झारख(cid:214)ड गजट
असाधारण अंक
झारख(cid:214)ड सरकार (cid:622)वारा (cid:292)का(cid:871)शत
16 वैशाख, 1948 (श०)
सं(cid:201)या – 309 राँची, बुधवार, 6 मई, 2026 (ई०)
वन, पया(cid:330)वरण एवं जलवायु प(cid:303)रवत(cid:330)न कवभाग
-------
अकधसूचना
30 अ(cid:292)ैल, 2026
सं(cid:421)ा- 02/भावसे ((cid:830)था)- 03/2018- 1629--कदनां ि29.08.2016 र्ोि स(cid:636)(cid:580) कवभागीय चयन सकमकत ीि अनुंसा ेि आर्लो िम(cid:336) (cid:373)ी आरआर हे(cid:640)म, भावसे (झा-83) ीि (cid:366)धान मु(cid:421) वन संर(cid:407) ि(HoFF) ेि पद पर कनयु(cid:304)(cid:389) ीि गई थी। उ(cid:389) कनयु(cid:304)(cid:389) ेि कव(cid:349)(cid:544) (cid:373)ी (cid:366)दीप ुि मार, कदनां ि30.09.2016 र्ोि सेवाकनवृत भावसे (झा- 82) (cid:554)ारा माननीय Central Administrative Tribunal, Patna Bench, Circuit Bench Ranchi म(cid:336) ए ि वाद सं(cid:421)ा- OA/051/00132/2016 दायर कयिा गया। उ(cid:389) वाद म(cid:336) माननीय (cid:586)ायाकधरिण (cid:554)ारा कदनांि-24.05.2017 (cid:554)ारा कन(cid:635) आदे पा(cid:303)रत कयिा गया-
"In view of the aforesaid facts, we are constrained and compelled to conclude that Sri R.R. Hembrom was not holding the post of PCCF and thus not eligible to be considered for HoFF when the SCM took place at about 3.30 PM on 29.08.2016. Consequently, in our considered opinion, the applicant was the sole eligible candidate for selection as HoFF at that time.
In conclusion, the selection committee proceeding dated 29.08.2016 for HoFF and consequent notification No. 4106 dated 01.09.2016 selecting and notifying Shri R.R. Hembrom to2 झारख(cid:214)ड गजट (असाधारण) बुधवार, 6 मई, 2026 the post of HoFF in the pay scale of Rs. 80,000/- (Fixed) are quashed and set aside as being illegal as he was not eligible for the post. The respondent State of Jharkhand is at liberty to convene a Selection Committee meeting for selection to this post as per law. Since the applicant has retired in the meanwhile, the respondent authorities are directed to consider granting him notional benefit and pension fixation in the Apex Pay Scale, if found suitable as on 29.08.2016. No order as to costs." 2. माननीय (cid:586)ायाकधरिण ेि उपयु (cid:330)(cid:389) कनदे ेि अनुपालन म(cid:336) कदनांि-05.07.2017 र्ोि कवभागीय चयन सकमकत ीि बैठ िआर्योकजत ीि गई। उ(cid:389) बैठ िम(cid:336) कदनां ि29.08.2016 र्ोि (cid:373)ी हे(cid:640)म ेि अलावा ेष र्यो(cid:438) पदाकधाि(cid:303)रयं, कजनम(cid:336) (cid:373)ी (cid:366)दीप ुि मार ाि नाम भी ाकमल था, पर कवचार कयिा गया था। (cid:373)ी ुि मार ीि वष(cid:330) 2009-10 से 2014-15 त िीि अवकध म(cid:336) ए ि एसीआर ीि अ(cid:631)ु(cid:304)(cid:389) ((cid:715र्)ोर- 7) आउट(cid:720)(cid:339)कडंग ीि (cid:373)ेणी म(cid:336) नहीं आने एवं उ(cid:590)(cid:336) 06.05.2011 र्ोि कन(cid:573)न ाि द(cid:503) अकधर्रोकपत र्होने ेि (cid:778)क(cid:700)पथ उ(cid:389) पद ेि चयन हेतु र्यो(cid:438) नहीं माना।
3. सकमकत ेि अनुंसा ेि आर्लो ि म(cid:336) रा(cid:475) सरािर ने यह कनण(cid:330)य कलया क ि (cid:373)ी ुि मार कदनांि-29.08.2016 र्ोि (cid:366)धान मु(cid:421) वन संर(cid:407) ि(HoFF) ेि पद पर कनयु(cid:304)(cid:389) हेतु र्यो(cid:438) नहीं थे। एतद् कवषय िकवभागीय आदे (cid:466)ापांि-2928, कदनांि-17.07.2017 ेि (cid:554)ारा कनग(cid:330)त आदे ीि (cid:366)कत (cid:373)ी ुि मारर् ोि भी (cid:366)ेकषत ीि गई।
4. (cid:373)ी ुि मार (cid:554)ारा कवभागीय आदे (cid:466)ापन सं(cid:421)ा- 2928, कदनांि-17.07.2017 र्ोि quash रिने तथा उ(cid:590)(cid:336) कदनांि-29.08.2016 ेि (cid:366)भाव से (cid:366)धान मु(cid:421) वन संर(cid:407) ि (HoFF) ेि वेतनमान म(cid:336) Notionally select रि तद् नुसार उनेि प(cid:336)नर् ोि र्संोकधत रिने ेि संबंध म(cid:336) माननीय Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Patna Bench, Circuit Bench Ranchi म(cid:336) ए िवाद सं- OA/051/00130/2017दायर कयिा गया।
5. माननीय (cid:586)ायाकधरिण (cid:554)ारा उ(cid:389) वाद म(cid:336) कदनांि-10.08.2018 र्ोि पा(cid:303)रत आदे ाि ऑपरे कटव पाट(cid:330) कन(cid:635)वत् ह(cid:339)ः -
"12. Be that as it may, the applicant has already superannuated from service on 30.09.2016.
Even if it is held that he has been unfairly ignored for the post of PCCF (HOFF), he cannot be brought back to the said post now. We, therefore, feel that ends of justice would be met only by allowing the applicant at least the pensionary benefits commensurate with the pay scale of PCCF (HOFF).
13. In the conspectus of the discussions in the foregoing paragraphs, the impugned order dated 17.07.2017 (Annexure A/2) is quashed and set aside. The respondents are directed to fix the pension of the applicant in the pay scale of PCCF (HOFF) i.e. Rs. 80,000 (Fixed) Pre-revised. We also direct that the applicant shall be given all consequential retiral benefits but without any interest.
14. The directions contained in para (13) shall be complied with by the respondents within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
15. The OA is disposed of accordingly. No order as to costs."3 झारख(cid:214)ड गजट (असाधारण) बुधवार, 6 मई, 2026 6. उ(cid:389) आदे ेि कव(cid:349)(cid:544) कवभाग (cid:554)ारा महाकधव(cid:389)ा से पराम(cid:330) (cid:366)ा(cid:593) रिते (cid:352)ए माननीय झारख(cid:503) उ(cid:452) (cid:586)ायालय, रँची म(cid:336) अपीलवाद सं(cid:421)ा- WP(S) No. 6206/2018दायर कयिा गया।
7. (cid:373)ी (cid:366)दीप ुि मार (cid:554)ारा OA/051/00130/2017 म(cid:336) माननीय CAT (cid:554)ारा कदनांि-10.08.2018 र्ोि पा(cid:303)रत आदे ेि (cid:354)म म(cid:336) CAT म(cid:336) अवमानना वाद- CP No.-89/2018 दायर कयिा गया।
8. WP(S) No. 6206/2018म(cid:336) कदनांि-05.02.2025 र्ोि पा(cid:303)रत (cid:586)ायादे ाि ािय(cid:330)ािरी अं कन(cid:635)वत् ह(cid:339)ः - "15. Selection Committee dated 17.07.2017 is that the competency and specific suitability for the post has been overshadowed by absence of outstanding merit and absolute integrity.
'Absolute Integrity' in the context of the selection would mean a high degree of integrity with moral and ethical values of the highest quality and non-compromising level of honesty accompanying the centre stage. As we have noticed above there is not much difference between the capability and competency of the respondent no. 1 and Sri A.K. Prabhakar in the context to the selection for the post of Principal Chief Conservator of Forest (HoFF) and in some of the APR's, the respondent no. 1 outshines and outweighs Sri A.K. Prabhakar. The only bottleneck seems to be the punishment of Censure imposed upon the respondent no. 1 which was also with effect from the year 1994 and which with the passage of time has lost its force. The respondent no. 1, therefore, fulfills the initial two conditions and such findings would automatically trigger his competence and suitability for the post of Principal Chief Conservator of Forest (HoFF).
16. The learned Central Administrative Tribunal in the impugned order dated 10.08.2018 has considered the relevant issues in its proper perspective and have accordingly quashed the decision of the Selection Committee as contained in Memo No. 2928 dated 17.07.2017 with a further direction to fix the pension of the respondent no. 1 in the Pay scale of Principal Chief Conservator of Forest (HoFF) along with all consequential retiral benefits but without any interest.
We do not find any reason to cause interference in such findings and consequently we dismiss this writ application.
17. Pending I.A.s, if any, stands closed.
9. कव(cid:554)ान महाकधव(cid:389)ा से पराम(cid:330) (cid:366)ा(cid:593) रि माननीय सव(cid:342)(cid:452) (cid:586)ायालय म(cid:336) Special Leave Petition दायर कयिा गया, कजसाि डायरी सं(cid:421)ा- 38560/2025 ह(cid:339)। वाद म(cid:336) माननीय (cid:586)ायालय (cid:554)ारा कदनांि-14.11.2025 र्ोि कन(cid:635) आदे पा(cid:303)रत कयिा गया ह(cid:339)-
2. Delay condoned.
3. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.
4. Having considered the contentions made across the Bar, we do not find any reason to grant Special Leave to Appeal.
5. As such, the present Special Leave Petition is dismissed, leaving the question of law open.
4 झारख(cid:214)ड गजट (असाधारण) बुधवार, 6 मई, 20266. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
10. (cid:373)ी (cid:366)दीप ुि मार, भावसे (सेवाकनवृत) ेि संबंध म(cid:336) मंक(cid:361)म(cid:503)ल सकचवालय एवं कनगरानी कवभाग (कनगरानी), झारख(cid:503), रँची तथा र्लोाियु(cid:389) ािया(cid:330)लय, झारख(cid:503), रँची से अ(cid:552)तन (cid:738)(cid:453)ता (cid:366)माण-प(cid:361) (cid:366)ा(cid:593) ह(cid:339)। साथ ही आंत(cid:303)र ि आर्रोप ीि अ(cid:552)तन (cid:304)(cid:830)थकत भी (cid:366)ा(cid:593) ह(cid:339)। (cid:373)ी (cid:366)दीप ुि मार ेि कव(cid:349)(cid:544) स(cid:637)कत र्ोिई आर्रोप यथा- जांच/ाि(cid:503)/अकभर्योजन/कवभागीय ािय(cid:330)वाही संचाकलत/लंकबत नहीं ह(cid:339)।
11. झारख(cid:503) रा(cid:475) एवं अ(cid:586) बनाम (cid:366)दीप ुि मार म(cid:336) माननीय सव(cid:342)(cid:452) (cid:586)ायालय (cid:554)ारा कदनांि-14.11.2025 र्ोि पा(cid:303)रत (cid:586)ायादे ेि अनुपालन म(cid:336) (cid:373)ी (cid:366)दीप ुि मार, सेवाकनवृत भावसे पदाकधािरीर् ोि उनीि सेवाकनवृकत ीि कतकथ- 30.09.2016 ेि (cid:366)भाव से (cid:366)धान मु(cid:421) वन संर(cid:407) ि(HoFF) ेि वेतनमान (पे मैकट(cid:332) (cid:411) लेवल-17) म(cid:336) प(cid:336)न एवं प(cid:303)रणामी लाभं ेि कनधा(cid:330)रण ीि (cid:738)ीृि कत (cid:366)दान रिते (cid:352)ए कबना कसिी (cid:623)ाज ेि भुगतान ाि आदे कदया जाता ह(cid:339)।
12. उपयु (cid:330)(cid:389) (cid:366)(cid:721)ाव पर कदनांि-28.04.2026 र्ोि स(cid:636)(cid:580) बैठ ि म(cid:336) मद सं(cid:421)ा- 10 ेि (cid:349)प म(cid:336) मंक(cid:361)प(cid:303)रषद् ीि (cid:738)ीृि कत (cid:366)ा(cid:593) ह(cid:339)।
झारख(cid:503) रा(cid:475)पाल ेि आदे से,
अबुब(cid:383)र कस(cid:542)ीख पी,
सरािर ेि सकचव।
-------
अधी(cid:162)कअधी(cid:162)क,, झारख(cid:214)डझारख(cid:214)ड राजक(cid:551)य मु(cid:289)णालयराजक(cid:551)य मु(cid:289)णालय,, राँची (cid:622)वारा (cid:292)का(cid:871)शत एवं मु(cid:465)(cid:289)तराँची (cid:622)वारा (cid:292)का(cid:871)शत एवं मु(cid:465)(cid:289)त,, झारख(cid:214)ड गजट झारख(cid:214)ड गजट ((असाधारणअसाधारण) ) 330099 –– 5500