Reg. No. RNP/GOA/32/2021-2023
RNI No. GOAENG/2002/6410
SERIES II No. 50
Panaji, 16th March, 2023 (Phalguna 25, 1944) PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY
GOVERNMENT OF GOA
Department of Agriculture
Directorate of Agriculture
–––
Department of Animal Husbandry &
Veterinary Services
Directorate of Animal Husbandry & Veterinary Services
–––
Notification
Order
No. 2/14/95/Agri(Part)/Vol.II/2022-23/2129
Government is pleased to order the transfer of
Shri Kirtiraj K. Naik Gaonkar, Zonal Agriculture
Officer, Canacona, Group 'B' Gazetted against the
vacant post of Farm Superintendent, Government
Agriculture Farm, Kalay, Sanguem-Goa with
immediate effect. He shall also exercise the powers
of Drawing and Disbursing Officer for the Office of
the Government Agriculture Farm, Kalay-Goa.
The additional charge of Farm Superintendent,
Government Agriculture Farm, Kalay, Sanguem
given to Kum. Milan S. Gaonkar, Zonal Agriculture
Officer, Sanguem is hereby stands withdrawn.
Shri Sharvanand R. Sarvankar, Assistant
Agriculture Officer, Zonal Agriculture Office,
Canacona, Group 'B' Gazetted shall hold the charge
of Zonal Agriculture Office, Canacona in addition
to his own duties, until further orders. He shall also
exercise the powers of Drawing and Disbursing
Officer for the Zonal Agriculture Office, Canacona.
No. 15-21/Part/2022-23/7100
In exercise of the power conferred by Rule 9 (2) of the Goa State Veterinary Council Rules, 1990, the Government of Goa hereby appoints the Additional/ /Deputy Collector in the Collectorate, North Goa District, Panaji to be appointed as the Returning Officer and Mamlatdar in the Collectorate, North Goa District as Assistant Returning Officer to assist the Returning Officer for conduct of election of Goa State Veterinary Council.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Sd/-, Director (AH).
Panaji, 13th March, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Co-operation
Office of the Asstt. Election Officer & Asstt.
Registrar of Co-operative Societies
–––
FORM "ELECTION-9"
(See Rule 74)
Form of declaration of result of
uncontested election
This is issued with approval of Government vide
entry No. 917 dated 27-02-2023.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Nevil Alphonso, Director (Agriculture) & ex officio
Jt. Secretary.
Tonca, Caranzalem, 8th March, 2023.
Election to the Board of Directors of "The Marcel Urban Co-op. Credit Society Ltd., Jana Vikas Bldg., Near Bus Stand, Marcela-Goa.
Year of Election:- 2022. Number of Seats:- 13
In pursuance of the provisions contained in the Goa Co-operative Societies Rules, 2003, I, declare that the following contesting candidates have been duly OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 elected to fill the seats on the Board of Directors of the above mentioned society as they were the only contesting candidates as stated below.
Womens Category- (02 Nos.)
Sr. No. Name of the candidates
Address
1 2
3
1. Amonkar Pushpa Shashikant Flat No. C-2, Shri Om Co-op. Hsg. Sty., Santacruz,
Cujira, Tiswadi-Goa.
2. Naik Vimal Laxman 95/1, Kelbai wada, Tivrem-Goa.
Reserve Category (SC/ST)- (01 No.)
1. Gaude/Tivrekar Sitaram Mukund H. No. 164, Wadiwada, Zuwarwada, Tivrem,
Ponda-Goa.
I also certify and declare that the above mentioned relevant number of seats to be elected to form the Board of Directors is duly elected.
Pankaj V. Marathe, Returning Officer for Election to the B.O.D.'s of the Marcel Urban Co-op. Credit Society Ltd., Jana Vikas Bldg., Near Bus Stand, Marcela-Goa.
Ponda, 6th February, 2023.
–––
FORM "ELECTION-17"
[See Rule 105(1)]
Form of declaration of result and publication of names of members of the Board
of Directors
(Return of Election)
Election to the Board of Directors of the Marcel Urban Co-op. Credit Society Ltd., Jana Vikas Bldg., Near Bus Stand, Marcela-Goa.
(i) Election for 2022-2027.
(ii) Name of Constituency: The Marcel Urban Co-op. Credit Society Ltd., Jana Vikas Bldg., Near Bus Stand, Marcela-Goa.
Sr. Name of the candidates No.
No. of valid votes polled by the candidates 1. Bhagat Vikas Raghuvir
1113
2. Chodankar Babi Devu
1108
3. Fadte Pundalik/Purshottam Morto
977
4. Naik Arjun Raghulo
880
5. Naik Gaonkar Bhanudas Krishna
934
6. Naik Hemant Durgaram
567
7. Naik Prakash Tukaram
981
8. Naik Pramod Gopinath
336
9. Naik Sandeep Chandrakant
443
10. Naik Satish Yeshwant
919
11. Narvekar Shantaram Ramnath
485
12. Narvekar Vinayak Krishna
1028
13. Tari Ramanand Ladu
911 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 Total No. of valid votes : 1379
Total No. of invalid votes : 86
Total No. of tendered votes : —
I, declare that the following candidates have been duly elected to the Board of Directors of The Marcel Urban Co-op. Credit Society Ltd., Jana Vikas Bldg., Near Bus Stand, Marcela-Goa in the election held on 05-02-2023.
Address
Sr. Name of the candidates No.
1 2
3
1. Bhagat Vikas Raghuvir 178/B, Deulwada, Marcel-Goa.
2. Chodankar Babi Devu 304/3, Atharva Hsg. Sty. BH. Shantadurga Temple,
Marcel, Ponda-Goa.
3. Narvekar Vinayak Krishna 316, Nr. Vithoba Temple, Bazarwada, Marcel,
Ponda-Goa.
4. Naik Prakash Tukaram H. No. 308/B, Devlay, Khandola-Goa.
5. Fadte Pundalik/Purshottam Morto H. No. 631, Shramajeevan, Tariwada, Marcel-Goa.
6. Naik Gaonkar Bhanudas Krishna H. No. 148, Gaonkar Wada, Khandola, Marcel-Goa.
7. Naik Satish Yeshwant H. No. 637, Tariwada, Marcel-Goa.
8. Tari Ramanand Ladu Akhada, St. Estevam, Tiswadi-Goa.
9. Naik Arjun Raghulo 893, Surchebhat, Kumbharjua, Tiswadi-Goa.
10. Vargaokar Shantaram Manohar H. No. 390, Nr. Primary School, Gavant Wada,
Kumbharjua, Tiswadi-Goa.
Pankaj V. Marathe, Returning Officer for Election to the B.O.D.'s of the Marcel Urban Co-op. Credit Society Ltd., Jana Vikas Bldg., Near Bus Stand, Marcela-Goa.
Ponda, 6th February, 2023.
–––
FORM-IV
In pursuance of power conferred by clause sub-section 6 of Section 66 of the Goa Co-operative Societies Act, 2001, the undersigned declares the election of office bearers of Marcel Urban Co-op. Credit Society Ltd., Jana Vikas Bldg., Near Bus Stand, Marcel-Goa as follows:-
Sr. Name Address Designation of No.
office bearer
1. Vinayak Krishna Narvekar 316, Nr. Vithoba Temple, Bazarwada, Chairman. Marcel, Ponda-Goa
2. Prakash Tukaram Naik H. No. 308/B, Devlay, Khandola-Goa Vice-Chairman.
Somnath M. Gaude, Presiding Officer.
Ponda, 1st March, 2023.
———u———
Office of the Asst. Registrar of Co-operative
Ltd., C-201, C/o AArshi Singh, Siolim"-Goa is Societies
registered under code symbol No. RCSNZ2022-
230032.
––– Notification
Harish S. Naik, Asst. Registrar (Co-operative
Societies), North Zone.
Mapusa, 8th March, 2023.
In exercise of the powers vested in me under Section 8 of the Goa Co-operative Societies Act, 2001, "Bella Casa Co-op. Hsg. Maintenance Scty.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023Certificate of Registration
"Bella Casa Co-op. Hsg. Maintenance Scty. Ltd., C-201, C/o AArshi Singh, Siolim"-Goa has been registered on 08-03-2023 and its bears registration Code Symbol No. RCSNZ2022-230032 and its classified as "Co-operative Housing Society" under sub-classification "No. 7-(d)-Co-operative Housing Maintenance Society" in terms of Rule 8 of the Goa Co-operative Societies Rules, 2003.
Harish S. Naik, Asst. Registrar (Co-operative
Societies), North Zone.
Mapusa, 8th March, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Education, Art and Culture Directorate of Technical Education
College Section ––
already retired Workshop Instructors in Goa College of Engineering and Government and Aided Polytechnics was under consideration of the Government.
Order
No. 8/1/81/Charge/GCA/DTE/2019/4014
Shri Wilfred E. Goes, Assistant Professor in Fine Art (Applied Art), Goa College of Art, Altinho, Panaji-Goa shall hold the charge of Principal, Goa College of Art in addition to his own duties with effect from 31-03-2023 (a. n.) until further orders.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Dr. Vivek B. Kamat, Director (Technical Education)
& ex officio Additional Secretary.
Porvorim, 10th March, 2023.
———u———
Directorate of Technical Education
Establishment Section ––
Now, Government has decided to extend all financial benefits like differential salary, increments, etc. to the Workshop Instructors of Goa College of Engineering and all Government and Aided Polytechnics under Directorate of Technical Education, who have retired on superannuation at the age of 60 years before the issuance of order dated 23-05-2022 read at above, as though they have superannuated at the age of 62 years, based on the Order No. 16/70/99-DTE/Ex-Age/2877 dated 11-10-2000 treating the post of Instructor as teaching post, Section 15A of the Goa University Amendment Act, 2009 and Order No. DTE/Estt/1-9-II/ /Pay Fixation/2009/273 dated 27-01-2011 enhancing the age of retirement of teachers of Diploma and Degree Institutions to 62 years. Further their pensionary benefits shall be worked out treating them as retired at the age of 62.
Accordingly, the Workshop Instructors who have retired upon attaining the age of 60 years, shall be accorded the salary benefits of 02 years, and their pensionary benefits shall be worked out by considering them as though they have retired at the age of 62 years.
Further, the Workshop Instructors who have retired upon attaining the age of 60 years, but not completed the age of 62 years shall join their respective Institution immediately within one week from receipt of this order and continue to serve till they superannuate upon attaining the age of 62 years.
This issues with the approval of the Government
vide U.O. No. 1482/F dated 16-02-2023.
Order
No. DTE/Estt/Writ Pet-Instructor/2021/4033
Read: Order No. DTE/Estt/Writ Pet-Instructor/2021/
/497 dated 23-05-2022.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Dr. Vivek B. Kamat, Director (Technical Education)
& ex officio Additional Secretary.
Porvorim, 13th March, 2023.
———u———
Directorate of Education
–––
Notification
Whereas, vide Order read at preamble, Government had decided to enhance the age of retirement on superannuation of Workshop Instructors under the Common Cadre of Directorate of Technical Education, working at Goa College of Engineering and Government Polytechnics, as well as Workshop Instructors in aided Polytechnics under Directorate of Technical Education, from 60 to 62 years.
Thereafter, matter regarding extension of the benefit of retirement age from 60 to 62 years to the No. DE/AE/30/276(PEMS)/2022-23/403
A new Scheme of Adult Education with the nomenclature "New India Literacy Programme is proposed to be implemented during F. Y. 2021-26 in line with National Education Policy, 2020. The OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023
Notification
Government is pleased to constitute the following Executive Council with immediate effect:-
Sr. Composition of the Category of No. Governing Council appointment of
member
1. Secretary, Education Chairman.
2. Director, State Council of Member
Educational Research & Secretary. Training, Porvorim
3. State Project Director, Goa Member.
Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan, Porvorim
4. Director, Director of Member.
Education
5. Director, Directorate of Member.
Health Services
6. Director, Directorate of Member.
Social Welfare
7. Director, Directorate of Member.
Tribal Welfare
8. Director, Directorate of Member.
Women & Child
9. Director, Directorate of Member.
Sports & Youth Affairs
10. Director, Directorate of Member.
Skill Development & Entrepreneurship
11. Director, Directorate of Member.
Panchayats
12. Director, Directorate of Member.
Art & Culture
13. Chairman, Goa Board of Member.
Secondary & Higher Secondary Education, Porvorim
14. President, Principal Forum Member.
15. President, Headmaster Member.
Association
16. President, Government Member.
Primary Teachers Association
The State Government shall have the authority to terminate the membership of any member including the Member Secretary at any time.
This issues with the approval of Government vide
inward No. 837/F dated 02-05-2022.
Shailesh R. Sinai Zingde, Director (Education) &
ex officio Jt. Secretary.
Porvorim, 8th March, 2023.
No. DE/AE/30/276(PEMS)/2022-23/404
A new Scheme of Adult Education with the
nomenclature "New India Literacy Programme is
proposed to be implemented during F. Y. 2021-26 in
line with National Education Policy, 2020. The
Government is pleased to constitute the following
Governing Council with immediate effect:-
Sr. Composition of the Category of
No. Governing Council appointment of
member
1. Education Minister of Chairman.
the State
2. State Project Director, Member
Goa Sarva Shiksha Secretary. Abhiyan, Porvorim
3. Secretary, Education Member.
4. Director, Director of Member.
Education, Porvorim
5. Director, Directorate of Member.
Health Services, Panaji
6. Director, Directorate of Member.
Social Welfare, Panaji
7. Director, Directorate of Member.
Tribal Welfare, Panaji
8. Director, Directorate of Member.
Women & Child, Panaji
9. Director, Directorate of Member.
Sports & Youth Affairs, Panaji
10. Director, Directorate of Member.
Skill Development & Entrepreneurship, Panaji
11. Director, Directorate of Member.
Panchayats
12. Director, Directorate of Member.
Art & Culture, Panaji
13. Chairman, Goa Board of Member.
Secondary & Higher Secondary Education, Porvorim
14. Director, State Council Member.
of Educational Research & Training, Porvorim
15. President, Principal Forum Member.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 20231 2
3
16. President, Headmaster Member.
Association
17. President, Government Member.
Primary Teachers Association
The State Government shall have the authority to terminate the membership of any member including the Member Secretary at any time.
This issues with the approval of Government vide
inward No. 837/F dated 02-05-2022.
Shailesh R. Sinai Zingde, Director (Education)
& ex officio Jt. Secretary.
Porvorim, 8th March, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Finance
Revenue & Control Division
–––
(i.e. Shri M L Patil) shall be entitled to pension at the revised rates from the date he attains the age of sixty years and has further held that arrears shall be paid accordingly;
And whereas, this Department vide Circular
dated 21-12-2022 had instructed Head of
Departments to examine and verify details of
premature employees of their Department with
respect to the date of appointment, if the pensioner
was appointed prior to 30-05-1987 and was made to
retire at the age of 58 years in terms of order
No. 2/6/94-PER dated 2nd July, 1999;
And whereas, the Head of Departments (HoDs) were instructed to decide on the extension of pensionery benefits based on the entitlement as per the above mentioned criteria and sanction the revised pensionery benefit and submit such cases to Directorate of Accounts by 30th December, 2022;
Order
No. 12/2/2022-Fin(R&C)/3233
Whereas, the Hon'ble High Court of Bombay at Goa vide judgement dated 05-09-2022, in W. P. No. 835/2017 has observed that, if the employees, whose cause the petitioners claim to espouse, were indeed appointed before the appointed date, i.e. 30-05-1987 and further, if before the appointed date, their service condition entitled them to continue in service until they attain the age of 60 years, then, there was no justification in retiring such employees upon their reaching the age of 58 years, in the absence of compliance with the provision of Section 60(6) of the Re-organization Act, 1987;
And whereas, Hon'ble High Court of Bombay at Goa, has directed to examine the representation received from prematurely retired pensioners in the context of law laid down in Laxman Chavan 2020 (5) MLS 428 and M L Patil, 2022 SCC (SC) 685;
And whereas, the Hon'ble Court had also directed that the appropriate authority shall examine the data available with itself to determine whether the instances of the allegedly prematurely retired employees are indeed covered by the decision in Laxman Chavan 2020 (5) MLS 428 and M L Patil, 2022 SCC (SC) 685, and if so to grant the financial benefits to them within the timelines indicated in the Judgement;
And whereas, Hon'ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 4100 of 2022 at para 4 of the judgement has held that the appellant in the Civil Appeal Now therefore, the Government is pleased to extend to the eligible pre-matured pensioners who were made to retire at the age of 58 years, the benefits of pension at the revised rates from the date, the eligible pensioner attains the age of 60 years including arrears of pension in terms of the order in W.P. No. 835/2017 read with judgement and order in W. P. No. 961/2015, modified by the Hon'ble Supreme Court vide judgement in Civil Appeal No. 4100 of 2022. All the HoDs are hereby directed to process such cases within a time bound manner failing which they will be held responsible for contempt of the orders of the Hon'ble High Court.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Pranab. G. Bhat, Under Secretary, Finance (R&C).
Porvorim, 10th March, 2023.
–––––— Order
No. 12/2/2022-Fin(R&C)/3234
The Committee constituted vide Order No. 12/2/
/2022-Fin(R&C)/1003 dated 17-11-2022 for examining/ /scrutinizing the representations received from pre- -maturely retired pensioners in view of the Judgment dated 05-09-2022 passed in Writ Petition No. 835/2017 by Hon'ble High Court of Bombay in Goa stands dissolved with immediate effect.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Pranab. G. Bhat, Under Secretary, Finance (R&C).
Porvorim, 10th March, 2023.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023Debt Management Division
–––
And whereas, the Government of Goa considers it expedient to refer the said dispute for adjudication.
Notification
No. 1-80-2006/Fin(DMU)/76
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 3 of the Goa Money Lenders and Accredited Loan Providers Act, 2013 (Goa Act 23 of 2013) (hereinafter referred to as "said Act"), the Government of Goa hereby appoints the Mamlatdars of all Talukas as Registering Authorities to exercise their powers and perform duties, as required under the said Act in their respective jurisdiction.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Pranab G. Bhat, Under Secretary, Finance
(Budget-II).
Porvorim, 23rd February, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Home
Home—General Division
–––
Now, therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by Clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947), (hereinafter referred to as the "said Act"), the Government of Goa hereby refers the said dispute for adjudication to the Labour Court-II of Goa at Panaji-Goa, constituted under sub-section (1) of Section 7 of the said Act.
SCHEDULE
"(1) Whether Shri Sushant B. Naik, Accounts Executive could be construed as "workman" as defined under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947(Central Act 14 of 1947)?
(2) If answer to the above issue No. (1) is in affirmative, then whether the action of the management of M/s. Beirsdorf India Private Limited, CMM Complex, 2nd floor, Renovadim, Merces, Goa in terminating services of Shri Sushant B. Naik, Accounts Executive with effect from 09-02-2021, is legal and justified?
Corrigendum
No. 2/58/2007-HD(G)/SPCA/Vol.I/732
Read: Order No. 2/58/2007-HD(G)/SPCA/Vol.I/193
dated 17-01-2023.
In partial modification to the Order read at the preamble, at para 3 the expression "with effect from January 2023" may be read as "with effect from 21st June, 2021".
(3) If answer to issue No. (2) above is in negative, then, what relief the workman is entitled to?."
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Amalia O. F. Pinto, Under Secretary (Labour).
Porvorim, 8th March, 2023.
———
Order
The other contents of the order shall remain
unchanged.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Vivek K. Naik, Under Secretary (Home-I).
Porvorim, 8th March, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Labour –– Order
No. 28/05/2023-LAB/180
Whereas, the Government of Goa is of the opinion that an industrial dispute exists between the management of M/s. Beirsdorf India Private Limited, CMM Complex, 2nd Floor, Renovadim, Merces, Goa and it's workman, Shri Sushant B. Naik, Accounts Executive, in respect of the matter specified in the Schedule hereto (hereinafter referred to as the "said dispute");
No. 28/06/2023-LAB/181
Whereas, the Government of Goa is of the Opinion that an industrial dispute exists between the management of M/s. Netzsch Technologies India Private Limited, L-10, Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Goa and it's workmen, represented by the Bhartiya Kamgar Sena, in respect of the matter specified in the Schedule hereto (hereinafter referred to as the "said dispute");
And whereas, the Government of Goa considers it expedient to refer the said dispute for adjudication.
Now, therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by Clause (d) of sub-section (1) of Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947), (hereinafter referred to as the "said Act"), the Government of Goa hereby refers the said dispute for adjudication to the Industrial Tribunal of Goa at Panaji-Goa, constituted under Section 7A of the said Act.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023SCHEDULE
(1) Whether the action of the management of M/s. Netzsch Technologies India Private Limited, L-10, Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Goa in transferring the 3 workmen, Shri Amit R. Gunjal, Operator, Nandeeshwar Kurle, Operator and Shankar Bobhate, Operator to Noida and Chennai respectively vide transfer orders dated 07-12-2021, 10-12-2021 and 01-04-2022 respectively, is legal and justified?
(2) If answer to issue No. (1) above is in the negative, then, what relief the workmen are entitled to?
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Amalia O. F. Pinto, Under Secretary (Labour).
Porvorim, 8th March, 2023.
————
AWARD
1. In exercise of the powers conferred by Clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947), the Government of Goa, by Order dated 23-06-2016, bearing No. 28/15/2016-LAB/436 referred the following dispute for adjudication to the Labour Court-II, Panaji-Goa.
"(1) Whether the action of the management of M/s. Pfizer Limited, Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcette, Goa, in dismissing its workman, namely Shri Suraj Salgaonkar, Management Associate, with effect from 16-06-2015, is legal and justified?
(2) If not, what relief the workman is entitled to?
Notification
No. 28/02/2023-LAB/Part-II/149
The following Award passed by the Labour Court-II, at Panaji-Goa on 30-01-2023 in Case No. Ref. LC-II/IT/30/16 is hereby published as required under Section 17 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947).
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Amalia O. F. Pinto, Under Secretary (Labour).
Porvorim, 24th February, 2023.
——— IN THE LABOUR COURT-II GOVERNMENT OF GOA AT PANAJI
(Before Shri Suresh N. Narulkar, Hon'ble Presiding Officer)
Case. No. Ref. LC-II/IT/30/16
Shri Suraj Salgaonkar, H. No. 4, Vacar Wada, Sanguem-Goa (403704) .... Workman/Party-I.
V/s
The Managing Director, M/s. Pfizer Ltd., Plot No. L-137, Phase III-A, Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcete-Goa (403722) .... Employer/Party-II.
Workmen/Party I represented by Ld. Rep. Shri Subhash Naik.
Employer/Party II represented by Ld. Adv. Shri G.K. Sardessai.
Panaji, dated: 30-01-2023.
2. On receipt of the reference, a case was registered under No. LC-II/IT/30/2016 and registered A/D notice was issued to the parties. In pursuance to the said notice, the parties put in their appearance. The Workman/Party-I (for short 'Workman'), filed his Statement of Claim on 19-08-2016 at Exhibit-5. The facts of the case in brief as pleaded by the Workman are that the Employer/ /Party-II (for short 'Employer') is a Multinational Pharmaceutical Company engaged in the production of tablets at its factory at Verna Industrial Estate, Salcette, Goa. He stated that the Employer was initially established at Verna in the year, 2001 as Wyeth Lederle Ltd. which was subsequently changed as Pfizer Ltd. in the year, 2009. He stated that he was employed with the Employer as "Operator-Production" since 29-01-2002. He stated that he has not received a single memo or a single charge-sheet except the charge-sheet which is the subject matter of the present reference. He stated that during his service of the Employer, he received awards from the Employer for his performance. He stated that he also received several "employee of the month" awards, long service awards, best nominee of the month awards, certificates for improving productivity and development, etc. He stated that after formation of a trade Union in 2014, all the workers of the Employer Company joined the said union. He stated that he was elected an office bearer of the said union and as such he was a Protected Workman as per the provisions of the I.D. Act, 1947. He stated that initially all workmen including himself were employed as Operator– Production. He stated that in the year, 2006, the designations of all workmen were changed to that of management associates Grade MA-01 and in year 2011, the grade of workers were changed to MA-02 although the duties performed by them remained OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 the same. He stated that all the workmen of the Employer including himself were issued appointment letters when they joined service and all of them were confirmed in the service of the Employer.
happy with Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh Union because of the developments which took place which workers least expected. He stated that all the workers, after holding a General Body Meeting decided to resign from the said Union and became the members of Kamgarancho Ekvott Trade Union of which Subhash Naik George is the president with effect from 20-05-2015 after resigning from Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh. He stated that these developments were informed to the Employer in writing. He stated that the said Union Kamagarancho Ekvott raised several Industrial Disputes with the Employer such as Charter of Demands on behalf of the workers, illegal and unjustified refusal of work with effect from 24-04-2015, unfair labour practice, non-payment of bonus, illegal termination of services of workmen and illegal imposition of punishments to workers etc. He stated that as the Employer did not accept the demands, the union raised disputes before Dy. Labor Commissioner who is also Conciliation Officer of Government of Goa, where all industrial disputes are pending conciliation and some disputes have been referred to this Hon'ble Tribunal for adjudication.
3. He stated that in June, 2014, workers formed a Trade Union for the first time, when all the workers of the Employer factory became members of Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh Trade Union. He stated that the Employer was informed about the formation of a Trade Union. He stated that names of seven Union office bearers of the Union including himself were also communicated to the Employer. He stated that the Employer did not appreciate the decision of the workers to form a Trade Union and started harassing the workers by withdrawing existing benefits and existing facilities. He stated that with effect from 20-04-2015, the Employer did not allot any work to workers inside the factory and kept them idle as the Employer was not happy with the workers forming a Trade Union. He stated that with effect from 24-04-2015, all workmen were kept outside the factory gates and were not allowed to resume work inside the factory. He stated that this continued for several months and later the Employer stated that they would not allow the workmen to report for work unless they gave an undertaking, the contents of which were not disclosed to them. He stated that later on, the Employer allowed all workmen to report for work without undertaking and all workmen reported for work with effect from 17-08-2015. He stated that the Employer has till date not paid wages of the workers from 20-4-2015 to 16-08-2015. He stated that however, eleven workmen, who were issued suspension orders pending enquiry, were not allowed to report for work. He stated that meanwhile, after formation of a Trade union, the Employer suspended the services of all office bearers of the Union namely, Ramdas Mayenkar, Sagar Dhume, Krishnakant Gawas, Navin Gaude, himself, Susen Jalmi, and Suraj Kurtikar.
5. He stated that although all seven union office bearers including himself were issued separate charge-sheets, the Employer decided to hold common enquiry. He stated that Shri Prashant Agarwal, Advocate who was appointed as an Enquiry Officer to conduct the enquiries in respect of charge- -sheets issued to seven union office bearers. He stated that Shri Prasanna Chawadikar, Advocate was appointed as Management Representative. He stated that initially, Puti Gaonkar was the Defense Representative on behalf of charge-sheeted workmen and later on, Subhash Naik George was appointed as Defense Representative by himself and other charge- -sheeted workers. He stated that on 02-06-2015 a date was fixed by the Enquiry Officer Mr. Agarwal to hold the enquiry. However, on that day Ld. Enquiry Officer did not attend the enquiry at the hearing fixed at Panaji-Goa. He stated that the Management Representative, Shri Prasanna Chawadikar who was present for the enquiry informed that Ld. Enquiry Officer had gone to his native place to bring his wife and he could not get tickets to return to Goa due to vacation rush and that he is still travelling in the train. He stated that the Management Representative informed him and all other charge- sheeted workmen as well as Defense Representative that Ld. Enquiry Officer, Mr. Agarwal had resigned from the post of Enquiry Officer and that he could not come for the enquiry for his personal reasons. He stated that Management Representative informed 4. He stated that all the aforesaid workers were issued charge-sheets on trumped up and fabricated charges. He stated that he himself and others replied to the charge-sheets denying the allegations levelled against them. He stated that the suspension of seven union office bearers including himself was from 21-04-2015. He stated that four more workmen were also suspended from service with effect from 23-04-2015 pending enquiry namely, Ankush Gaonkar, Mangaldas Gaude, Umakant Chari, and Samesh Naik. He stated that all eleven workmen were suspended and were issued charge-sheets based on false and fabricated charges. He stated that as the workers were not OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 that the next date of enquiry would be communicated after the management appointed a new Enquiry Officer.
6. He stated that after 5th June, 2015, no communication either oral or writing was received by him or his Defense Representative about the date of enquiry or appointment of a new Enquiry Officer. He stated that after few months, the Employer dismissed the service of the four union office bearers with effect from 16-06-2015 claiming that they held enquiry against them and claiming that Enquiry Officer held them guilty of the charges namely, Sagar Dhume, Krishnakant Gawas, Navin Gaude, and Suraj Kurtikar. Aggrieved by the said blatantly illegal and unjustified terminations, the Workman and three other Workman raised an industrial disputes with the Employer and later on with the Conciliation Officer/Dy. Labor Commissioner which ended in failure.
7. He contended during the pendency of such disputes as per provisions of Section 33 of the I. D. Act, 1947, the Employer cannot terminate the services of the workmen without prior permission or without approval of action taken by them. He submitted that the Employer, as an afterthought, terminated the services of remaining three office bearers namely, Ramdas Mayenkar, himself, and Susen Jalmi with effect from 23-12-2015. He submitted that with these termination, Employer have terminated all Seven office bearers who were elected after formation of Trade Union which clearly proves that this is a clear case of victimization for trade union activities. He submitted that since he himself, Sagar Dhume and Susen Jalmi were protected workmen as per provisions of I.D. Act, prior permission before termination ought to have been obtained from this Hon'ble Tribunal and/or Dy. Labour Commissioner, failing which the termination are bad-in-law. He submitted that the charge-sheet issued to him and six other office bearers of the union and four other union activities were fabricated and cooked up besides being false. He submitted that the same were issued to him and others to victimize them for their trade union activities as they had formed a union for the first time in the company. He submitted that Shailesh Redkar, whom the Employer claims to have been appointed as Enquiry Officer, was never appointed as Enquiry Officer and no intimation to that effect has been sent to him. He submitted that no intimation of dates of enquiry by the said Enquiry Officer if any, was sent to him. He submitted that the records of enquiry proceedings alleged to have been conducted by Shailesh Redkar have not being supplied to him till date. He submitted that the Employer, before terminating his service has not
issued him a show cause notice enclosing copy of the findings of the Enquiry Officer, if any, and records of enquiry proceedings if any, seeking his views before dismissal which is mandatory. He submitted that no enquiry was held in respect of charges levelled against him in the charge-sheet
issued to him. He submitted that copy of the findings of the enquiry if any, were not supplied to him before termination of his services. He submitted that since the date of dismissal, he is unemployed and is dependent on his family and friends on sustainance. He submitted that his termination is
illegal and unjustified as he has been dismissed from service in total violation of principles of natural justice. He submitted that no opportunity whatsoever was given to him to defend himself in the enquiry. He submitted that the management witnesses were not allowed to cross-examine by him. He submitted that the charges levelled against him have not been proved in a fair and impartial enquiry in accordance with the principles of natural justice. He submitted that his dismissal from services is malafide, vindictive, and by way of victimization for trade union activities, besides the same being discriminatory. The workmen therefore prayed that he be reinstated in service with full back wages and continuity of service with costs.
8. The Employer controverted the claim of Workman by filing its written statement on 02-12-2016 at exb. 6. The Employer, as an by way of its preliminary objections, submitted that the reference is not maintainable and it ought to be rejected as there is no "Industrial Dispute" as defined under the I.D. Act, 1947, that the Workman has accepted all the legal dues arising out of termination in full and final settlement and hence, the Workman is stopped from raising the present dispute, that there is non application of mind by the Appropriate Government while referring the present dispute and that the present reference is therefore null and void.
9. The Employer stated that it is a Private Limited Company incorporated under the provisions of the companies Act, 1956, having its registered office at the Capital, 1802, 1901 Bandra Kurla Complex, Bandra (East), Mumbai and the factory located at Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcette-Goa. The Employer stated that it is engaged in the manufacturing of pharmaceuticals at its factory located at Verna Industrial Estate, Verna-Goa.
10. The Employer stated that the workman was issued a charge-sheet dated 07-05-2015 alleging as under:
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023"It has been observed that from the month of December, 2014, the workmen have deliberately and willfully reduced production as a result of which the Management suffered heavy losses. The fall in production which commenced from the month of December, 2014 gradually reached to a stage where during the preceding week the production was reduced to around 25% of the normal.
The management has consistently requested the workmen to stop the unfair practice of lowering the production and to restore normalcy. However, the workmen continue with the unfair labour practice of lowering the productive process.
Subsequent there to by Notice dated 7th February, 2015, letters dated 14th April, 2015 and various communications, Management invited the attention of the workmen to the fall in production and requested the workmen to restore normalcy. However, instead of restoring normalcy, to the utter shock and surprise of the Management, the workmen in a concerted manner stopped production from the commencement of Second shift of 20th April, 2015 and started squatting within the factory premises. As a consequence thereto the entire productive process has come to a grinding halt. The Management has suffered huge losses till date and continues to do so. As you are aware, we are engaged in the manufacturing of drugs which include life- -saving drugs like Wysolone, Folvite, Pacitane, Overal-L etc.
All these products are listed in the National List of Essential Medicines (NLEM), issued by Ministry of Health, Government of India. Wysolone is a life-saving steroidal drug with anti-inflammatory properties and controls the painful symptoms of a temporary autoimmune condition called Polymyalgia Rheumatica (PMR), Folvite, essentially taken by women during the first trimester of pregnancy for development of the foetus and also used for all kinds of anaemic conditions, Pacitane, drug used by Patients suffering from early symptoms of Parkinson's Disease and Overal-L. You are fully aware that the discontinuation due to non-availability of these drugs can have an adverse effect on the patients and the society at large.
We have received various communications from our dealers, hospitals and doctors informing us of the serious consequences arising as a result of drugs not being available in the market and the suffering of the patients, especially those who had already been prescribed such drugs and consuming the same. The consequence of sudden discontinuation of supply to the patients has as expected adverse consequences on the health of the patients.
You are an office bearer of Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh. The Management has been consistently been communicating with you and other workmen who have been participating in the go slow/stoppage of work to desist from the unfair labour practice of reducing willfully and deliberately the production. The fall in production is as a consequence of your instigation and incitement of the workmen to commence and continue with the reduction of production. It has also been observed that you have been actively inducing the workmen to continue with the go slow.
The participation in the willful go slow and the instigation and incitement of the workmen to initiate the go slow and continue, wilful damage to or loss of employers good or properties as such amounts to a serious misconduct under the Model Standing Orders.
The Management has therefore decided to conduct an enquiry into the misconduct alleged against you. You were suspended pending enquiry by suspension order dated 21-04-2015.
Your above acts on your part constitute the following Acts of Misconducts under the Model Standing Orders:
a. Willful insubordination or disobedience, whether alone or in combination with others, to any lawful and reasonable order of a superior.
b. Willful damage to or loss of employer's good or
property.
c. Habitual absence without leave or absence
without leave for more than 10 days.
d. Habitual breach of any law applicable to
the establishment.
e. Riotous or disorderly behavior during working hours at the establishment or any act subversive of discipline.
f. Neglect of work.
g. Striking work or inciting others to strike work in contravention of the provision of any law, or rule having the force of law".
11. The Employer stated that the workmen was suspended pending enquiry. The Employer stated that the management has conducted an enquiry into the above said charges. The Employer stated that the enquiry was conducted by Mr. Shailesh Redkar in an impartial manner and every opportunity was given to the Workman to defend the charges levelled against him. The Employer stated that as the Workman failed to participate in the enquiry, the OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 enquiry was therefore held ex-parte. The Employer stated that Ld. Enquiry Officer submitted his findings dated 13-6-2015 and after appreciating the evidence on record held the Workman guilty of the charges levelled against him. The Employer stated that they considered the proceedings of the enquiry, the findings of the Enquiry Officer dated 13-6-2015 and concurred with the same. The Employer stated that they considered the past record and did not find any extenuating circumstances for mitigation of punishment of dismissal from its service. The Employer stated that considering the gravity of proved misconduct, the Workman was dismissed from its service vide letter dt. 16-06-2015.
12. The Employer stated that the Workman was paid full and final settlement of all his dues vide cheque bearing No. 101982 drawn on Deutche Bank, Mumbai for an amount of Rs. 1,23,254/- alongwith the full and final computation statement on 10-07-2015 that includes basic pay, P. L. encashment, house rent allowance, conveyance allowance, medical allowance and LTA alongwith gratuity. The Employer stated that the said amount has been received by the Workman and has been credited to his account on 29-09-2015. The Employer stated that the Workman has also collected all his provident fund dues and for the purpose of employees Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, is an excluded employee. The Employer stated that, since the Workman is prosecuting this matter after having received benefits/full and final settlements of all legal dues arising out of termination, it would be equitable to direct the Workman to return the benefits so received from them with 8.5% interest on the said money for prosecuting the reference on merits on the principle of "Who seeks equity must do equity". The Employer therefore prayed that the Workman will be directed to deposit the entire amount in the Court and in the event the Workman fails to deposit the amount within the period stipulated in this Hon'ble Court, the defense of the Workman may be struck off and the reference be rejected or the Workman may be stopped from agitating the present reference.
workmen in the third shift of 20th April, and first shift of 21st April, 2015, to the wilful stoppage of work and again advised them to report for work. The Employer stated that however, they failed to report for duty and continued to squat within the factory premises. The Employer stated that the management also decided to issue charge-sheets to some of the employees for the misconducts committed by them. The Employer stated that in view of the seriousness of the misconducts alleged against them and in the interest of conducting a proper inquiry, and to avoid any interference with such inquiry, the management decided to suspend them pending inquiry and formal charge-sheets. The Employer stated that the said workmen were suspended pending inquiry vide letter of suspension dated 21-4-2015. The Employer stated that in the letter of suspension, the management informed the workmen that the management has decided to institute an inquiry into the acts of misconduct alleged against them. The Employers stated that as the employees continued with the work stoppage and failed to report for work and on the contrary were sitting within the factory premises, the management by letter dated 23-4-2015, invited the attention of General Secretary of the union Mr. Puti Gaonkar to the stoppage of work by the employees from 20-4-2015 and to the notices displayed on its notice board requesting the striking employees to report for work. The Employer stated that in the said letter, management informed the union that the management is required a written undertaking from all the workmen that they will perform their duties of manufacturing and restored normalcy in the factory premises. The Employer stated that the said letter was also displayed on its notice board. The Employer stated that at the copy of the said undertaking that the workmen were required to sign was also displayed on its notice board and copies of the same were placed at the security gate. The Employer stated that on and from commencement of general shifts of 24-4-2015, the employees who had reported at the security gate were advised to sign the undertaking. The Employer stated that however, they refused to do so and squatted outside the factory premises in front of the security cabin from where all the employees enter inside the factory premises thereby, causing inconvenience to the employees who report for duty. The Employer stated that the action of the employees of stoppage of work from 28-4-2015 in a concerted manner and continuing such stoppage amounts to a strike which is illegal and unjustified.
14. The Employer stated that by notice dated 27-4-2015 displayed on 27-4-2015, the management 13. The Employer stated that by notice dated 20-4-2015, the management informed the employee that their act of stoppage of work from the second shift amounts to willful stoppage and gross indiscipline. The Employer stated that the management advised the employees to report for work as per the shift schedule. The Employer stated that however, the employees continued with the stoppage and continued squatting within the factory premises. The Employer stated that they, by notice dated 21-4-2015, invited the attention of the OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 workmen to be present and failed to participate in the enquiry and therefore the enquiry officer had no option but to conduct the inquiry ex-parte. The Employer submitted that Ld. Enquiry Officer on the basis of the evidence on record submitted a reasoned findings holding the Workman guilty of the charges levelled against him. The Employer submitted that the management considered the findings of the Enquiry Officer, concurred with the same and considering the gravity of misconduct decided to dismiss him from the service and hence the present application for permission for dismissal of the Workman. The Employer denies the case of the Workman as pleaded by him and prayed for rejection of the present reference.
16. Thereafter, the Workman filed his Re-joinder on 13-12-2016 at Exb. 7. The Workman, by way of his Re-joinder, confirms and reiterates all his submissions, averments and statements made in his Claim Statement to be true and correct and denies all the statements, averments and submissions made by the Employer in its Written Statement, which are contrary to his Statement and averments made in his Claim Statement.
17. Based on the pleadings filed by the respective parties, this Court framed the following issues on 05-04-2017 at Exb. 10.
1. Whether a free, fair and proper enquiry was conducted against the Workman/Party I in respect of charge-sheet dated 07-05-2015 in accordance with the principles of natural justice?
2. Whether the charges of misconduct levelled against the Workman vide charge-sheet dated 07-05-2015 have been proved to the satisfaction of this court by acceptable evidence?
3. Whether the Workman/Party I proved that his dismissal from service is in violation of Section 33 of the I.D. Act, 1947?
4. Whether the Workman/Party-I proves that the action of the Employer/Party II in dismissing him from service w.e.f. 16-06-2015, is illegal and unjustified?
5. Whether the Employer/Party II proves that the reference is not maintainable and bad- -in-law in view of the reasons stated in para 1 (a) to 1(d) of its written statement?
invited the attention of the Workman the stoppage of work by way of illegal strike from 28-4-2015 and to the undertakings which they declining to submit to the management giving an assurance of restoration of normalcy. The Employer stated that by the said notice, they were informed that not to sit at the security gate as squatting outside the security gate is illegal and causes inconvenience and as well as an atmosphere of fear and threat in the mind of managerial and other employees as well as the customers, welders who are entering the factory premises. The Employer stated that the employees were therefore advised not to squat near the factory gate and to stay away from the said place. The Employer stated that as the workmen continued to commit illegalities, the management filed a suit for permanent as well as temporary injunction on 27-4-2015. The Employer stated the Hon'ble Court after hearing them passed order stating that the defendent union and its members only those who are employed with them, their agents, friends, relatives and representatives are restrained from squatting within a radius of 200 meters from its factory premises at Verna, Salcette, Goa and from blocking the entrance thereof and/or preventing egress and ingress there from the other staff and employees, customers, goods, vehicles, raw material suppliers, there from till filing their reply thereto. The Employer stated that in the meanwhile the management, vide its letter to the individual workmen dated 02-06-2015, called upon the workmen to withdraw the agitation and report for work by giving by declaration/undertaking as mentioned therein. The Employer stated that the workmen however, did not respond. The Employer stated that they again by its letter dated 23-6-2015 sent to individual workmen requested to join the duties. The workmen did not respond. The Employer stated that the management once again vide its appeal dated 31-07-2015 sent to individual workers requested the workmen to report for work in their shift as per their regular shift. The Employer stated that on 16-7-2015 four employees who were members of "Kamgarancho Ekvott" resumed the duty. The Employer stated that thereafter, one more appeal was sent to the workmen on 11-08-2015 wherein, reference was given of the appeal of 23-06-2016, 03-07-2015, and 31-07-2015 to report for work in the shift and the shift schedule was annexed herewith. The Employer stated that finally on 17-08-2015 the remaining workers resumed duties.
6. Whether the Workman/Party-I is entitled to
any relief?
7. What order? What award?
15. The Employer submitted that the Ld. Enquiry Officer followed the principles of natural justice and granted every conceivable opportunities to the OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 ORDER
1. It is held that the reference as to whether the action of the management of M/s. Pfizer Ltd., Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcette, Goa, in dismissing Shri Suraj Salgaonkar, Management Associate, w.e.f. 16-06-2015 is legal and justified, does not survive.
2. Inform the Government accordingly.
Sd/- (Suresh N. Narulkar) Presiding Officer, Labour Court-II.
————
Notification
17. Thereafter, both the parties led their evidence on the preliminary issues No. 1 and 2. Thereafter, the Employer filed an application for amendment of its written statement which was allowed by order dated 17-03-2020 after hearing both parties. The Workman also filed its synopsis his written arguments on preliminary issues. On 12-03-2022, Ld. Rep. Shri Subhash Naik appearing for the Workman as well as Ld. Adv. Ms. N. Gaonkar representing the Employer submitted that the matter is likely to be settled amicably between the parties. Accordingly, on 20-01-2023, Ld. Rep. Shri Subhash Naik alongwith the Workman as well as Ld. Adv. Mrs. M. Rao h/f Adv. G. K. Sardessai representing the Employer alongwith its Director remained present and filed an application for Award in terms of settlement alongwith Memorandum of settlement u/s 2(P) r/w Sec-18 (1) of the I.D. Act, 1947 between the Employer and the Workman which is on record at Exb. 54-colly and submitted that the matter be disposed off in terms of the settlement arrived at between the parties hereinabove. The terms of settlement as agreed between the parties hereinabove are reproduced hereunder:
No. 28/02/2023-LAB/Part-II/150
The following Award passed by the Labour Court-II, at Panaji-Goa on 30-01-2023 in Case No. Ref. LC-II/IT/31/16 is hereby published as required under Section 17 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947).
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Amalia O. F. Pinto, Under Secretary (Labour).
Porvorim, 24th February, 2023.
––––
IN THE LABOUR COURT-II
a. The Management agrees to pay the workman Mr. Suraj J. Salgaonkar a sum of Rs. 21,00,000/- (Rupees twenty one lakhs only), vide cheque bearing No. 500006 dated 12-01-2023 drawn on JP Morgan Chase Bank, N. A., Mumbai 400098 Branch, in full and final settlement of all his claims.
GOVERNMENT OF GOA
AT PANAJI
b. It is agreed between the parties that the Management shall not deduct TDS from the Settlement amount and Mr. Suraj J. Salgaonkar undertakes to pay the Tax on the said amount.
(Before Shri Suresh N. Narulkar, Hon'ble
Presiding Officer)
c. Accordingly, Mr. Suraj J. Salgaonkar agrees not to pursue the references No. LC-II/IT/30/2016 before the Labour Court II or any dispute raised individually or through any union before any Tribunal, Court, Authority or Forum and treat the same as settled.
d. It is agreed between the parties that this settlement shall be filed before the Labour Court II under reference No. LC-II/IT/30/2016 for an Award in terms of the present settlement.
I have gone through the terms of settlement signed by the parties hereinabove and is of the opinion that the said terms of settlement are beneficial to both the parties. The said terms of settlement also useful for the harmonious relation between the parties. Hence, I approved the same.
In view of above and with regards to the facts and circumstances of the present case, I proceed to pass the following order.
. Case No. Ref. LC-II/IT/31/16
Shri Krishnakant Gawas, H. No. MHN-462, Near Vithal Takhumai Temple, Shantinagar, Vasco-da-Gama, Goa (403802) …. Workman/Party -I
V/s
The Managing Director, M/s. Pfizer Ltd., Plot No. L-137, Phase III-A, Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcete-Goa (403722) …. Employer/Party-II
Workman/Party-I represented by Ld. Rep. Shri Subhash Naik.
Employer/Party-II represented by Ld. Adv. Shri G. K. Sardessai.
Panaji, dated: 30-01-2023.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023AWARD
appointment letters when they joined service and all of them were confirmed in the service of the Employer.
1. In exercise of the powers conferred by Clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947), the Government of Goa, by Order dated 23-06-2016, bearing No. 28/14/2016-LAB/435 referred the following dispute for adjudication to the Labour Court-II, Panaji-Goa.
"(1) Whether the action of the management of M/s. Pfizer Limited, Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcette, Goa, in dismissing its workman, namely Shri Krishnakant Gawas, Management Associate, with effect from 16-06-2015, is legal and justified?
(2) If not, what relief the workman is entitled to?
3. He stated that in June, 2014, workers formed a Trade Union for the first time, when all the workers of the Employer factory became members of Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh Trade Union. He stated that the Employer was informed about the formation of a Trade Union. He stated that names of seven Union office bearers of the Union including himself were also communicated to the Employer. He stated that the Employer did not appreciate the decision of the workers to form a Trade Union and started harassing the workers by withdrawing existing benefits and existing facilities. He stated that with effect from 20-04-2015, the Employer did not allot any work to workers inside the factory and kept them idle as the Employer was not happy with the workers forming a Trade Union. He stated that with effect from 24-04-2015, all workmen were kept outside the factory gates and were not allowed to resume work inside the factory. He stated that this continued for several months and later the Employer stated that they would not allow the workmen to report for work unless they gave an undertaking, the contents of which were not disclosed to them. He stated that later on, the Employer allowed all workmen to report for work without undertaking and all workmen reported for work with effect from 17-08-2015. He stated that the Employer has till date not paid wages of the workers from 20-4-2015 to 16-08-2015. He stated that however, eleven workmen, who were issued suspension orders pending enquiry, were not allowed to report for work. He stated that meanwhile, after formation of a Trade union, the Employer suspended the services of all office bearers of the Union namely, Ramdas Mayenkar, Sagar Dhume, himself, Navin Gaude, Suraj Salgaonkar, Susen Jalmi, and Suraj Kurtikar.
2. On receipt of the reference, a case was registered under No. LC-II/IT/31/2016 and registered A/D notice was issued to the parties. In pursuance to the said notice, the parties put in their appearance. The Workman/Party-I (for short 'Workman'), filed his Statement of Claim on 19-08-2016 at Exhibit-5. The facts of the case in brief as pleaded by the Workman are that the Employer/Party-II (for short 'Employer') is a Multinational Pharmaceutical Company engaged in the production of tablets at its factory at Verna Industrial Estate, Salcette, Goa. He stated that the Employer was initially established at Verna in the year, 2001 as Wyeth Lederle Ltd. which was subsequently changed as Pfizer Ltd. in the year, 2009. He stated that he was employed with the Employer as "Operator-Production" since 26-11-2001. He stated that he has not received a single memo or a single charge sheet except the charge sheet which is the subject matter of the present reference. He stated that during his service of the Employer, he received awards from the Employer for his performance. He stated that he also received several "employee of the month" awards, long service awards, best nominee of the month awards, certificates for improving productivity and development, etc. He stated that after formation of a Trade Union in 2014, all the workers of the Employer Company joined the said union. He stated that he was elected an office bearer of the said union and as such he was a Protected Workman as per the provisions of the I.D. Act, 1947. He stated that initially all workmen including himself were employed as Operator–Production. He stated that in the year, 2006, the designations of all workmen were changed to that of management associates Grade MA-01 and in year 2011, the grade of workers were changed to MA-02 although the duties performed by them remained the same. He stated that all the workmen of the Employer including himself were issued
4. He stated that all the aforesaid workers were issued charge sheets on trumped up and fabricated charges. He stated that he himself and others replied to the charge-sheets denying the allegations levelled against them. He stated that the suspension of seven union office bearers including himself was from 21-04-2015. He stated that four more workmen were also suspended from service with effect from 23-04-2015 pending enquiry namely, Ankush Gaonkar, Mangaldas Gaude, Umakant Chari, and Samesh Naik. He stated that all eleven workmen were suspended and were issued charge sheets based on false and fabricated charges. He stated that as the workers were not happy with Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh Union because of the developments which took place which workers least expected, all the OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 by him or his Defense Representative about the date of enquiry or appointment of a new Enquiry Officer. He stated that after few months, the Employer dismissed the service of the four union office bearers with effect from 16-06-2015 claiming that they held enquiry against them and claiming that Enquiry Officer held them guilty of the charges namely, Sagar Dhume, Suraj Salgaonkar, Navin Gaude and himself. Aggrieved by the said blatantly illegal and unjustified terminations, the Workman and three other workmen raised an industrial disputes with the Employer and later on with the Conciliation Officer/Dy. Labor Commissioner which ended in failure.
workers after holding a General Body Meeting decided to resign from the said Union and became the members of Kamgarancho Ekvott Trade Union of which Subhash Naik George is the president with effect from 20-05-2015 after resigning from Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh. He stated that these developments were informed to the Employer in writing. He stated that the said Union Kamagarancho Ekvott raised several Industrial Disputes with the Employer such as Charter of Demands on behalf of the workers, illegal and unjustified refusal of work with effect from 24-04-2015, unfair labour practice, non-payment of bonus, illegal termination of services of workmen and illegal imposition of punishments to workers etc. He stated that as the Employer did not accept the demands, the union raised disputes before Dy. Labor Commissioner who is also Conciliation Officer of Government of Goa, where all industrial disputes are pending conciliation and some disputes have been referred to this Hon'ble Tribunal for adjudication.
5. He stated that although all seven union office bearers including himself were issued separate charge sheets, the Employer decided to hold common enquiry. He stated that Shri Prashant Agarwal, Advocate who was appointed as an Enquiry Officer to conduct the enquiries in respect of charge sheets issued to seven union office bearers. He stated that Shri Prasanna Chawadikar, Advocate was appointed as Management Representative. He stated that initially Puti Gaonkar was the Defense Representative on behalf of charge sheeted workmen and later on, Subhash Naik George was appointed as Defense Representative by himself and other charge sheeted workers. He stated that on 02-06-2015 a date was fixed by the Enquiry Officer Mr. Agarwal to hold the enquiry. However, on that day Ld. Enquiry Officer did not attend the enquiry at the hearing fixed at Panaji-Goa. He stated that the Management Representative, Shri Prasanna Chawadikar who was present for the enquiry informed that Ld. Enquiry Officer had gone to his native place to bring his wife and he could not get tickets to return to Goa due to vacation rush and that he is still travelling in the train. He stated that the Management Representative informed him and all other charge sheeted workmen as well as Defense Representative that Ld. Enquiry Officer, Mr. Agarwal had resigned from the post of Enquiry Officer and that he could not come for the enquiry for his personal reasons. He stated that Management Representative informed that the next date of enquiry would be communicated after the management appointed a new Enquiry Officer.
6. He stated that after 5th June, 2015, no communication either oral or writing was received
7. He contended during the pendency of such disputes as per provisions of Section 33 of the I. D. Act, 1947, the Employer cannot terminate the services of the workmen without prior permission or without approval of action taken by them. He submitted that the Employer, as an after thought, terminated the services of remaining three office bearers namely, Ramdas Mayenkar, Suraj Kurtikar, and Susen Jalmi with effect from 23-12-2015. He submitted that with these termination, Employer have terminated all Seven office bearers who were elected after formation of Trade Union which clearly proves that this is a clear case of victimization for trade union activities. He submitted that since he himself, Sagar Dhume and Susen Jalmi were protected workmen as per provisions of I.D. Act, prior permission before termination ought to have been obtained from this Hon'ble Tribunal and/or Dy. Labour Commissioner, failing which the termination are bad-in-law. He submitted that the charge sheet issued to him and six other office bearers of the union and four other union activities were fabricated and cooked up besides being false. He submitted that the same were issued to him and others to victimize them for their trade union activities as they had formed a union for the first time in the company. He submitted that Shailesh Redkar, whom the Employer claims to have been appointed as Enquiry Officer was never appointed as Enquiry Officer and no intimation to that effect has been sent to him. He submitted that no intimation of dates of enquiry by the said Enquiry Officer if any, was sent to him. He submitted that the records of enquiry proceedings alleged to have been conducted by Shailesh Redkar have not being supplied to him till date. He submitted that the Employer, before terminating his service has not issued him a show cause notice enclosing copy of the findings of the Enquiry Officer, if any, and records of enquiry proceedings if any, seeking his views before dismissal which is mandatory. He submitted that no enquiry was held in respect of charges OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 levelled against him in the charge-sheet issued to him. He submitted that copy of the findings of the enquiry if any, were not supplied to him before termination of his services. He submitted that since the date of dismissal, he is unemployed and is dependent on his family and friends on sustainance. He submitted that his termination is illegal and unjustified as he has been dismissed from service in total violation of principles of natural justice. He submitted that no opportunity whatsoever for given to him to defend himself in the enquiry. He submitted that the management witnesses were not allowed to cross-examine by him. He submitted that the charges levelled against him have not been proved in a fair and impartial enquiry in accordance with the principles of natural justice. He submitted that his dismissal from services is malafide, vindictive, and by way of victimization for trade union activities, besides the same being discriminatory. The workmen therefore prayed that he be reinstated in service with full back wages and continuity of service with costs.
8. The Employer controverted the claim of Workman by filing its written statement on 02-12-2016 at exb. 6. The Employer, as an by way of its preliminary objections, submitted that the reference is not maintainable and it ought to be rejected as there is no "Industrial Dispute" as defined under the I.D. Act, 1947, that the Workman has accepted all the legal dues arising out of termination in full and final settlement and hence, the Workman is estopped from raising the present dispute, that there is non-application of mind by the Appropriate Government while referring the present dispute and that the present reference is therefore null and void.
9. The Employer stated that it is a Private Limited Company incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956, having its registered office at the Capital, 1802, 1901 Bandra Kurla Complex, Bandra (East), Mumbai and the factory located at Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcette-Goa. The Employer stated that it is engaged in the manufacturing of pharmaceuticals at its factory located at Verna Industrial Estate, Verna-Goa.
10. The Employer stated that the workman was issued a charge-sheet dated 07-05-2015 alleging as under:
"It has been observed that from the month of December, 2014, the workmen have deliberately and willfully reduced production as a result of which the Management suffered heavy losses. The fall in production which commenced from the month of December, 2014 gradually reached to a stage where during the preceding week the production was reduced to around 25% of the normal.
The management has consistently requested the workmen to stop the unfair practice of lowering the production and to restore normalcy. However, the workmen continue with the unfair labour practice of lowering the productive process.
Subsequent there to by Notice dated 7th February, 2015, letters dated 14th April, 2015 and various communications, Management invited the attention of the workmen to the fall in production and requested the workmen to restore normalcy. However, instead of restoring normalcy, to the utter shock and surprise of the Management, the workmen in a concerted manner stopped production from the commencement of Second shift of 20th April, 2015 and started squatting within the factory premises. As a consequence thereto the entire productive process has come to a grinding halt. The Management has suffered huge losses till date and continues to do so. As you are aware, we are engaged in the manufacturing of drugs which include life- saving drugs like Wysolone, Folvite, Pacitane, Overal-L etc.
All these products are listed in the National List of Essential Medicines (NLEM), issued by Ministry of Health, Government of India. Wysolone is a life- saving steroidal drug with anti-inflammatory properties and controls the painful symptoms of a temporary auto immune condition called Polymyalgia Rheumatica (PMR), Folvite, essentially taken by women during the first trimester of pregnancy for development of the foetus and also used for all kinds of anaemic conditions, Pacitane, drug used by Patients suffering from early symptoms of Parkinson's Disease and Overal-L. You are fully aware that the discontinuation due to non- availability of these drugs can have an adverse effect on the patients and the society at large.
We have received various communications from our dealers, hospitals and doctors informing us of the serious consequences arising as a result of drugs not being available in the market and the suffering of the patients, especially those who had already been prescribed such drugs and consuming the same. The consequence of sudden discontinuation of supply to the patients has as expected adverse consequences on the health of the patients.
You are an office bearer of Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh. The Management has been consistently been communicating with you and other workmen who have been participating in the go slow/stoppage of OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 work to desist from the unfair labour practice of reducing willfully and deliberately the production. The fall in production is as a consequence of your instigation and incitement of the workmen to commence and continue with the reduction of production. It has also been observed that you have been actively inducing the workmen to continue with the go slow.
The participation in the willful go slow and the instigation and incitement of the workmen to initiate the go slow and continue, wilful damage to or loss of employers good or properties as such amounts to a serious misconduct under the Model Standing Orders.
The Management has therefore decided to conduct an enquiry into the misconduct alleged against you. You were suspended pending enquiry by suspension order dated 21-04-2015.
Your above acts on your part constitute the following Acts of Misconducts under the Model Standing Orders:
a. Willful insubordination or disobedience, whether alone or in combination with others, to any lawful and reasonable order of a superior.
b. Willful damage to or loss of employer's good or
property.
c. Habitual absence without leave or absence
without leave for more than 10 days.
d. Habitual breach of any law applicable to the
establishment.
e. Riotous or disorderly behavior during working hours at the establishment or any act subversive of discipline.
f. Neglect of work.
g. Striking work or inciting others to strike work in contravention of the provision of any law, or
rule having the force of law".
11. The Employer stated that the workmen was suspended pending enquiry. The Employer stated that the management has conducted an enquiry into the above said charges. The Employer stated that the enquiry was conducted by Mr. Shailesh Redkar in an impartial manner and every opportunity was given to the Workman to defend the charges levelled against him. The Employer stated that as the Workman failed to participate in the enquiry, the enquiry was therefore held ex-parte. The Employer stated that Ld. Enquiry Officer submitted his findings dated 13-6-2015 and after appreciating the evidence on record held the Workman guilty of the charges levelled against him. The Employer stated that they considered the proceedings of the enquiry, the findings of the Enquiry Officer dated 13-6-2015 and concurred with the same. The Employer stated that they considered the past record and did not find any extenuating circumstances for mitigation of punishment of dismissal from its service. The Employer stated that considering the gravity of proved misconduct, the Workman was dismissed from its service vide letter dt. 16-06-2015.
12. The Employer stated that the Workman was paid full and final settlement of all his dues vide cheque bearing No. 101981 drawn on Deutche Bank, Mumbai for an amount of Rs. 1,60,457/- alongwith the full and final computation statement on 10-07-2015 that includes basic pay, P.L. encashment, house rent allowance, conveyance allowance, medical allowance and LTA alongwith gratuity. The Employer stated that the said amount has been received by the Workman and has been credited to his account on 01-10-2015. The Employer stated that the Workman has also collected all his provident fund dues and for the purpose of employees Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, is an excluded employee. The Employer stated that, since the Workman is prosecuting this matter after having received benefits/full and final settlements of all legal dues arising out of termination, it would be equitable to direct the Workman to return the benefits so receive from them with 8.5% interest on the said money for prosecuting the reference on merits on the principle of "Who seeks equity must do equity". The Employer therefore prayed that the Workman will be directed to deposit the entire amount in the Court and in the event the Workman fails to deposit the amount within the period stipulated in this Hon'ble Court, the defense of the Workman may be struck off and the reference be rejected or the Workman may be stopped from agitating the present reference.
13. The Employer stated that by notice dated 20-4-2015, the management informed the employee that their act of stoppage of work from the second shift amounts to willful stoppage and gross indiscipline. The Employer stated that the management advised the employees to report for work as per the shift schedule. The Employer stated that however, the employees continued with the stoppage and continued squatting within the factory premises. The Employer stated that they, by notice dated 21-4-2015, invited the attention of the workmen in the third shift of 20th April, and first shift of 21st April, 2015, to the wilful stoppage of work and again advised them to report for work. The Employer stated OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 of normalcy. The Employer stated that by the said notice, they were informed that not to sit at the security gate as squatting outside the security gate is illegal and causes inconvenience and as well as an atmosphere of fear and threat in the mind of managerial and other employees as well as the customers, welders who are entering the factory premises. The Employer stated that the employees were therefore advised not to squat near the factory gate and to stay away from the said place. The Employer stated that as the workmen continued to commit illegalities, the management filed a suit for permanent as well as temporary injunction on 27-4-2015. The Employer stated the Hon'ble Court after hearing them passed the order stating that the defendent union and its members only those who are employed with them, their agents, friends, relatives and representatives are restrained from squatting within a radius of 200 meters from its factory premises at Verna, Salcette, Goa and from blocking the entrance thereof and/or preventing egress and ingress there from the other staff and employees, customers, goods, vehicles, raw material suppliers, there from till filing their reply thereto. The Employer stated that in the meanwhile the management vide its letter to the individual workmen dated 02-06-2015 called upon the workmen to withdraw the agitation and report for work by giving by declaration/undertaking as mentioned therein. The Employer stated that the workmen however, did not respond. The Employer stated that they again by its letter dated 23-6-2015 sent to individual workmen requested to join the duties. The workmen did not respond. The Employer stated that the management once again vide its appeal dated 31-07-2015 sent to individual workers requested the workmen to report for work in their shift as per their regular shift. The Employer stated that on 16-7-2015 four employees who were members of "Kamgarancho Ekvott" resumed the duty. The Employer stated that thereafter, one more appeal was sent to the workmen on 11-08-2015 wherein, reference was given of the appeal of 23-06-2016, 03-07-2015, and 31-07-2015 to report for work in the shift and the shift schedule was annexed herewith. The Employer stated that finally on 17-08-2015 the remaining workers resumed duties.
that however, they failed to report for duty and continued to squat within the factory premises. The Employer stated that the management also decided to issue charge-sheets to some of the Employees for the misconducts committed by them. The Employer stated that in view of the seriousness of the misconducts alleged against them and in the interest of conducting a proper inquiry, and to avoid any interference with such inquiry, the management decided to suspend them pending inquiry and formal charge-sheets. The Employer stated that the said workmen were suspended pending inquiry vide letter of suspension dated 21-4-2015. The Employer stated that in the letter of suspension, the management informed the workmen that the management has decided to institute an inquiry into the acts of misconduct alleged against them. The Employers stated that as the employees continued with the work stoppage and failed to report for work and on the contrary were sitting within the factory premises, the management by letter dated 23-4-2015, invited the attention of General Secretary of the union Mr. Puti Gaonkar to the stoppage of work by the employees from 20-4-2015 and to the notices displayed on its notice board requesting the striking employees to report for work. The Employer stated that in the said letter, management informed the union that the management is required a written undertaking from all the workmen that they will perform their duties of manufacturing and restored normalcy in the factory premises. The Employer stated that the said letter was also displayed on its notice board. The Employer stated that at the copy of the said undertaking that the workmen were required to sign was also displayed on its notice board and copies of the same were placed at the security gate. The Employer stated that on and from commencement of general shifts of 24-4-2015, the employees who had reported at the security gate were advised to sign the undertaking, however, they refused to do so and squatted outside the factory premises in front of the security cabin from where all the employees enter inside the factory premises thereby, causing inconvenience to the employees who report for duty. The Employer stated that the action of the employees of stoppage of work from 28-4-2015 in a concerted manner and continuing such stoppage amounts to a strike which is illegal and unjustified.
14. The Employer stated that by notice dated 27-4-2015 displayed on 27-4-2015, the management invited the attention of the Workman the stoppage of work by way of illegal strike from 28-4-2015 and to the undertakings which they declining to submit to the management giving an assurance of restoration
15. The Employer submitted that the Ld. Enquiry Officer followed the principles of natural justice and granted every conceivable opportunities to the workmen to be present and failed to participate in the enquiry and therefore Ld. Enquiry Officer had no option but to conduct the inquiry ex-parte. The Employer submitted that Ld. Enquiry Officer on the basis of the evidence on record submitted a reasoned OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 findings holding the Workman guilty of the charges levelled against him. The Employer submitted that the management considered the findings of the Enquir y Officer, concurred in the same and considering the gravity of misconduct decided to dismiss him from the service and hence the present application for permission for dismissal of the Workman. The Employer denies the case of the Workman as pleaded by him and prayed for rejection of the present reference.
16. Thereafter, the Workman filed his Re-joinder on 13-12-2016 at Exb. 7. The Workman, by way of his Re-joinder, confirms and reiterates all his submissions, averments and statements made in his Claim Statement to be true and correct and denies all the statements, averments and submissions made by the Employer in its Written Statement, which are contrary to his Statement and averments made in his Claim Statement.
17. Based on the pleadings filed by the respective parties, this Court framed the following issues on 05-04-2017 at Exb. 10.
1. Whether a free, fair and proper enquiry was conducted against the Workman/Party I in respect of charge-sheet dated 07-05-2015 in accordance with the principles of natural justice?
2. Whether the charges of misconduct levelled against the Workman vide charge-sheet dated 07-05-2015 have been proved to the satisfaction of this court by acceptable evidence?
3. Whether the Workman/Party I proved that his dismissal from service is in violation of Section 33 of the I.D. Act, 1947?
4. Whether the Workman/Party-I proves that the action of the Employer/Party II in dismissing him from service w.e.f. 16-06-2015, is illegal and unjustified?
5. Whether the Employer/Party II proves that the reference is not maintainable and bad-in-law in view of the reasons stated in para 1 (a) to 1(d) of its written statement?
6. Whether the Workman/Party-I is entitled to any
relief?
7. What order? What award?
18. Thereafter, both the parties led their evidence on the preliminary issues No. 1 and 2. Thereafter, the Employer filed an application for amendment of its written statement which was allowed by order dated 17-03-2020 after hearing both parties. The Workman also filed its synopsis his written arguments on preliminary issues. On 12-03-2022, Ld. Rep. Shri Subhash Naik appearing for the Workman as well as Ld. Adv. Ms. N. Gaonkar representing the Employer submitted that the matter is likely to be settled amicably between the parties. Accordingly, on 20-01-2023, Ld. Rep. Shri Subhash Naik alongwith the Workman as well as Ld. Adv. Mrs. M. Rao h/f Adv. G. K. Sardessai representing the Employer alongwith its Director remained present and filed an application for Award in terms of settlement alongwith Memorandum of settlement u/s 2(P) r/w Sec-18(1) of the I.D. Act, 1947 between the Employer and the Workman which is on record at Exb.46-colly and submitted that the matter be disposed off in terms of the settlement arrived at between the parties hereinabove. The terms of settlement as agreed between the parties hereinabove are reproduced hereunder:
a. The Management agrees to pay the workman Mr. Krishnakant K. Gawas a sum of Rs. 21,00,000/- (Rupees twenty one lakhs only), vide cheque bearing No. 500002 dated 12-01-2023 drawn on JP Morgan Chase Bank, N. A., Mumbai 400098 Branch, in full and final settlement of all his claims.
b. It is agreed between the parties that the Management shall not deduct TDS from the Settlement amount and Mr. Krishnakant K. Gawas undertakes to pay the Tax on the said amount.
c. Accordingly, Mr. Krishnakant K. Gawas agrees not to pursue the references No. LC-II/IT/31/2016 before the Labour Court II or any dispute raised individually or through any union before any Tribunal, Court, Authority or Forum and treat the same as settled.
d. It is agreed between the parties that this settlement shall be filed before the Labour Court II under reference No. LC-II/IT/31/ /2016 for an Award in terms of the present settlement.
I have gone through the terms of settlement signed by the parties hereinabove and am of the opinion that the said terms of settlement are beneficial to both the parties. The said terms of settlement are also useful for the harmonious relation between the parties. It furthers industrial harmony at the workplace. Hence, I approved the same.
In view of above and with regards to the facts and circumstances of the present case, I proceed to pass the following order.
ORDER
1. It is held that the reference as to whether the action of the management of M/s. Pfizer Ltd., OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcette, Goa, in dismissing Shri Krishnakant Gawas, Management Associate, w.e.f. 16-06-2015 is legal and justified, does not survive.
2. Inform the Government accordingly.
Sd/-
(Suresh N. Narulkar) Presiding Officer, Labour Court-II.
bearing No. 28/27/2016-LAB/474 referred the following dispute for adjudication to the Labour Court-II, Panaji-Goa.
"(1) Whether the action of the management of
M/s. Pfizer Limited, Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcette, Goa, in dismissing its workman, namely Shri Suraj Kuttikar, Operator, with effect from 23-12-2015, is legal and justified?
(2) If not, what relief the workman is entitled to?
————
2. On receipt of the reference, a case was Notification
No. 28/02/2023-LAB/Part-III/155
The following Award passed by the Labour Court-II, at Panaji-Goa on 30-01-2023 in Case No. Ref. LC-II/IT/14/16 is hereby published as required under Section 17 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947).
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Amalia O. F. Pinto, Under Secretary (Labour).
Porvorim, 24th February, 2023.
——— IN THE LABOUR COURT-II GOVERNMENT OF GOA AT PANAJI
(Before Shri Suresh N. Narulkar, Hon'ble Presiding Officer)
Case. No. Ref. LC-II/IT/14/16
Shri Suraj Kuttikar, H. No. 592, Dhaushire, Near Sai Bana Temple, Tisk, Usgao-Goa .... Workman/Party-I.
V/s
The Managing Director, M/s. Pfizer Ltd., Plot No. L-137, Phase III-A, Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcete-Goa (403722) .... Employer/Party-II.
Workmen/Party I represented by Ld. Rep. Shri Subhash Naik.
Employer/Party II represented by Ld. Adv. Shri G.K. Sardessai.
Panaji, dated: 30-01-2023.
AWARD
1. In exercise of the powers conferred by Clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 10 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Central Act 14 of 1947), the Government of Goa, by Order dated 08-07-2016, registered under No. LC-II/IT/14/2016 and registered A/D notice was issued to the parties. In pursuance to the said notice, the parties put in their appearance. The Workman/Party-I (for short 'Workman'), filed his Statement of Claim on 30-01-2017 at Exhibit-4. The facts of the case in brief as pleaded by the Workman are that the Employer/ /Party-II (for short 'Employer') is a Multinational Pharmaceutical Company engaged in the production of tablets at its factory at Verna Industrial Estate, Salcette, Goa. He stated that the Employer was initially established at Verna in the year, 2001 as Wyeth Lederle Ltd. which was subsequently changed as Pfizer Ltd. in the year, 2009. He stated that he was employed with the Employer as "Operator-Production" since 02-07-2003. He stated that he has not received a single memo or a single charge-sheet except the charge-sheet which is the subject matter of the present reference. He stated that during his service of the Employer, he received awards from the Employer for his performance. He stated that he also received several "employee of the month" awards, long service awards, best nominee of the month awards, certificates for improving productivity and development, etc. He stated that after formation of a Trade Union in 2014, all the workers of the Employer Company joined the said union. He stated that he was elected an office bearer of the said union and as such he was a Protected Workman as per the provisions of the I.D. Act, 1947. He stated that initially all workmen including himself were employed as Operator–Production. He stated that in the year, 2006, the designations of all workmen were changed to that of management associates Grade MA-01 and in year 2011, the grade of workers were changed to MA-02 although the duties performed by them remained the same. He stated that all the workmen of the Employer including himself were issued appointment letters when they joined service and all of them were confirmed in the service of the Employer.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023the members of Kamgarancho Ekvott Trade Union of which Subhash Naik George is the president with effect from 20-05-2015 after resigning from Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh. He stated that these developments were informed to the Employer in writing. He stated that the said Union Kamagarancho Ekvott raised several Industrial Disputes with the Employer such as Charter of Demands on behalf of the workers, illegal and unjustified refusal of work with effect from 24-04-2015, unfair labour practice, non-payment of bonus, illegal termination of services of workmen and illegal imposition of punishments to workers etc. He stated that as the Employer did not accept the demands, the union raised disputes before Dy. Labor Commissioner who is also Conciliation Officer of Government of Goa, where all industrial disputes are pending conciliation and some disputes have been referred to this Hon'ble Tribunal for adjudication.
3. He stated that in June, 2014, workers formed a Trade Union for the first time, when all the workers of the Employer factory became members of Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh Trade Union. He stated that the Employer was informed about the formation of a Trade Union. He stated that names of seven Union office bearers of the Union including himself were also communicated to the Employer. He stated that the Employer did not appreciate the decision of the workers to form a Trade Union and started harassing the workers by withdrawing existing benefits and existing facilities. He stated that with effect from 20-04-2015, the Employer did not allot any work to workers inside the factory and kept them idle as the Employer was not happy with the workers forming a Trade Union. He stated that with effect from 24-04-2015, all workmen were kept outside the factory gates and were not allowed to resume work inside the factory. He stated that this continued for several months and later the Employer stated that they would not allow the workmen to report for work unless they gave an undertaking, the contents of which were not disclosed to them. He stated that later on, the Employer allowed all workmen to report for work without undertaking and all workmen reported for work with effect from 17-08-2015. He stated that the Employer has till date not paid wages of the workers from 20-4-2015 to 16-08-2015. He stated that however, eleven workmen, who were issued suspension orders pending enquiry, were not allowed to report for work. He stated that meanwhile, after formation of a Trade Union, the Employer suspended the services of all office bearers of the Union namely, Ramdas Mayenkar, Sagar Dhume, Krishnakant Gawas, Navin Gaude, himself, Susen Jalmi and Suraj Salgaonkar.
5. He stated that although all seven union office bearers including himself were issued separate charge-sheets, the Employer decided to hold common enquiry. He stated that Shri Prashant Agarwal, Advocate who was appointed as an Enquiry Officer to conduct the enquiries in respect of charge- -sheets issued to seven union office bearers. He stated that Shri Prasanna Chawadikar, Advocate was appointed as Management Representative. He stated that initially, Puti Gaonkar was the Defense Representative on behalf of charge-sheeted workmen and later on, Subhash Naik George was appointed as Defense Representative by himself and other charge- -Sheeted workers. He stated that on 02-06-2015 a date was fixed by the Enquiry Officer Mr. Agarwal to hold the enquiry. However, on that day Ld. Enquiry Officer did not attend the enquiry at the hearing fixed at Panaji-Goa. He stated that the Management Representative, Shri Prasanna Chawadikar who was present for the enquiry informed that Ld. Enquiry Officer had gone to his native place to bring his wife and he could not get tickets to return to Goa due to vacation rush and that he is still travelling in the train. He stated that the Management Representative informed him and all other charge-sheeted workmen as well as Defense Representative that Ld. Enquiry Officer, Mr. Agarwal had resigned from the post of Enquiry Officer and that he could not come for the enquiry for his personal reasons. He stated that Management Representative informed that the next date of enquiry would be communicated after the management appointed a new Enquiry Officer.
4. He stated that all the aforesaid workers were issued charge-sheets on trumped up and fabricated charges. He stated that he himself and others replied to the charge-sheets denying the allegations levelled against them. He stated that the suspension of seven union office bearers including himself was from 21-04-2015. He stated that four more workmen were also suspended from service with effect from 23-04-2015 pending enquiry namely, Ankush Gaonkar, Mangaldas Gaude, Umakant Chari, and Samesh Naik. He stated that all eleven workmen were suspended and were issued charge-sheets based on false and fabricated charges. He stated that as the workers were not happy with Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh Union because of the developments which took place which workers least expected, all the workers after holding a General Body Meeting decided to resign from the said Union and became
6. He stated that after 5th June, 2015, no communication either oral or writing was received by him or his Defense Representative about the date of enquiry or appointment of a new Enquiry Officer.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023He stated that after few months, the Employer dismissed the service of the four union office bearers with effect from 16-06-2015 claiming that they held enquiry against them and claiming that Enquiry Officer held them guilty of the charges namely, Sagar Dhume, Krishnakant Gawas, Navin Gaude, and Suraj Salgaonkar. Aggrieved by the said blatantly illegal and unjustified terminations, the Workman and three other workmen raised an industrial disputes with the Employer and later on with the Conciliation Officer/Dy. Labor Commissioner which ended in failure.
7. He contended during the pendency of such disputes as per provisions of Section 33 of the I. D. Act, 1947, the Employer cannot terminate the services of the workmen without prior permission or without approval of action taken by them. He submitted that the Employer, as an afterthought, terminated the services of remaining three office bearers namely, Ramdas Mayenkar, himself, and Susen Jalmi with effect from 23-12-2015. He submitted that with these termination, Employer have terminated all Seven office bearers who were elected after formation of Trade Union which clearly proves that this is a clear case of victimization for trade union activities. He submitted that since he himself, Sagar Dhume and Susen Jalmi were protected workmen as per provisions of I.D. Act, prior permission before termination ought to have been obtained from this Hon'ble Tribunal and/or Dy. Labour Commissioner, failing which the termination are bad-in-law. He submitted that the charge-sheet issued to him and six other office bearers of the union and four other union activities were fabricated and cooked up besides being false. He submitted that the same were issued to him and others to victimize them for their trade union activities as they had formed a union for the first time in the company. He submitted that Shailesh Redkar, whom the Employer claims to have been appointed as Enquiry Officer, was never appointed as Enquiry Officer and no intimation to that effect has been sent to him. He submitted that no intimation of dates of enquiry by the said Enquiry Officer if any, was sent to him. He submitted that the records of enquiry proceedings alleged to have been conducted by Shailesh Redkar have not being supplied to him till date. He submitted that the Employer, before terminating his service has not issued him a show cause notice enclosing copy of the findings of the Enquiry Officer, if any, and records of enquiry proceedings if any, seeking his views before dismissal which is mandatory. He submitted that no enquiry was held in respect of charges levelled against him in the charge-sheet issued to him. He submitted that copy of the findings of the enquiry if any, were not supplied to him before termination of his services. He submitted that since the date of dismissal, he is unemployed and is dependent on his family and friends on sustainance. He submitted that his termination is illegal and unjustified as he has been dismissed from service in total violation of principles of natural justice. He submitted that no opportunity whatsoever for given to him to defend himself in the enquiry. He submitted that the management witnesses were not allowed to cross-examine by him. He submitted that the charges levelled against him have not been proved in a fair and impartial enquiry in accordance with the principles of natural justice. He submitted that his dismissal from services is malafide, vindictive, and by way of victimization for trade union activities, besides the same being discriminatory. The workmen therefore prayed that he be reinstated in service with full back wages and continuity of service with costs.
8. The Employer controverted the claim of Workman by filing its written statement on 03-05-2017 at exb. 5. The Employer, as an by way of its preliminary objections, submitted that the reference is not maintainable and it ought to be rejected as there is no "Industrial Dispute" as defined under the I.D. Act, 1947, that the Workman has accepted all the legal dues arising out of termination in full and final settlement and hence, the Workman is estopped from raising the present dispute, that there is non application of mind by the Appropriate Government while referring the present dispute and that the present reference is therefore null and void.
9. The Employer stated that it is a Private Limited Company incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956, having its registered office at the Capital, 1802, 1901 Bandra Kurla Complex, Bandra (East), Mumbai and the factory located at Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcette-Goa. The Employer stated that it is engaged in the manufacturing of pharmaceuticals at its factory located at Verna Industrial Estate, Verna-Goa.
10. The Employer stated that the workman was issued a charge-sheet dated 07-05-2015 alleging as under:
"It has been observed that from the month of December, 2014, the workmen have deliberately and willfully reduced production as a result of which the Management suffered heavy losses. The fall in production which commenced from the month of December, 2014 gradually reached to a stage where during the preceding week the production was reduced to around 25% of the normal.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023The management has consistently requested the workmen to stop the unfair practice of lowering the production and to restore normalcy. However, the workmen continue with the unfair labour practice of lowering the productive process.
Subsequent there to by Notice dated 7th February, 2015, letters dated 14th April, 2015 and various communications, Management invited the attention of the workmen to the fall in production and requested the workmen to restore normalcy. However, instead of restoring normalcy, to the utter shock and surprise of the Management, the workmen in a concerted manner stopped production from the commencement of Second shift of 20th April, 2015 and started squatting within the factory premises. As a consequence thereto the entire productive process has come to a grinding halt. The Management has suffered huge losses till date and continues to do so. As you are aware, we are engaged in the manufacturing of drugs which include life- -saving drugs like Wysolone, Folvite, Pacitane, Overal-L etc.
All these products are listed in the National List of Essential Medicines (NLEM), issued by Ministry of Health, Government of India. Wysolone is a life-saving steroidal drug with anti-inflammatory properties and controls the painful symptoms of a temporary autoimmune condition called Polymyalgia Rheumatica (PMR), Folvite, essentially taken by women during the first trimester of pregnancy for development of the foetus and also used for all kinds of anaemic conditions, Pacitane, drug used by Patients suffering from early symptoms of Parkinson's Disease and Overal-L. You are fully aware that the discontinuation due to non-availability of these drugs can have an adverse effect on the patients and the society at large.
We have received various communications from our dealers, hospitals and doctors informing us of the serious consequences arising as a result of drugs not being available in the market and the suffering of the patients, especially those who had already been prescribed such drugs and consuming the same. The consequence of sudden discontinuation of supply to the patients has as expected adverse consequences on the health of the patients.
You are an office bearer of Gomantak Mazdoor Sangh. The Management has been consistently been communicating with you and other workmen who have been participating in the go slow/stoppage of work to desist from the unfair labour practice of reducing willfully and deliberately the production.
The fall in production is as a consequence of your instigation and incitement of the workmen to commence and continue with the reduction of production. It has also been observed that you have been actively inducing the workmen to continue with the go slow.
The participation in the willful go slow and the instigation and incitement of the workmen to initiate the go slow and continue, wilful damage to or loss of employers good or properties as such amounts to a serious misconduct under the Model Standing Orders.
The Management has therefore decided to conduct an enquiry into the misconduct alleged against you. You were suspended pending enquiry by suspension order dated 21-04-2015.
Your above acts on your part constitute the following Acts of Misconducts under the Model Standing Orders:
a. Willful insubordination or disobedience, whether alone or in combination with others, to any lawful and reasonable order of a superior.
b. Willful damage to or loss of employer's good or
property.
c. Habitual absence without leave or absence
without leave for more than 10 days.
d. Habitual breach of any law applicable to the
establishment.
e. Riotous or disorderly behavior during working hours at the establishment or any act subversive of discipline.
f. Neglect of work.
g. Striking work or inciting others to strike work in contravention of the provision of any law, or rule having the force of law".
11. The Employer stated that the workmen was suspended pending enquiry. The Employer stated that Mr. Prashant Agarwal was appointed as Enquiry Officer and Mr. Prasanna Chawadikar was appointed as the Management Representative. The Employer stated that Mr. Puti Gaonkar was appointed as Defense Representative by the Workmen. The Employer stated that Mr. Agarwal conducted the enquiry on 15-05-2015 and 22-05-2015. The Employer stated that thereafter the enquiry was fixed on 02-06-2015 at 3.30 p.m. The Employer stated that on 02-06-2015, Ld. Enquiry Officer was in personal difficulty and hence, the enquiry could not held on the said date. The Employer stated that in the mean while Mr. Prashant Agarwal by his letter dated OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 medical allowance and LTA alongwith gratuity. The Employer stated that the said amount has been received by the Workman and has been credited to his account on 23-03-2016. The Employer stated that the Workman has also collected all his provident fund dues and for the purpose of employees Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, is an excluded employee. The Employer stated that, since the Workman is prosecuting this matter after having received benefits/full and final settlements of all legal dues arising out of termination, it would be equitable to direct the Workman to return the benefits so received from them with 8.5% interest on the said money for prosecuting the reference on merits on the principle of "Who seeks equity must do equity". The Employer therefore prayed that the Workman will be directed to deposit the entire amount in the Court and in the event the Workman fails to deposit the amount within the period stipulated in this Hon'ble Court, the defense of the Workman may be struck off and the reference be rejected or the Workman may be stopped from agitating the present reference.
04-06-2015 informed them due to prior commitments, he is unable to continue with the conduct of the enquiry and therefore has decided to withdraw from the enquiry. The Employer stated that in view of inability of Mr. Prashant Agarwal to continue with the enquiry, Mr. Shailesh Redkar was appointed as an Enquiry Officer vide appointment letter dated 05-06-2015. The Employer stated that on 05-06-2015, by notice dated 05-06-2015 the Workmen were informed that in view of the change of the Enquiry Officer, and the appointment of new Enquiry Officer, the enquiry was fixed on 06-06-2015 at 4.30 p.m. at the same venue. The Employer stated that the letter of appointment of new Enquiry Officer was also served on the charge-sheeted workmen. The Employer stated that the charge-sheeted workmen however, refused to accept the notice of enquiry as well as the letter of appointment and the amended charge-sheet. The Employer stated that on 06-06-2015, none of the charge-sheeted workmen were present. The Employer stated that the charge- -sheeted workmen stayed away from the enquiry deliberately with the sole object of delaying the enquiry proceedings in spite of being informed about the enquiry fixed on 06-06-2015 at 4.30 p.m. The Employer stated that Ld. Enquiry Officer on the basis of documents on record and considering the contentions of the Management Representative and after being satisfied that it is a fit case to proceed ex-parte and held enquiry ex-parte against the charge-sheeted workmen. The Employer stated that the enquiry was conducted by the Ld. Enquiry Officer in an impartial manner and every opportunity was given to the Workman to defend the charge-sheet levelled against the charge-sheeted workmen. The Employer stated that Ld. Enquiry Officer submitted his findings dated 13-06-2015 and after appreciating the evidence on record held the Workman guilty of charges levelled against him. The Employer stated that they considered the proceedings of the enquiry, the findings of the Enquiry Officer and concurred with the same. The Employer stated that they considered the past record and did not find any extenuating circumstances for mitigation of punishment of dismissal from its service. The Employer stated that considering the gravity of proved misconduct, the Workman was dismissed from its service vide letter dt. 23-12-2015.
12. The Employer stated that the Workman was paid full and final settlement of all his dues vide cheque bearing No. 106323 drawn on Deutche Bank, Mumbai for an amount of Rs. 1,03,806/- alongwith the full and final computation statement on 30-01-2016 that includes basic pay, P. L. encashment, house rent allowance, conveyance allowance,
13. The Employer stated that by notice dated 20-4-2015, the management informed the employee that their act of stoppage of work from the second shift amounts to willful stoppage and gross indiscipline. The Employer stated that the management advised the employees to report for work as per the shift schedule. The Employer stated that however, the employees continued with the stoppage and continued squatting within the factory premises. The Employer stated that they, by notice dated 21-4-2015, invited the attention of the workmen in the third shift of 20th April, and first shift of 21st April, 2015, to the wilful stoppage of work and again advised them to report for work. The Employer stated that however, they failed to report for duty and continued to squat within the factory premises. The Employer stated that the management also decided to issue charge-sheets to some of the employees for the misconducts committed by them. The Employer stated that in view of the seriousness of the misconducts alleged against them and in the interest of conducting a proper inquiry, and to avoid any interference with such inquiry, the management decided to suspend them pending inquiry and formal charge-sheets. The Employer stated that the said workmen suspended pending inquiry vide letter of suspension dated 21-4-2015. The Employer stated that in the letter of suspension, the management informed the workmen that the management has decided to institute an inquiry into the acts of misconduct alleged against them. The Employers stated that as the employees continued with the OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 work stoppage and failed to report for work and on the contrary were sitting within the factory premises, the management by letter dated 23-4-2015, invited the attention of General Secretary of the union Mr. Puti Gaonkar to the stoppage of work by the employees from 20-4-2015 and to the notices displayed on its notice board requesting the striking employees to report for work. The Employer stated that in the said letter, management informed the union that the management is required a written undertaking from all the workmen that they will perform their duties of manufacturing and restored normalcy in the factory premises. The Employer stated that the said letter was also displayed on its notice board. The Employer stated that at the copy of the said undertaking that the workmen were required to sign was also displayed on its notice board and copies of the same were placed at the security gate. The Employer stated that on and from commencement of general shifts of 24-4-2015, the employees who had reported at the security gate were advised to sign the undertaking, however, they refused to do so and squatted outside the factory premises in front of the security cabin from where all the employees enter inside the factory premises thereby, causing inconvenience to the employees who report for duty. The Employer stated that the action of the employees of stoppage of work from 28-4-2015 in a concerted manner and continuing such stoppage amounts to a strike which is illegal and unjustified.
14. The Employer stated that by notice dated 27-4-2015 displayed on 27-4-2015, the management invited the attention of the Workman the stoppage of work by way of illegal strike from 28-4-2015 and to the undertakings which they declining to submit to the management giving an assurance of restoration of normalcy. The Employer stated that by the said notice, they were informed that not to sit at the security gate as squatting outside the security gate is illegal and causes inconvenience and as well as an atmosphere of fear and threat in the mind of managerial and other employees as well as the customers, welders who are entering the factory premises. The Employer stated that the employees were therefore advised not to squat near the factory gate and to stay away from the said place. The Employer stated that as the workmen continued to commit illegalities, the management filed a suit for permanent as well as temporary injunction on 27-4-2015. The Employer stated the Hon'ble Court after hearing them passed order stating that the defendent union and its members only those who are employed with them, their agents, friends, relatives and representatives are restrained from squatting within a radius of 200 meters from its factory premises at Verna, Salcette, Goa and from blocking the entrance thereof and/or preventing egress and ingress there from the other staff and employees, customers, goods, vehicles, raw material suppliers, there from till filing their reply thereto. The Employer stated that in the meanwhile the management, vide its letter to the individual workmen dated 02-06-2015, called upon the workmen to withdraw the agitation and report for work by giving by declaration/undertaking as mentioned therein. The Employer stated that the workmen however, did not respond. The Employer stated that they again by its letter dated 23-6-2015 sent to individual workmen requested to join the duties. The workmen did not respond. The Employer stated that the management once again vide its appeal dated 31-07-2015 sent to individual workers requested the workmen to report for work in their shift as per their regular shift. The Employer stated that on 16-7-2015 four employees who were members of "Kamgarancho Ekvott" resumed the duty. The Employer stated that thereafter, one more appeal was sent to the workmen on 11-08-2015 wherein, reference was given of the appeal of 23-06-2016, 03-07-2015, and 31-07-2015 to report for work in the shift and the shift schedule was annexed herewith. The Employer stated that finally on 17-08-2015 the remaining workers resumed duties.
15. The Employer submitted that the Ld. Enquiry Officer followed the principles of natural justice and granted every conceivable opportunities to the workmen to be present and failed to participate in the enquiry and therefore Ld. Enquiry Officer had no option but to conduct the inquiry ex-parte. The Employer submitted that Ld. Enquiry Officer on the basis of the evidence on record submitted a reasoned findings holding the Workman guilty of the charges levelled against him. The Employer submitted that the management considered the findings of the Enquiry Officer, concurred with the same and considering the gravity of misconduct decided to dismiss him from the service and hence the present application for permission for dismissal of the Workman. The Employer denies the case of the Workman as pleaded by him and prayed for rejection of the present reference.
16. Thereafter, the Workman filed his Re-joinder on 12-05-2017 at Exb. 6. The Workman, by way of his Re-joinder, confirms and reiterates all his submissions, averments and statements made in his Claim Statement to be true and correct and denies all the statements, averments and submissions made by the Employer in its Written Statement, which are contrary to his Statement and averments made in his Claim Statement.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 202317. Based on the pleadings filed by the respective
parties, this Court framed the following issues on
28-6-2017 at Exb. 7.
1. Whether a free, fair and proper enquiry was
conducted against the Workman/Party I in
respect of charge-sheet dated 07-05-2015 in
accordance with the principles of natural
justice?
2. Whether the charges of misconduct levelled
against the Workman vide charge-sheet
dated 07-05-2015 have been proved to the
satisfaction of this court by acceptable
evidence?
3. Whether the Workman/Party I proved that
the action of the Employer in dismissing from
service w.e.f. 23-12-2015 is in violation of
Section 33 of the I. D. Act, 1947?
4. Whether the Workman/Party-I proves that
the action of the Employer/Party II in
dismissing him from service w.e.f. 23-12-2015,
is illegal and unjustified?
5. Whether the Employer/Party II proves that
the reference is not maintainable and bad-
-in-law in view of the reasons stated in para
(I) to (IV) of its written statement?
6. Whether the Workman/Party-I is entitled to any
relief?
7. What order? What award?
18. Thereafter, both the parties led their evidence
on the preliminary issues No.1 and 2. Thereafter, the
Employer filed an application for amendment of its
written statement which was allowed by order dated
17-3-2020 after hearing both parties. The Workman
also filed its synopsis his written arguments on
preliminary issues. On 12-3-2022, Ld. Rep. Shri
Subhash Naik appearing for the Workman as well as
Ld. Adv. Ms. N. Gaonkar representing the Employer
submitted that the matter is likely to be settled
amicably between the parties. Accordingly, on
20-01-2023, Ld. Rep. Shri Subhash Naik along with
the Workman as well as Ld. Adv. Mrs. M. Rao h/f Adv.
G. K. Sardessai representing the Employer along with
its Director remained present and filed an
application for Award in terms of settlement along
with Memorandum of settlement u/s 2(P) r/w
Sec-18 (1) of the I. D. Act, 1947 between the Employer
and the Workman which is on record at Exb. 60-colly and submitted that the matter be disposed off in
terms of the settlement arrived at between the
parties hereinabove. The terms of settlement as
agreed between the parties hereinabove are
reproduced hereunder:
a. The Management agrees to pay the
workman Mr. Suraj Kur tikar a sum of
Rs. 21,00,000/- (Rupees twenty one lakhs
only), vide cheque bearing No. 500003 dated
12-01-2023 drawn on JP Morgan Chase
Bank, N. A., Mumbai 400098 Branch, in full
and final settlement of all his claims.
b. It is agreed between the parties that the
Management shall not deduct TDS from the
Settlement amount and Mr. Suraj Kurtikar
undertakes to pay the Tax on the said
amount.
c. Accordingly, Mr. Suraj V. Kurtikar agrees not
to pursue the references No. LC-II/IT/14/
/2016 before the Labour Court II or any
dispute raised individually or through any
union before any Tribunal, Court, Authority
or Forum and treat the same as settled.
d. It is agreed between the parties that this
settlement shall be filed before the Labour Court II under reference No. LC-II/IT/14/ /2016 for an Award in terms of the present settlement.
I have gone through the terms of settlement signed by the parties hereinabove and is of the opinion that the said terms of settlement are beneficial to both the parties. The said terms of settlement also useful for the harmonious relation between the parties. Hence, I approved the same.
In view of above and with regards to the facts and circumstances of the present case, I proceed to pass the following order.
ORDER
1. It is held that the reference as to whether the
action of the management of M/s. Pfizer Ltd., Verna Industrial Estate, Verna, Salcette, Goa, in dismissing Shri Suraj Kurtikar, Operator, w.e.f. 23-12-2015 is legal and justified, does not survive.
2. Inform the Government accordingly.
Sd/- (Suresh N. Narulkar) Presiding Officer, Labour Court-II.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023Department of Law & Judiciary
Law (Establishment) Division
–––
Order
No. 8-5-2015-LD(Estt)/390
In pursuance of the provisions of Section 6 of the Notaries Act, 1952 (Central Act 53 of 1952), read with Rule 17 of the Notaries Rules, 1956, Government of Goa hereby publishes a list of Notaries appointed by it and in practice at the beginning of the Year 2023, as shown in the Schedule, annexed hereto.
By order and in the name of the Governor of Goa.
Avelina D'sa e Pereira, Under Secretary (Law-Estt.) (Link).
Porvorim, 3rd March, 2023.
SCHEDULE
List of Notaries appointed and in practice at the beginning of the year, 2023 (Rule 17 of the Notaries Rules, 1956, r/w, Section 6 of the Notaries Act, 1952).
Sr. Name of the Residential & Qualification Area in which Remarks No. Notary Professional
Addresses
he/she is authorized to practice
1 2 3 4 5 6
1. Shri Fernando Res:- Ajanta, flat No. Law Graduate Panaji Senior Division.
Jorge Colaco 3, 1st floor, Opp. Dr. Linecido,
Braganza Pereira Road, Emdireito Legal Panaji-Goa. Practitioner Off:- 104, Manguirish, Since 1960 18th June Road, Panaji Ph. No. 2228104(O)
2. Shri Sudhanshu Res:- Bella View Apts., Law Graduate Bardez Judicial Jaiwant Sardessai Altinho, Mapusa, Senior Division.
Bardez-Goa. Off:-Vishnu Smruti, Near Civil Court Mapusa
3. Mrs. Irmina Res:- Ratnadeep Bldg., BA. L.L.B. Margao Judicial
D'Costa Fernandes flat No. C/21/B, Opp. Senior Division.
R.P. Stadium, Margao. Off:- H. No. 14/4/A, Hill View Estate behind the Goa Paradise Restaurant, Gaunlloy, Nuvem, Salcete, Goa. Ph. No. 2791764(O)/ /9822149547(M)
4. Shri Sanjiv G. Res:- "Saroj" No. 226/9, BA. L.L.B. Mapusa Area.
Sardessai Housing Board Colony,
Mapusa, Goa. Off:- H. No. 13/133, Wagle House, Feira Baixa, Near Joao Menezes, Mapusa-Goa. Ph. No. (O)6529998/ /(M)9822120186 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
5. Shri Daniel Res:- Baira Alto, Ponda Goa BA. L.L.B. Ponda Area.
Minguel Off:- Navelkar Bldg., Rodrigues Near Ponda Municipality, Ponda. Ph. No. (O)2314171 (M)9822103035
6. Shri Gajanan Res:- Vidyanagar, Near Vidya BA. L.L.B. Bardez Judicial Govind Prabhodini High School, Senior Division. Dhumatkar Alto, Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
Off:- A-5, Hill Top Apartments, Near Teen Building, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa Ph.No.: (O)2415688 (M) 9822154748
7. Shri Prabhakar Res:- "Dambab" Bernando BSc. L.L.B. Margao Judicial
Jaganath F. Costa Road, Opp. Damodar Senior Division. Kunkolienkar Sal, Margao, Salcete-Goa.
Off:- Ratnadeep Bldg., 1st Floor, Opp. Rajendra Prasad Stadium, Margao, Salcete-Goa
8. Shri Upendra Res:- Miramar Panaji L. L. B. Tiswadi Judicial
Ramchandra Off:- Fo-8 Atmaram Senior Division. Timble Commercial Complex,
Dr. A. B. Road, Panaji-Goa
9. Shri Prabhakar Res:- Vaman Smruti Bldg, BSc. Hons. Bardez Taluka.
G. Narulkar 2nd floor, Opp. Laxmi L.L.B.
Narayan Temple, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa Off:- Saldanha Business Towers, Off. No. 105, Block E, 1st floor, Near Mapusa court, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa
10. Shri Francisco Res:- Goodwill Farms, MA., L.L.B. Quepem Judicial
Nicolau Vodlemmoll, Kakoda, Division. Veronica Curchorem Fernandes Off:- H. No. 13A, Opp.
Municipal Garden, Quepem New Address:- Opp. Municipal Garden, 34, 2nd floor, Municipal Market Building, Quepem, Goa 403705
11. Shri Vithoo Res. & Off.:- 271, Bepkegale, B.A. L.L.B. Sanguem &
Krishna Naik Curchorem. Quepem Taluka.
12. Shri Ulhas Govind Res:- Melquiedes Bldg, B.G.L. L.L.B. Mormugao
Shetye behind Court, Vasco. Judicial Senior
Off:- Melquiedes Bldg, Division. 1st Floor, Fr. Joseph Vaz Road, Vasco-da-Gama. Ph. No.:- 2513001 2540768, 9822380114 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
13. Shri Caetano Res:- Bandora, Ponda Goa BA. L.L.B. Ponda Judicial
Gabriel Da Costa Off:- Kaziwada, Bandekar Senior Division.
building, 1st Floor, Opp. Bank of India, Ponda-Goa. Ph. No. 2335074(R) 2314385 (O)
14. Shri Marcelino Res & Off.:- Raghunath L.L.B. Mormugao Judicial C. Fernandes Apartment, Francisco Luis Senior Division.
Gomes Road, Vasco-da-Gama. Ph. No:-2511462
15. Shri Paul Santana Res:- K.V. No. 1 Teachers B.A. L.L.B. State of Goa.
Rodrigues Quarters, Mangor hill,
Vasco-da-Gama, Goa Off:- Aliados Bldg, Abade Faria Road, Margao Office-Guia bldg., 3rd floor, Vasco-da-Gama Ph. No.:- 2734639 (O) 2510865 (R)
16. Shri Premanand Res:- Indira Niwas, Bardem, BSc. Hons. Bicholim Judicial
Shripad Naik Bicholim-Goa L.L.B. Senior Division.
Off:-36-A, 1st floor, Municipal Market Complex, Bicholim
17. Shri Vijay J. Res:- Canacona B.A., L.L.B. South Goa District.
Gaycar Off:- Satyabhama bldg.,
Shellar, Canacona Ph. No. 2643196(O) 2752564 (R)
18. Shri Suresh Res:- Mapusa, Bardes-Goa M.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Balso Gauns Off:-1st Peter's bldg., Dessai 2nd floor, office No.-4,
Opp. Mapusa Clinic, Mapusa.Ph. No. 2263345
19. Shri Satishchandra Res:- Vasco-da-Gama B.A., L.L.B. Mormugao Judicial V. Talaulikar Off:-9-Karma Paes, Senior Division.
Avenue, 2nd floor, Opp. Civil and Criminal Court, Vasco-da-Gama, Goa Ph. No. 2518188
20. Shri Yves Emanuel Res:- Mapusa, Bardez-Goa. B.Sc., L.L.B. Bardez Judicial Carmo Jose Off: C-1 Junta House, Senior Division. Martinha Zuzarte Behind Mapusa Municipality
Offices, Mapusa, Bardez Ph. No. 2262127
21. Shri Goculdas Res:- Housing Board, B.A. (Hons.) Panaji Judicial
M. Naik Porvorim Bardez-Goa. B.Ed, LLB. Senior Division.
Off:- 3rd Excelsior Chamber(b) Opp. Entrance of Rizvi Chambers, Market, Panaji-Goa Ph. No. 2220010 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
22. Shri Edmunda Res:- H. No.203, Nr. Hospital, B.A. (Hons) Mormugao Taluka.
Vitaliano D'Costa Cansaulim L.L.B. Off:-F-1 3rd floor, Apna Bazar, Vasco-da-Gama. Ph. No. 2511027(O) 2733118 (R)
23 Shri Vanmali Res:- Vasco Da Gama B.A., L.L.B. Mormugao area.
Dattaram Naik Off:- Karma Poes Avenue alias Rajan D. Naik Chambers, N 5, 2nd floor,
Near Count Bldg, Vasco-da-Gama Ph. No. 2512463/5644129
24. Shri Menino A. Res:- H. No. 467/2, B.Sc., L.L.B. Quepem and
Fernandes Cusmano, Quepem, Salcete Taluka.
Off:- C-204, Osia Commercial Arcade, SGPDA, Market Complex, Margao-Goa Ph. No. 982159068
25. Shri Albino Res:- Baina, Vasco-da-Gama B.Com.(Hons.) Entire State Santana Cosm Off:- 42, 2nd Floor, Apna Bazar, L.L.B. of Goa. Vales Vasco Ph. No. 2511041
26. Shri Menino Off: House No. 887, L.L.B. South Goa District.
Patrick Diniz Pontemol, Curchorem,
Goa- 403706
27. Shri Arjun Krishna Res:- H. No. 96,C-S, B.A(Hons.) Bardez Area.
Phadte Alto-Mapusa L.L.B.
Off:-El Capitan Centre, 1st floor, Room No. 17, Near Manjunath Hotel, Mapusa Ph. No. 2252471 (O) 2254621 (R)
28. Shri Minino Teles Res: Altinho, Panaji B.Sc. L.L.B. State of Goa.
Off:- 1st floor, Kamat Chambers, Opp. Hotel Neptune, Panaji Ph. No.:- 2224465/2431905
29. Kum. Philomena Res:- Nagoa, Verna M.A. L.L.B. State of Goa.
Da Silva Salcete-Goa
Off:- Apna Bazar, F/6, A/Bldg., Varde Valaulikar Road, Margao-Goa Ph. No. 2704110
30. Miss Sharayu M. Res:- Sanvordem, Curchorem B.A, L.L.B. Quepem Judicial
Sawardekar Off:- As-4, Vishwanath Senior Division.
Mansion, Nr. Kadamba Bus Stand, Curchorem-Goa
31. Shri Ganesh V. Res:- Khadpabandh B.A. LLB. Ponda Judicial
Khandeparkar Ponda-Goa Division.
Off:- Near Post Office, Ponda-Goa Ph. No. 2314722/2313127
32. Shri Kishore Res:- Quepem, Rivona L.L.B. South Goa District.
Premanath Off:- Cusmane, Apts., Prabhudessai 1st floor, Behind Bus Stand , Quepem OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
33. Shri Jose Agnelo Res:- Ward No. 7, Tisk, L.L.B. Judicial Division
Nelson Cardozo Near Ponda Court, of Ponda. Soares alias Ponda-Goa Nelson Soares Off:- Tisk, Ponda-Goa
Ph. No. 2312536
34. Shri Victor Diniz Res:- H. No. 64, Cusman, B.A. L.L.B. State of Goa.
Quepem-Goa Off:-Reliance Magnum Building Off. No. 206, 2nd Floor, Opp. Kadamba Bus stand, Madel, Margao-Goa. Ph. No. 2662258/2664187
35. Shri Uday Ganesh Res:- Curchorem Quepem B.A. L.L.B. Quepem Judicial
Kudchadkar Taluka.
Senior Division.
Off:-1st Floor, Kudchadkar Bldg., Opp. State Bank of India, Curchorem-Goa
36. Shri Agnelo Res:- Near Bhandare BA., L.L.B. Judicial Division
D'Costa Hospital Fountainhas, of Tiswadi.
Panaji-Goa Off:-31st January Road, Opp. Hotel Vennite Panaji-Goa Ph. No.:- 2426028
37. Shri Prakash V. Res:- Sunanda Niwas, B.A., L.L.B. Margao Judicial Senior Division.
Borkar Chandrawado, Margao,
Salcete-Goa Off:-S-4, 2nd floor, Laxmi Plaza, Behind Grace Church, Margao Ph. No.: 2742624(R)/ 2712386(O)
38. Shri Jose Joey Res:- Calata, Majorda, Salcete B.Sc. (Hons.) Margao Judicial
Rodrigues Off:- Kamat Commercial L.L.B. (Bomb.) Senior Division.
Centre, 2nd floor, Next to Bombay Cafe, Station Road, Margao-Goa Ph. No.:- 2715074(O) 2739093 (R)
39. Shri Shivanand Res:- Porvorim L.L.B. Bardez Judicial Manohas Singbal Off:-4, Navelkar Arcade, Senior Division
5th Floor, Dr. A.B. Road, and Tiswadi Taluka. Panaji, Goa Ph. No. 2232999
40. Shri Shashikant Res:- Mayem, Bicholim BSc. (Hons.) Bicholim Judicial
Anant Parab Off:- R. No. 33, Municipal L.L.B. Senior Division.
Market Complex, Bicholim
41. Shri Mohandas Res:- Anya Prasad, B.A. L.L.B. Bicholim Judicial
Pandurang Plot No. 148, Housing Board Senior Division. Sawaikar Colony, Harvalem,
Sankhalim-Goa. Off.:- Opp. HDFC Bank, Near Municipal Ground, Bicholim-Goa Ph. No.:- 2365274 (R)/2361175 (O) OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
42. Shri Mukund Res:- Kudne, Sanquelim, B.Sc., L.L.M. Bicholim Judicial
Rawalu Malik Bicholim, H. No.16, Senior Division.
Bhailipeth, Bicholim Off: 1st Floor, Carlito Tower Centre, Near K.T.C. Bus stand, Bicholim-Goa
43. Shri Bhavanishankar Res:- Ponda Off:- P-Central B.Sc., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Sukhtankar Mansion, Flat S-1, Ponda
Ph. No. 2312266 (O) 2314163 (R) 9422057356 (M)
44. Shri Ramakant Res:- Margao Salcete-Goa B.A. (Hons.), Judicial Division of Mahadeo Lotlikar Off:- Raikar House, L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Pe Miranda Road, Margao, Goa. Ph. No. 2715672
45. Shri Anant Res:- Ansabhat, Mapusa, B. Com. (Hons), State of Goa.
Bhagwant Sawkar Bardez-Goa L.L.B. Off:-2, 4th Floor, Communidade Ghor, Nr. The 3 Mapusa Urban Bank of Goa (HQ) Mapusa
46. Shri Govind Res:- H. No. 108, Near Police B.Com., L.L.B. South Goa District.
Hegde Desai Station, Quepem.
Off:- Cushban Enclav, F-1 First Floor, Near Bank of India, Quepem, Ph. No. 2662946/2662264 9822129070
47. Shri Babuso Savlo Res:- 850/A/2, Parvati Niwas, B.A.(Hons.) North Goa District.
Gaunker Journalist Colony, L.L.B.
Alto-Betim, Bardez-Goa Off:- Block-I, B-3, Skylark Apts, Menezes Braganza Road, Panaji-Goa
48. Shri Tulsidas Res:- Amrut Smruti, Saipem, B.A.(Hons.) Judicial Division of V. Naik Candolim, Bardez-Goa L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Off:- Phoenix Plaza, A-06, Feira Alta, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa Ph. No. 2255020 (O)
49. Shri Anant C. Res:- Om Sai, Behind KTC B.A.(Hons.) North Goa District.
Pansekar Bus Stand, Amona Road, L.L.B.
Marcela Off:- S-4, 2nd floor, Fatima Chambers, Dr. Atmaram Borkar Road, opp. Hotel Samrat, Panaji-Goa Ph. No. 6642154/2287828
50. Smt. Kishori N. Res & Off:- "Kinara Darshan" B.A., (Hons.) Tiswadi Taluka.
Fugro 27, Lake View Colony, L.L.B.
Miramar, Panaji-Goa. Ph.No.:- 2462603 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
51. Shri Ramkrishna Res:- Nr. Canacona, B.A. (Hon.) Canacona Taluka.
Ramdas Kamat Police Station Canacona L.L.B.
Off:- Manunath Bldg. Shellar, Canacona-Goa Ph.No.:-2643585
52. Shri Mahandev Res:- Urmila Apts. B.Com., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Govind Bandekar St. Mary's Colony Miramar alias Mahesh Off:- Akash Bhavan, Bandekar Gr. Floor, Opp Mathias Plaza,
Panaji-Goa Ph. No. 2422384 (O)/ /2463923 (R)
53. Shri Shivprasad Res:- H. No. E-215, B.Com., L.L.B. State of Goa.
V. Manerkar Fountainhas, Panaji
Off:- 1st Floor, Albuquerque Apts., Near Vaidya Hospital, Panaji-Goa. Ph. No. 2431739/ /2424222/2228030 (O)
54. Smt. Meera M. Res.:- S/2 Lourdes Apts, B.Com., B.Ed., State of Goa.
Medhekar Nr. Hotel Delmon, Panaji L.L.B.
Off:-S/2, 2nd floor, Pinto Chambers, M.G. Road, Panaji-Goa Ph.No :- 2421130/ 9822104365
55. Shri Jertudes Res:- Flat No. 212, M.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Santana Rebello Altesmanai bldg, Caranzalem, Ilhas Off:- Alfran Plaza G-13, M. G. Road, Panaji-Goa Ph. No. 2221451
56. Shri Dilip P. Res:- H. No. A 40, Verem Reis B.Sc.(Hons.). Bardez Taluka.
Dabholkar Magos, Bardez L.L.B
Off:- Opp. Old Sub Registrar's office, Near SBI (Agri Dev. Bank) Feira-Alto, Mapusa-Goa Ph. No.:- 2402245 (R)/2262591(O)
57. Shri Ashok P. Naik Res:- Cuncolim, Post Mardol B.A., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Off:- Ponda 2, Priolkar Bldg, Near Cine Aisha-Goa, 1/3 Roshan Manzil, Near National Cinema. Ph.No. 2316009/2225881 (O), 2395674 (R)
58. Shri Shashikant Res:- Government Quarters, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Narayan Joshi D-11-9, Altinho, Panaji-Goa
Off:- T-13, Jayaram Complex, Rua de Aurem, Neugi Nagar, Panjim Ph. No.:- 2230770 (O)/ 2222612 (F)9822102604 (M) OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
59. Shri Deelip Res:- H. No. 456, Guddem, B.A., L.L.B. Pernem Junior
Yeshwant Govekar Siolim, Bardez-Goa Division.
Off:- Pernem Division Office, Near Bhagwati Temple, Pernem-Goa Ph. No.:-2272511
60. Shri Anthony Res:-H. No. 35, Jacknim, B.A., L.L.B. Bardez, Taluka.
Stephen Santan Parra, Bardez-Goa D'Mello Off:-104, Commerce Centre,
Mapusa, Bardez Ph. No.:2251174/2250219
61. Shri Shrikant Res:-Flat No. 6, 1st floor, B.Com., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Bhikaro Parab Marcela Township Apts.,
Khandola, Marcel-Goa Off:- 47, 1st floor, Ponda commerce centre, Tisk Ponda –Goa. Ph.No:-2287349 /2316553
62. Shri Edwin Res:- "Vivenda" "Monte B.A.,L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Antonio De Furtado" St. Mary's Colony, Monte Furtado Miramar
Off:-12/1, Luis de Menezes Road, Opp. Menezes & Cia, Behind Head Post office,Panaji Ph.No.2221800/2225368 (R) 2422939(O)
63. Shri Mahendra Res:-H. No.78, Pimpolcotta, B.A., L.L.B. Quepem, Sanguem and Salcete Taluka.
Vasudev Gavas Quepem.
Off:-1st floor, Municipal Bldg, Quepem, and C/o. Cuckoos Nest, Dando Sanguem Ph.No. 2662452/2662315(R)
64. Shri Ramkrishna Res:-G-11, Ground floor, B.Com., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
S. Naik Fonseca Arcade, Tisk, Opp.
O/o. of the Mamlatdar, Ponda Goa. Off:-57, 2nd Floor, Ponda Commerce Centre, Ponda Ph.No. 2315045
65. Shri Hanumant Res:-H. No. 143, Yeshodee B.Com., L.L.B. Pernem Taluka.
G. Gawandi Niwas, Gawandiwada,
Parse, Pernem Ph.No.2246215/2291260
66. Shri Prakash Res:-H. No. 381, Tambudki, M.A., L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Corgaonkar Arpora Bardez-Goa.
Off:-Gr. floor, Carvalho's Bldg., Nr. Joao Menezes Pharmacy, Mapusa-Goa
67. Shri Shantaram Res:- Gurudev Mansion, M.Com., L.L.B. Quepem and
Vassudev Curchorem Salcete Taluka. Kudchadkar Off: Kapdi Bldg,
Station Road, Bepkegal, Curchorem-Goa Ph. No. 2650162 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
68. Smt Vidhya Arjun Res:- A/6, Sai Complex, B.A., LLB. State of Goa.
Shet Co-op. Hsg. Sty., Regina
Mundi Road,Chicalim Off:-No. 47, Gr. floor, Apna Bazar, Near Vasco Civil Court, Vasco-Goa Ph.No. 2514130 (o)/ /2540010 (R)
69. Shri Prem Pal Res:-C, Kancho Apts., B.Sc., MA, Salcete Taluka.
Margao LLM, PGDLLR, Off:- Awani Lamp Industries, 4th Floor, Velho Building , Panaji. 2) 2nd floor, D'Costa's Chambers, Opp. Metropole Theatre, Margao-Goa Ph.No.2224694 /2228094/ /2730947/ 9822126579 (M)
70. Shri Rajendra Res:-H. No. 219/A Dattawadi, B.A.,(Hons.), Judicial Jurisdiction
Tukaram Naik Sanvorderm, Curchorem L.L.B. of Sanguem, Quepem
Off:-16/A, Sateri Chambers, and Ponda Taluka. 2nd floor, Sarvodaya High School Road, Curchorem Ph. No. 2605711/9823953046
71. Shri Somnath Res:- Vasanti 443, B.Com., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
V. Patil Uddswaddo, Goa Velha
Off:-205, 2nd floor, wagle vision bldg., 18th June Road, Panaji-Goa Ph. No.:-2221932(O)/2218509 (R)
72. Shri Subhash Res:- Porvorim, Bardez-Goa B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Pundalik Sawant Off:-Velho Bldg., 3rd floor,
Panaji-Goa
Ph. No.:-2444554 (R)/2426115 (O)
73. Shri Nishakant Res:-Karaswada Khorlim, B.A., L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Suryaji Shinde Mapusa
Off:-5, Karekar Bldg.,
Mapusa Clinic Road,
Opp. Laxmi Narayan Temple,
Mapusa-Goa
Ph. No.:-2262973 (O)/
/2255534 (R)
74. Shri Govind Usno Res:-Nerul, Bardez-Goa B.A., L.L.M. Tiswadi Taluka.
Bhobe Off:-2/8, Roshan Manzil,
Near Cine National
Panaji-Goa.
Ph.No. 2401933(R)/
2427944(O) OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
75. Shri Prashant Res:- Shaligram, B.Sc., L.L.M. South Goa District.
Datta Rajadhyax Ghantamord Aquem Baixo,
Navelim Off:-101, 1st floor, Phase II, Damodar Bldg, Near Gomant Vidya Niketan, Margao-Goa. Ph. No.:-2662263 (O) 2765059 (R)
76. Shri Rajiv Mukund Res:-H. No. 44, Borda, B.A.,(Hons.), South Goa
Shinkre Margao-Goa L.L.B. District.
Off:-Behind Municipality, Post Box No. 270, Margao-Goa Ph.No:-2732329 (R)/2732212(O)
77. Shri Shailesh Res:-H. No. 508, Tithawada B.Sc., L.L.B. North Goa District.
Janardhan Nerul, Bardez Kalangutkar Off:-T-7, 3rd floor,
Vrindavan Chambers, Patto, Panaji-Goa
78. Shri Jayant Res:- 135/C, Baga Dovorlim, B.A., (Hons.) Judicial Division Shridhar Prabhu Navelim, Salcete Goa L.L.B. of Salcete Taluka. Shanbhag Off:-2nd Floor, Data Prasad
Bldg., Dioga Costa Road, Near Popular High School, Comba, Margao-Goa Ph.No. 2737045(O)/2714808 (R)
79. Shri Bruno Res:-Machevol, Assagao, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Nazareth alias Bardez-Goa Off:-A-107, Bruno Caetano 1st Floor, Saldanha Business Nazare Towers, St. Xavier's College
Road, Opp. Civil Court, Altinho, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa. Ph No.:- 2253062/2250012
80. Shri Surexa Res & Off:- H. No. 52, B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Pandurang Abade Faria Road, Lotlecar Opp. Damodar temple,
Old market, Margao Ph. No.:- 2702675
81. Shri Sanjay Suryaji Res:- Baga, Curchorem, Goa B.Sc., L.L.B. South Goa District.
Malkarnekar Off:-Sanzgiri Bhavan
Curchorem-Goa Ph. No.:- 26550554
82. Shri Narhari Datta Res & Off:- Flat. No. 302, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Keni IIIrd floor, Laxmi A-2,
Building, Data Giri Co-op. Hsg. Society, Varde Valaulikar Road, Margao, Salcete-Goa
83. Shri Nanda Alias Res:- "Asro", F-2 Asro Co-op. B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Nandkumar R. Hsg Society Ltd, Bale Near BPS club, Margao
Off:-T-5, 3rd Floor, Chandan Bldg, Erasmo Carvalho Street, Margao OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
84. Shri Durgaram Res:-AF/17, Kamat Arcade, L.L.B. North Goa District.
Shankar Naik St. Inez, Panaji
Off:- 1st Floor, Vijaya Apts, Above Satkar Hotel, 18th June Road, Panaji
85. Shri Dene Noe Res:- 249/A, Soareswaddo, B.Com., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Rosario Maina Siolim, Bardez-Goa
Off:-1st Floor, Milan Apartments, Behind Hotel Shiv Sagar, Panaji.Ph.No.:-2270109 (R) 2425030 (O) 9822153322 (M)
86. Shri Damodar Res:-E-161, "Laxmi", Agni B.Com., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Premanand Opp sangam lodge, Mala,
Panaji-Goa Off:-Near Pharmacy E Menezes, Joao de crasto Road, Panaji-Goa Ph.No:-2227980 (R), 2232601 (O) 9822147799 (M)
87. Smt Deepa Arun Res;-F-4, Gaurish Apartments, B.A. (Hons.), Ponda Taluka.
Sinai Singbal Khadpaband, Ponda-Goa L.L.B.
Off:-Near Pharmacy E Menezes, Joao de castro Road, Panaji Ph. No.:-2227980 (R) 2232601 (O) 9822147799 (M)
88. Shri Anand Res:- "Anand" Bldg., B.Com., South Goa
Mohan Redkar Dr. Antonio Colaco Road, L.L.M. District.
Margao Off:-S-4, Kurtarkar Manor, Near Santosh Garage, Aquem, Margao
89. Shri Madhav Res:- "INDU", Bunglow No. 6, M.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Shankar Bel Air Condo, Byepass Road, Bandodkar Gogol, Margao-Goa
Off:-G-26, Ground floor, Phoenix estate, Byepass Road, Gogol, Margao-Goa Ph. No.:-2759684
90. Mrs. Kamala Nair Res:-D-9-C Govt. Flats, B.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
alias Mavila St. Inez, Panaji-Goa Kamala Kutty Off:-A-4, Shop No. 17,
3rd Floor, Navelkar Trade Centre, M.G. Road, Panaji-Goa Ph.No:-2229021 (R), 2426332 (O)
91. Shri Gluck Res:-Opp. Airport Plaza, B.Sc.(Hons.), Mormugao Taluka.
Nanny D'Souza Dabolim, Goa. L.L.B.
Off:-Room No. 105, Hotel Ricone, Vasco-da-Gama, Mormugao-Goa Ph. No. 2555742 (R), 2511723 (O) OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
92. Shri Ulhas Res:-Flat. No. 303, Khalap BA., L.L.B. Mormugao Taluka.
Venkatesh mansion, Vasco-da-Gama, Shirodkar Goa.
Off:-1st Floor, Santa Pelagia Bldg. Opp. Khalap Mansion, Vasco-Da-Gama. Ph.No. 9890838969
93. Miss Kunda Res:-4th floor, Midaas Touch, B.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Ramchandra Naik Opp. Eldorado Plaza, Rua Ganthe Heliodoro, Salgado Municipal Market, Panaji-Goa Off:-Hotel Ashok Plaza –Z square, Samrat Ashok Theatre Complex , 18th June Road, Panaji-Goa
94. Shri Madhu Res:- Shapora Dabolwaddo, B.Com., L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Ramesh Redkar Bardez
Off:-Off. No. 3 First Floor, Souza Sanctuary Building, Near Mapusa Municipal Council, Feira Baixa, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa Ph. No.:-2273815/9763819276
95. Shri Rajendra Res:-Kurtarkar Modern B.A.(Hons.), Salcete Taluka.
Ganoba Raut Homes, Co-op. Hsg. L.L.B. Dessai Society Ltd., Flat No. F-1,
Bldg. No. A-2, Rawanfond, Aquem, Baixo, Navelim, Salcete Off:- Same as above Ph. No.:- 2765969
96. Smt. Ranjana C. Res:-Doz , Phoenix, Plaza, B.Com., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Salgaonkar Feira Alto, Mapusa,
Bardez-Goa Off:-BO4, Phoenix Plaza, Feira Alto, Mapusa Bardez-Goa Ph.No.2263066 (R), 2251354 (O)
97. Shri Jose Fulvio Res:-Opp. Mother care B.Com., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Da Piedade Colaco Hospital, Borda, Margao
Off.:-Office No. 8, 2nd floor, Midaas Touch Building, Opp. District & Session Court, Margao-Goa Ph. No.:- 2733410
98. Shri Krishnanath Res.:-Flat No. C-4, B.Com., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Ladu Gaonkar 3rd Floor, Shivam Apts.,
Upper Bazar, Ponda Off.:-S-O-7, Ponda Commerce Centre, Ponda Ph. No.:-2314705 (R) 2317980 (O) OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
99. Shri Kishore Res:-H. No. 617, B.A.,L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Laxman Bhagat Samarth Niwas,
Ganesh Nagar, Khandola-Marcela, Ponda-Goa Off:-3rd Floor, Shabana Chambers, Municipal Market, H.Salgado Road, Panaji Ph.No.2288013,9881313831
100. Shri Joaquim Res.:-S-2, 2nd floor, B. Com., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Godinho Ivory Towers, St. Marys
Colony Rd, Miramar, Panaji Off.:-Navelkar Trade Centre, C/S-3, IInd floor, M.G. Road, Opp. Azad Maidan, Panaji
101. Shri Vinayak Res:-Bazarwada, Marcela M.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Krishna Narvekar Off:-1st floor, Mosquitos
House, Near Vistar Hotel, Panaji-Goa Ph. No.:-2287780 (R), 2431297 (O)
102. Smt. Tolentina Res.:-H. No. 377/A, Banda, B.Sc., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Xavier Telaulim, Salcete-Goa
Off:-OS2, Maria Luiza Plaza, Comba, Margao-Goa
103. Mrs. Sawli Sainath Res:-Flat No. 2, 2nd Floor, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Arolkar Andrade Bldg,
Behind Bicholim Municipal Council , Bicholim, Goa Off.:- No. 5, Laxmi Parvati Arcade, Near Bicholim Municipal Council, Bicholim Ph.No. 9860026790
104. Shri Sanjay M. Res.:-H. No. 427, B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Chodankar Battywaddo, Tamdeg, Carmona, Salcete-Goa Off:-203, 2nd floor, Damodar, Phase II, Near Gomant Vidhya Niketan, Margao, Salcete-Goa Ph. No.: 2744852 (R) 2702631 (O) /9890792631
105. Shri Uday D. Res: Dongorwada, Dessai B.Com., (Hons.), State of Goa.
Chodankar Residential and commercial L.L.B
Complex, Fatorda, Margao-Goa Off:-2nd floor, Apna Bazar Building, Margao Ph No.:-2742282 (R), 2737458 (O) OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
106. Shri Narayan P. Res:- H. No. 124,Vithalapur B.Com., L.L.B. Bicholim Taluka.
Sawant Sankhli-Goa.
Off:-Office No. 5, 1st floor,
Vassudeva Arcade,
Near Chatrapati Shivaji
Maidan, Bicholim
Ph. No.: 2364698
107. Shri Joao Emerico Res:-Lacksha Jyot Complex, M.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Maria Agnelo Mundvel, Vasco-da-Gama
Pereira Off.:-S-6, 2nd floor, Patto,
Centre, Near KTC bus stand,
Panaji-Goa
Ph.No:-2438225
9822964394
108. Smt. Kala Res & Off:-H. No. 386, B.Sc., L.L.B. Sattari Taluka.
Premanad Dalal Near Post Valpoi,
Sattari-Goa
Ph. No.:-2374175/2374219
9423810665
109. Smt. Maria Ruth Res & Off:- H.No.176, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
De Noronha Near Holy Spirit Church,
Margao.
Ph.No.:-2711781
110. Shri Dipak Gurudas Res:-Tonca, St. Estevam B.Com., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Shet Ilhas-Goa.
Off:-C/o. Deep Stationers,
Magnum Centre, Panaji-Goa. Ph. No.:-2287921 (R) 5641028 (O)
111. Shri Pranay Kamat Res:-Flat No.2, Joemac B.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Building Pundalik Nagar, Porvorim-Goa
Off.:-AF-2, Casa Immaculada Bldg., Near Church & Progress High School, Panaji-Goa Ph.No:-5612124 9422386975
112. Shri Somdas Res:-G-102, Goa Housing B.Com., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Krishna Manjrekar Board Colony, Gogol,
Margao-Goa Off.:-C/o Adv. M.S. Bandodkar, G-26, Gr. floor, Pheonix Estate, Bypass road, Gogol, Margao-Goa Ph.No.:-2750787 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
113. Shri Govind Res:-B-6/212, Guarden B.Sc., L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Tukaram Centre I, Opp. Police Station, Dhavjekar Mapusa, Bardez-Goa
Off.:-203, Commerce Centre, Near Municipality, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa Ph. No.:-2262565/9420818400
114. Shri Vilas Res:-C-2, Rohini B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Anant Naik Apartments, Old Market,
Margao-Goa Off:-F-5, 1st floor, Kurtarkar Shopping centre, Near Hari Mandir, Margao-Goa Ph. No.:-2733640 (R) 2733171 (O) 9822108929
115. Shri Nagesh C. Res & Off:-302, Louiss Olive B.A., L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Gaonkar Apts, Near Civil & Criminal
Courts, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa Ph.No.: 2251498
116. Shri Ravindra F. Res.:- H. No. 222, B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Ayir Near Damodar English High
School & Higher Secondary School, Gudi Paroda, Quepem Goa Off: B-19 Wing, Ground Floor, Osia Commercial Arcade, Opp. SGPDA Market Complex, Margao, Salcete-Goa Ph. No.:-2710844(O) 2860634 (R)
117. Shri Dominick H.No.994/1, Ambirna Socorro, B.Com., B.Ed., Bardez Taluka.
Benedict Nazareth Bardez-Goa L.L.B. alias Benedict Off:-o-5, 4th floor, Dominic Nazare Communidade Ghor,
Angod, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa Ph. No.:-2262615 /2415071 9822151691
118. Smt. Sangeeta G. Res:-Ganesh Smtuti Bldg. B.A., L.L.B. Bardez Taluka
Deshprabhu Below Tar Dental Clinic, Feira, Alta Mapusa Goa Off:- same as above Ph.No:-9403176239
119. Shri Rajendra S. Res:-Flat No. BF-5,1st floor, B.A., L.L.B Salcete Taluka.
Prabhudessai (Block-B-2) C.D. Patanga, Co-op. Hsg. Society Ltd., N.D.Naik Road, Aquem, Alto, Margao-Goa Off:-222, 2nd floor, Ashish Co-op. Hsg Society Ltd., Aashirwaad Bldg, Opp. Isidore Baptista Road, Margao-Goa Ph.No.:-2736259 /2752820 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6 120. Shri Sanjay Anand Res:-H. No.13 Rua de B.Com., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Shirodkar Saudade, Pajifond,
Margao, Salcete-Goa Off.:-S-19" A bldg, 2nd Floor, Apna Bazar V.V. Road, Margao, Salcete-Goa Ph.No.:-2713755/ 2750853
121. Shri Rama Laxman Res:- H. No. 241, Cudnem, B.A., L.L.B. Bicholim Taluka.
Mapari Sanquelim-Goa 403505
Off.:- F-4, Vassudeva Arcade,
Opp. Chatrapati Shivaji Maidan, Bicholim
122. Shri Satishkumar Res.:- "Datta Laxmi Niwas" B.Com., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Shamba Shenvi I.D. Hospital Road, Ponda Pilgaonkar Off.:-410/411, 4th floor,
Rajdeep Galleria,
Above Axis Bank, Sadar, Ponda-Goa Ph. No.:-2314434(O) 2313949 (R) /9822155647 (M)
123. Shri Nandkumar Res.: Saikunj, B.Com., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
N. Naik Behind Almeida High School,
Khadpabandh, Ponda-Goa Off.:-F-G, 1st floor, Paihouse,
Ponda-Goa Ph. No.:-2318073 (R)
124. Shri Prashant N. Res:- C-11, B.Com., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Kamat Padmanarayan Estate,
Near Mutt, Gogol, Margao-Goa
Off.:- Kamat Commercial centre,
2nd floor, Station Road,
Margao-Goa
Ph. No.:-2759247 (R)/
2737025(O)/9822128774 (M)
125. Shri Manohar Res.:-H. No. W/9/13/12, B.A., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Chandru Adpaikar Khadpabandh, Ponda-Goa
Off:-f-6, 1st floor, Baba
Associate Bldg.,
Opp. O/o. Mamlatdar of Ponda,
Tisk, Ponda-Goa
Ph. No.:-9822167033/ 2314515
126. Shri Ramkrishna Res: H.No.111, Old Bazar, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Govind Bale Margao, Salcete-Goa
Off:-S-4, 2nd Floor, Bldg. D,
Behind Collectorate Bldg.,
Margao, Salcete-Goa
Ph. No.:-2736860/ 2736862 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
127. Shri Jaiprakash Res.:-407/1, F/1, B.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Venkatesh Naik Vijaya apartments,
Opp. Chodankar Nursing Home, Pilerne, Alto-Porvorim, Goa Off.:-167/1, Ground floor, 31st Jan Road, Opp. Hotel Vinite, Panaji-Goa Ph. No. :- 2235470/9923623818
128. Shri Harishchandra Res.:- 2020/1, Sashtiwada, B.A.,(Hons) Bicholim Taluka.
Ladu Naik Bordem, Bicholim L.L.B.
Off:- E-1 & 2, 1st flr, Vassudev Arcade, Bicholim -Goa Ph. No. 2362604/6530414 9226421718
129. Shri Rajkumar Res.:-H. No. 85, J.N.C. B.Com., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Nagba Naik Viernagar Co-op. Hsg. Society,
Chicolna, Bogmalo, Vasco Off:-Shop No.54, 2nd floor, Apna Bazar Bldg., Next to Civil & Criminal Court, Vasco-da-Gama Ph. No.:-9423819813 9890547717
130. Shri Surajkumar Res.:-H. No. 85, J.N.C. B.Com., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Nagba Naik Vieranagar Co-op. Hsg.
Society, Chicolna Bogmalo Off.:-Shop No. 54, 2nd floor, Apna Bazar Bldg, Next to Civil & Criminal Court, Vasco-da-Gama, Goa Ph. No.:-9423310194 9960366967
131. Mrs. Harsha Rajiv Res.:-H. No. A/53, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Naik Ambekhand, Verem, Bardez Off:-H. No. 252, Cardozwado, Taleigao-Goa Ph. No.:-9225902610/2421225
132. Shri Janardhan Res:-H. No.:-101,Vancio B.Com., L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Shivram Parshekar Waddo,Guirim, Bardez-Goa
Off.:-5, La Brag Chambers, Above Mapusa Clinic, Mapusa Ph. No.:-9637290191/2254476
133. Shri Ramakant B. Res.:-H. No.103/3, "SUKRUT" M.Sc., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Vernekar Grande Vanelim, Colva, (28/02/1939) Salcete-Goa
Off.:-F/5, Champa Vihar, Near Popular High School, Comba, Margao-Goa OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
134. Shri Ghanashyam Off:-A/1,F-12, 1st floor, B.Com., BDPS., Tiswadi Taluka.
Vasant Poi Lotlikar Jairam Kurtarkar Complex, L.L.B.
Neugi Nagar, Panaji-Goa Ph. No.:-9371558383
135. Shri Marshall Res.:-H.No. 38, Dando, B.A., L.L.B. South Goa District.
Fernandes Sanguem
Off.:-Cockoos Nest, Dando Sanguem. Ph. No. :-9623910233 / 9823693474
136. Miss Sushma L. Res:-3, Salkar Colony, B.A., LLB. Mormugao Taluka
Chodankar Vaddem , Vasco-da-Gama
Off.:-4, Our lady of Coguila Bldg Above Commercial Tax Office, 3rd floor, F. L. Gama Road, Vasco-da-Gama Ph. No.:-9822143440
137. Shri Ravindra Res:-H. No. 13/3,33/3, B.Sc., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Purushottam flat B/4,1st floor, Navketan, Pednekar Hsg. Colony, St. Inez,
Panaji-Goa Off.:- Rani Pramila Arcade, 2nd floor, SF-3, 18th June Road, Panaji-Goa Ph.No.:9404144073/2432993
138. Shri Sachin Res.:-A-2/4, Sapna Spendor, B.Com., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Sadashiv Near Costa Hospital , Kolwalkar Fatorda-Goa
Off.:-T-3 Laxmi Plaza, 3rd floor, Behind Grace Church, Varde Valaulikar Road, Margao-Goa Ph. No.:-9422642729/ /2710628
139. Shri Suresh Res.:- "Kaveri" Alto, Aquem, B.Sc., M.B.A, Mormugao
Subba Rao Aithal Post Box No. 66, South Goa L.L.B. and Salcete
District, Margao-Goa Taluka. Off. :-No 7, 1st floor, Chase chambers, P.B.147, South Goa District, Vasco-da-Gama
140. Shri Vinod Res:-H. No. 114/B, M.A. D.A.M, Salcete Taluka.
Pundalik Suprabhat, Ward No.V, L.L.M. Halarnkar Zariwado, Dovorlim,
Salcete-Goa Off.:- Off No.:-113 & 114, 1st floor, Gracias Plaza, Behind Loyola High School, Margao, Salcete-Goa OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
141. Shri Virendrakumar Res.:-H. No.:-1386/1, B.Com., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Pandurang Dessai Rangallim-Betul, Velim,
Salcete-Goa Off:-T-9, 3rd floor, Fatima Chambers, Near ICICI Bank, Margao-Goa Ph. No.:-9822183176
142. Shri Sunil Shankar Res.:-Mercury Chambers, B.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Naik Flat No.-G-2, Ground Floor,
Fondvem wadda, Raibandar-Goa Off.:-SF-4, 2nd floor, Padmavati Towers, 18th June Road, Panaji-Goa Ph.No.:-9850456465
143. Shri Shahsikant Res:- "Vipul", B.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
V. Nabar H.No.:-2/104/C, Cotula,
Goletim, Saligao, Bardez Off.:-Milan Apts.,1st flr, Bh. Hotel Shiv Sagar, Panaji-Goa Ph. No.:-9823219757
2278185/2425030
144. Shri Kashinath Res.:- "Shivneri" H. No. 381, B.A., L.L.B. Sattari Taluka.
Shiva Mhalshekar Mhalshewada, Parye,
Sattari-Goa Off.:-Apa Commercial Complex, Block No.-5, Valpoi Sattari Ph. No.:-9763131392/2374939
145. Shri Sayed Abbas Res.:-304, Zarina Towers, B.A., (Hons.) Tiswadi Taluka.
L.L.B.
Magnum Plaza, Nr. Ganpati Temple, St. Inez, Panaji-Goa Off.:-Edcon Towers, Opp. Skylark Apts, Near Dena Bank, Panaji-Goa.
146. Smt. Rupa Babi Res:-H. No. 277, B.A., L.L.B. Pernem and
Kotkar alias Rupa Kikotkarwada, Pernem-Goa Tiswadi Taluka. Amit Kumar Off:-Ground Floor, Dublay Mary Blessings Building,
Near Civil & Criminal Court, Pernem-Goa Ph. No.:-9422056634/2201466
147. Shri Menino Res.:-H. No. 121, Bhamai, B.Com., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Piedade Gomes Pali-Goa
Off.:-Ponda Commerce Centre Ponda-Goa Ph.No.:-6573018 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
148. Shri Vishwanath Res.: H. No. 1502/33, B.A, LLB. Bardez and
B. Thali "Samarth Datta" Pernem Taluka.
Model Hsg. Board Colony, Madel Tivim, Bardez-Goa Off.:-St. Peter building, Opp. Old Mapusa Clinic, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa Ph. No.: 651079
149. Smt. Maria Agnela Res.: Villa De- Iberetade- B.Sc., LLB. State of Goa.
Honorina Araujo -Neura, Grande, Ilhas, Goa
Off.:-H. No.:-805-A, Post St. Lawrence Malwara, Agassaim, Pilar-Goa Ph. No.:-2208412/3260093
150. Shri Krishna Res:-H.No. 923/155, B.Com., L.L.B. North Goa District.
Nayrayan Naik Opp. Morais S.T.D.,
Near Village Panchayat of Socorro, Porvorim, Bardez -Goa Off.:-Opp. Civil Court of Pernem, Mausawada, Pernem Ph.No.:- 2901604 9422451267/9421250386
151. Shri Joao Vincent Res.:-H.No. 229, Copelabhat, B.A., L.L.B. Quepem Taluka.
Fernandes Reao, Quepem-Goa
Off.:Shop No. 104, 1st floor, Zeferino Commercial Complex, Ph.No:9822169547/ 2663837
152. Smt. Ujjwala Girish Res:-H.No. 81, Aras Blg, B.A, LLB. Tiswadi Taluka
Aras Nr. Mahalaxmi Temple,
Panaji-Goa Off.:-Ghanekar Bldg Nr. Old Secretariat, Jose Falcao Road, Panaji Ph. No.:-2224019/ 2225363
153. Smt. Lucia Fatima Res & Off.:-H.No. 201/2, B.A, L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Fernandes Mollar, Corlim, Ilhas-Goa
Ph.No.:-2285765
154. Miss Geeta Res: Near Swami, B.A, L.L.B. State of Goa.
Manohar Payaji Samarth Temple, Siolim,
Bardez-Goa Off:- same as above Ph.No.:9823129536
155. Smt. Sandra Vaz e Res & Off:-55-, B.A, L.L.B. Mormugao Taluka.
Corriea Newton Apts, II, Mangor Hill,
Vasco-Da-Gama, Goa Ph.No.:-9422063637/2531111
156. Shri Sanjay A. Res :AT/1, B.Com., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Gaonkar Annapurna apartment,
Opposite Gomantak Press, St.Inez Panaji-Goa Off:-1st Floor, Vikas Bldg , Nr Pharmacy College, St. Inez Panaji-Goa Ph.No. 2223243/2424279 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
157. Miss Shilpa Bhikaji Res. & Off.:-H. No. 852/1, B.A, L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Salgaonkar Journalist Colony,
Alto-Porvorim, Bardez-Goa Ph. No.:- 2412984/ 9423311843
158. Smt. Sandra Res.:-Noronha Heritage Apts, B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Fernandes e Dongorwaddo, Fatorda, Goa D'Souza Ph.No.:- 2743455/ 9823951401
159. Smt. Ruby Res:-Mascarenhas wado, B.Sc. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Venkatesh Goa Velha, Tiswadi Goa Shirodkar alias Off:-H.No. 528, Pradnya G. Borkar Mascarenhas vaddo,
Goa Velha Ph. No.:- 2218147/9823882032
160. Smt. Deepti D. Res.: H. No. 714/6 B.Com, LLB Bardez Taluka.
Kandolkar Near R. N. D. Workshop,
Betim, Bardez-Goa Off.:-Shabana chambers, T-3, 3rd Floor, Panaji Municipal Market, Panaji Goa
161. Smt. Swati Kamat Res:-A-3 Akbarali Karmali B.Com., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Wagh Bldg., Next to CBI,
Altinho, Panaji-Goa Off.:- 305, 3rd floor, Central Towers, Near Sai Baba Temple, Boca-de-Vaca, Panjim Goa Ph. No.:- 9822387442/6510228
162. Shri Iftikhar Aga Res.:-4-S-2, Rosary Apts., B.Com L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Miramar, Panaji-Goa Off.:-1) G-3 "Anandi" Adwalpalkar Apts, Lyceum Road, Nr. High Court of Bombay at Goa, Altinho, Panaji-Goa 2) 1st flr., Mhamai Kamat bldg., Old Secretariat, Panaji Ph. No.:-9422450228
163. Smt. Aruna K. Res:-H. No. 290, Mhalpe, B.A., L.L.B. Pernem Taluka.
Shahapurkar @ Vinorda, Pernem-Goa Rutuja Chetan Off.:- Near Mahadev Temple, Kubal Pernem-Goa
Ph. No.:-9422386965
164. Shri Mark Anthony Res:-Menezes Home, B.Com., LLB. Salcete Taluka.
Menezes 1st floor, Opp. Tarsanzor,
Near Babu Naik House, Vidyanagar, Aquem, Margao-Goa 2)Pelican Building, 2nd floor, No1.opp.Lohiaq Maidan, Margao Ph.No.:- 9323863717 2724654/6555290 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
165. Shri Sandesh G. Res.:-H. No. M-46, B.A, L.L.B. State of Goa.
Shigaonkar Housing Board colony,
Gogol, Margao-Goa Off.:same as above Ph.No.:-9422640567/571554
166. Smt. Asha P. Rane Res:G-10-A, Ground floor, B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
alias Ashwita A. Ditoza Residency, Dessai Behind SBI Bank,
Cuncolim Salcete-Goa Off:-T-7, 2nd floor, Laxmi Plaza Bldg., Behind Grace Church, Margao Ph. No.:9763133778/2763650
167. Smt. Cristina Res.:-Angel Violla, B.Com, L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Candelina Dias Opp. Glorio Bar,
South Stand Stadium Road, Fatorda, Margao Off.:- B-III, B wing, Osia Commercial Arcade, S.G.P.D.A. Market Complex Margao Ph.No.:- 6694198/9823387394
168. Shri Noel Res.:-H. No.:E 60, B.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Domingos Dias Segundo Bairro, Santa Cruz, Sapeco P. O. Tiswadi-Goa
Off.:-Above Ajanta Hotel, Opp. New Patto Bridge, Old Bus Stand, Panaji-Goa Ph.No.:-2449817
169. Shri Ajay G. Res:-H.No.72-D, Culvaddo, B.Com., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Naik alias Ajay Cuncolim Salcete-Goa G.N. Dessai Off:- T-7, 2nd floor, Laxmi Plaza Bldg, Behind Grace Church, Margao Ph.No:- 2763650/9850477425
170. Smt. Ujwala Res :- Flat No. F-7 B.A.,LLB. Tiswadi Taluka.
Tukaram Ribandar Residency, Kouthankar Co-operative Housing
Society Ltd. Near Divar Ferry, Sao Pedro Ribandar-Goa Off:-Villa Olievant Marchom Bldg, 2nd floor, Near Geeta Bakery, Panaji-Goa Ph.No:-9850651403
171. Shri Suryakant Res:- Flat. No.202, B.A, L.L.B. Bicholim Taluka.
Murali Naik 2nd phase, Sankalp Garden,
Bicholim-Goa Off:-1st Floor, Tari Building, Bandar wada, Bicholim. Ph.No. 9226316179/6530228 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
172. Smt. Roshan Res:-H.No.:-79, Vodlem Bhat, B.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Suresh Palkar Bambolim,Tiswadi-Goa.
Off.:-2nd floor, Gurudatt Bldg., Dr. Dada Vaidya Road, Panaji-Goa Ph. No.:- 2458033/9923379470
173. Shri Silvano Res.:-H.No. 341/2, B.A, L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Estibeiro Copremorddi, Assolda,
P. O. Chandor Salcete-Goa Off:-S-17, 2nd floor, Casa Dos Alidos Bldg., Abade Faria Road, Behind Gomant Vidya Niketan, Margao-Goa Ph.No:- 2784065/9822175639
174. Shri Godfrey Res.:-Silva Norton Building, B.Sc. LLB. State of Goa.
Norton Station Road, Margao-Goa
Off.:- same as above Ph.No.:- 2736892/9422058660
175. Shri Damodar M. Res :-H. No. B/329, Shantai, B.Sc., (Hons), Tiswadi Taluka.
Dhond Plot No. 40, L.L.B.
Near Vista Do Rio Resort, Volant, Alto-Porvorim Off.:-SF 586, Sukerkar Mansion, Opp. Government Printing Press, M.G. Road, Panaji-Goa Ph.No.:- 2901008/2232068/ /2422364/9823034081
176. Ms. Savita Res.&Off.: H. No. 315, B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Guiridhar Comba, Margao Kurtarkar Ph. No.:- 2714045
177. Smt. Rajashri Patil Res:-C-@-A, PHE complex, B.A., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
(PWD), Daag, Ponda-Goa, Off.:-S-10, IInd floor, Coelho Apartments, Sadar, Ponda-Goa Ph.No.:-9404911539/ /9371176696/9404959895
178. Shri Udaynath Res:-H.No. 87, Near Railway B.A., L.L.B. & South Goa
Raghuvir Bicholkar Station, Thorlemol, Kalay, Diploma in District.
Sanguem-Goa Computer Off.:- Cusmane Apartments, Programming 1st floor, Quepem-Goa in Personal
Management
179. Ms. Kavita Res. & Off.:-H. No. 83A, B.Com., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Purushottam Ward No. 6, Altinho Karekar Panaji-Goa
Ph. No.:9923196904/ /2262943 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
180. Shri Arthur Res:-Flat No. 1, 1st floor, B.Com., L.L.B. Mormugao and Menino Raghunath Apts., Salcete Taluka. Fernandes Francisco Luis Gomes Rd,
Vasco-Da-Gama, Goa. Off:-17, 1st flr, Apana Bazar, Vasco Da Gama, Goa. Ph.No:-2511462/ 2517140 / 9822140434
181. Shri Krupesh Res.:-H.No. 1995, Tisco Valley, B.Com., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Narhari Patil Opp.M.R.F. Factory,
Tisca,Usgaon, Ponda-Goa Off.:-2nd floor, Netalkar Complex, Above Bank of India, Ponda Goa Ph. No.:-9422439471
182. Ms. Nishigandha Res:-C-101, Dhanlaxmi BSc. L.L.B., Tiswadi Taluka.
N. Shet Nagar, Bhatlem, Panaji-Goa. L.L.M.
Off:-B-4, Dhanlaxmi Nagar, Bhatlem Panaji-Goa Ph. No :- 2230713/ /99231449856/6512006
183. Mr. Mohammed Res. & Off.:- "REHMAT" B.Com., L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Ibrahim H. No. 2/J/3, near Dayanand
Narvekar's Residence, Karaswada, Mapusa-Goa. Ph. No.:- 2255003/ 9822157300
184. Mrs. Sharmila Res.:-H.No. 178/135, B.Sc, L.L.B. Sattari Taluka.
T. Patil alias Behind Indian Oil Petrol
Paryekar Pump, Honda Post,
Pratap Nagar, Sattari-Goa.
Off.:- 178/137/C,
Near Indian Oil Petrol Pump,
Honda Post, Pratap Nagar,
Taluka Sattari Goa.
Ph. No.:-9823880946
185. Smt. Nilima Res.:- H. No. 401, Kolmamol, B.A., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Dipu Gaude Bori, Ponda (Temp) H. No.149,
Shirshire, Bori, Ponda, Goa.
Off:-A-105, 1st floor,
Block –A heritage princess
Ponda Goa
Ph.No.:-9822382952
186. Shri Pratapsingh Res:-H.No.1876, B.A., L.L.B Bicholim Taluka.
Mohanrao Desai Nagar, Sanquelim
Nimbalkar Taluka, Bicholim,Goa-403505
Off:-73, Gokulwadi, Sanquelim Taluka, Bicholim. Ph.No.:9822382952 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
187. Ms. Anita Nitant Res:-H.No. 269, Purshottam B.A., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Khandeparkar Niwas Kadsal, Khandepar, nee Anita Ponda Taluka-Goa Surendra Borkar Off:- Shop No. 2,
Ground floor, "Taarangan" Next to Civil & Criminal Court, Tisk, Ponda-Goa Ph. No.:-2344883/ 9422439883
188. Ms. Zenia Hermina Res:-H. No. 66-B , Ratvaddo, B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Fernandes-e Vas Navelim, Salcete-Goa
Off.:-A-321, 3rd floor, Reliance Trade Centre, Opp. Grace Nursing Home, Margao, Salcete-Goa Ph.No.:- 2758500/ 9923657937
189. Mr. Prakash Rsw:-H. No.:-114/A, Dhadio, B.A., L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Manuel Caeiro Talaulim, Navelim, 24-04-1964 Salcete-Goa
Off.:-No. EF-8 1st floor, Pancharatna Co-op. Hsg. Society, Margao Off:-No.104, 1st floor, Niana Gracias Plaza, Near Fatima Convent, Margao, Salcete-Goa Ph. No.:-2757744
190. Ms. Akshata M. Res:-H. No. 43, W. No. 10, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Redkar Shanti Nagar, Khorlim, 24-12-1978 Mapusa, Bardez-Goa
Off.:-Opp. Old S. T. Stand, Behind Maruti Mandir, Mapusa Ph. No.:94221248133
191. Ms. Lalana Bhaskar Res.:H.No. 187/1A, B.Com., L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Shirodkar Ruzaiwaddo Duler,
Mapusa, Bardez-Goa Off.:- No. 108, Block E, First Floor, Saldanha Business Tower, Nr. Mapusa Court, Mapusa Ph. No.:- 9823882976
192. Ms. Deepti Dilip Res.:-H. No. 85, B.Com., L.L.B. Pernem Taluka.
Sanvordekar alias Sampada Niwas, Keri, Surekha S. Kerkar Pawanwada, Pernem 06-11-1978 Goa 403524
Off:-Next to Sanjivani Patho lab, Arambol, Pernem-Goa Ph. No.:- 2249323/9921878020
193. Ms. Tejaswini Res.:- Sonum Township, LLM. Salcete Taluka.
Shirodkar Flat No.1, 1st floor, Atlantic
Mill, Sao Jose de Areal, Nessai, Salcete-Goa Off.:-same as above Ph. No.:-9822175138 8805020813 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
194. Ms. Pradnya Res: "Shivam" H. No. 644/4, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Pradeep alias Madhyegal, Kakoda, Purushottam Curchorem, Quepem-Goa Bhobe alias Off:-8, "Shriniwas", Pradnya Ajinkya Kapdi Building, next to SBI, Salelkar Curchorem, Quepem-Goa
Ph.No:-2651142/9822124845
195. Shri Bhikaji Res.:-H. No. 271., Near P.W.D. B.A., L.L.B. Sattari Taluka.
Atmaram Gawas Colony Keri,
Sattari-Goa 403505 Off:- C/o., Dr. G. R. Sharma, Advocate, High Court, 210, 2nd floor, Nizari Bhavan, Panaji-Goa New office:-Shop No. 2 Mahadev Kanekar, Building Near valpoi police station, Valpoi, Sattari-Goa Ph.No.:-2369283/ 2225555/ /9420159453
196. Smt. Abhilasha Res.:-H. No.:-565/A, B.A, L.L.B. South Goa District.
Manguesh Dessai Karashirmoll, Agonda, Canacona-Goa 403702 Off.:-2/154/1, F-1, Savitri Apartment, Chaudi, Canacona Ph. No.:-2647367/ 2647208/ /9421152151
197. Shri Prashant Res.:-H.No.799, Mhalwada, B.Com., L.L.B. Canacona Taluka.
Vishranti Painguinim, Canacona-Goa Painginkar Off:-No.-14,1st floor, Anandi
Apts, Chaudi, Canacona-Goa. Ph.No:-2641220/ 9423813570/ /9673846357
198. Smt. Anjali Anand Res. & Off.:-H. No.:-149, B.A., L.L.B. Canacona
Faldessai alias Nagorcem, Canacona 6 months Taluka. Kavyanjali Kishor Goa-403702 computer Naik Gaunkar
diploma
199. Ms. Donella Do Res.:-UG-2, Sahyadri B.Com., L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Rozario Enclave, Durgabhat,
Ponda, Goa-403401
Off:-3, Varadh Apartments, Nr.Corporation Bank, Shantinagar, Ponda-Goa. Ph.No:-9422388233
200. Smt. Prachi Bhate Res. & Off.:-H.No. 1358, B.Sc., L.L.M. Bardez Taluka.
alias Prachi Vad Housing Board Colony ,
Alto-Porvorim, Bardez-Goa Ph. No.:-2417637/ 9822689296 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3 4 5 6
201. Shri Vinoj K. Res.:-A/17/1, B. Com., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Daniel Goa University, Campus, L.L.M.
Taligao Plateu-Goa Off.:-1) S-I,block-B, 2nd floor, Colaco Bldg, Opp. Vibes, Comba-Margao 2) C/o.-CA. Ahmed, Sindhu Bldg, 1st flr, Behind ICICI Bank, A.B. Road, Panjim Ph.No.:- 9422446363
202. Ms. Elsa Santana Res:-H. No. 659, Bamanbhat, B.A., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Fernandes Cujira, St.Cruz, Ilhas-Goa
Off.:-Adcon Apts, 2nd floor, Near Hotel Fidalgo, Panaji-Goa Ph. No.:-9422642199
203. Smt. Raksha Res.:- Marwa Co-operative B.Sc. LLB. Ponda Taluka.
Hemant Phadte Housing Society,
F-3,1st floor, Dhawali, Ponda Goa. Off.:- 36, 2nd floor, Ponda Commerce Centre, Ponda Goa. Ph. No.:- 7798677342
204. Smt. Reshma Res.:- Flat No.G-1, B.Com, LLB. Tiswadi Taluka.
Kanchan Karishma Apts, Gaulebhat, Karapurkar Chimbel.
Off.:- C/o. Adv. Manoj. H. Govekar, T-1-13, 3rd flr, Sattaadhar Chambers, Opp. PWD, Govt. Quarters, Nr. Ruchi Hotel, Patto Panaji. Ph. No.:- 9921719942
205. Shri Vishnu Res.:- H. No. 217, near Rukmini B.Com, LLB. Tiswadi Taluka.
Dattaram Naik Apts, St. Inez Panaji-Goa
Off.:- Chamber No. 6 Lawyers Bldg, High Court Annexure, Altinho, Panaji. Ph. No.:- 2231954/ /9850891212
206. Smt. Sonali Res.:- Flat No.109, Bldg-3, B.Sc, LLB. Tiswadi Taluka.
Siddharth Kamat Reveira, Samant Caranzalem Goa-403001
Off.:- 405, 4th floor, Wagle Vision, 18th June Road, Panaji Ph. No.:- 2425587/2465632
207. Smt. Vimmy V. Res. & Off.:-F-2, 1st floor, B.A, LLB. Mormugao Taluka.
Redkar alias Laxmi Narayan Niwas, Devika alias Belabai, Vasco-da-Gama 403802 Vimmy D. Ph. No.:- 2530687/ Korgaonkar /9823623248 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3
4 5 6
208. Ms. Rupali Res.:- H. No. 38, Kothiwada, B.A., L.L.B Bicholim and Govind Panashekar Karapur, Bicholim Tiswadi Taluka.
Off.:- S-4, 2nd floor, Fatima Chambers Dr. A. B. Rd, Hotel Samrat, Panaji-Goa. Ph.. No. 2295100/ /2262493/9850450823
209. Smt. Salome Res.:-Flat No. S-3, 2nd flr, B.GL., LLB Bardez Taluka.
Dinesh Naik Axle Residency, Alto Torda, (Hons).
Alto Porvorim.Off:- No.211, 2nd floor, bldg No. S-2, Nova Cidade Comm. Complex, Above Indus Sea Farers Welfare
& Health Centre, Alto Porvorim
Ph. 9850926413
210. Shri Shankar Res.:- H. No.109, "Shankar Smruti", B.A., LLB. Bardez Taluka.
Mukund Phadte Hanumant Wada, Ekoshi, Post,
Betim, Bardez-Goa 403501 Off.:- G-9 Deepti Chambers, Near Canara Bank, Mapusa Goa 403507 Ph. No.:- 2295100/2262493/ /9850450823
211. Shri Premanath Res.: Flat No. S-1, 2nd floor, B.A, LLB Ponda Taluka.
Anand Dessai Verekar Apts,
Silvanagar, Ponda. Off.:- S-3, 2nd floor, Gateway Towers, Tisk Ponda Goa Ph. No.: 2316095/9823253128
212. Shri Sandeep Res. & Off.:- Lobowaddo, Parra B.Com, LLB. Bardez Taluka.
Baburao Raikar Ph. No.: 9822585404
213. Shr. Venefreda Clarina Res.:- 6/75-A, behind Priety Chapel, B.A. LLB. Bardez Taluka.
Pallavil Perpetua Cobra waddo, Calangute.
Barreto Gracias Off.:- 6/78-A/AG-1,
Bh. Preity Chapel,
Cobra waddo, Calangute
Ph. No.:- 2277459/9822984598/
/9822179967
214. Mr. Ashley Res.:- H. No. 27/1, Cana B. Com, LLB Salcete Taluka.
Anthony Gonsalves Benaulim Goa.
Off.:- 203, 2nd floor, Naina
Gracias Plaza, Margao
Ph. No:- 278862/9822152635
215. Ms. Luiza Antao Res.:- H. No. 27, Bindimoll, Behind B. Com, M. Com, Quepem Taluka. 06-02-1976 Municipal Council, Quepem, LLB
Goa 403507 Off.:- Shop No. SF-1, Caserose Mag. Arcade, near Guardian Angel School, Curchorem. Ph. No.:- 9049775949 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3
4 5 6
216. Shri Sandeep Res.: H. No. 559/2, Murida, Cuncolim, M.A., LLB. Salcete Taluka.
Babusso Dessai Salcete, Goa 403703
Off.:- R-6, IInd floor, Montezinha Bldg. Above Mayur-Kamat Hotel, Old Market, Margao-Goa. Ph. No.:- 3226950
217. Shri Pramod D. Res.:-Flat No. 205, 2nd floor, B. Com, LLB. Bardez Taluka.
Shetgaonkar Satt Addhar Arcade, Peddem,
Mapusa Bardez-Goa 2) H. No. 2223, Kattewadda Morjem, Pernem Goa 403512 Off.:- 405, 4th floor, ATRIA Near Court junction, Altinho-Mapusa-Goa 403507 Ph. No.:- 9822663544
218. Ms. Panchami Res.:- House No. 457/1 LLB (Hons), State of Goa.
Tulsidas Naik First Floor, Malawada, LLM PGD
Kumbharjua, Tiswadi Goa (HR) 403107 Off.:- Office No. 7 Ground floor, upstair, Tech Avenue, Shiv Tower, Patto, Panaji-Goa
219. Mrs. Pratibha Anandu Res.:- H. No.1/A, Karvem, Gaodongrim, B.A., LLB Canacona Taluka.
Gane Dessai Canacona Goa 403702 Diploma in
Off.: Char Rasta, Canacona Goa Computer Ph. No.:- 9420760351 Applications
220. Shri Ulhas Res.:- Vadamol, Shristal B.A., LLB Canacona and Krishna Parwar Canacona-Goa 403702 Salcete Taluka.
Off:- Savitri Apt. Chaudi
Canacona-Goa.
Ph. No:- 9326130998
221. Mrs. Ashwina Res.:- H. No. 527, Penha de Franca, L.L.B (Hons) Bardez Taluka.
Ubaldina Valdares Malim P. O. Betim,
Bardez-Goa 403101 Off.:- H. No. 435/31, Chogam Road, Savlem, Opp. Rose Garden School, Alto-Pilerne Porvorim, Bardez-Goa 403501 Ph. No.: 9822383343/2413702
222. Mr. Alfred Fernandes Res.:- H. No. 255, Novo waddo, M.Com, LLB. South Goa District. Ugvem, Sanguem,Goa 403704 Off.:- Shop No. 117, SMC Adm. Bldg, Sanguem Goa. Ne Off.:- 1st Floor, Shrison Plaza Building Sanguem Goa 403704 Ph. No.:- 8275381976/9049510648
223. Mr. Ravindra Res.:- H. No. 15, Opp. Sanguem Court, B.Com, LLB Salcete Taluka to Gajanan Tilve Sanguem, Goa 403704 Sanguem & Off.:- F-8, 1st floor, Quepem Taluka.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 20231 2 3
4 5 6
Nr. Big "G" Chamundi Bldg, Marties Dias Road, Malbhat Margao-Goa 403601 Ph. No.:- 2732845/9822983562
224. Ms. Jyotsna Res.:- Vyankatesh Sadan, B.Com., LLB Ponda Taluka.
Anant Sawaikar H. No. 445, Opp to Syndicate
Bank, Dhavali, Ponda Goa 403401 Off.:- Shop No.1, Ground Floor, Ray Aurtin Plaza, Sadar, Ponda-Goa.Ph. No.:- 2314509
225. Ms. Audrey Res.:- 137/B, Villa Viola B.A. (Economics) State of Goa.
Edociana Vales Chicalim, Goa 403711 LLB, LLM.
Off.:- 45, Second floor,
Apna Bazar, Vasco-da-Gama
Off.: 2555663/2511041/9823092542
226. Mr. Dewal Res:- H. No. 235/A Nagzar Curti B.Com, M.Com South Goa Purushottam Naik Ponda Goa 403401 LLB District.
Off.:- Off. No.13, Second floor, Ponda Commerce Centre, Tisk Ponda Goa 403401 Ph. No.:- 9921343792
227. Ms. Preeti P. Res.:- Flat No. S-2, Krishna Kunj, B.G.L (Hons.) State of Goa.
Prabhu Agrasani alias Near Nagdev Temple, Murida LLB (Hons.) Preeti Vinayak Bhat Fatorda Margao
Off.:- No. 309, 3rd Flr, Reliance Magnum, opp. K.T.C. Bus Stand, Above Navtara Rest, Madel, Margao Ph. No.:- 2742927/9423812132
228. Vinay V. Naik Res.:- Bhatwada, Mallem, Sacorda, B.Com., LLB Dharbandora Taluka.
Dharbandora, Goa Off.: C/o Adv. Vikas Dessai, Tamsodo, Dharbandora Taluka Dharbandora Goa Ph. No.:- 9422018771
229. Ms. Melvina Marcelina Res.:- H. No.:- 534, Poresbhat, B.A., LLB Salcete Taluka.
D'Laura Fernandes Verna, Salcete Goa 403722
Off.:- H. No. 534, Verna Goa 403722 Ph. No.:- 2782486
230. Shri Utkarsh Res.:- H. No.:- 117, B.Com, LLB Salcete Taluka.
Yeshwant Verenkar Fatorda Margao Goa 403602
Off.:- Near Holy Spirit High School, Borda Margao-Goa. Ph. No.:- 2740471/2705075/ /9422059753
231. Shri Somnath B. Karpe Res.:- H. No. 255/B, B.A, LLB State of Goa.
Janaki Niwas, Molloco Merces, P. O. St. Cruz, Ilhas Goa. 403005 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3
4 5 6
Off.:- No. 4, Bhanav Apts, 5th floor, Nr. Mahalaxmi Temple, Panaji, Goa Ph. No.:- 9822587373/2447374/ /2222771
232. Mrs. Geta Purshottam Res.:- Shree Damodar Housing B.A. LLB (spl.) Salcete Taluka.
Kantak e Bhagat Co-op Scty, B/6/2, Aquem, Alto
Margao-Goa Off.:- (1) No. 8, Anna Felicia Bldg, Above Vibes Music Store, Comba Margao-Goa 403601 2) Off:- No. GF-3, B-2, Block Anusaya Apts. Opp. Multi Purpose School, Borda Margao, Goa Ph. No:- 9822583185
233. Sweta Subhash Res.:- B-6 Kundaikar Nagar, LLB(Hons) Tiswadi Taluka.
Naik Gaunekar Dr. Dada Vaidya Road, Panaji,
Tiswadi Taluka Off.:- Gr. Floor, Kamdhenu Bldg, Dr. Dada Vaidya Road, Panaji-Goa 403001 Ph. No.:- 2223438
234. Mr. Rajendra T. Res.:- Rich Builders Residency, B.Com, LLB Tiswadi Taluka.
Chodankar BS-%/6 Cabesa, St. Cruz,
Ilhas-Goa, 4030054 Off.:- Casa Immaculada Bldg, 2nd floor, Jose Falcao Road, Nr. Progress High School, Panaji-Goa 403001 Ph.No:- 2445754/2236036
235. Mr. Francisc D'Souza Res.:- Kamakshi Prasad Bldg, B.Com, LLB Tiswadi Taluka.
Next to Department of Tourism, IIIrd floor, Flat No. 304, Patto Panaji-Goa 403001 Off:- Same as above. Ph. No.:- 9822774778
236. Shri. Surendra G. Res.:-Flat No. A-7, Block A Feira M.A, LLB. Bardez Taluka.
Narulkar Alta Apatments, Feira Alta,
Mapusa Bardez Goa Off.:- Kolwalkar's Complex, F-1 1st floor, near Cine Alankar Behind L.I.C., Bldg, Mapusa Bardez-Goa 403507 2) Shop No. I, upper ground floor, El-Capitan Centre, opp. Caffe Coffee Day Altinho, Mapusa Bardez-Goa Ph. No.:- 9422445546
237. Mrs. Amina Shaikh Res.:- H. No. 27, Ward No. 19, B.Com, LLB Tiswadi Taluka.
alias Amina Phadte Behind Clecy Store, Mala Portais,
Panaji-Goa 403001 Off:- 4th floor, Off. No. 15, OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2 3
4 5 6
Navelkar Trade Centre,
Opp. Azad Maidan Panaji-Goa
Ph. No.: 9822138396
238. Shri Satish Shrinivas Res. & Off:- H.No.163, B.A. LLB. Salcete Taluka.
Pai Raiturkar 1st floor, Yeshwant,
Opp. State Bank of Mysore,
Isidoro Bapatista Road, Margao
Ph. No:- 9922482537
239. Ms. Maria Alice Res.:- H. No.: 1397/C, B.A. LLB, Salcete Taluka.
Silvia Sa Misquita Nr. St. Anthony Chapel,
Dangvaddo, Benaulim,
Salcete-Goa
Off:-same as above
Ph. No.:- 2771834/9881715541/
/9822486040
240. Mr. Laxmikant Res.:-Dattaguru Sadan, B.Sc. LLB. Bardez Taluka.
M. Gajinkar Flat No. 1, Near Azad
Bhavan, Porvorim Off.:- F-2,1st floor, Dattaguru Sadan, Near Azad Bhavan, Porvorim Bardez Ph. No.:- 9503482481
241. Ms. Pratima Res.:- H. No. 446, L.L.B. (Hons). State of Goa.
Rajaram Khobrekar Sawanwada, Mayem, Bicholim Goa 403504 Off:- C/o Diginet Off. No. f/115, 1st Floor, Zeib Tower, Bicholim Market, Bicholim-Goa Ph. No. 2387098/9823711006
242. Ms. Pramila Res.:- H. No. 42/B, Medkevado, B.A. LLB Salcete Taluka.
Kunkolienkar Dicarpale, Navelim, Salcete Goa 403707. Off.:- S-23, Ground floor, "Souza Enclave" Madel Margao Ph. No.:- 9960706074
243. Shri Pandurang P. Res.:- "Saikunj" Ganeshpuri, B.A, LLB Bardez Taluka.
Banaulikar Mapusa Bardez-Goa 403507
Off:-B-206, Saldanaha Business Tower, Near Civil and Criminal Court Mapusa Goa Ph. No.:- 2475223/9423313888
244. Shri Bhagwan D. Res.:- H. No. MA-1/6, B. Com. L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Shirodkar Gaunswaddo, Bhilwas,
Bh. Priti International Hotel, P.O. Mapusa. Off:- 24, Mapusa Trade Centre, Above Royal Foods, Opp. Sub Registrar Building, Morod, Mapusa, Bardez, Goa 403507 Ph. No. 9822133302 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2
3
4 5 6
245. Babuso Rama Sawant Res.:- Flat No.TF-302, B. A. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka. 3rd floor, Gurukupa Building, Opp. Madhuban Shopping Complex, Tamdi Mati, St. Inez, Panaji-Goa 403001 Off:- No.15, 2nd flr, Gurudatta Building, Dr. Dada Vaidya Road, Panjim-Goa. Ph. No. 9764759889
246 Ms. Shubhada C. Res.:- H. No. 202/99, Kailasnagar, L.L.B. (Hons). Bardez Taluka.
Dessai alias Assonora, Bardez Ms. Shubhada A. Raul Off.:- Archie Fantacy Bldg.,
Flat No. 53, 2nd floor,
Assonora, Bardez-Goa
Ph. No. 9923881353
247. Ms. Muktabai S. Parab Res. & Off.:- H. No. 650, Umal B.Com. L.L.B. Pernem Taluka.
alias Anu A. Bagwada, Morjim, Pernem Shetgaonkar Ph. No. 9423318933
248. Shri Mahesh Anant Res:- H. No. 510, Ram Niwas, B.Com, L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Shetgaonkar Canca Bandh, Parra, Bardez Goa Off.:- L-2, Upper Gr. Flr, Saldanha Business Tower, Court Circle Altinho, Mapusa Bardez-Goa Ph. No. 2255438/9370567466
249. Ms. Reshma R. Prabhu Res.:- H. No. 297/1, Ravalnath B. Com. L.L.B. State of Goa.
Nagar, Rangado, Corlim, Goa Off.:- C/o Bholanath Saw Mill, Betora Road, Ponda Goa New Off. Add:- Off.. No. 34, 1st floor, Ponda Commerce Centre, Tisk, Ponda Goa Ph. No. 2285092/9923326626
250. Shri Vishwas Res.:- H. No. 431/7, Ghanemorod, B. A. L.L.B. Quepem Taluka.
Gopinath Naik Quepem, Goa 403705
Off:- Ashok Apts, Opp. Corporation Bank, Curchorem-Goa 403706 Ph. No. 9822130917/2651544
251. Shri Santosh G. Naik Res:- Flat No. 202,B (b), B.A. LLB Salcete Taluka.
Fatima Apts., Arlem, Raia, DI RPM Salcete-Goa 403720 Off:- R/o 310, 3rd floor, Antivierza Bldg., New Market, Margao, Salcete-Goa. Ph. No. 2742286/9326160404
252. Ramnath A. S. Res.:- Midland Apts., 2nd floor, M. Com. L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Kharangate Opp. Fatima Convent High School, Margao Off.:- 1) Cruz Mansion, 2nd flr, Opp. Panchaaratha Complex, Margao 2) H. No. 107, Paroda Post, Quepem, Goa. Ph. No. 2869516/9822136600 /915840009.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 20231 2
3
4 5 6
253. Shri Purushottam Res.:- H. No. 30/1,
B. A. L.L.B. South Goa District. Krishna Phaldessai Amona, Post Quepem
Off:- Shop. No. F-8, 1st floor, Dasha Classic Bldg, Opp. Municipal Market, Quepem Ph. No. 9922542344/2663815
254. Smt. Vandana Res.:- Kamaxi Niwas, M. Com. L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Sushant Naik Mahalwada, Madkai-Goa
Off.:- Mahalwada, Karanjal,
Madkai, Ponda Taluka
Ph. No. 9923248371/2392293
255. Shri Subhash Res:- Bhavani Prasad, M. A. L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Krishna Kanekar Plot No. 62, Housing Board
Colony, Gogol, Margao, Salcete Off.:- s-2, 2nd floor, D'Wing, Nr. Café Tato, Apna Bazar, Margao-Goa. Ph. No. 9823916502
256. Shri Purushottam Res.:- Janki Niwas, B. Com. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Ramkrishna Karpe H. No. 255/A, Molloco,
Merces, Ilhas-Goa 403005 Off.:- Datta Prasad Bldg, Flat No. 1, 3rd floor, M. G. Road, Panaji-Goa Ph. No. 2445929/9881245929
257. Shri Amol Res.:- Plot No.5, PDA Colony B. Com. L.L.M. Tiswadi Taluka.
Purushottam Thali Mallar, Corlim, Tiswadi Off:- No. 302, 3rd floor, Wagle Vision, 18th June Road, Panaji-Goa 403001 Ph. No. 9822179135/2285497
258. Shri Bharat F. Naik Res.:- H. No. 289, Parkebhat, B. A. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Carambolim, Tiswadi-Goa. Off:- Bhomkar Chambers Bldg, Flat No. GF-6, Ground floor, Mollar, Corlim, Tiswadi Ph. No. 2284213/9226319460
259 Shri Manguirish U. Res.:- Flat No. V-C, 5th flr, B. Com. L.L.B. Mormugao Taluka.
Kenkre St. Andrews Residency, A' Block V-C, Opp. KTC Bus Stand, Vasco-da- -Gama, Goa 403802 Off.:- FO-3, Gurukrupa Bldg, F. L. Gomes Road, Vasco-da-Gama-Goa. Ph. No. 2515969, 2511770
260. Shri Ganpat Res.:- H. No.18, B. A. L.L.B. Sattari Taluka.
Pandurang Gaonkar Kumbharhkham, Sattari Off.:- Shop No. 8, Quba Commercial Complex, Thane Road, Valpoi, Sattari-Goa Ph. No. 9423810995 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2
3
4 5 6
261. Shri Sarvadnya Res.:- Flat No. X-III,
L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
D. Patil Braganza Trade Centre, Rajwado, opp. Remanso Hospital, Mapusa-Goa Off:- No. 22, Grnd. Flr, Phoenix Plaza, Alto, Near H. P. Gas, Mapusa, Goa Ph. No. 9637628070/ /9422635454
262. Shri Shailendra Res.: H. No. 376, B. A. L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
G. Madkaikar Simepain, Veling Post,
Mardol-Goa Off.:- F-15, 1st floor, Kurtarkar Commercial Arcade, Bh. Canara Bank, Kaziwada, Ponda Ph. No. 2343331/ /9422641807
263. Ms. Rashmi R. Res. & Off.:- H. No. 121, B. Com. L.L.B. Quepem Taluka Manerkar alias Rashmi Siddhesh Paroda Quepem-Goa. Padiyara Ph. No. 2662983/
/9850112764
264. Shri Gajanan Res:- Flat No. XS-8, B. Com. L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
K. Korgaonkar 2nd flr, Sunset Boulevard,
Near Mapusa Industrial Estate, Mapusa-Goa. Off.:- 315 & 316, 3rd floor, Cosmos Centre, Morod Mapusa Goa Ph. No. 2253677, 2262320
265. Shri Arjun Vaman Res.:- H. No. 502(1), B. A. L.L.B. Pernem Taluka.
Gawandi Mahalaxmi Niwas
Deulwada, Tuem, Pernem Off.:- Near Mahadev Temple, Bazarpeth, Pernem 403512 Ph. No. 9423821307
266. Shri Chetan Res. & Off.:- H. No. 242, B. A. L.L.B. Ponda Taluka.
Pundalik Shirodkar Agapur, Ponda-Goa
Ph. No. 9822828825/
/9765182429
267. Shri Suraj Rohidas Res.:- Type III, Block-D, B. Com. L.L.B. State of Goa.
Naik Flat No. 26, GMC,
Complex, Bambolim Off.:- H. No. E-71, Bhatlem, Panaji Ph. No. 9860322618/ /9860322619, 2458641 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2
3
4 5 6
268. Shri Dhaktu Gopi Pal Res.:-M-1,15, Mahamaya M.A., L.L.M. Bicholim Taluka.
Nagar Hsg Board Colony, Bordem, Bicholim-Goa 403504 Off:- F-8, 1st Floor, Vassudev Arcade, Nr. Shivaji Maidan, Bicholim. Ph. No. 2361452/ /9422018582
269. Shri Arun Anant Naik Res.:- H. No. 98, M.A., L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Tapalwada Kumbharjua, Tiswadi-Goa 403407 Off:- 1st flr, Misquita House, Nr. Hotel La Capital, Panaji-Goa. Ph. No. 9371196126/2431297
270. Shri Prasad Suresh Naik Res. & Off.:- Row Villa B.Sc. PGDCA Salcete Taluka.
No. 6, Marelda Residency, L.L.B. Laymati, Davorlim, Salcete-Goa 403707 Ph. No. 2756345
L.L.B. State of Goa.
271. Shri Noel Parras D'Cruz Res.:- H.No. 211, Bogmalo Beach, Vasco-da-Gama-Goa Off.:- 1) Shop No. 4, 1st flr, Ave Maria Bldg., Margao-Goa 2) Shop No. 2, Ground flr, Ave Maria Bldg., Margao-Goa Ph. No. 2731274
272. Shri Nilesh Res.: G-3, Estrocio Apts., B. Sc. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Ashok Manerkar Near Ganesh Prasad Bldg
Altinho, Panaji-Goa Off.: G-6, Pinto Chambers, Opp. Dena Bank, Menezes Braganza Road, Panaji-Goa. Ph.No. 2220833/9422443434
273. Shri Edwin Mauro Res.: H. No. 1054/1, Bairo-Dias, B. A. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Menezes Mathew Goa Velha, Ilhas-Goa
Off.:- C-5, 3rd floor, Sapana Regency, above Mens Baron Showroom, Dr. Shirgaonkar Road, Panaji, Goa Ph. No. 9822383895/2218524
274. Ms. Sulekha S. Kamat Res: Bldg. No. 5B2, B. A. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Dukle Residency, Tamdi Mati, Taleigao-Goa 403002. Off.:- 302, Durga Chambers, Third flr, 8th June Road, Panaji-Goa, 403001 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023 1 2
3
4 5 6
New Off.:- Shop No. 8,
Bhomkar Residency, Opp. ICAR Research Centre, Near Petrol Pump, Old Goa Ph. No. 99850682477/ /2422031
275. Shri Shantaram Res. & Off.:- H. No.1726, B. Com. L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Pundalik Naik Coelho wado,
Penha-da-Franca,
Bardez-Goa
P.O. Betim 403401
Ph. No. 9049610041/
/2218524
276. Shri Vikesh Res.: H. No. 5/3, B. Com. L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Krishna Harmalkar Nr. Hotel Spice Goa, Karaswada, Mapusa Off.:- A-503, 5th flr, Saldanha Business Towers, Nr. Court
Circle, Altinho, Mapusa
Ph. No. 9923484499/2253538
277. Shri Pandurang Res.:- 102, Carvalhos Apts., B.A. L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Surya Amonkar Comba, Margao Goa
Off.:- No. 110,1st floor, Guru Ashish Bldg., New Market,
Margao Goa
Ph. No. 2705670/9822181296
278. Shri Raghvenda Res.:- H. No.165, B.G.L. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Namdev Kalangutkar Carmibhat, Merces, (Hons) LLM
Tiswadi-Goa
Off:- Cabin No.2, Z-square
Business Centre, Hotel Ashok Plaza, 18th June Road, Panaji-Goa. Ph. No. 9822987576
279. Ms. Madhumita Res.:- H. No. 890/2, Bachelor of Law Bardez Taluka.
Avadhut Nayak Salatry "Venkatesh", Near Holy Family (Hons) L.L.B.
High School, Porvorim-Bardez. Hons Off:- C/o Adv. Avadhut V. Nayak Salatry, Vithalwadi, Ansabhat, Mapusa, Bardez-Goa 403507 Ph. No. 2417861 (R) 2250068 (O)
280. Mrs. Karuna Shriram Bakre Res. & Off.:- H.No. 80/B, B.Com., L.L.B. State of Goa.
Vithalapur,
Sankhli Goa 403504
Ph. No:- 2366541/9420979535
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 20231 2
3
4 5 6
281. Mrs. Darshana C. Res.:- H.No.61/C, Ratwado, B.A. L.L.B. Salcete Taluka.
Gauns Desai alias Navelim, Salcete-Goa Mrs. Darshana S. Off.:- H.No. 506, Near Borkar Naik Dessai Super stores, Ratwaddo,
Navelim, Salcete, Goa
Ph. No. 9932657896/2738051
282. Ms. Varsha Naik Res.: 115, Savorfond, B. Com. L.L.B. South Goa District. Volvoikar Sancoale, Cortalim
Off.:- Shop No. 16/A, 1st floor, Karma Express Bldg, above O/o. Sub-Registrar Vasco Ph. No. 9881283471
283. Shri Vilas Soma Res.:- H. No.814/1-A, B. A. L.L.B. Bardez Taluka.
Goltekar Vascar waddo, Shirgal,
Dhargal, Pernem-Goa. Off:- Ninho D'Souza, Business Centre, Ground floor, G-6, Alto Feira, Mapusa-Bardez-Goa 403507 Ph. No. 9860243470
284. Miss Deepali Zilu Naik Off:- Near Kasturba Matoshri B. Com. Tiswadi and Quepem
High School, Jose Falcao Road, L.L.B. Taluka. Panaji-Goa 403001. Communication Address: Office No. 3, First Floor, Sateri Chambers, Near Sarvodaya High School, Curchorem, Goa. Ph. No. 9823194038 2234038 (R)
285. Shri Shridhar S. Kamat Res.:- H. No. 250/3, B. Com. Bardez Taluka.
Near Railway Station, L.L.B Sus Stop Sirsaim, Thivim, Bardez-Goa Off.:- Off. No. 7, 2nd flr, Riturai Plaza, Keriwaddo, Mapusa-Goa. Ph. No. 9822139060/2298415
286. Shri Linus Emmanuel Res.:- H. No. E-333, B. Com. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Yasmin Manzil, Opp. St. Inez, Post Office Panaji-Goa Off.:- 3rd floor, Trionora Apts., Navtara Panaji-Goa 403001 Ph. No. 2420534, 2421194, 6643420
287. Shri Sandip alias Res. & Off:- 524, B. Com. Mormugao Taluka.
Babi Ramkrishna Parab C/o Sapna Stores, L.L.B.
Nr. Saibaba Temple,
New Vaddem, Vasco-da-Gama.
Ph. No. 9923037687/2510358
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 20231 2
3
4 5 6
288. Mrs. Sudha Santosh Res.: 5/F/5, Shantaban Hsg B. A. L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Lad alias Sugandha Complex, opp. Swami Ramchandra Patil Samarth Mandir, Merces
Off.:- 413, Shiv Towers,
Patto, Panaji.
Ph. No. 9422065476
289. Shri Arun Anant Wadkar Res:- H. No. 221/1, B. Com. Ponda and
Wadi wada, Betki, L.L.B Tiswadi Taluka. Marcel, Ponda Goa 403107 Off:- G/4, Ground floor, Omkar Commercial Centre, Behind Tivrem Orgao Panchayat Marcel, Ponda Goa Ph. No. 9823680183
290. Mrs. Roya Laticia Res.:- SF4, IInd floor, B. Com. State of Goa.
Laura Ferrao Rorigues Apts., Co. op. L.L.B.
Society, Behind Edmar House, Ela Old Goa 403402. Off:- TF1, Third floor, Rorigues Apts.,Co. op. Society, Behind Edmar House, Ela Old Goa 403402. Ph. No. 9822103985
291. Mr. Paulo R/o AF-3 & AF-5, L.L.B. Tiswadi Taluka.
Francisco Rodrigues Casa Immaculada Building,
Jose Falcao Road,
Near Panjim Church,
Panaji Goa
———uuu———
13. Shri Pravinkumar G. Vast.
Department of Personnel
14. Shri Sagar P. Ekoskar.
––– Order
15. Shri Rajesh Kumar.
No. 22/1/2013-PER/Part/594
16. Shri Manoj V. Mardolkar.
17. Shri Tushar N. Vernekar.
18. Shri Vishwesh P. Karpe.
19. Shri Sudesh S. Narvekar.
20. Shri Suraj S. Halarnkar.
The Government is pleased to extend the officiating promotion in respect of the following Deputy Superintendent of Police, for a period of three months (03 months) w.e.f. 01-01-2023 to 31-03-2023:-
21. Shri Sudesh R. Naik.
1. Shri Wilson C. D'Souza.
22. Shri Rupendra A. Shetgaonkar.
2. Shri Francis X. Corte.
23. Shri Ram Asare.
3. Shri Roy Pereira.
24. Shri Nilesh S. Rane.
4. Shri Braz T. Menezes.
25. Shri Shivram M. Vaigankar.
5. Smt. Nutan U. Verenker.
6. Shri Gurudas A. Kadam.
7. Shri Siddhant U. Shirodkar.
This issues with the concurrence of the Goa Public Service Commission conveyed vide its letter No. COM/II/11/37(1)/2023/1833 dated 27-02-2023.
8. Shri Jivba G. Dalvi.
By order and in the name of the Governor of 9. Shri Rajan Y. Nigalye.
Goa.
10. Shri Rajendra S. P. Dessai.
11. Shri Nerlon L. B. Albuquerque.
Nathine S. Araujo, Under Secretary (Personnel-II).
12. Shri Ashish S. Shirodkar.
Porvorim, 2nd March, 2023.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 20234. Shri Meghanath P. Porob.
Order
No. 6/28/2016-PER/673
On the recommendation of the Departmental Promotion Committee as conveyed by Goa Public Service Commission vide letter No. COM/II/11/42(6)/ /2016/509 dated 03-03-2023, the Governor of Goa is pleased to promote the following Selection Grade Officers of Goa Civil Service to Senior Administrative Grade (Group 'A' Gazetted), under Rule 34 of the Goa Civil Service Rules, 2016, in Level 14 of Central Civil Services (RP) Rules, 2016 with immediate effect:-
1. Shri Gopal Parsekar.
2. Shri Gurudas P. Pilarnekar
3. Smt. Shabari Manjrekar alias Ruhi Redkar.
5. Shri Venancio Furtado.
6. Shri Derrick P. Neto.
7. Shri Srinet N. Kotwale.
The Officers shall exercise their option for fixation of pay in promotional grade in terms of F.R. 22 (I)(a)(1), within a period of one month from the date of issue of the order. The option once exercised shall be final.
On promotion, the Officers shall continue to hold the post presently held by them, until further orders.
By order and in the name of the Governor of Goa.
Eshant V. Sawant, Under Secretary (Personnel-I).
Porvorim, 10th March, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Public Health
–– Order
No. 44/16/2016-I/PHD/Part-I/367
Government is pleased to transfer the below mentioned Doctors under Directorate of Health Services, with immediate effect:-
Sr. Name of the Doctor Present place of posting Proposed transfer at
No.
1. Dr. Amey Raikar, Primary Health Centre, South Goa District Hospital, Medical Officer Pilliem, Dharbandora Margao, in place of Dr. Balkrishna B. Gaude, M. O.
2. Dr. Balkrishna B. Gaude, South Goa District Hospital, Primary Health Centre, Pilliem, Medical Officer Margao Dharbandora, in place of Dr. Amey Raikar, M.O.
By order and in the name of the Governor of Goa.
Gautami Parmekar, Under Secretary (Health-II).
Porvorim, 10th March, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Public Works
Office of the Principal Chief Engineer
–––
Order
No. 34/4/2023/PCE-PWD-ADM(II)/147
Government is pleased to promote the following Superintending Engineer/Superintending Surveyor of Works (Civil) to the post of Chief Engineer on ad hoc basis in Public Works Department, Group "A" Gazetted in Level 14 in the Pay Matrix under 7th Pay Commission with immediate effect till the date of their regularization or till the date of retirement on superannuation whichever is earlier, subject to Vigilance Clearance from Vigilance Department and post them in the places shown against their names in column No. 4 below.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023Sr. Name of the Present place Place of posting No. Officers
of posting on promotion
1 2
3
4
1. Shri A. J. George Pereira Superintending Engineer, As Chief Engineer, NH (R&B), Circle Office III, PWD, PWD, Altinho, Panaji in the Altinho, Panaji-Goa existing vacancy.
2. Smt. Angelica Lianne Sarita Odette Superintending Surveyor As Chief Engineer II, PWD, Da Silva alias Angelica Leana of Works, PWD, Altinho, Altinho, Panaji in the existing Odetta Sarita Da Silva Panaji-Goa vacancy.
The above ad hoc promotion will not bestow on the promoted officers any claim for regular promotion nor the service rendered on ad hoc in the grade will be counted for purpose of seniority in that grade for eligibility for promotion to the next higher grade.
Their pay shall be fixed as per rules.
By order and in the name of the Governor of Goa.
Uttam P. Parsekar, Principal Chief Engineer (PWD) & ex officio Addl. Secretary.
Panaji, 6th March, 2023.
–––––—
Notification
No. 8-4/PCE-PWD-Accts/2022-23/1826
Whereas, the Notification No. 8-4/CE-PWD-Accts/96-97/330 dated 7th October, 1996 issued by Public Works Department stands withdrawn with immediate effect.
This is issued with the approval of the Government vide U.O. No. 3111 dated 11-01-2023.
By order and in the name of the Governor of Goa.
Uttam P. Parsekar, Principal Chief Engineer (PWD) & ex officio Addl. Secretary.
Panaji, 14th February, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Social Welfare
Directorate of Social Welfare
––– Notification
No. 61-156-2022-23-DSW/6660
Read: Notification No. 13/4/90-SWD/Part/1933 dated 04-07-2017.
In exercise of powers conferred under provision of Clause 116 of the Articles of Association of Goa State Scheduled Castes and Other Backward Classes Finance and Development Corporation Limited, the Government of Goa is pleased to reconstitute the Board of Directors of the Goa State Scheduled Castes and Other Backward Classes Finance and Development Corporation Limited as under:-
Sr. No. Name & Address Designation
1. Shri Anil Hoble, Chairman.
r/o. Merces, Tiswadi-Goa
2. Shri Dayanand Karbotkar, Vice- r/o. Mayem, Bicholim-Goa -Chairman.
1 2 3
3. Shri Siddesh Pednekar, Director.
r/o. Pernem
4. Shri Mahanand Asnodkar, Director.
r/o. Porvorim, Bardez-Goa
5. Shri Yeshwant Kanolkar, Director.
r/o. Calangute
6. Shri Avadhoot Naik, Director.
r/o. Panchawadi, Shiroda, Ponda-Goa
7. Shri Suryakant Anand Naik, Director.
r/o. Rivona, Sanguem-Goa
8. Shri Shubham Chodankar, Director.
r/o. Mala, Panaji
9. Director, Social Welfare Director.
10. Representative of Lead Bank Director.
viz SBI, Panaji
11. The Managing Director, Goa Director.
State SC & OBC Finance & Development Corporation Ltd.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023The non-official Directors shall be entitled for sitting allowances at the rate of Rs. 800/- per sitting. No separate TA/DA shall be paid.
By order and in the name of the Governor of Department of Urban Development
(Municipal Administration)
–––
Notification
Goa.
Sandhya Kamat, Director (Social Welfare) & ex
officio Add. Secretary.
Panaji, 10th March, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Transport
Directorate of Transport
–––
No. 14/DMA/STAT/Notifications-CSS-GSUDA/ /2020-21/4866
The Government of India, Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs under the Flagship Programme of DAY-NULM has introduced the PM Street Vendors
Notification
No. D.Tpt/EST/1997/(PF)2022/680
In pursuance to Article 68 read with Article 78 of the Articles of Association of the Kadamba Transport Corporation Limited and in supersession of all the earlier notifications, Government is pleased to reconstitute the Board of Directors of Kadamba Transport Corporation Limited, as hereunder with immediate effect:-
1. Shri Ulhas Tuenkar, MLA, — Chairman.
Navelim
2. Shri Kritesh Gaonkar, r/o — Vice
Vasco Chairman.
3. Shri Bayo Bhandari, r/o — Director.
Sanguem, Goa
4. Shri Shamba Gaonkar, — Director.
Velge, Bicholim, Goa
5. Shri Prabhakar Gaonkar, — Director.
r/o Balli, Quepem, Goa
6. Shri Samir Dayanand — Director.
Mandrekar, r/o Oxel, Siolim, Bardez, Goa
7. Smt. Madhukala Shirodkar, — Director.
r/o Navelim, Salcete
8. Shri Kapil Sardesai, — Director.
r/o Navelim, Salcete
9. Smt. Ujwala Naik, r/o — Director
H. No. 261, Mayer, Sancoale, Goa
10. Director (Transport) — Director.
11. Managing Director, — Director.
Kadamba Transport Corporation Limited
By order and in the name of the Governor of Goa.
Rajan Satardekar, Director & ex officio Addl.
Secretary (Transport).
Panaji, 15th March, 2023.
AtmaNirbhar Nidhi (PM SVANidhi), a Scheme for Special Micro-Credit Facility to Street Vendors for providing affordable working capital loan to resume their livelihoods that have been adversely affected due to COVID-19 lockdown.
In order to link the PMSVANidhi beneficiaries and their families, as per their respective eligibilities, to the existing welfare schemes of the Government of India, the Government of Goa is pleased to constitute the District Level Monitoring Committee (DLMC) to implement and monitor all aspects of the Phase III of SVANidhi se Samriddhi program (socio-economic profiling of PM SVANidhi scheme beneficiaries and their families').
The composition of DLMC for Phase III of SVANidhi se Samriddhi program scheme shall be as follows:-
1. Dy. Collector, — Chairperson.
Bardez Taluka
2. Labour Inspector, — Member.
Bardez Taluka
3. Inspector, Civil Supplies, — Member.
Bardez Taluka
4. Health Officer, Urban — Member.
Health Centre, Mapusa
5. CDPO, Bardez Taluka — Member.
6. Lead District Bank — Member.
Manager, SBI, North Goa
7. The Chief Officer, — Convener.
Mapusa Municipal Council
The committee will carry out the following
activities:-
(I) Monitor and supervise the entire exercise of socio-economic profiling and linkages of PM SVANidhi beneficiaries and their families to eligible Central welfare schemes at the city level.
(II) To ensure linkages of the PMSVANidhi beneficiaries and their families to the following Central welfare schemes:-
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 50 16TH MARCH, 2023(a) Pradhan Mantri Jan Dan Yojana and
Issuance of RuPay card.
(b) PM Suraksha Bima Yojana.
(c) Pradhan Mantri Jeevan Jyoti Bima Yojana.
(d) Registration under BoCW (Building and
Other Construction Workers).
(e) Pradhan Mantri Shram Yogi Manadhan
Yojana.
(f) NFSA portability benefits - One Nation One
Ration card.
(g) Janani Surkasha Yojana.
(h) Pradhan Mantri Matru Vandana Yojana.
By order and in the name of the Governor
of Goa.
Gurudas P. Pilarnekar, Director (Municipal Administration/Urban Development) & ex officio Joint Secretary.
Panaji, 10th March, 2023.
———uuu———
Department of Women & Child Development
Directorate of Women & Child Development
–––
Government Printing Press __
S u b s c r i p t i o n R a t e s
N o t i c e
The subscribers to the Official Gazette are kindly reminded that their present subscription term ends on the 31st March, 2023, being the end of financial year.
In case they wish to continue to be subscribers for the ensuing financial year 2023-2024 they have to renew their subscriptions from 1st April, 2023.
Subscriptions also can be opened for half year i.e. from 1st April or 1st October or for any quarter, beginning on 1st April, 1st July, 1st October or 1st January.
Renewal of subscription from 1st April should be effected on or before 31st March, 2023 in order to avoid interruption in the despatch of copies of the Gazette. It should be noted that, in case the subscription is not opened/renewed before the commencement of the period to which it refers, the subscribers will be entitled to receive copies of the Gazette only from the date the subscription is actually opened/renewed.
Official Gazette is now available through e-mail for an annual subscription of Rs. 250/- (Rupees two
hundred and fifty only).
Notification
No. 4-19-96-SWO-W&CD/11245
In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 4 of the Goa State Commission for Women Act, 1996 (Goa Act 10 of 1996) (hereinafter called as the "said Act"), read with Rule 3 of the Goa State Commission for Women Rules, 1997, the Government of Goa hereby appoints Smt. Ranjita S. Pai, R/o Katyayani, 10/1171, Comba, Margao, Goa, as Chairperson of the State Commission for Women to exercise the powers conferred on and to perform the functions assigned to it, under the said Act and Rules.
The tenure of the above Chairperson shall be for
three years from the date of its constitution.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
Deepali Naik, Director & ex officio Joint Secretary
(Women & Child Development).
Panaji, 06th March, 2023.
The subscription charges are accepted either in cash, postal order, demand draft or cheques (subject to clearance) drawn only on State Bank of India, Panaji, in favour of the Director, Printing and Stationery, Panaji-Goa.
SUBSCRIPTION RATES
(Within the Union of India)
All 3 Series Series Series Series I II III
Rs. P. Rs. P. Rs. P. Rs. P.
For any quarter .................. 1200.00 600.00 500.00 300.00 (Postage) ........................... 60.00 15.00 15.00 15.00
For half year ........................ 2300.00 1200.00 1000.00 600.00 (Postage) ........................... 60.00 30.00 30.00 30.00
For any period exceeding 6 months up to one year... 4350.00 2300.00 1850.00 1150.00 (Postage) ............................ 110.00 60.00 60.00 60.00
www.goaprintingpress.gov.in
Published and Printed by the Director, Printing & Stationery, Government Printing Press, Mahatma Gandhi Road, Panaji-Goa 403 001. PRICE–Rs. 70.00
PRINTED AT THE GOVERNMENT PRINTING PRESS, PANAJI-GOA—449/100—03/2023.