petitioner, therefore, the evidence that the petitioner and the witness PW-2 have deposed about the offer made for withdrawal of candidature, in both the statements though the specific phone number with particular timing has been stated, but nothing has been placed on record to show and prove that the recipients of the number were the witnesses i.e. the petitioner and PW.-2. In absence of reliable evidence of the petitioner who was in the hold of such evidence to show his dentity of holding a particular number the adverse inference would follow that he has withheld the evidence himself, therefore, only on the basis of bald statement the facts cannot be accepted as a gospel truth that he had received the phone call with offer of money to withdraw the candidature.
21. The degree of proof as required man election petition has been laid down by the Supreme Court in a case law reported in (1995) 5 SCC 347-Gajanan Krishnaji Bapat vs. Dattaji Raghobaji Meghe wherein Their Lordship held that "in order to unseat a returned candidate the crrupt practice must be specifically alleged ard strictly proved to have been committted by the returned candidate, himself or by his election agent or by any other person with the consent of the returned candidate or by his election agent. The suspicion however strong cannot take the place of proof, whether the allegations are sought to be established by direct evidence or by circumstantial evidence. Since pleadings play an important role in an election petition, the legislature has provided that the allegations of corrupt practice must be properly alleged and both the material facts and particulars provided in the petition itself so as to disclose a complete cause of action."र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1935 22. With respect to undue influence and corrupt practice nothing is pleaded that the named person Omprakash Gupta was acting on behalf of the respondent or he was acting on behalf of any other candidate. Only by making reference that offer was made to withdraw the candidatures, it cannot be conclusively proved that Omprakash Gupta was acting on behalf of the respondent.
23. with respect to pleading of undue influence, the petitioner has failed to furnish concise material practiculars as to in what manner the undue influence was exercised. On reading of Section 83 of the Act, 1951 it shows that substantive part of Section 83 consists of three improtant elements namely the election petition should contain concise statement of material fact which the election petitioner relied upon. The emphasis is on the material facts which should be stated in the concise form. Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Charan Lal Sahu Vs. Giani Jail Singh (1984) 1 SCC 390 while considering the "undue influence" as enumerated in Section 18(1), emphasizing the need of precise, specific and unambiguous pleading of corrupt practice particularly with reference to undue influence held thus :—
"Therefore, in order that the offence of undue influence can be said to have been made out within the meaning of Section 171-C of the Penal Code, something more than the mere act of canvassing for a candidate must be shown to have been done by the offender. That something more may, for example, be in the nature of a threat of an injury to a candidate or a voter as stated in sub-section (2) (a) of Section 171-C of the Penal Code or, it may consist of inducing a belief of Divine displeasure in the mind of a candidate or a voter as stated in sub-section (2) (b). The act alleged as constituting undue influence must be in the nature of a pressure or tyranny on the mind of the candidate or the voter it is not possible to enumerate exhaustively the divers categories of acts which fall within the definition of undue influence it is enough for our purpose to say, that of one thing there can be no doubt; The mere act of canvassing for a candidate cannot amount to undue influence within the meaning of Section 171-C of the Penal Code."
24. The Supreme Court in case of Krishnamoorthy V. Sivakumar (2015) 3 SCC 467 has reiterated the law laid down in Aad Lal v. Kanshi Ram 1980 (2) SCC 350 with respect to degree of pleading and proof of undue infuence. Para 55 of the decision rendered in Krishnamoorthy v. Sivakumar (Supra) is relevant here and quoted below ;
55 In Aad Lal v. Kanshi Ram, while deliberating on undue influence as enshrined under section 123(2) of the 1951 Act, it has been held thus: (SCC pp 353-54, para 11).
"11. it has to be remembered that it is an essential ingredient of the corrupt practice of "undue influence" under sub-section (2) of Section 123 of the Act, that there should be any direct or indirect interference or attempt to interfere' on the part of the candidate or his age, or of any other person with the consent of the candidate or his agent, with the free exercise of any electoral right. Therre are two provisios to the sub-section, but they are obviously not applicable to the contro- versy before us. It was therefore, necessary, for the purpose of establishing the corrupt practice of "undue influence", to prove that there was any direct or indirect interference or attempt to interfere with the exercise of any electoral right.
(Emphasis supplied) 25. With respect to undue influence, the principles have been explained in (2015) 3 SCC Para, 58 which reads thus : 58. From the aforesaid authorities, the following principles can be culled out; 58.1 The words "undue influence" are not to be understood or conferred a meaning in the context of "English Statutes"
58.2 The Indian election law pays regard to the use of such influence having the tendency to bring about the result that has been contemplated in the clause.
58.3 If an act which is calculated to interfere with the free exercise of electoral right, is the true and effe- ctive test whether or not a candidate is quilty of undue influence.
58.4 The word "direct or indirect" used in the provision have their significance and they are to be applied bearing in mind the factual context.
58.5 Canvassing by a Minister or an issue of a whip in the from of a request is permissible unless there is compulsion on the electorate to vote in the manner indicated.
58.6 The structure of the provisions contained in Section 171-C IPC are to be kept in view while appre- ciating the expression "undue influence" used in Section 123(2) of the 1951 Act.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 193658.7 The two provisos added to Section 123(2) do not take away the effect of the principal or main provision.
58.8 Freedom in the exercise of the judgment which engulfs a voters right a free choice, in selecting the candidate whom he believes to be best fitted to represent the constituency, has to be given due weightage.
58.9 There should never be tyranny over the mind which would put fetters and scuttle the free exericse of an electorate.
58.10 The concept of undue influence applies at both the stages, namely, pre-voting and at the time of casting of vote.
58.11 "undue influence" is not to be equated with "proper influence" and, therefore, legitimate canvassing is permissible in a democratic set up.
58.12 Free exrcise of electoral right has a nexus with direct or indirect interference or attempt to interfere."
26. In the instant petition, it would reveal that though different names have been stated by the petitioner but nowhere the returned candidate has been named to be instrumental in such allurement for withdrawal. The evidence is completely blurred and ambiguous because the fact that the persons who have been named and at whose behalf they were working has not been clearly stated. The identity of the said callers who rang up to different associates of the petitioner is also not clear. The associates of the petitioner who received the Phone calls have also not come up in evidence and one of the witnesses e., P.W.2 has given shaky evidence which also do not substantiate any fact, therefore, in absence of such evidence when the proof is required to be akin to the evidence like a cirminal case no presumption can be drawn Consequently, after evaluating the entire evidence with respect to the offer made by phone calls, the same has not been established by accept- able cogent evidence which may lead to show that undue influece was exercised. In the result, it is held that the petitoner has failed to bring any evidence on record that the returned candidate has exrcised undue influence threat or pressure for withdrawal of the candidature of petitoner as also the other contesting candidates. Accordingly, the finding to issue no. 1 s answered in negative i.e., "as not proved".
27. Now with respect to issue No. 2 that "whether the respondent No. 1 (returned candidate) had offered free food and other articles to the electors to influence the electors to vote for him". the respective pleading and evidence is examined. At paras 8.11 to 8.14 the petitioner has made different pleadings in this regard. The reading of petition would show that it is stated that the pettioner visited different polling booths along-with Arjun Singh Thakur, Rajesh Kumar Pudo, Shri Santosh Yadav and Shri Pankaj Sarkar. They saw that the voters were brought to the polling booths in transport vehicle bearing No. C.G. 19T 0841 driven by one vikas Gaine and in another vehicle bearing No. C.G. 04ZD-7891 Dirven by one Asim Das. It has also been stated that the food articles were also given to the different voters. A perusal of statements of Rupdhar Pudo, the petitioner; Arjun Singh (P.W.2), Shri Santosh Yadav (P.W.3) and Rajesh Kumar Pudo (P.W. 4) would show that similar statements have been made. The drivers of the vehicles who have been named as Vikas Gaine or Asim Das have not been examined. Even they were not summoped. Reading of the statements would show that the witnesses have deposed that having asked the drivers, they have disclosed that the voters were being brought at the instance of Bhoj Raj Nag, the returned candidate, and Rs. 200/- was paid for each voters Except the oral evidence no other supporting evidence in support of fact has been placed on record. Another person who disclosed the fact is named as Uttam Das. Uttam Das was said to be the worker of Bjp. He has also not been examined.
28. Therefore the evidence which has been adduced by witnesses P.W. 1 to P.W. 4 are in similar line that having aksed the drivers of the vehicles, they discolsed the fact that they had brought the voters at the instance of the returned candidate is only hearsay. The petitioner did not make any effort even to call for the witnesses so as to make enlightenment of facts. The said statements are not direct and they contain only bald allega- tions which have been denied by the respondent No. 1 flatly, therefore, in order to prove the fact that the voters were being carried at the instance of respondent/returned candidate., it is presumptive to attach the liability with the returned candidate and such presumption cannot be drawn in an election petition.
29. Furhter more it is stated that near the voting booths within 100 meters foods were distributed and having asked it was disclosed that it was at the instance of Bhojraj Nag. Likewise statements have been made by witnesses P.W. 1 to P.W. 4. The statemnts would show that carryign of voters and the distrubtion of food were recorded in the video camera and mobile by the witnesses. No evidence has been placed about such electornic evidence. The petitioner has stated that no complaint was made about the bringing or carryingर्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1937 the voters by vehicle at Booth No. 18 either to the election and proof there of would be not preponderance of probabilities as in Civil action but proof beyond reasonable doubt as in criminal trials". 16. The above decision has been followed in MercyKutty Amma v. Kadavoor Sivadasan (2004) 2 SCC 217, vide SCC vide SCC pp 225-26 para 27 where it was abserved; "27. Allegations of corrupt practices are quasi-criminal charges and the proof that would be required in the support thereof would be as in a criminal charge. The charges of corrupt partices are to be equated with crimianl charges and proof thereof would be not preponde- rance of probabilities as in civil action but proof beyond reasonable doubt as in a crimianl trial."
17. A basic principle in the law relating to elections and election petitions is that the mandate of the people as expressed in the electionresults should ordinarily be respected by courts, and the election of a successful candidate should not be lightly set aside, vide R.P. Moidutty v. P.T. Kunju Mohammad (2000) 1 SCC 481 vide SCC pp. 488-89, para 14, where it was observed.
"14. It is a basic to the law of elections and election petitions that in a democracy, the mandate of the people as expressed at the hustings must prevail and be respected by the courts and that is why the election of a successful candidate is not to be set aside lightly. A heavy onus ies on the election petitioner seeking setting aside of the election of a successful candidate to make out a clear case for such relief both in the pleadings and at the trial. The mandate of the people is one as has been truly, freely and purely expressed. The electoral process in a democracy such as ours is too sacrosanct to be permitted to be polluted by coruupt practices. If the court arrive at a finding of commission of corrupt practice by a returned candidate or his election agent or by any other person with the consent of a returned candidate or his election agent or by any other person with the consent of a returned condidate or his election agent then the election of the returned candidate shall be declared to be void. The underlying principle is that corrupt practice having been committed, the result of the election does not echo the true voice of the people. As a consequences flowing from the proof of corrupt practice at the election are serious, the onus of establishing commission of corrupt practice lies heavily on the person who alleges the same. The onus of proof is not discharged merely on preponderance of probabilities, the standard of proof required is akin to that of proving a criminal or quasi-criminal charge. Clear cut evidence, wholly credible and reliable, is needed to prove beyond doubt the charge of corrupt practice."
18. The same view has been taken by this Court in Mahant Shreo Nath v. Choudhary Ranbir Singh (1970) 3 SCC 647, SCC at p. 649 para 4; Manphul Singh v. Surinder sing (1973) 2 SCC 599, SCC at p 608 para 13, Rahim Khan v. Kursid Ahmed (1974) 2 SCC 660, SCC at p. 666, para 9, Bir Chandra Barman vl. Anil Sarkar (1976) 3 SCC 88, SCC at p 91, para 5. Lakshmi Raman Acharya v. Chandan Singh (1977) 1 SCC 423, SCC at p. 424, para 2; Amolak- chand Chhazed v. Bhagwandas Arya SCC at p. 573 (1977) 3 SCC 566, SCC at p. 573, para 13."
32. Similar view was also taken in Anvar P.V. Vs. P.K. Basheer and others (2014) 10 SCC 473 wherein it was held that the corrupt practice is substantially akin to the criminal charges and has held as under. "39. It is now the settled law that a charge of corrupt practice is substantially akin to a criminal charge. A two judge bench of this Court while dealing with the said issue in Razik Ram v. Jaswant Singh Chouhan (1975) 4 SCC 769 held as follows (SCC p. 776 para 15); "15. The same evidence which may be sufficient to regard a fact as proved in a civil suit, may be considered insufficient for a conviction in a criminal action. While in the former, a mere preponderance of probability may constitute an adequate basis of decision, in the latter a far higher degree of assurance and judicial certitude is requisite for a conviction. The same is largely true about proof of a charge of corrupt practice, which cannot be established by mere balance of probabilities, and, if, after giving due consideration and effect to the totality of the evidence and circumstances of the case, the mind of the Court is left rocking with reasonable doubt-not being the doubt of a timid, fickle or vacillating mind-as to the veracity of the charge, it must hold the same as not proved."{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1938 33. The same view was followed by the Supereme Court in P.C. Thomas v. P.M. ismail (2009) 10 SCC 239 wherein it was held thus; "42. As regards, the decision of this Court in Razik Ram and other decisions on the issue, relied upon on on behalf of the appellant, there is no quarrel with the legal position that the charge of corrupt practice is to be equated with criminal charge and the proof required in support thereof would be as in a criminal charge and not preponderance of probabilities, as in a civil action but proof beyond reasonable doubt. It is well settled that it after balancing the evidence adduced there still remains little boubt in proving the charge, its benefit must go to the returned candidate. However, it is equally well settled that while insisting upon the statndard of proof beyond a resonable doubt, the courts are not required to extend or stretch the doctrine to such an extreme extent as to make it well-nigh impossible to prove any allegation of corrupt practice. Such an approach would defeat and frustrate the very laudable and sacrosanct object of the Act in maintaining purity of the electoralprocess, (See 5. Harcharan Singh v. S. Sajjan Singh (1985) 1 SCC 370."
34. Thus having regard to the pleadings and evidence on record, this Court is of the opinion that neither the petitioner is able to prove the undue influence that the respondent or his associates have offered any amount for withdrawal of the candidature to the petitioner by any acceptable cogent evidence and the evidence which is on record do not substantiate the facts that the money was offered for withdrawal of the candida- ture.
35. Further the evidence of bringing the voters to the polling booth as a also supplying them food has neither been proved by any acceptable evidence except the oral bald averments. The incidents though were stated to have been captured by videography, but the same is not placed on record. The alleged complaint made to the officials about the same incidents i.e., distribution of food and brining of the voters to the polling booths has also not been placed on record. Therefore, no reliable evidence has been placed on record to show that it was at the behest of returned candidate and the voters were influenced to exercise their free choice by such offering. As a result, the petitioner has failed to bring the evidence in view of the law laid down by the Supreme Court (Supra).
36. As a result, the election petiton is table to be and is hereby dismissed.
Sd/- GOUTAM BHADURI JUDGE.
र्ऽी॰र्५ी ॉए
२न्ैर्ईीण्ध्.
;श्न्ह्म]र् ीण् ष्ींर्न्ीप्रर्९ीद्ध र्र्क्तीी ॉप्रए र्झ्ीन्ई र्प्रीय् र्र्ऽीी्रण् ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA Nirvachan Sadan, Ashoka Road, New Delhi-110001
New Delhi, dated 13th March, 2018—22 Phalguna, 1939 (Saka)
No. 82/CG-LA/(16/2014)/2018.—In pursuance of Section 106 (b) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (43 of 1951), the Election Commission hereby publishes Judgement dated the 8th December, 2017 of the High Court of Chhattisgarh Bilaspur in Election Petition No. 16 of 2014.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1939HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR
EP No. 16 of 2014
PETITIONER : Rupdhar Pudo S/o Jalluram Pudo Aged About 30 years R/o Village-Dargarh, P.O. Sadhu-Michgaon, Tah Durgukondal, P.S. Kodeknurse, Distt. Kanker C.G., Pin-
494669.
VERSUS
RESPONDENTS : 1. Bhojraj Nag S/o Laxminath Nag Aged About 42 Yeas R/o Village-Himoda, P.O.
P.S. & Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker, C.G.
2. Manturam Pawar S/o Subran Singh Pawar Aged About 47 years R/o Pakhanjur
P.O. And P.S. Pakhanjur, Tah. Pakhanjur, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 3. Jaiprakash Padmakar Padda S/o M.R. Padmakar Padda Aged About 30 Years R/o Gawdepara, Ward No. 15, P.O. & P.S. Bhanupratappur, Tah. Bhanupratappur, Distt. Uttar Bastar, Kanker C.G.
4. Anil Netam S/o Daniram Netam Aged About 38 Yeas R/o Chikhli, P.O. Useli,
Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar, Kanker C.G.
5. Bhim Singh Usendi S/o Mayaram Usendi Aged Acbout 36 years R/o Bade Jaitpur,
Post Office-Kamta, P.S. And Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 6. Devnath Hidko S/o Sunher Hidko Aged About 27 years R/o Pufgaon, P.O. &
P.S. Antagarh, Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar, Kanker C.G.
7. Mahadev Mandavi S/o Vishalram Mandavi Aged about 27 Years R/o Koilibeda Chandni Chowk, P.O. And P.S. Koilibeda, Tah. Pakhanjur Distt. Uttar Bastar
Kanker C.G.
8. Parsuram Pawar S/o Jagoram Pawar Aged About 44 Years R/o Belgal Sitlapara,
P.O. Tekameta, P.S. Bande, Tah. Pakhanjur, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 9. Raghunath Kumeti S/o Late Samrath Kumeti Aged About 42 Years R/o Tenkal Patelpara, House No. 26 P.O. And P.S. Antagarh, Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G.
10. Savita Pawar W/o Manturam Pawar Aged About 35 Years R/o Pakhanjur P.O.
And P.S. Pakhanjur, Tah. Pakhanjur, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 11. Shankarlal Netam S/o Late Sukhlal Netam Aged About 25 Years R/o imlipadar, P.O. and P.S. Antagarh, Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G. 12. Virendra Kumar Hidami S/o Sagruram Hidami Aged About 25 Years R/o Sarandi Uparpara, P.O. Sarandi, P.S. And Tah. Antagarh, Distt. Uttar Bastar Kanker C.G.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1940For the Petitoner : Mr. Sudeep Verma Advocate For the Respondent No. 1 : Mr. Ramakant Mishra, Advocate For the intervener : Mr. Himanshu Kr. Sharma, Adv.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Goutam Bhaduri
C. A. V. JUDGMENT
Judgment reserved on 15.11.2017
Judgment delivered on 08.12.2017
1. The primary relief sought in this petition is to declare the election of returned candidate Bhojraj Nag who was declared elected in the by-election of Chhattisgarh State Legislative Assembly Area No. 79 of Antagarh Constituency as held on 13.09.2014.
2. The instant petition is under Sections 80 & 80-A read with section 81 of the Representation of the People Act., 1951 (hereinafter referred to as the Act of 1951). The grounds which are urged in this petition are that respondent No. 1 has resorted to corrupt practice thereby the result of election is liable to be set aside.
3. The brief facts of the case are that initially in the year 2013, the general election to the Antagarh Legislative Assembly was conducted by the Election Commission. The present election petition is concerned with the result of by-election of Legislative Assembly Area no. 79 of Antagarh Constituency held on 13.09.2014. After the initial election of 2013, the returned candidate who was elected in the year 2013 had vacated the seat therefore new notification for election was issued. The election Commission thereafter issued notifica- tion on 20.08.2014 to conduct by-election for the Antagarh Constituency and the following dates were fixed for conducting the election.
S. No. Event
Date
20-08-2014 1. Issue of notification 2. Last date for filling nominations 27-08-2014
3. Scrutiny of nominations 28-08-2014 4. Last date for withdrawal of candidatures 30-08-2014 13-09-2014 5. Date of Polling
6. Counting of votes 16-09-2014 7. Date before which the election shall be completed 19-09-2014
4. After the result of polling, respondent no. 1 was declared as returned candidate.
5. (i) Mr. Sudeep Verma, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner would submit that as per the election programme, the last date of withdrawal of candidature was on 30-08-2014 and out of 13 candidates who had filled their nominations, 11 had withdrawn their candidature. The petitoner belongs to ambedkarite Party of India and the repondent returned candidat belongs to Bhartiya Janta Party. It is stated that in order to pressurize withdrawal of the candidates who were 11 in number undue influence and pressure tactics were adopted by the respondent returned candidate. It is stated that the petitioner was also approached and request was made to him for withdrawal of his candidature through mobile of one Omprakash Gupta and money was offered but the petitioner did not accept the same.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1941(ii) It is further stated that during such conversation it was also disclosed that the candidature of Indian National Congress has withdrawn his candidature by use of undue influence and by payment of money, therefore, the corrupt practice was adopted by the respondent it is furhter submitted that the petitioner had visited various polling booths on the date of polling on 13.09.2014 and it was found that different voters were carried to the polling booths in different vehicles, It was stated that having enquired, it was revealed that the voters were being brought to the polling stations at the behest of respondent no. 1 and in lieu of thereof amount was paid by respondent no. 1 therefore the same also amounts to corrupt practice. Further, it is submitted that free supply of fruits was made to the voters apart from various means of conveyance used to carry the voters to the polling booths.
(iii) Referring to the pleadings and statements, learned counsel would submit that the oral evidence in this respect has been adduced before the Court and the petitioner has examined as many as 4 witnesses including the petitioner and all have equivocally supported the fact that during the poll- ing, the voters were being carried on payment of money and the work was delegated to few per- sons. He went through to the statements of petitioner Rupdhar Pudo and 3 witnesses namely Arjun Singh Thakur (P.W.2), Santosh Yadav(P.W.3) and Rajesh Kumar Pudo (P.W.4) and submitted that all the videos were also recorded and the complaint was also made to the Election Commission. Therefore, the petitioner has placed all the evidence on record to show that corrupt practice was adopted by respondent No. 1 Bhojraj Nag by payment of money and by other allurements to the voters. Therefore it would be termed as corrupt practice and the election of respondent no. 1 be set aside.
6. Per contra, Shri Ramakant Mishra, learned counsel appearing for repondent No. 1 would submit that the pleadings in the petition are completely vague and no primary evidence has been adduced by the respondent it is further submitted that though the reference of one O.P. Gupta, has been made but no efforts were made to call and examine him as a witness. He further submitted that mere pleading of fact that the other candi- dates who were contesting the election have withdrawn their candidatures, will not prove the fact that money was paid by the returned candidate. He further submitted that no pleading has been made and despite the fact that it is stated that occurrence of incidents was captured in camera, no evidence has been led in this behalf. Therefore, the petition is devoid of merits and deserves to be dismissed at the threshold.
7. On the basis of pleadings of the parties, this Court has framed the following issues on 19.02.2016.
S. No. Issues
Findings
1. Whether the respondent No. 1, (returned candidate) exercised "Not proved" undue influence, threat and Pressure and if so whether it amounts to commission of corrupt practices ?
2. Whether the respondent No. 1 (returned candidate) had offe- "Not proved" red free food and other articles to the electors to influence the electors to vote for him, therefore, it amounts to corrupt Practices ?
3. Whether the election of Respondent No. 1 (returned candi- No
date is liable to be set aside) ?
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have also perused the record and documents filed along- with the petition as well as the evidence adduced during the counsel of trial.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 19429. After closure of the trial, on the last day of closure of arguments of respondents, an applicant has been filed by one Shri Pankaj Mahawar u/s 151 of CPC read with Order 1 Rule 10(2) to implead the applicant Pankaj Mahawar as a party in the case Along-with the petition certain documents have also been placed and the allegations have been made that the petitioner was not able to bring evidence properly before the Court and therefore he may be allowed to be impleaded as a party. The said argument was vehemently opposed by the petitioner and the respondent and submits that the applicant Pankaj Mahawar has neither any locus-standi nor has any interest instead he is trying to protract the trial and the effort is to keep this petition pending. The counsel for the petitioner further refutes the allegation that the case was not contested properly. It is contended that the like nautre of allegation at the closure of case casts a stigma on the petitioner, therefore the application be dismissed with heavy cost.
10. Section 81 of the Representation of People's Act 1951 says that the election petition may be presented on the grounds enumerated u/ss 100 and 101 by any candidate on the elector of concerned constituency within 45 days. The document which has been filed along-with the application by the applicant Pankaj Mahawar would show that the applicant is resident of Gujrati Colony, Dhamtari, Tahsil and District Dhamtari there- fore, apparently as appears he is not an elector/voter of the Antagarh constituency. Along-with the appliaction, the order sheets of 2015 have been placed on record which would show that the applicant was also in know of the fact that the election petition is pending before this Court. The word elector has been defined in the Act of 1951 that person to vote at the election to which the election petition relates. The election petition is of Antagarh constituencey therefore, applicant even remotely can be considered within the definition of elector. The documents e. order sheets of this petition suggest that the applicant was aware of the fact that the case was pending since 2015. At the fag end when the final argument of the respondents were in con- cluding stage, the said application has been filed with an averment that the petitioner was unable to place the evidence which was existing in the case.
11. I an afraid that if such like nature of third party's application is allowed to intervene in such a manner then the entire object of section 81 of the R.P. Act 1951 would be defeated. At the same time the applicant cannot claim himself to be the repository of the entire wisdom and casts stigma on the petitioner especially when the petitioner was also a candidate who contested the election and having lost the election, has filed the election petition before the High Court to set aside the election of the returned candidate on the grounds of undue infulence and corrupt practice. As such the said application appears to have been filed with an oblique motive and to protract the trail of election petition or to keep it alive for some reason or the other. In the result, on overall evaluating the facts, I am of the opinion that the said application is devoid of merits and is liable to be rejected.
12. The record would show that the petitioner has examined himself as P.W. 1 and one Arjun Singh Thakur has been examined as P.W. 2, Santosh Yadav has been examined as P.W. 3, Rajesh Kumar Pudo has been examined as P.W. 4 whereas the respondent no. 1 has examined himself alone.
13. Section 100 (1) (b) lays down that the /commission of corrupt Practice is a ground for declaring the election veid in this context, Section 100 (1) (b) (d) is relevant here and quoted below.
Section 100 of the R.P Act. 1951.
100 Grounds for delcaring election to be void -(1) Subject to the provisions of such sub-section (2) if the High Court is of the opinion:— 1. (a) xxx xxx xxx
(b) that any corrupt practice has been committed by a returned candidate or his election agent or by any other person with the consent of a returned candidate or his election agent; or (c) xxx xxx xxx
(d) that the result of the election, in so far as it concerns a returned candidate, has been materally effected— (i) xxx xxxर्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1943 (ii) by any corrupt practice committed in the interests of the returned candidate by
an agent other than his election agent or.
(iii) xxx xxx
(iv) by any non-compliance with the provisions of the Constitution or of this Act or
of any rules or orders made under this Act,
The High Court shall declare the election of the returned candidate to be void."
14. Further coming back to the point of pleading, reading of Section 83 would show that where an election petition alleges commission of corrupt practice by a candidate, the pleading must contain (a) direct and detailed nature of corrupt practice as defined in 1951 Act; (b) the details of every important particulars giving the time, place, names of persons, use of words and expressions, etc. it must also clearly appear from the allegations that the corrupt practice was indulged with either express or implied consent of the candidate or his election agent.
15. In the present case, with respect to issue no. 1 whether the retrned candidate has exercised undue influence threat and pressure to pressurize the withdrawal of his opponent candidates, the respective pleadings made by the petitioner was perused. At Para 8.8 of the petition, the pleading has been made that one Om Prakash Gupta had given a call to him by his mobile number and offered money for withdawal of candidature and tried to allure, influence and pressurize the petitioner, in the pleading and avidence of the pititoner it is stated that on Mobile No. 9406466221 he had received the call from one Om Prakash Gupta. In the pleading though it has been stated that apart from allurement, influence pressure was exerted, but in the statement nothing particulars have been described. Only omni-bus averments have been made and in the evidence it is stated that in lieu of withdrawal of his candidature, he was offered whatever he would have asked that would be fulfilled. It has also not been made clear that how much amount was offered and what sort of pressure was exerted. Though a particular mobile phone number has been stated, but no evidence is adduced or on record to show that to whom the said number belonged. The evidence is furhter absent to show that whether the phone number which received the call, whether it was of the petitioner or any of the other persons. It is also not clear that what was the identity of the alleged caller O.P.Gupta. If the petitioner who was also a contesting candidate had received such phone call, the best evidence to prove the call details could have been placed on record along-with the identity of the caller. Nothing has been placed on record to show that when it was called, what was the timing, who was the caller and his identity.
16. The petitioner though claimed that the receiving number belonged to him but that too has not been estab- lished. Only paid oral staement has been adduced about the call. The official records to prove the identity of receiver and caller could have been proved by evidence, but the same was withheld by the petitioner. Despite the best evidence available to the petitioner, the petitioner has chosen not to place it on record. Only by mere submission that the petitioner was offered money and allured for withdrawal of candidatures, no inference can be drawn in absence of proof beyond doubt. Further more, the statement of petitioner in this regard would show that it was the opinion and inference of the petitioner that the other candidates barring respondents have received the money for withdrawal. If the petitioner was so sanguine of the fact that the money was offered to other 11 candidates then in order to prove the facts and denial any one could have been summoned as a witness. Therefore, the opinion of the petitioner cannot take place of evidence to prove the facts.
17. Further in evidence the petitioner had given a specific date of call, it was stated by the petitioner that on 29.08.2014 one Johan Gawade, who was the ex-president of Durg kondal and one Narendra Besre, who was one of the worker of the Bjp, contacted the petitioner on his mobile and asked the petitoner to meet and thereafter it was suggested to the petitioner to take back his name as condidate. It is further stated that in lieu of withdrawal of names of Jagannath Sahu, Anil Chandel and Narendra Besre offer was made to pay heavy amounts. Subsequently, the petitioner came to know that one Manturam Pawar who was authorised candidate of Congress Party, had also taken back his name.
18. So again inference has been made that respondent had paid different amounts to the contesting candidates and the other candidates have withdrawn their names to contest the election after acceptance of such money. However, except the inference nothings on record to come to a definite finding. Despite the fact that specific date has been given that on 29.08.2014 the petitioner had received the phone call from Johan Gawade and Narendra Besare, the call details which could have been placed on record as a proof of a positive call on a particular date has not been produced. Therefore, even if the conversation was not recorded in order to draw{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1944 a little inference, the petitoner could have produced the call details along with the identity of caller and phone number to show that he received certain phonecalls from a particular person on a particular date, So the minimum evidence too is completely absent. There is no reason assigned by the petitioner that why such evidence was withheld, which would have been otherwise available so as to climb even the first ladder of evidence.
19. The statement would further show that the petitoner has stated that on 30.08.2014 while he was with Arjun Singh Thakur at his residence, he received a phone call on his mobile number. The Mobile number is again stated to be 9406466221. There is no evidence on record to show that the said mobile number belonges to the petitioner,. Furhter the statement is made that similar phone call was received by Arjun Singh Thakur and Narendra Bansod, who were the post holders in the party from which the petitioner was contesting. Arjun Singh Thakur has been exmined as PW-2. He has stated that he was holding the mobile no. 9406371295. it is stated that the Secretary of Chief Minister, Raman Singh had called him disclosing his identity as Om Prakash and he was aksed to advice Rupdhar Pudo to take back the name and in lieu thereof money was offered. Neither the evidence thereof has been produced nor any document has been placed to show with reference to the phone number that it belongs to him. Similar analogy also applied here that when the details of particular date and the mobile number was given by the witness of the petitioner, then in such case, the petitioner could have placed on record the minimum fact that the said number belongs to Arjun Singh. Thakur (PW 2), who had recevied the alleged phone call. The caller identity could have been proved by the record, but nothing has been placed on record. In the cross-examination the witness has referred the hearsay conversation with Rupdhar Pudo about receipt of the phone call, which too is not admissible in evidence.
20. Arjun Singh Thakur (PW-2) has further stated the petitioner had made complaint to the Chief Election Officer but the same fact is not stated by the petitioner. No document is also placed on record to show that the offer was made to the petitioner Rupdhar Pudo and party workers have complained to the Election Officer. In the statement, the furhter reference is also made to one Narendra Bansod, who was shown as National Secretary of Ambedkarite Party. It was stated that he also received phone call, whereby the offer was made to take back the candidature in lieu of the money. The said Narendra Bansod has not been examined before the Court, it is not clear that why his evidence was withheld when he was also availabel as a primary witness and could have disclosed the facts with respect to the allegations made by the petitioner, therefore, the evidence that the petitioner and the witness PW-2 have deposed about the offer made for withdrawal of candidature, in both the statements though the specific phone number with particular timing has been stated, but nothing has been placed on record to show and prove that the recipients of the number were the witnesses i.e. the petitioner and PW.-2. In absence of reliable evidence of the petitioner who was in the hold of such evidence to show his dentity of holding a particular number the adverse inference would follow that he has withheld the evidence himself, therefore, only on the basis of bald statement the facts cannot be accepted as a gospel truth that he had received the phone call with offer of money to withdraw the candidature.
21. The degree of proof as required man election petition has been laid down by the Supreme Court in a case law reported in (1995) 5 SCC 347-Gajanan Krishnaji Bapat vs. Dattaji Raghobaji Meghe wherein Their Lordship held that "in order to unseat a returned candidate the crrupt practice must be specifically alleged ard strictly proved to have been committted by the returned candidate, himself or by his election agent or by any other person with the consent of the returned candidate or by his election agent. The suspicion however strong cannot take the place of proof, whether the allegations are sought to be established by direct evidence or by circumstantial evidence. Since pleadings play an important role in an election petition, the legislature has provided that the allegations of corrupt practice must be properly alleged and both the material facts and particulars provided in the petition itself so as to disclose a complete cause of action."
22. With respect to undue influence and corrupt practice nothing is pleaded that the named person Omprakash Gupta was acting on behalf of the respondent or he was acting on behalf of any other candidate. Only by making reference that offer was made to withdraw the candidatures, it cannot be conclusively proved that Omprakash Gupta was acting on behalf of the respondent.
23. with respect to pleading of undue influence, the petitioner has failed to furnish concise material practiculars as to in what manner the undue influence was exercised. On reading of Section 83 of the Act, 1951 it shows that substantive part of Section 83 consists of three improtant elements namely the election petition should contain concise statement of material fact which the election petitioner relied upon. The emphasis is on the material facts which should be stated in the concise form. Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Charan Lal Sahu Vs. Giani Jail Singh (1984) 1 SCC 390 while considering the "undue influence" as enumerated inर्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1945 Section 18(1), emphasizing the need of precise, specific and unambiguous pleading of corrupt practice particularly with reference to undue influence held thus :—
"Therefore, in order that the offence of undue influence can be said to have been made out within the meaning of Section 171-C of the Penal Code, something more than the mere act of canvassing for a candidate must be shown to have been done by the offender. That something more may, for example, be in the nature of a threat of an injury to a candidate or a voter as stated in sub-section (2) (a) of Section 171-C of the Penal Code or, it may consist of inducing a belief of Divine displeasure in the mind of a candidate or a voter as stated in sub-section (2) (b). The act alleged as constituting undue influence must be in the nature of a pressure or tyranny on the mind of the candidate or the voter it is not possible to enumerate exhaustively the divers categories of acts which fall within the definition of undue influence it is enough for our purpose to say, that of one thing there can be no doubt; The mere act of canvassing for a candidate cannot amount to undue influence within the meaning of Section 171-C of the Penal Code."
24. The Supreme Court in case of Krishnamoorthy V. Sivakumar (2015) 3 SCC 467 has reiterated the law laid down in Aad Lal v. Kanshi Ram 1980 (2) SCC 350 with respect to degree of pleading and proof of undue infuence. Para 55 of the decision rendered in Krishnamoorthy v. Sivakumar (Supra) is relevant here and quoted below ;
55 In Aad Lal v. Kanshi Ram, while deliberating on undue influence as enshrined under section 123(2) of the 1951 Act, it has been held thus: (SCC pp 353-54, para 11).
"11. it has to be remembered that it is an essential ingredient of the corrupt practice of "undue influence" under sub-section (2) of Section 123 of the Act, that there should be any direct or indirect interference or attempt to interfere' on the part of the candidate or his age, or of any other person with the consent of the candidate or his agent, with the free exercise of any electoral right. Therre are two provisios to the sub-section, but they are obviously not applicable to the contro- versy before us. It was therefore, necessary, for the purpose of establishing the corrupt practice of "undue "influence", to prove that there was any direct or indirect interference or attempt to inter- fere with the exercise of any electoral right.
(Emphasis supplied) 25. With respect to undue influence, the principles have been explained in (2015) 3 SCC Para, 58 which reads thus : 58. From the aforesaid authorities, the following principles can be culled out;
58.1 The words "undue influence" are not to be understood or conferred a meaning in the context of "English Statutes"
58.2 The Indian election law pays regard to the use of such influence having the tendency to bring about the result that has been contemplated in the clause.
58.3 If an act which is calculated to interfere with the free exercise of electoral right, is the true and effe- ctive test whether or not a candidate is quilty of undue influence.
58.4 The word "direct or indirect" used in the provision have their significance and they are to be applied bearing in mind the factual context.
58.5 Canvassing by a Minister or an issue of a whip in the from of a request is permissible unless there is compulsion on the electorate to vote in the manner indicated.
58.6 The structure of the provisions contained in Section 171-C IPC are to be kept in view while appre- ciating the expression "undue influence" used in Section 123(2) of the 1951 Act.
58.7 The two provisos added to Section 123(2) do not take away the effect of the principal or main provision.
58.8 Freedom in the exercise of the judgment which engulfs a voters right a free choice, in selecting the candidate whom he believes to be best fitted to represent the constituency, has to be given due weightage.
58.9 There should never be tyranny over the mind which would put fetters and scuttle the free exericse of an electorate.
58.10 The concept of undue influence applies at both the stages, namely, pre-voting and at the time of casting of vote.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 194658.11 "undue influence" is not to be equated with "proper influence" and, therefore, legitimate canvassing is permissible in a democratic set up.
58.12 Free exrcise of electoral right has a nexus with direct or indirect interference or attempt to interfere."
26. In the instant petition, it would reveal that though different names have been stated by the petitioner but nowhere the returned candidate has been named to be instrumental in such allurement for withdrawal. The evidence is completely blurred and ambiguous because the fact that the persons who have been named and at whose behalf they were working has not been clearly stated. The identity of the said callers who rang up to different associates of the petitioner is also not clear. The associates of the petitioner who received the Phone calls have also not come up in evidence and one of the witnesses e., P.W.2 has given shaky evidence which also do not substantiate any fact, therefore, in absence of such evidence when the proof is required to be akin to the evidence like a cirminal case no presumption can be drawn Consequently, after evaluating the entire evidence with respect to the offer made by phone calls, the same has not been established by accept- able cogent evidence which may lead to show that undue influece was exercised. In the result, it is held that the petitoner has failed to bring any evidence on record that the returned candidate has exrcised undue influence threat or pressure for withdrawal of the candidature of petitoner as also the other contesting candidates. Accordingly, the finding to issue no. 1 s answered in negative i.e., "as not proved".
27. Now with respect to issue No. 2 that "whether the respondent No. 1 (returned candidate) had offered free food and other articles to the electors to influence the electors to vote for him". the respective pleading and evidence is examined. At paras 8.11 to 8.14 the petitioner has made different pleadings in this regard. The reading of petition would show that it is stated that the pettioner visited different polling booths along-with Arjun Singh Thakur, Rajesh Kumar Pudo, Shri Santosh Yadav and Shri Pankaj Sarkar. They saw that the voters were brought to the polling booths in transport vehicle bearing No. C.G. 19T 0841 driven by one vikas Gaine and in another vehicle bearing No. C.G. 04ZD-7891 Dirven by one Asim Das. It has also been stated that the food articles were also given to the different voters. A perusal of statements of Rupdhar Pudo, the petitioner; Arjun Singh (P.W.2), Shri Santosh Yadav (P.W.3) and Rajesh Kumar Pudo (P.W. 4) would show that similar statements have been made. The drivers of the vehicles who have been named as Vikas Gaine or Asim Das have not been examined. Even they were not summoped. Reading of the statements would show that the witnesses have deposed that having asked the drivers, they have disclosed that the voters were being brought at the instance of Bhoj Raj Nag, the returned candidate, and Rs. 200/- was paid for each voters Except the oral evidence no other supporting evidence in support of fact has been placed on record. Another person who disclosed the fact is named as Uttam Das. Uttam Das was said to be the worker of Bjp. He has also not been examined.
28. Therefore the evidence which has been adduced by witnesses P.W. 1 to P.W. 4 are in similar line that having aksed the drivers of the vehicles, they discolsed the fact that they had brought the voters at the instance of the returned candidate is only hearsay. The petitioner did not make any effort even to call for the witnesses so as to make enlightenment of facts. The said statements are not direct and they contain only bald allega- tions which have been denied by the respondent No. 1 flatly, therefore, in order to prove the fact that the voters were being carried at the instance of respondent/returned candidate., it is presumptive to attach the liability with the returned candidate and such presumption cannot be drawn in an election petition.
29. Furhter more it is stated that near the voting booths within 100 meters foods were distributed and having asked it was disclosed that it was at the instance of Bhojraj Nag. Likewise statements have been made by witnesses P.W. 1 to P.W. 4. The statemnts would show that carryign of voters and the distrubtion of food were recorded in the video camera and mobile by the witnesses. No evidence has been placed about such electornic evidence. The petitioner has stated that no complaint was made about the bringing or carrying the voters by vehicle at Booth No. 18 either to the election and proof there of would be not preponderance of probabilities as in Civil action but proof beyond reasonable doubt as in criminal trials". 16. The above decision has been followed in MercyKutty Amma v. Kadavoor Sivadasan (2004) 2 SCC 217, vide SCC vide SCC pp 225-26 para 27 where it was abserved; "27. Allegations of corrupt practices are quasi-criminal charges and the proof that would be required in the support thereof would be as in a criminal charge. The charges of corrupt partices are to be equated with crimianl charges and proof thereof would be not preponde- rance of probabilities as in civil action but proof beyond reasonable doubt as in a crimianl trial."र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1947 17. A basic principle in the law relating to elections and election petitions is that the mandate of the people as expressed in the electionresults should ordinarily be respected by courts, and the election of a successful candidate should not be lightly set aside, vide R.P. Moidutty v. P.T. Kunju Mohammad (2000) 1 SCC 481 vide SCC pp. 488-89, para 14, where it was observed.
"14. It is a basic to the law of elections and election petitions that in a democracy, the mandate of the people as expressed at the hustings must prevail and be respected by the courts and that is why the election of a successful candidate is not to be set aside lightly. A heavy onus ies on the election petitioner seeking setting aside of the election of a successful candidate to make out a clear case for such relief both in the pleadings and at the trial. The mandate of the people is one as has been truly, freely and purely expressed. The electoral process in a democracy such as ours is too sacrosanct to be permitted to be polluted by coruupt practices. If the court arrive at a finding of commission of corrupt practice by a returned candidate or his election agent or by any other person with the consent of a returned candidate or his election agent or by any other person with the consent of a returned condidate or his election agent then the election of the returned candidate shall be declared to be void. The underlying principle is that corrupt practice having been committed, the result of the election does not echo the true voice of the people. As a consequences flowing from the proof of corrupt practice at the election are serious, the onus of establishing commission of corrupt practice lies heavily on the person who alleges the same. The onus of proof is not discharged merely on preponderance of probabilities, the standard of proof required is akin to that of proving a criminal or quasi-criminal charge. Clear cut evidence, wholly credible and reliable, is needed to prove beyond doubt the charge of corrupt practice."
18. The same view has been taken by this Court in Mahant Shreo Nath v. Choudhary Ranbir Singh (1970) 3 SCC 647, SCC at p. 649 para 4; Manphul Singh v. Surinder sing (1973) 2 SCC 599, SCC at p 608 para 13, Rahim Khan v. Kursid Ahmed (1974) 2 SCC 660, SCC at p. 666, para 9, Bir Chandra Barman vl. Anil Sarkar (1976) 3 SCC 88, SCC at p 91, para 5. Lakshmi Raman Acharya v. Chandan Singh (1977) 1 SCC 423, SCC at p. 424, para 2; Amolak- chand Chhazed v. Bhagwandas Arya SCC at p. 573 (1977) 3 SCC 566, SCC at p. 573, para 13."
32. Similar view was also taken in Anvar P.V. Vs. P.K. Basheer and others (2014) 10 SCC 473 wherein it was held that the corrupt practice is substantially akin to the criminal charges and has held as under. "39. It is now the settled law that a charge of corrupt practice is substantially akin to a criminal charge.
A two judge bench of this Court while dealing with the said issue in Razik Ram v. Jaswant Singh Chouhan (1975) 4 SCC 769 held as follows (SCC p. 776 para 15); "15. The same evidence which may be sufficient to regard a fact as proved in a civil suit, may be considered insufficient for a conviction in a criminal action. While in the former, a mere preponderance of probability may constitute an adequate basis of decision, in the latter a far higher degree of assurance and judicial certitude is requisite for a conviction.
The same is largely true about proof of a charge of corrupt practice, which cannot be established by mere balance of probabilities, and, if, after giving due consideration and effect to the totality of the evidence and circumstances of the case, the mind of the Court is left rocking with reasonable doubt-not being the doubt of a timid, fickle or vacillating mind-as to the veracity of the charge, it must hold the same as not proved." 33. The same view was followed by the Supereme Court in P.C. Thomas v. P.M. ismail (2009) 10 SCC 239 wherein it was held thus; "42. As regards, the decision of this Court in Razik Ram and other decisions on the issue, relied upon on on behalf of the appellant, there is no quarrel with the legal position that the charge of corrupt practice is to be equated with criminal charge and the proof required in support thereof would be as in a criminal charge and not preponderance of probabilities, as in a civil action but proof beyond{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1948 reasonable doubt. It is well settled that it after balancing the evidence adduced there still remains little boubt in proving the charge, its benefit must go to the returned candidate. However, it is equally well settled that while insisting upon the statndard of proof beyond a resonable doubt, the courts are not required to extend or stretch the doctrine to such an extreme extent as to make it well-nigh impossible to prove any allegation of corrupt practice. Such an approach would defeat and frustrate the very laudable and sacrosanct object of the Act in maintaining purity of the electoralprocess, (See 5. Harcharan Singh v. S. Sajjan Singh (1985) 1 SCC 370."
34. Thus having regard to the pleadings and evidence on record, this Court is of the opinion that neither the petitioner is able to prove the undue influence that the respondent or his associates have offered any amount for withdrawal of the candidature to the petitioner by any acceptable cogent evidence and the evidence which is on record do not substantiate the facts that the money was offered for withdrawal of the candida- ture.
35. Further the evidence of bringing the voters to the polling booth as a also supplying them food has neither been proved by any acceptable evidence except the oral bald averments. The incidents though were stated to have been captured by videography, but the same is not placed on record. The alleged complaint made to the officials about the same incidents i.e., distribution of food and brining of the voters to the polling booths has also not been placed on record. Therefore, no reliable evidence has been placed on record to show that it was at the behest of returned candidate and the voters were influenced to exercise their free choice by such offering. As a result, the petitioner has failed to bring the evidence in view of the law laid down by the Supreme Court (Supra).
36. As a result, the election petiton is table to be and is hereby dismissed.
Sd/- GOUTAM BHADURI
JUDGE.
By order,
Sd/-
(NARENDRA N. BUTOLIA) Principal Secretary, Election Commission of India.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1949न्र्ड्डी र्र्ह्मीी९ र्ऽी॰र्५ी र्ऽीभन् ऽप्रॉर्ट्टी
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 802/Confdl./2018/II-1-5/2018.—It is hereby notified that pursuant to Notification No. K. 13016/01/ 2018-US.II dated 01-07-2018 of the Government of India, Ministry of Law and Justice, (Department of Justice), New Delhi, Hon'ble Shri Justice Ajay Kumar Tripathi, Judge of the Patna High Court has assumed charge of the office of the Chief Justice of the High Court of Chhattisgarh in the afternoon of 07th July, 2018.
Bilaspur, the 11th July 2018
No. 810/Confdl./2018/II-1-2/2017.—Hon'ble Shri Justice Thottathil Bhaskaran Nair Radhakrishnan, Chief Justice, High Court of Chhattisgarh, relinquished the charge of the Chief Justice of the High Court of Chhattisgarh in the forenoon of 07th July, 2018 upon his Lordship's appointment as Chief Justice of the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the States of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh pursuant to notification No. K. 13013/01/2018-US.II dated 01-07-2018 issued by the Joint Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry of Law & Justice, (Department of Justice), New Delhi.
Bilaspur, the 12th July 2018
No. 813/Confdl./2018/II-2-1/2018.—Shri Manoj Kumar Singh Thakur, Additional District and Sessions Judge of the special Court for trial of Naxalite Cases, Dantewara is, hereby, assigned the additional charge of the Court of I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Dantewara from the date Shri Nand Kumar Singh Thakur hands over the charge of the Court of I Additional District and Sessions Judge, Dantewara nutil further orders.
By order of the High Court,
NEELAM CHAND SANKHLA, Registrar General.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 54/L.G./2018/II-2-10/2007.—Shri K. Vinod Kujur, Principal Judge, Family Court, Bilaspur is hereby, granted earned leave for 04 days from 18-06-2018 to 21-06-2018 along with permission to remain out of headquar- ters after the Court hours of 15-06-2018 till 21-06-2018 and earned leave for 06 days from 30-06-2018 to 05-07-2018 along with permission to remain out of headquarters after the Court hours of 29-06-2018 till before the court hours of 06-07-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Kujur, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 300+10 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1950Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 55/L.G./2018/II-2-17/2006.—Shri A. L. Joshi, I Additional Principal Judge, Family Court, Raipur is hereby, granted earned leave for o4 days from 03-07-2018 to 06-07-2018 along with permission to remain out of headquarters.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Joshi, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 280 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 56/L.G./2018/II-2-4/2014.—Shri Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal, District & Sessions Judge, Raigarh is hereby, granted earned leave for 05 days from 29-06-2018 to 03-07-2018 along with permission to leave headquarters from the evening of 28-06-2018 till the morning of 04-07-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Jaiswal, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 300+10 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 57/L.G./2018/II-2-14/2015.—Shri Sudhir Kumar, District & Sessions Judge, Dantewara is hereby, granted earned leave for 10 days from 06-06-2018 to 15-06-2018 along with permission to leave headquarters after the Court hours of 05-06-2018 till before the Court hours of 18-06-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Kumar, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 146 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 58/L.G./2018/II-3-14/2003.—Shri Rakesh Bihari Ghore, District & Sessions Judge, Korba is hereby, granted earned leave for 06 days form 29-06-2018 to 04-07-2018 along wih permission to remain out of headquarters after working hours of 28-06-2018 till 04-07-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1951Certified that if Shri Ghore, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been work- ing on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 279 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 59/L.G./2018/II-3-26/2014.—Shri Shahabuddin Qureshi Officer-on-Special Duty-cum-Central Project Co-ordinator, High Court of Chhattisgarh, Bilaspur is hereby, granted earned leave for 05 days from 03-07-2018 to 07-07-2018 along with permission to remain out of headquarters from the evening of 02-07-2018 till the morning of 09-07-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Qureshi, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 169 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 60/L.G./2018/II-3-23/2010.—Shri Shailesh Kumar Tiwari, Judge Family Court, Surguja at Ambikapur is hereby, granted earned leave for 18 days from 01-05-2018 to 18-05-2018 along with permission to remain out of heaqquarters from the night 08.00 p.m. of 30-04-2018 till before the office hours of 21-05-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Tiwari, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been work- ing on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 300+02 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 61/L.G./2018/II-2-11/2017.—Dr. Pragya Pachouri, Judge, Family Court, Rajnandgaon is hereby, granted earned leave for 15 days from 01-06-2018 to 15-06-2018 along with permission to leave headquarters from 01-06- 2018 to 17-06-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Dr. Pachouri, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 79 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
{र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1952Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 62/L.G./2018/II-3-7/2015.—Shri Santosh Sharma, District & Sessions Judge, Baloda-Bazar is hereby, granted commuted leave for 11 days from 21-05-2018 to 31-05-2018 along with permission to remain out of head- quarters.
During the period of commuted leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Sharma, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 131 days of half-pay-leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 63/L.G./2018/II-3-2/2009.—Shri Jaideep Vijay Nimonkar, Judge, Family Court, Raigarh is hereby, granted earned leave for 05 days from 06-06-2018 to 10-06-2018 along with permission to remain out of headquar- ters.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Nimonkar, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 186 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 64/L.G./2018/II-3-4/2014.—Shri Hemant Saraf, District & Sessions Judge Kanker is hereby, granted earned leave for 04 days from 30-05-2018 to 02-06-2018 in continuation of summer vacation along with permission to remain out of headquarters from 19-05-2018 to 03-06-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Saraf, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 164 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 65/L.G./2018/II-3-13/2007.—Shri N. D. Tigala, District & Sessions Judge, Bilaspur is hereby, granted earned leave for 03 days from 16-06-2018 to 18-06-2018 in continuation of summer vacation along with permission to remain out of headquarters till the morning of 19-06-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1953Certified that if Shri Tigala, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been work- ing on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 300+06 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 66/L.G./2018/II-3-4/2008.—Shri Neelam Chand Sankhla, the then District & Sessions Judge, Raipur is hereby, granted earned leave for 04 days from 21-05-2018 to 24-05-2018 with summer vacation along with permis- sion to remain out of headquarters from 21-05-2018 to 10-06-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Sankhla, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 246 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 67/L.G./2018/II-2-13/2017.—Shri Yogesh Pareek, Special Judge (Atrocities), Korba is hereby, granted earned leave for 03 days from 28-06-2018 to 30-06-2018 along with permission to remain out of headquarters after the office hours of 27-06-2018 till before the office hours of 02-07-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Pareek, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 137 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
Bilaspur, the 10th July 2018
No. 68/L.G./2018/II-2-4/2009.—Shri Ashok Kumar Sahu, District & Sessions Judge Mungeli is hereby, granted earned leave for 05 days from 16-04-2018 to 20-04-2018 along with permission to remain out of headquar- ters from 16-04-2018 till the night 08.30 p.m. of 20-04-2018.
During the period of earned leave, he shall be entitled to leave salary equal to pay drawn immediately before proceeding on leave as aforementioned.
Certified that if Shri Sahu, had not proceeded on leave as aforementioned then he would have been working on the same post.
After deduction of the aforementioned leave, 300+02 days of earned leave are remaining in his leave account as on date.
By order of the High Court,
ATUL KUMAR SHRIVASTAVA, Additional Registrar (ADMN){र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1954 प्रष्र्९ीॉींन्ए प्रर्॰ी गर् िँट्ट ूर्अिद्व र्ी गअद्यध्र्॰ी.ू.गक्ष्ध्ूर्र्लििर्ण्ीध् र्न्ीर्र्क्तीीप्रॉ ऽर््री९ए प्रँर्९ी ञर् ॉी र्र्ह्मीीर्क्तीध्र्५ीए ॰ीं्रय्र् ी न् र्ऽी॰र् ी प्रर्॰ीञ अअ.र््र.ि ूर्अिद्व र्ऽीर्र्क्तीीन् न् र्॰ी ऽय् ध् ह्यत्र्न् ऽप्रर्क्ती र्ऽीय्ई प्रर्॰ीञ र्अि.अअ.ूर्अ्रि ॉ गअ.अर्.िूर्अिद्य २न्ईीं न् र्ऽीर्५ीर् ीर्ईी ञ र्५ीऽ ऽप्रँय्ई र्ऽीर्५ी ञ ॉ गर् िप्र॰ॉ र्ऽीर्५ी ्र॰ध्न्र्ह्यी ध् ैध्ट्ठप्रई {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्५ीीॉए प्रप्र र्ऽीभन् र्प्रीध्र् ीय् प्रर्झ्ी्रए र्न्ीींन् र्ऽी॰र्५ीर् ी अगर्लिर्ध्ूिअ. ष्ध्{न्ण््रण्ध्र्क्ष् िप्रर्॰ी गअ.अर्.िूर्र्क्ष् िि र्ऽीर्९ी ञ र्॰ी ध्र् ँीईध् २भन्ण्
र्ऽी॰र्र्र्५ीीींॉीन्ए
ण् ध्ण् प्रर्ष्ॉी"य्ए ष्ँन् ऽर्प्रीन्ध्ण् र्झ्ीन्ई र्र्५ीीॉ र्ऽी॰र्५ी र्ऽीभन् ऽप्रर्क्तीॉर्ट्टीञ
र्न्ीैँ ञ र्ऽीर्॰ी ष्ञर्क्ती प्रर्झ्ी्र
र्र्ञीी९ए २र्न्ी॰ध् झ्एर् ी र्न्ीींन्
र्ी र्न्ीींन्ए प्रर्॰ीञ ूग ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व
र्ीञ ल.ूक्ष्ध्ूर्अिद्वर्ध्ॉीई.अर्ण्ीर्९ी र्र्क्तीीन्र्र् ीी ;ऽँय् र्ऽीभन् र्प्रीॉद्ध ऽप्रर्क्तीप्रए अ््रद्य ऽञई्रय्ई झ्ट्ट.ऽँय् ॉञष्ञर्क्ती ञ र्झ्ीन्ई ॉर्न्ीन्एर् ीर्९ी र्र्ञीी९ "य्न्प्र॰}९ध् र्उीर्न्ीर् ँीन्ध् ऽप्रर्क्तीॉर्ट्टी प्रर्॰ीञ अग ँट्टए ूर्अिद्वर् ी ॉर्य्ॉीर्र्क्तीीन्र्ह्यी ध्र्र् ँीीन्ध् २न्ईीं {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँी ञ र्ीप्रर्५ीई र्प्रीर् ँीर्ईी २भन्ण्
र्ऽीन्ण् ण् ञर्९ीध्ए ऽन् ॉप्रण् ख् र्ऽॉीर्र्क्तीीन्र्ह्यी र्झ्ीन्ई र्र्न्ीँीए र्झ्ी्र.IIए ह्यत्र्न् ग.न्.ञत्र्न् ;iiद्ध ञर् ीर्र्५ीीय् ,
र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1955 {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1956 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1957 {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1958 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1959 {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1960 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1961 {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व ख् र्झ्ी्र अ 1962 र्झ्ी्र अ , {र्न्ीध्ॉ्र३न् र्र्न्ीँीए प्रर्॰ी ूद्य ँींर्९ी"य्न् ूर्अिद्व 1963