RNI No. GOAENG/2002/6410 Reg. No. RNP/GOA/32/2024-2026Panaji, 12th April, 2024 (Chaitra 23, 1946) SERIES II No. 2
PUBLISHED BY AUTHORITY
Note:- There is one Extraordinary issue to the Official Gazette, Series II No. 1 dated 4-04-2024 namely, Extraordinary dated 4-04-2024 from pages 37 to 40 regarding Orders and Notifications from Goa State Election Commission.
GOVERNMENT OF GOA
Department of Co-operation
Office of the Asstt. Registrar of Co-operative Societies
—––
Final list of Members/Voters list of
Vassant Vistas Co-operative Housing Society as on 01-12-2023
ANNEXURE "I"
to membership shares held /Gen.
Sr. Name of the Members/ Main/ Flat No. Date of No. of fully Remarks Category No. /Voters list /Joint admission paid up SC/ST/ Male/Female in the Members Register (G Form)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 1. Ms. Nanda V. Pednekar M B-44 22-02-2017 5 Gen F
2. Smt. Nima Subash Patil M A-12 22-02-2017 5 Gen F Gen M Mr. Subash Dattatray Patil J
3. Shri Lenzyl Bartolomeu M A-13 22-02-2017 5 Gen M Antonio Soares
4. Mrs. Uma Anil Amonkar M A-14 15-07-2022 5 Gen F Gen M Mr. Anil Shankar Amonkar J
5. Mrs. Lourdes Teresa D'souza M A-21 20-02-2017 5 Gen F Gen M Mr. Diago Xavier D'souza J
6. Mr. Jeffery Rodrigues M A-22 22-06-2018 5 Gen M Gen F Mrs. Paloma D'sa J
7. Mrs. Tanuja Shirodkar M A-23 1-20-2022 5 Gen F Gen M Mr. Dattaprasad Shirodkar J
8. Mr. Joseph Nazarius Pereira M A-24 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
9. Shri Kalpit Anant Tendolkar M A-31 22-02-2017 5 Gen M Gen F Smt. Krupali K. Bhagat J
10. Mrs. Pranali L. Prabhudesai M A-32 22-02-2017 5 Gen F Gen M Shri Ladcoba Prabhudesai J OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
11. Smt. Krupali K. Bhagat M A-33 22-02-2017 5 Gen F
Shri Kalpit Anant Tendolkar J Gen M
12. Smt. Jouelle Baracho alias M A-34 22-02-2017 5 Gen F
Joulle Baracho Lewis
13. Shri Raju Vasant Tar M A-41 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
Smt. Sara Raju Tar J 22-02-2017 Gen F
14. Shri Raju Vasant Tar M A-42 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
Smt. Sara Raju Tar J Gen F
15. Shri Vinayakrao Prabhakar M A-43 20-02-2017 5 Gen M
Nadkarni
16. Shri Errol Eustace Jerome M A-44 20-02-2017 5 Gen M
D'souza
17. Shri Raju Vasant Tar M A-51 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
Smt. Sara Raju Tar J Gen F
18. Mr. Amay Arjun Phadte M A-52 1-22-2021 5 Gen M
19. Shri Anil Shrikant Kenkare M A-53 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
Smt. Anagha Anil Kenkare J Gen F
Mangurish Anil Kenkare J M
20. Shri Savio Brian D'mello M A-54 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
21. Mr. Ashish Rodricks M B-11 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
23. Shri Gurudas Rama M B-13 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
Harmalkar
Smt. Sugandha Gurudas J Gen F
Harmalkar
25. Shri Gulam Yakub Shaikh M B-21 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
alias Yakub C. Shaikh
26. Shri Michael Rangel M B-22 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
27. Shri Ronald Braganza M B-23 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
Smt. Alva Maria Braganza J Gen F
28. Shri Ronald Braganza M B-24 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
Smt. Alva Maria Braganza J Gen F
29. Shri Vishvesh S. Phaldesai M B-31 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
30. Mr. Joseph Souza Pereira M B-32 29-07-2020 5 Gen M
Mrs. Beatrice Souza Pereira J Gen F
31. Shri Francisco Xavier Mendes M B-33 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
Smt. Albertina Ana Rosa Mendes J Gen F
32. Shri Kaizad Mody M B-34 6-28-2018 5 Gen M
33. Smt. Diana Philomena M B-41 6-28-2018 5 Gen F
D'souza
34. Smt. Cecilia D'souza M B-42 6-28-2018 5 Gen F
35. Shri Lino Braz Rodrigues M B-43 6-28-2018 5 Gen M
36. Mr. Jerry Clement Domnic Vaz M A-11 3-9-2020 5 Gen M
37. Mr. Rahil Hassan Shaikh M B-51 2-3-2021 5 Gen M
Mrs. Sanofar Rahil Shaikh J Gen F
38. Smt. Shahin Siraj Birya M B-52 6-28-2018 5 Gen F
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA
SERIES II No. 2
12TH APRIL, 2024
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
39. Smt. Supriya Dashrath Jadhav M B-53 6-28-2018 5 Gen F
Shri Nikhil Suresh Chavan J Gen M
40. Smt. Jolly Rego M B-54 6-28-2018 5 Gen F
42. Mr. Datta Tar M B-14 22-02-2017 5 Gen M
Mrs. Sandhya Datta Tar J Gen F
Sd/-, Chairperson/Administrators.
Mapusa, 14th December, 2023.
————
Kamat Prime Co-op. Housing Society Ltd.
B.B. Borkar Road, Porvorim, Bardez-Goa 403521
Reg. No. ARCS/NZ/HSG/477(B)/Goa dated 20-02-2020
——
Provisional list of Voters of Kamat Prime Co-op. Housing Society Ltd.
Sr. Unit Type* Admission Name of Gender Age Address Phone Email No date voting member
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1. Shop# Comm 20-02-2020 Rohan Ramesh Kamat M 35 501, Kamat 9822980269 rohan.kamat 1 & 2
Metropolis- @kamat
-II, St. Inez, realty.com
Panaji 403001
2. Shop# Comm 09-01-2021 Jerome Marcel Lewis M 69 H. No. 264/ 9326101004 joelewis3108 3 & 4
/75, Near @gmail.com
Gautam Hotel,
Pilerne, Bardez,
Goa 403114
3. UG3 Res 20-02-2020 Dr. Rohit Vishwanath M 59 H. No. 1571, 9822482010 rvhede
Hede "SITEJ", B. B. @gmail.com
Borkar Road,
Penha de
Franca, Alto
Porvorim
403521
4. F1 Res 20-02-2020 Anjali Arun Sardessai F 56 633/1, Nandan 9822385399 anjali.
Bungalow, sardessai@
Law College gmail.com
Road, Miramar,
Caranzalem,
P. O. 403002
5. F2 Res 20-02-2020 Sheela Dhume F 73 Flat No. F2, 9604559962 sheela.dhume
Kamat Prime, @gmail.com
B. B. Borkar,
Road, Porvorim OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
6. F3 Res 20-02-2020 Madhav Shivaji M 55 Flat No. F3, 9923063318
Sinai Desai Kamat Prime,
B. B. Borkar
Road,
Porvorim
7. S1 Res 20-02-2020 Milan Vilas F 78 711/64, 9511746872 vilasbhangui Bhangui Green Hill @gmail.com Society, Soccorro, Bardez 403501
8. S2 Res 20-02-2020 Shailaja Shashikant F 65 Flat No. S2, 9822385346 shaila
Sardessai Kamat Prime, sardessai
B.B. Borkar @gmail.com Road, Porvorim
9. S3 Res 20-02-2020 Suhas Ramkrishna M 78 Flat No. S3, 7020046909 rs.nagarsekar
Sinai Nagarsekar Kamat Prime @gmail.com
B.B. Borkar Road, Porvorim
10. T3 Res 20-02-2020 Zeferino Luciano M 58 Flat No. T3, 9637093958 zeferinoc
Castro Kamat Prime, @yahoo.com
B.B. Borkar Road, Porvorim
*Type: Comm-Commercial, Res-Residential.
Any claims/objections/omission or error in respect of the name or address or other particulars in the list may be brought to the notice of the Assistant Registrar, Mapusa in writing by any member of the Society who is a voter, during office hours within 15 days from the date of publication of the provisional list of voters
Sd/-, Chairperson/Secretary
Porvorim, 27th December, 2023.
————
Final list of Voters of Kamat Prime Co-op. Housing Society Ltd.
Sr. Unit Type* Admission Name of Gender Age Address Phone Email No date voting member
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1. Shop# Comm 20-02-2020 Rohan Ramesh Kamat M 35 501, Kamat 9822980269 rohan.kamat 1 & 2
Metropolis- @kamat -II, St. Inez, reality.com Panaji 403001
2. Shop# Comm 09-01-2021 Jerome Marcel Lewis M 69 H. No. 264/ 9326101004 joelewis3108 3 & 4 Joint Member: /75, Near @gmail.com
Theresa Lewis Gautam Hotel,
Pilerne, Bardez- -Goa 403114
3. UG3 Res 20-02-2020 Dr. Rohit Vishwanath M 59 H. No. 1571, 9822482010 rvhede@
Hede "SITEJ", B. B. gmail.com Joint Member: Borkar Road, Shanta Rohit Hede Penha de
Franca, Alto Porvorim 403521 OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
4. F1 Res 20-02-2020 Anjali Arun Sardessai F 56 633/1, Nandan 9822385399 anjali.
Bungalow, sardessai@ Law College gmail.com Road, Miramar, Caranzalem, P. O. 403002
5. F2 Res 20-02-2020 Sheela Dhume F 73 Flat No. F2, 9604559962 sheela.dhume
Kamat Prime, @gmail.com B. B. Borkar Rd, Porvorim
6. F3 Res 20-02-2020 Madhav Shivaji M 55 Flat No. F3, 9923063318
Sinai Desai Kamat Prime,
B. B. Borkar
Road,
Porvorim
7. S1 Res 20-02-2020 Milan Vilas F 78 711/64, 9511746872 vilasbhangui Bhangui Green Hill @gmail.com Joint Member: Society, Vilas B. Bhangui Soccorro,
Bardez 403501
8. S 2 Res 20-02-2020 Shailaja Shashikant F 65 Flat No. S2, 9822385346 shailasardessai Sardessai Kamat Prime, @gmail.com Joint Member: B. B. Borkar Richa S. Sardessai Road, Porvorim
9. S3 Res 20-02-2020 Suhas Ramkrishna M 78 Flat No. S3, 7020046909 rs.nagarsekar
Sinai Nagarsekar Kamat Prime, @gmail.com
B. B. Borkar Road, Porvorim
10. T3 Res 20-02-2020 Zeferino Luciano M 58 Flat No. T3, 9637093958 zeferinoc
Castro Kamat Prime, @yahoo.com
B.B. Borkar Road, Porvorim
*Type: Comm-Commercial, Res-Residential.
Sd/- Chairperson/Treasurer.
Porvorim, 11th January, 2024.
————
Kamson Residency Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. Reg. No. HSG(b)-243/NZ/GOA dated 11-07-2005 Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa
email: [email protected]
—–––
Provisional List of Members
Sr. No. Flat No. Name of Member Address
1 2 3
4
1. AF-1 Devdutta Sail AF-1, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd., Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
2. AF-2 Chetan Achrekar AF-2, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd., Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 20241 2 3
4
3. AF-3 Purshottam/Dhiraj Borkar AF-3, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
4. AG-1 Suraj Jannakunavar AG-1, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
5. AG-2 Nilkanth Prabhu AG-2, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
6. AG-3 Kirti Sawaikar AG-3, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
7. AG-4 Sangeeta Chikhalika AG-4, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
8. AS-1 Pankaj Kumar Singh AS-1, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
9. AS-2 Domnick Fernandes AS-2, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
10. AS-3 Narendra Prabhugaonkar AS-3, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
11. BF-1 Vandana Bale BF-1, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
12. BF-2 Mandar Bale BF-2, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
13. BF-3 Vaishali Dabolkar BF-3, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
14. BG-1 Seema Singh BG-1, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
15. BG-2 Govardhan Gaonkar BG-2, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
16. BG-3 Usha Channabassappa BG-3, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
17. BG-4 Mandar Bale BG-4, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
18. BS-1 Dheesona Sen BS-1, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
19. BS-2 Venkatesh Warkar BS-2, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
20. BS-3 Gopal Sawant BS-3, Kamson Residency Co-op. Hsg. Scty. Ltd.,
Salvador-Do-Mundo, Alto Porvorim, Bardez-Goa.
Sd/-, Secretary.
Mapusa, 11th March, 2024.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024The Samrudhi Lifestyle Co-operative Housing Maintenance Society Ltd.,
Porvorim, Goa
—––––
ANNEXURE-E-1
Provisional List of Members of the Samrudhi Lifestyle Co-operative Housing Maintenance Society Ltd., as
on 31st March, 2023
Sr. Sr. No. in Name of the member and Date of No. of Remarks
No. the members his/her Flat/House No. admission fully
register to paid up
(G-Form) membership shares held
1 2 3 4 5 6
1. 1 Mr. Sandesh Raghvendra Prabhu, A-Bldg, S-3 08-09-2022 10
2. 2 Mrs. Tirthana Sunil Lotliker, B-Bldg, UG-1 08-09-2022 10
3. 3 Dr. Ehrlson Savio De Sousa, B-Bldg, F-1 08-09-2022 10
4. 4 Mr. Vinay Vithal Nayak, B-Bldg, S-1 08-09-2022 10
5. 5 Mr. Jagdeesh Goudappa Ambiger, A-Bldg, S-4 08-09-2022 10
6. 6 Mr. Dilip Vasant Sawant, A-Bldg, F-3 08-09-2022 10
7. 7 Mrs. Shraddha Prashant Naik, A-Bldg, UG-3 08-09-2022 10
8. 8 Mr. Rama Anant Shetye, B-Bldg, UG-2 08-09-2022 10
9. 9 Mrs. Kunda Vinayak Sardessai, A-Bldg, S-2 08-09-2022 10
10. 10 Mr. Ramchandra G. Gawade, A-Bldg, S-1 08-09-2022 10
11. 11 Mr. Kiran Sukdo Salunke, B-Bldg, S-2 08-09-2022 10
12. 12 Mrs. Rosy Barboza (alias) Rosy Vaz, A-Bldg, F-4 08-09-2022 10
13. 13 Mr. Ramesh Choudhary, A-Bldg, G-3 08-09-2022 10
14. 14 Mr. Dileep Bhiku Bandekar, A-Bldg, G-1 08-09-2022 10
15. 15 Mr. Purshottam Mulji Patel, Shop No. 6 08-09-2022 10
16. 16 Mr. Jacob Verghese, Shop No. 1 08-09-2022 10
17. 17 Mr. Sunil Laxman Zalmi, A-Bldg, F-2 08-09-2022 10
18. 18 Mr. Vilas Sadanand Naik, A-Bldg, UG-2 08-09-2022 10
19. 19 Mr. Bhupendra Patel, Shop No. 7 08-09-2022 10
20. 20 Mr. Sham Shetye, Shop No. 4 08-09-2022 — Share amount
not paid.
21. 21 Mr. Vikas Brahmdutt Churiwala, A-Bldg, G-4 08-09-2022 10
22. 22 Mr. Umesh G. Dessai, B-Bldg, T-2 08-09-2022 10
Sd/-, Secretary/Chairman.
Porvorim, 6th February, 2024.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024The Monarch Palms Co-op. Housing Society Ltd. Bamanwado, Candolim, Bardez-Goa —––
Provisional List of Voters of Monarch Palms Co-op. Housing Society Ltd.
Sr. No. Owner Name Bldg. Flat No. Emal Id Phone No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 1. Kevin Sequeira A 003 [email protected] 9822163964 2. Swapnil Gaur/Reetu Gaur A 004 [email protected], 9623197009 [email protected] 3. Manish Agarwal A 101 [email protected] 8828029351 4. Sydney Barboza A 103 [email protected] 9819478355 5. Sri Chaudhary A 104 [email protected] 9867156564 6. Francisco M. Pereira A 203 [email protected] 9822163964 7. Gordon Pereira/Beaula G. Pereira A 204 [email protected] 7738827414 8. Udit Aggarwal A 302 [email protected] 9540062222 9. Gunjan Grover A 303 [email protected] 9873350208 10. Maurice Gomes A 304 [email protected] 9820737963 11. Om Prakash Dwivedi B 001 [email protected] 7720905567 12. Gaurav Setia B 002 [email protected] 8805105352 13. Sunil Mohan Sukhani B 003 [email protected] 8999921658 14. Shankar Chandu Sukhani B 004 [email protected] 9960806688 15. Domnic Coutinho B 101 [email protected] 9822381013 16. Judy Desouza Lobo/Linus Michael B 102 [email protected]/ 9620447540 Lobo [email protected] 17. Judy Desouza Lobo/Linus Michael B 103 [email protected]/ 9620447540 Lobo [email protected] 18. Barbara Zuzarte/Rex Zuzarte B 201 [email protected] 7066616151 19. Rex Zuzarte/Barbara Zuzarte B 204 [email protected] 7066616151 20. Gurpreet Deshpal Sethi B 302 [email protected] 9820151025 21. Nishant Chaudhary C 001 [email protected] 9910908720 22. Meer Singh HUF C 002 [email protected] 9910908720 23. Meer Singh C 003 [email protected] 9910908720 24. Prashant Chaudhary C 004 [email protected] 9910908720 25. Rashmi Joshi/Deepak Joshi C 101 [email protected] 9654328735 26. Amit Gaur C 102 [email protected] 8802556677 27. Farida Konarwala C 104 [email protected] 9821135165 28. Prashant Pant C 201 [email protected] 9676222330 29. Neil Pinheiro C 202 [email protected] 9821111206 30. Marlon Peter Gomes C 203 [email protected] 9820085129 31. Alo Pal C 204 [email protected] 8906059655 32. Saroj G. Godekar C 301 [email protected] 9049584268 33. Lyandra J. Dsouza/Iris E. D'souza C 302 [email protected] 9820051246 34. Romel Monteiro C 303 [email protected] 9820700213 35. Archana Rani C 304 [email protected] 9868156954 36. Amit Bakshi D 001 [email protected] 9958818899OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024
1 2 3 4 5 6 37. Kalyan Shirodkar D 002 [email protected] 9822585023 38. Rajiv Chabra D 003 [email protected] 9818460259 39. Pravin Shirodkar D 004 [email protected] 9822585023 40. Meghna Vaikul D 101 [email protected] 9833533235 41. Mandar Sherlekar D 102 [email protected] 9833533235 42. Glanvet Barretto/Joseph Barretto D 103 [email protected] 9833800532 43. Antoneta Clara Vaz/Natasha D 104 [email protected] 9423059886 Perpetua Vaz 44. Jacinta Jose Fernandes/Jose RC D 201 [email protected] 9820753661 Fernandes 45. Azra Makarem D 202 [email protected] 9326138650 46. Raj Jacob Kollenchery/Vivian M. Raj D 301 [email protected] 9845273233 47. Geetha Menon D 302 [email protected] 9560655811 48. Rajesh Kumar D 303 [email protected] 9868156954 49. Abhay Pawar D 304 [email protected] 9892118027 50. Yogandar Singh E 001 [email protected] 9868357736 51. Raghini Singh E 002 [email protected] 9868357736 52. Arvind Sequeira/Meena S. E 003 [email protected] 9823160126 53. Rita Sadwelkar E 004 abhay [email protected]/ 9822167840 [email protected] 54. Mario Felix Fernandes/Sharon E 101 [email protected]/ 9867508018 Fernandes [email protected] 55. Thomas Felix Rodrigues/ E 103 [email protected] 9029490964 Yvette Anna Rodrigues 56. Christilina Almeida E 104 [email protected] 971507061383 57. Pradeep Rathod E 201 [email protected] 9822336494 58. Gopal S. Shanbhag/Anitha G. E 203 [email protected] 9900684918 Shanbhag 59. Stella Ida Dsilva/John Nocolaus E 204 [email protected] 965-90920960 60. Asha Gedam E 301 ash [email protected] 8879643788 61. Salil A. Pawar E 303 [email protected] 9892118027 62. Davinder Singh Grover E 304 [email protected] 9212404101 63. Abhijit R. Belhe/Archana A, Belhe F 001 abhijit [email protected] 9850553008 64. Tulio Faria F 002 [email protected] 9890074339 65. Constantine Fonseca F 003 [email protected] 9823746061 66. Remedios Teresa Mascarenhas F 004 [email protected] 9850929862 67. Eshwar Chawan F 101 [email protected] 8888880207 68. Savio Ribeiro F 201 [email protected] 8999368389 69. Niranjan Pereira F 202 [email protected] 7843016906 70. Dr. Neel Amonkar F 203 vikas [email protected] 9823196361 71. Dr. Roshan A. Nazareth F 204 [email protected] 9372170545 72. Alka Agarwal F 301 [email protected] 9322274464 73. Farul Agarwal F 304 [email protected] 8828029351
Sd/-, Mr. Nishant Chaudhary, Chairman and Mr. Rajesh Kumar, Secretary.
Mapusa, 5th March, 2024.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024Goa Human Rights Commission
Office of the Goa Human Rights Commission
–– Before the Goa Human Rights Commission Panaji-Goa
Proceeding No. 76/2023
Shri Edwin Vaz, Ex-Vocational Instructor (P), R/o. House No. 84, No Bairo, Amboi, P. O. Piedade, Tiswadi-Goa …… Complainant.
V/s
The Director,
Directorate of Skill Development &
Entrepreneurship,
3rd Floor, Shrama Shakti Bhavan,
Patto, Panaji-Goa …… Respondent.
whether increments granted to the appellant, while he was in service, can be recovered from him almost 10 years after his retirement on the ground that the said increments were granted on account of an error. In para (9), the Supreme Court noted that the Court in a catena of decisions has consistently held that if the excess amount was not paid on account of any misrepresentation or fraud of the employee or if such excess payment was made by the employer by applying a wrong principle for calculating the pay/allowance or on the basis of a particular interpretation of rule/order which is subsequently found to be erroneous, such excess payment of emoluments or allowances are not recoverable. In para 28, it held that such relief, restraining back recovery of excess payment, is granted by courts not because of any right in the employees, but in equity, in exercise of judicial discretion to relieve the employees from the hardship that will be caused if recovery is implemented.
INQUIRY REPORT
(18th January, 2024)
The complaint was received from the Complainant on 16-03-2023, stating that he had retired as a Vocational Instructor from the Directorate of Skill Development & Entrepreneurship, Panaji, on 30-06-2016. He found that an amount of Rs. 1,30,556/- was recovered from his Gratuity towards overpayment made to him from January 2006 to 30-06-2016, by corrigendum dated 05-07-2016, after his retirement. He stated that he had made representations to the Respondent but the same was not considered by the Government. Accordingly, he filed the present complaint for refund of his dues of Rs. 1,30,556/-.
2. On perusing the complaint, the Commission by Order dated 06-12-2023, called for the report from the Respondent.
3. The Respondent filed their report dated 08-01-2024 conceding that the amount of Rs. 1,30,556/- was recovered from his retirement graturty.
4. The Commission heard the Complainant and heard Ms. Siya Parsekar, Office Superintendant, on behalf of the Respondent.
5. In their reply, the Respondent stated that they had moved a proposal to give the benefits to the Complainant to the Finance (R & C) Department but the same was not considered.
6. Before the Division Bench of the Supreme Court of India, in Civil Appeal No. 7115 of 2010, Thomas Daniel Versus State of Kerala & Ors., decided by Judgment dated 2nd May, 2022, the issue was as to 7. In State of Punjab and Others v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) and Others, (2015) 4 SCC 334, in Para 18, it held as under:
"18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship which would govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as a ready reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees who are due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment has been made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even though he should have rightfully been required to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of the employer's right to recover." OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024 8. The respondent in their reply dated 08-01-2024
have stated that two other Ex-Group Instructors,
Shri Stephen Coutinho and Shri Sudhir S. Kubde
had earlier approached this Commission and based
on the Inquiry Reports dated 08-11-2022, the
amounts deducted of these two have been now
refunded. But as the present complainant was not 14. Copy of the Inquiry Report be sent to the
Respondent, calling for their comments, including
the action taken or proposed to be taken within a
period of 60 days or on or before 19-03-2024, in terms
of Section 18(e) of the Protection of Human Rights
Act, 1993.
before this Commission earlier, his request was not considered by the Finance Department.
9. As held by the Supreme Court in (2015) 4 SCC 334 (Supra), recoveries from the retired
employees or the employees who are due to retire
within one year of the order of recovery, are
impermissable. So also recoveries from Group 'C and D
Government employees was barred.
10. The respondent, in their reply, in para 6, had
in fact stated that the Central Government had
issued the office memorandum dated 02-03-2016,
regarding waving of recovery of wrongful/excess
payments made to Group 'C' Government servants,
which was adopted by the Government of Goa and
circulated vide office Memorandum dated
07-03-2017.
11. The Commission finds that the complainant
herein, who was a Group C employee, had retired
on superannuation on 30-06-2016. Thereafter by
corrigendums dated 05-07-2016, the excess amounts
paid of Rs. 1,30,556/-, were ordered to be recovered
from his Gratuity amount, which was impermissible.
12. In the facts of the present case, the
Commission accordingly recommends to the
Respondent that in view of the law laid down by
the Supreme Court as outlined above, the
Respondent pursues the matter afresh with the
Finance Department for refund of the said amount
of Rs. 1,30,556/- (Rupees one lakh thirty thousand
five hundred fifty six only), to the Complainant.
13. Under Section 18(e) of the Protection of Human
Rights Act, 1993, the Commission shall send a copy of
the Inquiry Report together with its
recommendations to the concerned Government or
authority and they shall, within a period of one
month or such further time as the Commission may
allow, forward its comments on the report, including
the laction taken or proposed to be taken, to the
Commission.
Date: 18-01-2024. Place: Panaji-Goa.
———
Directorate of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship Shram Shakti Bhavan, 3rd Floor, Patto Plaza, Panaji-Goa ——
O rd er
No. DSDE/EST/Rec./2017/4151
In pursuance of Inquiry Report/Order dated 18-01-2024 passed by Hon'ble Human Rights Commission in proceeding No. 76/2023 together with its recommendation in terms of Section 18(e) of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.
Whereas, Shri Edwin Vaz, Ex-Vocational Instructor (P) of Directorate of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship, Panaji retired on attaining the age of superannuation on 30-06-2016 (a.n.) and the pension has been authorized under the Pension Payment Order No. GOA-A/22186.
2. And whereas, an amount of 1,30,556/- (Rupees one lakh thirty thousand five hundred and fifty-six only) was recovered from the retirement gratuity (DCRG) of Shri Edwin Vaz, Ex-Vocational Instructor (P) on account of overpayment of pay and allowances for the period from 01-01-2006 to 30-06-2016.
3. And whereas, the representation dated 25-11-2019 was placed before the Government for a refund of an amount of Rs. 1,30,556/- (Rupees one lakh thirty thousand five hundred and fifty-six only) so deducted from DCRG in terms of O.M. No. F. No. 18/03/2015/Estt (Pay-I) dated 02-03-2016 adopted by Government of Goa vide O.M. No. 8/7/2008 Fin (R & C) dated 07-03-2017.
4. And whereas, Finance (R & C) Department have instructed to fix the responsibility on the officials responsible for overpayment and to recover the amount from them.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 20245. And whereas, aggrieved with the recoveries of the aforesaid amount, Shri Edwin Vaz, Ex-Vocational Instructor (P) approached the Hon'ble Human Rights Commission on 16-03-2023 against the decision of the Government.
6 . A n d whereas, Hon'ble Human Rights Commission vide Inquiry Report/Order dated 18-01-2024 in proceeding No. 76/2023 recommends to the Respondent to pursue the matter afresh with the Finance (R&C) Department for refund of the said amount of Rs. 1,30,556/- (Rupees one lakh thirty thousand five hundred and fifty-six only), to the complainant Shri Edwin Vaz.
7. And whereas, upon the instructions of the Hon'ble Human Rights Commission, the matter was placed before the Government and the Finance (R&C) Department for its concurrence on 29-01-2024.
8. And whereas, the Government has inter alia accepted the recommendation of Hon'ble Human Rights Commission, which are in line with Hon'ble Supreme Court vide U.O. No. 11051/F dated 28-12-2024.
9. Now therefore, sanction of the Government is hereby accorded to refund an amount of Rs. 1,30,556/- (Rupees one lakh thirty thousand five hundred and fifty six only) to the complainant Shri Edwin Vaz.
The Assistant Account Officer of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship, Panaji is hereby authorized to draw and disburse the amount.
The above expenditure shall be debited to the Budget Head from where Shri Edwin Vaz was drawing his pay and allowances.
This isues with the concurrence of Finance (R&C) Department vide U.O. No. 1400086179 dated 05-03-2024.
By order and in the name of the Governor of
Goa.
S. S. Gaonkar, Director (Skill Development &
Entrepreneurship) & ex officio Jt. Secretary.
Panaji, 15th March, 2024.
————
Before the Goa Human Rights Commission Panaji-Goa
Proceeding No. 106/2022
Urmila Umesh Gaonkar, H. No. 226, Paltadwada. Maulinguem-Goa …… Complainant.
V/s
1. The Director General of Police,
Police Headquarters,
Panaji-Goa
2. The Incharge,
Fire Station,
Ona, Maulinguem,
Bicholim-Goa …… Respondents.
INQUIRY REPORT
(22nd February, 2024)
The complaint dated 07-06-2022, was received from the Complainant praying for compensation on account of the wound caused to her resulting from the bullet fired at the Lakherem Firing Range of the Goa Police at Bicholim-Goa.
2. On perusing the complaint, the Commission by Order dated 16-06-2022, issued notices to the two Respondents, i.e. (1) The Director General of Police, Police Headquarters, Panaji-Goa and (2) The Incharge, Firing Station, Ona, Maulinguem, Bicholim-Goa, calling for their replies.
3. The Respondent No. 1 filed their reply on 27-07-2022 and the Respondent No. 2 filed his reply on 21-07-2022.
4. Thereafter, the Complainant filed her two
Rejoinders to the two replies, on 10-11-2022.
5. The Commission heard Adv. Shri Rahul Kamat for the Complainant and Police Prosecutor, Mrs. A.R. Carvalho for the Respondents.
6. The Commission has gone through the complaint, the replies of the Respondents, the Rejoinders of the Complainant, the documents on record and has considered the submissions on behalf of the Complainant and on behalf of the Respondents.
7. The complaint had been filed stating that she resides at Maulinguem and at a distance of around 3 kms. from her house, there is a firing range of the Department of Police and on 27-01-2021, when she was working at her residence a bullet from a gun fired from the Lakherem Firing Range penetrated and hit her right leg. She took medical treatment for around eight to ten days but as the swelling of her leg had not disappeared, she was taken to the Goa Medical College on 03-02-2021, wherein she was admitted and she had to undergo a surgery for removing a bullet from her right leg and was discharged on 06-02-2021.
8. She stated that after her discharge, her physical capability to work was badly affected. It is her case that she was earning her daily livelihood by working OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024 in various houses and her husband is also a daily wage labourer. She has stated that due to the negligence of the Police Department, she has suffered and as such, she has approached this Commission for compensation from the Police Department.
9. The Respondent No. 1, i.e. the Director General of Police, filed his reply through the Superintendent of Police stating that they had obtained detailed reports from the Police Inspector, Bicholim Police Station and the Incharge, Firing Range, Ona Maulinguem, Bicholim-Goa.
10. The Respondent No. 1 stated that on 02-02-2021, the Bicholim Police Station had received written information from the Complainant that on 27-01-2021, a bullet projectile had hit her on the right leg and fallen in her courtyard and she had taken treatment at PHC, Bicholim. The Respondent No. 1 also stated that the spot of the incident was jointly examined at the residence of the Complainant and it was revealed that the distance between the residence of the Complainant and the firing range is around 3 kms. The Respondent No. 1 also stated that on 03-02-2021, she was referred for medical examination at Goa Medical College, Bambolim and it was revealed that a bullet projectile was inside the heel of her right leg and surgery was performed and the bullet projectile was removed from her leg. Consequently, Bicholim Police Station registered a case as Other Accident No. 01/2021 dated 03-02-2021.
11. So also, the Respondent No. 1 stated that the Sarpanch of Village Panchayat Ona-Maulinguem- -Kudchirem had submitted a letter dated 02-02-2021, to the Bicholim Police Station, requesting to take precautionary measures by erecting a safety wall around the firing range or to shift the same to some other convenient place to avoid any untoward incident in future. So also, the Sarpanch had filed a complaint with the DGP office that the Complainant had been hit by a bullet projectile while she was washing clothes at her residence and the Panchayat had also received complaints from three other persons stating that three bullets projectiles were found in their locality.
12. The Respondent No. 1 further stated that the Incharge of the Firing Range, conducted a detailed inquiry and the inquiry revealed that 'stray bullets had been flying over the hillock and landing in the village which is about two kilometers from the firing spot'. Thereupon, firing was stopped till further Orders and at present no firing practice is conducted at the Firing Range, Maulinguem, Bicholim-Goa.
13. The Respondent No. 2 had filed a reply on similar grounds and stated that there was no negligence on the part of Goa Police Department as all precautionary measures were taken at the Firing Range at the time of firing practice to ensure safety and security of the villagers residing in the surrounding areas.
14. In her Rejoinders, the Complainant reiterated that the gunshot fired from the Firing Range travels over the hills and falls in the village of Maulinguem on several occasions and denied that the firing had stopped after the incident with the Complainant.
15. The Commission has considered the submissions of Adv. Shri Rahul Kamat on behalf of the Complainant and of Police Prosecutor Mrs. A.R. Carvalho on behalf of the Respondents.
16. The undisputed fact emerges that the Complainant had sustained a bullet injury on the heel of her right leg on 27-01-2021 and she was eventually hospitalized at the Goa Medical College, Bambolim, where she underwent a surgery and the bullet was removed on 03-02-2021. Though the Police Prosecutor contended that there was no negligence on the part of the Respondents and the Complainant may have come close to the firing range despite the warnings, the fact that the bullet was fired from the Firing Range is not denied by the Respondents. The complaint and the subsequent developments indicate that the Complainant had sustained an injury near her residence at Maulinguem, when she was washing clothes in her courtyard.
17. Again, though the learned Police Prosecutor submitted that the maximum range of the projectile fired from the gun is 1350 meters and the residence of the Complainant is beyond that distance, the very reply of the Respondent No. 1 admits that the inquiry conducted by the Police Department reveals that stray bullets had been flying over the hillock and landing in the village which is about two kilometers from the firing spot, as found in para 7 of the reply of the Respondent No. 1 dated 27-07-2022.
18. The complaint had been filed before the Bicholim Police Station by the Complainant on 02-02-2021 regarding the bullet injury sustained by her on 27-01-2021 and the reply of the Respondent No. 1 again indicates that the Bicholim Police Station had registered a case as Other Accident No. 1/2021 dated 03-02-2021.
19. There is also a letter dated 02-02-2021, which is written by the Sarpanch of Village Panchayat Ona, Maulignem, Kudchirem to the Police Inspector of the Bicholim Police Station regarding this incident and suggesting to construct a safety wall OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024 around the Firing Range or to shift the same to some other convenient place to avoid any untoward incident in future.
20. The discharge card of the Complainant of the Goa Medical College, Bambolim, indicates that she was admitted on 03-02-2021 and discharged on 06-02-2021 and was found to have a bullet injury and she was operated on and the bullet was removed.
21. Under Section 2(d) of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, "Human Rights" means the rights relating to life, liberty, equality and dignity of the individual guaranteed by the Constitution or embodied In the International Covenants and enforceable by Courts in India.
22. In Union Carbide Corporation and Ors. v. Union of India and Ors. [1991] 4 S.C.C. 584, the Supreme Court stated that we have to develop our own law and if we find that it is necessary to construct a new principle of liability to deal with an unusual situation which has arisen and which is likely to arise in future, there is no reason why we should hesitate to evolve such principle of liability.
23. In the case of Joginder Kaur v. The Punjab
State and Ors., 1996 ACJ 193, (1995) 109 PLR 117,
it was held as under:-
"In the matter of liability of the State for the tort committed by its employees, it is now the settled law that the State is liable for tortious acts committed by its employees in the course of their employment".
24. In N. Nagendra Rao v. State of AP, AIR 1994
SC 2663, the Supreme Court held that the State is vicariously liable and bound, constitutionally legally and morally, to compensate and indemnify the wronged person.
25. The Supreme Court has always leaned in favour of a welfare state. Hence, wrong committed by a government servant can be attributable to the State and can be compensated.
26. In the facts of the present case, and guided by the case laws cited above, the Commission agrees with the submissions of the learned Advocate for the Complainant that the Complainant has made out violation of her human rights due to the actions of the Respondents in conducting their firing practices, resulting in a bullet travelling beyond the Firing Range and injuring the Complainant. The acts of the Respondents resulted in injury to the Complainant and loss of work to her for over three months as well as pain and suffering.
27. Considering that she was working as a
domestic helper and that the wages in Goa for such
work were around Rs. 12,000 per month, for "Loss of
wages", for three months, she is entitled for
Rs. 36,000/- and for "Pain and Suffering"due to the
injury, Rs. 14,000/- is a reasonable amount. Thereby,
we find that Rs. 50,000/- can be considered the
quantum of Loss to her, resulting from the acts of
the Respondents.
28. Under Section 18(a) (i) of the Protection of
Human Rights Act, 1993, the Commission may take
any of the following steps during or upon the
completion of an inquiry held under this Act,
namely:-
(a) where the inquiry discloses the commission of
violation of human rights or negligence in the
prevention of violation of human rights or abetment thereof by a public servant, it may recommend to the concerned Government or authority—
(i) to make payment of compensation or damages to the complainant or to the victim or the members of his family as the Commission may consider necessary:
29. The Commission considers that the Complainant is entitled for compensation of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand only) from the Respondent No.1 as she had sustained the bullet injury from the bullet which had travelled from the Firing Range operated by the Respondent No. 1 at the Firing Station at Ona, Maulinguem.
30. Accordingly, the Commission recommends that the Respondent No. 1 pays compensation of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand only) to the Complainant, within 30 days from today, alongwith simple interest thereon at 6% p.a. from the date of the complaint i.e. 07-06-2022 till final payment.
31. The Commission notes as stated in the replies of the Respondents that the Firing Range at Maulingem has been closed down. This was also submitted by the Police Prosecutor at the time of arguments. Accordingly in this respect, no relief is necessary from the Commission.
32. Under Section 18(e) of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, the Commission shall send a copy of the Inquiry Report together with its recommendations to the concerned Government or authority and they shall, within a period of one month or such further time as the Commission may allow, forward its comments on the report, including the action taken or proposed to be taken, to the Commission.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 202433. Copy of the Inquiry Report be sent to the Respondent No. 1, calling for their comments, including the action taken or proposed to be taken within a period of 30 days or on or before 26-03-2024, in terms of Section 18(e) of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.
6% p.a. from the date of the complaint i.e. 07-06-2022 till final payment.
Further, at para No. 32 & 33 of the Inquiry Report, the Hon'ble Commission has called for comments from the concerned authority/Respondent No.1 including the action taken or proposed to be taken within period of 30 days or on or before 26-3-224, in terms of Section 18(e) of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.
In view of the above, it is submitted that the Date: 22-02-2024.
Place: Panaji-Goa.
—––––
Superintendent of Police, Legal and Vigilance
Office of the Director General of Police
PHQ, Panaji-Goa 403001
No. PHQ/PET-CELL/GHRC/BICH-19/22/433/2024 dtd. 15-3-2024
To,
The Secretary,
The Goa Human Rights Commission,
O/o The Goa Human Rights Commission,
Old Education Department Bldg.,
18th June Road, Panaji-Goa.
Sub.: Compliance in respect of Inquiry Report
dated 22-02-2024 passed by the Hon'ble Goa
Human Rights Commission in Proceeding
No. 16/22022.
Sir/Madam,
With reference to the above, I am directed to
submit that in the above proceeding No. 106/2022
into the complaint filed by Smt. Urmila Umesh
Gaonkar, r/o. H. No. 226, Paltadwada, Maulinguem
Goa v/s. Respondent No. (1) The Director General of
Police, PHQ, Panaji-Goa and Respondent No. (2) The
Incharge, Firing Station, Ona, Maulinguem,
Bicholim Goa before the Goa Human Rights
Commission, Panaji-Goa the Hon'ble Goa Human
Rights Commission has passed the following
recommendations at para No. 30:-
That Respondent No.1 pays compensation of
Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand only) to the
complainant, within 30 days from date of issue
Inquiry Report alongwith simple interest thereon at Respondent No. 1 i.e. Director General of Police Goa,
has applied for approval of the Government to stay
and challenge the Inquiry Report of the Hon'ble
GHRC by filing Writ Petition before the High Court
of Bombay at Goa. As soon as approval of the
Government is granted, further action will be
initiated and the same will be intimated to the
Commission.
Yours faithfully
Sunita Sawant
Superintendent of Police (L&V),
for Director General of Police.
——————
Notification by the High Court of Judicature
Appellate Side, Bombay
––––
No. A-3924/G/2024/874
Subject: Grant of First Assured Career Progression Scale (A.C.P.-I) to the Judicial Officers in the Cadre of Civil Judge, Senior Division as per the recommendations of the Honourable Shetty Commission, the directions of the Honourable Supreme Court in All India Judges' Association V/s Union of India and Others [Writ Petition No. (C) 643/2015] and revised Pay Scale as per recommendations of the Honourable Reddy Commission.
The High Court is pleased to confer the First Assured Career Progression Scale i.e. Rs. 122700/- up to next level of pay on the following Judicial Officers in the cadre of Senior Civil Judges w.e.f. the dates shown against their respective names. Accordingly, the concerned Head of the departments shall refix the pay of these Officers as per the Order No. 8/44/97-Fin (R & C)-FPC/Part IV dated 8th May, 2003 issued by the Government of Goa in Finance (Rev. & Cont.) Department and other relevant orders/circulars/judgments.
OFFICIAL GAZETTE — GOVT. OF GOA SERIES II No. 2 12TH APRIL, 2024Sr. Judge Name of the Date of actual Date of Present posting No. Code Judicial Officer charge taken conferment of A.C.P.-I
1 2 3 4 5 6
1. 100040 Ms. Apurva Ramnath Nagvekar 30-04-2016 30-04-2021 Ad-hoc DJ-1 Panaji North Goa.
and Asstt. Sessions Judge
2. 100043 Ms. Saee Anil Prabhudessai 20-12-2016 20-12-2021 Ad-hoc DJ-2 Panaji North Goa.
and Asstt. Sessions Judge
3. 100044 Ms. Artikumari Nagba Naik 12-02-2018 12-02-2023 CJSD & Quepem South Goa.
JMFC
4. 100046 Ms. Shilpa Shashikant Pandit 03-09-2018 03-09-2023 CJSD & Mapusa North Goa.
JMFC
High Court, Bombay.
R. N. JOSHI,
Dated: 2nd April, 2024.
Registrar General.
www.goaprintingpress.gov.in
Published and Printed by the Director, Printing & Stationery, Government Printing Press, Mahatma Gandhi Road, Panaji-Goa 403 001.
PRICE–Rs. 16.00
PRINTED AT THE GOVERNMENT PRINTING PRESS, PANAJI-GOA—10/80—4/2024.