१ RNI No. MAHBIL/2012/46121
महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र
असाधारण भाग दोन
वर्ष ८, अंक ३३] गुरुवार, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ [ पृष्ठे ७५, किंमत : रुपये १२.००
असाधारण क्रमांक ६१
प्राधिकृत प्रकाशन
MUMBAI PORT AUTHORITY
No. FA/OEA-L/8(22)/Gen/36
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the power conferred on it under Sub-Section (1) of Section 27 of the Major Port Authorities Act, 2021 and Clause 7 of the Major Port Authorities (Fixation and Implementation of the Scale of Rates, Fees and Conditions) Rules, 2021, the Board of Mumbai Port Authority (Board) has approved to adopt existing Scale of Rates, Fees and Conditions in respect of TAMP Notifications Nos. 32, 165 read with amended Notification No. 453, 535, 552, 553, 554, 555, 556, 557, 558 and 559 that were existing immediately prior to the commencement of the Major Port Authorities Act, 2021. The Board of Mumbai Port Authority hereby publishes Scale of Rates for Port Trust estate for information of all concerned as required under Clause 6(2) of the Major Port Authorities (Fixation and Implementation Scale of Rates) Rules, 2021. The Scale of Rates in above notifications will be vaild upto 30th September 2022.
(१)
भाग दोन---६१-१२ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४
{P~blished ih Pa,.I,. - Ill kectiLn 4 ~f thJ Gazltte of India, Extraordinarr>
, I, T~Rl~F ~uTfiO~ITr F?R f-"Af OFf P
1 •
',
',
Q.No. ;32 ',
\ Ne1w Delhi, ' ',
', 18 January j2021
'
'
I
I
I
I
I
II
II
I I II
II I
' '
NOT,"IFIC..A.T l ',C>N I
' ' '
i,
i,
i;
:
'
1.
I
.
'
'I
'I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 1 In extrcise pf the bowers conferred under Section 1-9 of tfjle Major Port Trusts Act, 1~63 {3~ of 19~3), th\e. Tari{f. Auttib.rity for Major Ports here~y disJioses1f the propo$al received from Mumbai ~art Trµst (M13PT) seekin{il appr<\>val fof fixati~n of ched le of Rates for Lar:id at the Pfriod t1·om 01 Octof;)er 20~7 to 30 Se .temb r 202~, as i'l the qrder
, i , 1
Gqvandi ',of MBFT for 1 appendectl hereto. . .
1 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} . . I I
1 1 1 1 I I I
I
I
II
I I I j I I I I
I
I
I
I
I
(T.S. Balasubramanian) Member (Finance)महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ३
~aritf Auth~rity fo.- MajO~I Po~s I
Case No. T AMP/46/2020.,MBPT
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I I l I Apphcant 1
I
T~e Mjimba' Pori TruJt - -' -
I I
\ aubRu~ \
I
(i). (ii).
I I
<> !R. i> ~ R.
•
\ 1 (Pa~sed cm this128 th day of Deceri,1ber, 2020) : : \ 1 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
' I I I I I I I I
This case relates to a proposal receiv~ from Mum~ai Port Trus~ (MBPIT) vide its
let~er No. lFA/OEA-~-7 :(02)/U~5/101 for Land at Govand1 of MBPil for the penotl 01 October 2017 to 30 September 2022. !
I
I
I I I I I I
I I ' I ' I
The main p9ints made by the MBPT ih its proposal dated 14 October 2020 are 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} 2. , summarized below:
1 1 1 I I
I
I ' I I (i). Background\
I I I I '
Mumb¥i Port .Trust ~wns ~bout 882 Hai of larid in Mumbai' City. frhese· land t1ns under the jurisdiction of A, B, C, M, G-North, ~. F-N~rth and F-S9uth wards. l"he said lahd stretches Ifrom ¢olabal to W~dala, Mahimr WorU., Gov~ndi, etc. and. is divided into 15 admlnistratlve units for rrlanagement of these estates. Additionally, ~.1bout f8.09 Ha. of Iland ,t Titwaila is ~wned iby M[JPT. The lantied e~tates bre I I
I i
1
dividedi into 2, main ~atego~ies, viz. (i) leitable l~nd arid (ii) n'on-lettfable land. N6n lettable land inclu.des areas occupied by offices o1 sistrr departm~nt, admini$trative offices of ~umbai Po~ Trus~. Port I Trust, quart~rs, Port TrljJst hospital, etc. iThe lettable bitegdry inclilides areas let out to long term leases, 15 n 1onthly lease,s, mo~thly tenancie;s and /!cense~. . Thrre are al~o few plthts which a,re vaaant and can be let out. Fi'lot at povand1 1s v,cant and 1s to be let out las decided by the Board.
I I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 1
, 1 I I ' I ' I I I I I ' I I
I
I I (ii).
I I I 1
Policy Guidel:ines • .
1
I I T
I I ' I ' I I I I I I he Lahd Mainagenient PC>licy Guidelines for Major Ports, 2010 issuec~ by ~e I I
MinistryI were adopt~d by the Board vid~ TR No.21 bf 201 ~ readl with Supre .. re I I
I I
Court Jlfldgement. The Min'istry slJbsequently, \with t~e approval 6f the Cabinet, issued Land Policy guidelin~s for Land Ma. nagerr1_ ent by Major Portsj2014 (PGLM), which were applicable for all Ports except for 1 the lard relating tq> the tbwnshlp I I ar·eas o~ Kand!a, Mu~bai and Kolkata Port, for which it was stated that separate p9licy wi 11 be farmula~d . The ame111ded policy gl!Jidelin¢s were issuetJ in 2q15. \ I
I l I I ' I ' I I I I
I I
The Mimstr;: vide clari~catic,~n Ci~cular (tand ~anag~men9 I N~ .. 1 pt 2018 date~ I
I
, ,meroial occ"1pations of the township areas of: Mumtllai Port Trust 14.05.2Q18 1ss'ued clanficat,on crrbular extend1~9 the1apphaab111ty I of the PGLM 2015 to lthe ncm-ho~e occupatio~ / cori1mercial area of the township areas of Mymbai,[olkata and Kandla Port. 1Thus the PGILM 2015 have becdme applicablf I to 1the co
II
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
Legal 1s$ues
I I I I
i
(iii). I
I
भाग दोन---६१-१अ४ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ I '. I II I I II I II I ', T'.AMP had vi~e notirication '', No. TAMP/1~/98-Mlsc of 1,5.03.2000 is~ued o~ders dn it~ jurisdiction-~or framing s 'cale o~ Rates and s1tatem~nt of ®nditio,n on the iss~e
If>
I •
I I I I
' I I I
I
I I
I
I II
I
II
I
11, I
:
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
II
',
II
',
II
Ii
'
I
II
II
i
I
',
I
',
II
' I Ii
' I 1
I 1 letting Rates for Estate
1
11
I i • I
'
I
I
i
I i
I II
', '. I I I
I I ; I I '· ', I II
(a). 1
, annurn and 1
1 in ca~e of
', ·,
,
',
,
,
1
(v).
I I I
B~ard b~ Resolution i~o.43 dated *1.05_io19 acceptel the ~c report dated 6.ij.2019 r. ecom/nendirig rate !of l.1,55,800/- perk. mti. for F~l-1 as ,indica~d in ti1e Valyation ~eport for plot of Ian~ at G~vandL \
I
II
II
I I
I II
I
I
I
I
; I I '
1 111
111
1111
I
, Land ,
, Policy Guidklines I
Ni}. I for Plot, of Ian~ at Govandi falling In Starrp Duty Rea~y Recko~er ~one 1~0/471 ',,!s requested. Thus, TA\MP's approvG)I is requestec:t to th~ SoR arnved I Iat on the ba~1s I
'
\
II
I
I II
i i
I 3.1. ', The M~PT ha~ furnished t~e Sch~dule Of Rates for ~lot of Land ~,t Govandi (R~ Zone 100/471) as given 1,below ',: ·. \ ', , ', , 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I I
I I
II
II I
I
I Land V lue Per ' Rate Per Sq. Mtr .A.
I I
I '
Sq. Mtr. For Fsi,=1 As On 01.'10.2017 11 Int. '
- ot appli~ability',, of SOR to ~II lands of all Major Ports) The ',,.said notificatjon wa c allenQed by :the Mµmbai \Port b ~ Writ'tPetition 115* of 2000. I~ the ~aid wrjt p , titian, 'by int~' rim order dat~d 02.05.2000 the ~ombay High Court ~as stayed the I applicability o TAM f's or~er to areas II not f~lling yvithin i Port limit aiitd Port ap>proaches. ubsequently, 'Under advisory from the Ministry,\ the Writ petition ha~ ,, b!en w1t~drawr:i. I 11 , (iv) ', 1 : ', L C Report '1 , , 1 In ,~erms of par$ 13 ot PGLM 2015',M/s. Mahesh Shettr Con~ultants and Valuers,, wais app~inted for valL.1ation ~f Plot ',at Govandi (Ready 1 1 Reckdner Zone 100/4 71 ). ', La~d Alldtment '~ommittee {YAC) h~aded by the :oy. C~airmah and 9omprising ot'i Estate Managerl Finaf)cial Advisor & Chief Accounts omcer, Chief (Engine~r and '• I Tra,ffic Manager, as other members was donstit~ted to! recornmend 1, Schedule of 's with effect from 01 .10.2d17 up to 30.Q9.2022. As per the the following factors in PG~M-2015, the Corr1mitteeI, is re~uired , to consider \ det,rmini~g the market value ~f the ~Ort la~d. ' {{^{{FOOTNOTE 11}}}} State Gqvernm~nt's r~ady re{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}ckone~ of lanp values in tHe area'~ if av~ilable · for similar classification/ activities. I ' I I • (b). Av,erage ,.rate of actual', releva,nt transactions regi~tered ';in the last 3 years in {{^{{FOOTNOTE 11}}}},the ports vicinity ~dding :,2% e$calation per {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} Mumbai Port Tmst @4% escalation per anpum. · i ', I pcepted tend~r of P9rt Ian~ for si~ilar tr$nsactions. i, Highest a (c). (d). Rate arri~ed at p. y an approv~. d valu. er appointe1 for t~e purpose b\ the Por;t. , {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} (e). AnY, other:relevant factor as rn:ay be identified by t~e Port. : l (b). The {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}, rate given by the 'llaluer for the ,subject land .o. f 't.1j55,80Q/- per :sq. , mtr for FS!-1 is ~s of September 2018, Th, SoR .thus ~pplica~le for ',the ',, year 2017~2018 for lanc1 falling under Ready Reckoner zone'. 1001471. , SoR @ 6%', per annum return wprks out t.93181- pe,r Sq. Mtr. per: annum & ',, 't.7791- per :Sq. Mtr. per month ror FS!-1 wit~ 4% a:,nnual ~scalation evbry ', Octoper. : ', ' , , \ ', ', ~he proposa'1 is fdrmu1at~d in terms ~f the 'for Lard Management2015. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}.Under 'sectiolil 49 of;MPT Act, 19133 and\ para 13 (c) c:,f PGLM :2015, r AMP'$ approval to lhe SQR for the pe11iod fror, 01.1, 0.201 r to 3d.09.2022 of TR No. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 43}}}} {{^{{FOOTNOTE 6}}}}f {{^{{FOOTNOTE 2019}}}} in respect of! Plot o~ land ~t Govandi. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}, ', '1 Sr. RrZone PlotNo. No. , ln ','f. .. 5 , . f.1,5 ,800 f.9,3 8 2 i ,100/471 ↩
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
IGovandi
I
I
I
',,NOTE_§_:
:, ,
•
I
'.
.
I : I
II I I
I I I I
I
II
I I
II I
I ', 1. Aboye rate is subiect tq increase @!4% p.a. Fir~t such incre~se will be eijective I ',
I I '
I I '
I
1
1
':
',
.
1
':
:
•
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} '
• '
I
' : I I
11
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
,
: ,
, '
1
'
'
II I
' I I I
' I
' i I
I
'
I I ' . I I ' . I I I I ' I ', ' I ' I I I I ' ' I ' I I ' . I I ' . I I '
I I '
I I '
I
I : I I ' :
'
\
I
'
.
'
I I
' ' I I '
I ', '
I I '
I ', ' • I I I ' . : I I I '
1
1
',
:
:
',
,
,
'. 1 I
\
I
I
p I
I ~ : ' l : , ,
I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
i - - . - - - - -+ -+ -+ - - -' _ \ ,_ I I 1_ I 1 I
1
',
•
\
'1
,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I I
1
:
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I
·,
',
',
I I
I II
I II
II
'
'
I
I
I
' '
I
I
'
'
I i \
I I I I I I
I I I I I I
I I I I I I
: 4.2; . ~he L: nd Allotme~t eaniffiittee\ has rkomn\ended the ~ghesti mark~! value of !markat value of t1)55,800.00 per sq tr. a~ived by the:va1u1r in tHe Valuation Report. The
- 3. : Above ratss are , · Interest. et~. Same are ~eparately p~yable by les~ees, as may 'be applicable. 3;2 : The MBPT:has also fur~ished {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} the C~py of',,the R~port of the ~aluer, {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}},,Copy pf the L~nd Allotment Committee\ {LAC)':Report and Copy of the ~oard ResoltJtion of the ~BPT Soard approvi~g the recommendations oJ the LAC (TR No.43 dated 31.05.2019). : ' '1 Fro~, the ~aluation rep~rt, it ~s see~ that\ the V~luer ~as cqnsidered different 4 .:,1. \ of the part la'~d as prescriped at:, para ~o. 13 method of valuation for determini~g the market value ·{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} (a~ in th~ Land:Policy Guid~lines ~nd arrived at the f~llowin~ market value of l~nd un~er different mbthods: - ': , {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} ethod4II I '· R·t ·s , , 1 1 ,. a, e er, . mlr. Market Value of ~and as er $tate Read ijeckoner \, t 1,06,600.dO Hig~est raie of actual relevant transactions:, No:,, such : regi~tered':in last':3years in th~ vicinity ! transactions M~thod-HI Hig~est adcepteq tend~r cum ~ction bf the port la~d ; Not occurre~ for ~imilar ransattions {{^{{FOOTNOTE 11}}}} M thod tlV ',, Oth~r Rel ,vant F~ctors':· Highest rat~ of ac~ual : :r1,32,,310.0p ' ' rele ant transactions arket ale lnstanc~ i \ : :, Method~ V Value Con$idering exis ng infrastructure facilities L :t 1,55:1800.00 ',, Feasibilit ' etho of Land valuation {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} ↩
.i - - - - -६ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४
| I SI. 11 1. 2. a) b). c). d) e) f). o) • h). | I Calculation \ ' Un(t : St~tement i I I I 1 I Area 1of Plot I I 69848.84 Sa.mtr I I 1 I , 1 . ', Sq.mtr Op "Reservation l ' Municipal Market : I 1 3497.92 1 1 1 Sq.mtr 11 I Gard13n Plot , I I 1 Sa.mtr ;2258.80 Homeless Shelter:. \ Sq.,ntr 2483.$4 I I I i ' School I Sa.mtr 1 1211.8.7 ' 1 , Hospital : Sq.mtr 2763.1'.7 - I I I Proposed D)=> Roa~ 1 Sa.mtr . 857.99 I Set Back Area I Sa.mtr I , 742.90 : Total \ Rese~ationi 13816.19 \ Sa.m r I | , 1 | |
| 3. , 4. ' : 5. | 1 Area bf Plot 1 i i 565032.64 Sa.m r | ||
| I \ , , · Dedu~tion for Opeh Spade Sa.m r 00 I 1 ' · ' . Oedu6tion fdr Internal Road 00 | |||
| ,7. 18. 1 9. 1 10. , 11. | 56032.64 I 1 1 , I I , FSI · I \ ,Permissible FSI 1 I I , Permissible Floor Area (6 * 1 FSI) 56032.64 tSa.mb' i : 13816.19 'Additional F$1 OP r:eservation atea (Hr 1 FS!) 1Sa.mfr 1 1 Permissible Floor Area . 6$848.8, I I Sq.mtr I , BaseffSI , , I I I 69848.8• : 1 FSI, | ||
| 1 12 | 1 , 1 1 \ !Additional 28016.3~ | ||
| 1 13 ~4 | 1 I ' . 39222.86 lDR 0.7 FSi.1 I i , , 47980.Bt I Funoitile FSI 'i I 0.35 FSI | ||
| ~5 | I 1 1rotalfi'SlonPlot(1'1to14) ' ' ; 185068.83 Sa. mtr. | ||
| 16 17 ' | I 222082.59 ~er~i~sible Floor IArea ~Sale~ble Mea) with 2Q% I ' I i ; , · rbadind (15.2b%) \ I I I ' ' , , Total, Expeated Output I ' I I 215280.00 1 Rate qJnsidered fori valuation ~Rs.2, 1;5,280/~ sq.mtr. I 1 • • • • ' I I I or f.20!0001- ber sa ! ft | ||
| 18 1 19 1• | 1 , \ 1 \ 478~9944492.00 i Total e~pected outppt (16 f 17) I I , I 1 1 Total cost of the oroiect Construction , cost. @~s.275(1)0 per s~. r11tr 1 1 1 1 (16*coristructipn cost per sb. ft.) \ | I f , ' | 6107271~91.00 1. . I I |
| 20 I \ | Construction • cost for reservation @~s.27~00 p~r sp.mtr. 1 1(h*construction cost per ,sq mtt) (13816.19 I* I ' • I I I I 2i7500) i | I f . I | 319945225.00 1 1 . I |
| 2 11 1 | qther e~penses 7% \const~ction :cost {Architeft Fee~ I 313/o, 1 %1 plan aooroval and out of exoenses 3o/<1) | 427508990.00 1 | |
| 22 | Contingencies (19+20) *5% ; , , | I 3214360826.00 | |
| 23 | Approv~ls costs (M¢GM approvals co~t INR: 10764 1 ' s~.mtr) (16 * 10764) 1 | I I | 2390497025.00 1 I |
| 24 2$ | , Site develoom~nt charoes ~1 * 10t6 so. 1-ntr) i' TOR / Addi. ~SI Cqst {50% of Govt. Land Rate) 1. * 50% Readv Rec~oner ~ate) 106600 (12 + ,3 + 1..:1 | i | I 75157352.00 7 6141225367.00 I I I I |
| 26 | 1 : I Total cost of Proiect 1B) 1 1 | i \ 1584$966016.00 | |
| 27 | Net income inclusive bf Lantl Cost (A-B) . | , 319639744n6.00 | |
| 28 | I Less- lnterest 1cost dllrina donstruction | 31691932d3.00 | |
| 30, | Less - Developer Profit 30% (27*30%) i Tqtal cost of developed Land (27-28-2$) | I | 9589192343.00 , 19205588930.00 |
| 31 1 | 1 Tdtal Potential value of Land I I | 119205588930.00 | |
| I , , Lahd Rate oer sa.mtr .. FSI 2.2. (31/3) | I I | I 1342757.00 | |
| Lard Raie per ~q. mtr. con ideri~g 1 FSI \ 1s I I I I | Pef sq. \ mtr. | t.15~799.0;0 or say t.155800.00 |
\
5. , 1 11n acC9rdanc~ with the corisultati~e proc~dure ~rescri~ed, a ,bopy o~ the ~BPT proposal dated 14 pctober 2020 was forwarded to the concerned users/ user orsanizations (a~ per the u~er listifurnished by MBPT) vide letter dated 22 1October 2029 seeki~g their comments. one of the users i user 1,:,rgani~ations \have given cdmmen~s till the case iwas fi~alized: 1
I I
I I .
Shipping (MbS) letter No 1
• 11053/30/2020-Coord .. dated 16 'April 2020 to. hold ":irtual rreetings, a . joint rearin~ on the case in I refererce was hel~ on 1117 Nqvember 2020 through V\deo · Conferencins . At t~e join~ heari~g. MBPT made a btief power point presentatidn of it~ prop~sal. The MBPT ahd the users/ user organisa,tions hf1ve made the ,submissions during the joi1t hearing.
' I I ' I 1· I I I I ' I I '
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
proJ
1 \ '
1 '
I '. 7. : \ Ba~ed o~ a pteliminary sctutiny of the sal, the following I additional , informlation/ !larification was sought fro,p MBPr, vide' letter dated 6 Nov~mber 12020. rhe M$PT ,has respond d vide\ its lett~r dated 04 December 2020. The infor ation sought ~nd th response 'of MBPT the eon are tabulated below: ·1 . I I
| ' SI. ;No. : (i) 1 1 I 1 : \ 1 1 \ 11 1 I 1 1 \1 | I I lnformatibn/ clarification sought 1 : 1 I 1 r~e market value of l 155,800 per isq. mtt. For FS( - I v~lued ~y the valuer Is as 9f $eptember 2018. I Ther~fore, ~eekin_~ approval for1 the I proposed rental$ r~trospectivelY! from \01 Odober ~017 to ~e justified with the significance of ldate of 1 • 01 Octoper 2017. : : 1 1 \ ' 1 • · 1 1 1 ' , ' I \ ' : \ I I ' , 1 1 1 I , \ , , 1 1 , , \ \ , ', 1 1 ' 1 1 , , 1 1 1 : \ ' 1 ' 1 1 1 I I I | Response ,of MBPT : : 1 ', : \ , The land at Govandi do not have any lettinp. Previously! there were r~siden~ial Quarters on the 11s aid l~nd. MbPT proposes to lease out this l land ~nd therefore in t~rms or PGLM 2014-15, it is necessary to fi~ the SOR with I the apprbval of TAMP. As Aer th~ Qui~quen1a1 revision irl termJ of P(]LM the revision of I rates 'of all MbPT land Would bb effe9tive fr~m 1.10.2017( Accordingly; for thr subject lahd, from SPR ft the I period 1.10(2017 to 30.~9.202 ;:., has been p;;opose~ with 1 the rate as or,1 1.1 0.,i::017 being escalate~ 1 by 41% ever year.' The valuation of the said thel, repo1 land 1 _has been carried I out ard subntutted on 29.0~.201 a1r The value given by as o129.09l2018, Which {alls wi~hin the perio9 1 of fifst year of revisiori i.e. ·1.10.2b11 to t~e re~tal ha~ been 1 30.0~.2018.l Therefore, I I : I proposed retrospectively. I | the Valuer i~ 'f .1,55,800/- per sq,mtr. fqr FSI 1 |
| (ii) I (ii)) I ' I I I I I I I I I I | THe reason a~ to why no 1 prospective for eff~ct is I sough~ the proposed ! lease re~tals, ~iven that no \ rental~ have , been approved by ~AMP ~n respect of the su~ject lard at Govandi, in th1 abse~ce of any propdsal from MBPT. I 1 I : I A \ note _prescribing the validity of the proposed Rent $chedyle to be 5 years, to 1 1 •• : be 1 1proposed. 1 , 1 ' 1 1 1 I 1 11 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I ' , 1 \ : , 11 11 I 1 I I : \ \ | The $OR b~ing pr?posed would have yalidity from 1.10 .. 2017 tp 30.0~.2022: for ti. perid with % annual ihcrease, whereafter Quin ,uenni~I revisipn would applJ'.. \ 1 , 1 i • 1 , , Thus, . rate ~rospe~tive effect µp I has 1 1 1 \ \ 1 30.09~2022. \ l I Trust ',Board 1 1 \TAMP,, for fixing the SOR of the land taking 1 into account 1the hi~~est of the 51 factors give 1 I in par~ 13(a~ to de~rmine the l~test market lvalue of Port land. or fixjng th; latest. SOR \ for th~ land,\ the Port Trust Board is! also required to fix annual escalation which could not be less thfln 2%.1 Further it is Arovided that the SO,R wou~d be fixed every five \,years. ', | fresh , , to ! I According to para 13 of P~LM 2014 th,e Port , is req~ired to mak~ proposal to ' I |
I I I I ' I I ' I
I८ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ,
| I I I, I I I I I I I ' I I ' I I ' I I ' ' ' \ ' ' ' ' ; \ \ : : 1 I ' ,, 1 1 \ , ', 1 \ 1 ',, : 1 1 1 , the M.PT A9t, 19p3 m~ndate& no~ify S¢ale of Rates and *atem~nt of conditipns for use ~f porli ~ropertirs, TAMP will\ not b~, able t~ notifyl 1 • ·. : , | It is provided in the said pa~a that 1the latest in accord~nce tith para s;· R determined 13 a) and 13(c}'~ould In no case be 1. less than 6° I of tht latest mark~t valur recorrmend~d 1 1 \ by \the Pol , Trust. ! In ionsonrnce ~ith the;above\provisi n of t~e 1o return p.a~ on tl:le PG,LM, t~e SOf\l at 613/o highest f~ctor of f .1,15,800/.i. work~ out ~o !effective t.9~48 p~r sq.n\}tr. P1 for FSl=1 from 1.10.~017, t,,ith al"\nual escalation of 4% ever'/ Octc;,ber. 1he firs~ such .increase would be effective on 1.,10.2011.8 and the SOR would be valid ti11 ·30.09.go22. l I . This is noted. : : , 1 \ : I I : I 1 1 l I |
.
I I \ ' ' ' h't II lff I • I • I,
8,. ': the offic~ of th/s Aut~ority. \An excerpt of the argume~ts ma~e by t e corlcerne~ partie~ will tle 1 them. I These details w1.U also be Imade available at our , website sent s~parately to 1 t p: tar:. authq.nty.goy.m. 1 1 : ': : \ : ', ', '
'
I I I
: I I I
' ' I 9. : : With ~eferenbe to iotality ; of infdrmatioi,1 colle~ted d~ring t~e professing of this {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I resider~tial qu,arters Were situatedj which it has decided to let out. At:cordirlgly, the 11 a proposal tpr fixation of ! lease ! rent f~r the ,and at 1 MBPT , has come u'p with 1 11 of thelamencled Lahd Poli~y Gui\jelines,, 2014 :
1
',
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} ~ovandi based on the proyisions 1 rhe pmposal of the j)Ort has the approva . of its Board Of Trustees. 1,
'.
i
i I I II
', I I I ' ' I I
' ', I : I
I I rhe M$PT has filed : its prqposal Vide its\ letter ~ated 14 October 2~20. T~e said: proposal alonµwith the information/ claryficatiof(l furni~hed by MBPT during the:
~roces~ing of ~he case, is c<,,nsidered in t~is analysis. I • : : :
I I I I
' '. . .
' I I I I I I
I I
I
I I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I I
' I I \ I : ' I I ,
Heads of fepart\ents tf Finarce, Traffic a~d Esta~e bein? the o~her mfmbers.
- 1 I t.9~48 p~r sq.n\}tr. P1 for FSl=1 !effective ~se, the follow~ng po~ition ererge~: \ • : : \ \ I : : I (i). ;The Mumbai:, P~rt * rust (fyiBPT) I has some few vac~nt plots in dpvandi where ' {i9. 1;his AJthority~ is ma11datedi to follow thJ Land \ Policy\ Guiddlines i~sued by the \ (iii). ~overn~ent _frpm tim~ to time for tpe purp_o~e of; dete~rrii~ing lease r~' ntals for the ! lands be,ilongmg to thQ Port Trusts. 1 The M1mstry i,of Sh1Rpmg 111 the G vernment of : India has anni)unce~ Land \ Policy Guide!ines f<;>r MajC:,r Ports, 201 in January ' 2014 which has come into effect frqm 2 J~nuary {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}2014. Subsequently) the Ministry \ of Shipping has issue~ ame~ded L$nd Policy Gu!delineS, 201~ unde~ISectior 111 · of the MPT Act, 1963 for implementation with effect from 1 :7 July {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} 2015. 1 The \ Mr8PT has, col"\1e up ~ith a proposal for fo~ing Saale of Rates (SOR) for allo~ment \ of land at Govandi ba~ed on the pro~isions\of the Land Policy Guidelirl,es for ~ajar PC!lrt Trusts, 2014, as ~mended in July 2015. I . : : : (iv).\ A~ per cl~use 13(a) re~d withiclaus~ 11 .2{J) of th~ Land policy Guideli~es 20~4, a Lard Allo,tment pommittee (LAC) copstitut~d by t~e Port ~rust Board c,onsistiJ~g of D~puty Qhairmc\n of the Port,{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} and Heads of Departmen~ of Finance, , Estat~ and per th~ methqd?lo~y. presc~ibed ! Traffic sh~II det~rmine i~e mafket va\ue of 1$nd as {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} in clause ',13(a). ~ccordingly, the MBPT has repo~ed abqut con~btut,on of a !.:.and AIIG>tment: Committee {ILAC) headed by the Dy. Chairman of :the P~rt and the ↩
1
I
I
I
I
I I I
I I I I
' I I I I
I
(v). (a}.
I I
'
\ Para l13(a} :of the:. Land \ polic~ guidelines ~f Jul~ 201 . prescribes the 1,methddology for dhtermif')ation of marfet vafue of the larld based on the 11 as prescribed thetein. 111 terms of the s~id pa~i8 of the Jive factors ':amen~ed Lard policy gui~elines of 2014, the Land Allotment Committee -may normalf:Y takeI into tccount the \highe~t of the fa~ors ~ention~d herein, viz. (i). St~te Go ernmE:mt re~dy redkoner of land values in the trea if available fdr simil I r cla~sificati,on/ aqtivitiesI, (ii). Highest rate ',pf ~ctual relevant tran~action,s regi tared i,n the last three years in the Por\'s vicinity'1with an appr'?priate, annu I escalation ~ate to ;be ap~roved}he Port trust ~oard, '(iii). Highest :accep~ed terlder-cum-auciion rate of Rort land for similar tramsactions, updated on the ~asis df the ~nnual ~scalation rate ~pprov~d by the Pdrt Tru$t Boa~d. (iv); Rate I arrived at by an approved ~aluer appoin~ed for1 the purpose ',by th~ Port ~nd {v). Anyi,other releva~t fli3ctor as is id¢ntified by the Port. ·,The amended Land Policy guidelines of
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
2P14 ai~so stipulates, that ir casEr the ~C is not qhoosirig the :highe~t f,;1ctor, t e reasons fqr the s~me h~ve to be recorded. \ . : : ', ' : \ I ' '. ', I ~ ' ' I ' I I I ' ' I
(b).'
1
1 In, conn~ction with the Valuation as per \various methods as stipu ated in ',indicat~d that the Guidelines~the valuatior~ reporjt of SeptemtJer 20118 has no tender CUf11 auc\ion of: the port tar-id foM similar transactioras has oqcurred in the past :3 years. Th~ valu~ of th~ land, as reflected! in thJ St~mp 0uty Ready I.Reckoner 2017-18 is re;ported1 by the Val,uer at f1 ,,06,60t· /- pe~ .. sq.m. !The H!ghest \rate arnongs~ of ac,ual rel~vant ~arket,1 S~le Inst nee ttansactions hi3s be~n indiqated b'.y the 'Valuer in his Report'. at !{1,32, 10/- per sq.m. The :Valuer has 81's0 determined the rnarkei value : of :the land at ~11,55,800/- per sq.fll., as ijrought out in the $rlier ~art o( th.' d ~ I ·, : I I ' ' '
',
1s or e,~ 1, , , ·,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
11 ' ' ' I
', I I ' ' I II (c). Th~refor~. the LlAC in lits Report has recdmmenbed to! take ihto ac6ount, I, the\ highest of the ma~et valye amongst ~II the 111arket\ values of th~ land ',, at ?ovarn!ii, as determ:ined br the Valuer : in the \ Valua~ion Report. Thus, the ,,LAC h~s recommer:ided to consider the the m~rket ~alue of the l~nd at ~ 1,~5,809:I- per \q.m, being ie higH\est va\ue amongst f" the 1actorsl I I I
\ (d). Clal;lse .13(b) of the guidelines stip~lates ~at R,serve : Price :in tern;is of annual lea~e rent, woul~ be arrived, a,s a percentage of latest rnarket ~alue of land de,termin~d based ori the five factors in accordance with para 13{a,) and \hat the perc~ntage 1Ishould not ti,e less 11 1than ~% which is tp be fixeq by ttie Port; Trus~ Boarcjl. Accordingly, the \ lease \ rental'. has been arriv~d by MBPT ~t 6% of the market value~· of the: land ~t f1 ,5?,800/~ per sq.m, which:works\out to f9,34et- per sq.m. er annum. i \
i
\
' I
i i I ' I I
I I
' '· I ' ', I ' ' '· I Considering that t~e maljket valµe of the land as determined by the Valuer {e).
\bY the LAC ~nd giv:en tha~ the Bbard or Trust~es
I ': has been r~comm~nded \ of MBPT h~s approved the recommendation of the LAC and also sihce : there , have \been ho obj~ction~ from :any of the ~sers, ~ho have b~en ',, cons4lted i11 the c.,se in ',reference, this Authority is incli~ed to Iprescribe ' the L~ase R1
11 as prqposed:by thi MBPT. ', : : ', \
I
I
I I \
: \ I
: \
ent fa~ the land at ~ovan~i at f 1,348/- per SR·m p~r annum,
(vi),.
' : ! ' ' I .
I~ the ~ubject' propo~al, th~ MBAT has' sought apprbval fdr the lease tent tof: a period df 5 years beginnin~ from p1 October 2017. th this ~egard,: the MBPT hf3S s~ated that Valuation :given py the ,Valuer is in September 2018, which falls witttin 11 the peri~d of ~rst y,ar of ~evisio~ i.e. from O 1 Oct~ber 2q11 to 30 Septemb,er 2018. 1 I
'
I
\
I
I I I I भाग दोन---६१-२
I I I I I I१० महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ '
I I ' I I I '
I ' * I
In thi~ connection), it is rJ.11evan~ to merition here th~t the 16. ase r~ntals !appro ed by the 9ioard of Trustees fbr the I lands 1of MBPT fo~ the pbriod from 1~80 upto 30 , September ~012 as per ~he Compro~ise foimula had been upheld b~ the Hbn'ble 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
'
I I
'
I I '
,
1 I 1
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
' I I
I '
. I ' I i I
I I I
.
' i I I
I I
I
this Authority ii; not ·t a pq>sition Ito notify mafket v~lue. T~is position ~as bsen
,
•
\ {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
,
,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1
,
,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I
I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
.
I I
I I
\ I ' '
I I '. . I I I
1
, •
I I
'
I
' '
' I I I
I I
' I
I
. I I I .
I
I I ' I I
I,
' ' ' '
\
- 2019 'to fix the SOR for {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}all are,as of l~umb~i Port iinclud!ng Townshi~ area$ with effect', from 01 Oc~ober 2012 tjnwards. Sin¢e dunng th~ _quin~uenni,I perid 01 :octo~er 2012 to 3P September 2017, {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} there were only res1denti~I Quarters qn the 1 land ~t Govandi and the rort has iden~ified the Ian~ at Govandi tor letting out only 1durinQ the quinquehnial Pi9riod 01 Oct<';)ber 2017 to ~O September 2022, the MBPT \is presumed to have approach~d this f\uthor;ity seeking retrospective ~pproval for '.lease tent for the land at Govandi from\01 October 2017 tA 30 sJptem~er 2022. : I I I ' I I I ' 1 I ,t is notewo~hy that this ~uthor:ity do~s not prdinarily give retrdspectiye eff~ct to ~he Order. !ut, in\ cases gove,rned ~y sp~cial circumstance~, it does require retrospective applidation of its Order. In a ca~e rel~ting to an agreem~rt bet-.yee. n. New f0angalbre Pqrt Tru$t and \ the Kµdrempkh lrqn Or~ Company ytd., 01 the 1 , ~dvice \ of Mi~istry ~f La~, the ~then) Ministry of Surface' Tran~port hpd vidr its omm nicatipn No. PR 1401115197-f4 dated 1 Marieh 1998 advised this ?~thor.y to !live r_eb"ospeJlive eff~ct- S!milarlY, bastd on ~ropos81s received _mm iBPT, 1 retrospective effe~ was given ~or rec~very of way· leave I charg~s lev1table ais per the ag~eeme~t bet'A'.een ONGC and M~PT as!, well as for t~e lev~ of Sp~cial V~ay Leave Ct,arge~. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} Under t,hese circum~tances and ':for the; reasdns gi~n in the earlier paragra~hs, the proposal bf the ! MBPT seeki'ng ret~ospective aRproval for lease rent for i the l~nd at ~ovan~i from {{^{{FOOTNOTE 01}}}} O{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}tober ~{{^{{FOOTNOTE 017}}}} t~ {{^{{FOOTNOTE 30}}}} S~ptem~er {{^{{FOOTNOTE 20}}}}1{{^{{FOOTNOTE 2}}}}, is approv~d. ! (vii). T~e M~PT h~s sou~ht approval I for prescriptjon of :mark~t value of the land at Govand1 as w~II as U,e lease ren~. In this regard, it i$ to st~te th~t the Major Port Trusts Act, 19£S3 mar'ldates 'this At~thority to not/fy Scqle of Rates ~nd Statemen~ of c~nditiof'.ls for pse of\port p'roperties. Al~o, the 1Land policylGuidejines, manda~es this Authority tp pres~ribe 1£:ase rent basbd on the market value of the lahd. Thus, 1 1as (viii)f b~bught t.o _the notice of_MBpT. Thus, thi~ Authprity nptifies ~nly the leas\e rent d1~cussed m the prec ding paragraph. . : 1 T l MBl?T is ~een tc) have\ propo~ed a :note t9 the ~ffect ~hat th~ leas$ rent is su 1ect tel> incre~se @:4 % p.~. and\ that first such incr~ase will be e~ectiv~ from ~1 0 tober 2018. In this regard, it is rel~vant here to mendon that Clau~e 13(c) of the La11d Policy Guidelin~s of 2()14 givles fle~ibility to the ports td fix anrual e$calation whi¢h w~U:ld not be less than 2%. Accorqingly, the MBPT has proposed 4% annual escalatioh. Alsb, since the lease ~ent tol be approved is for the PfiOd ~eginning 01 Octob~r 2017, the {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}1 said IErase rent will 11be_ su~ject to', its firs~ annurl esc~lation ':on 01 Octob~r 201{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}8. Thus, the proposed note 1s approvect. · : 1 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} I I I L ' I I The MBPt has propos~d another npte to the effect that the land value and rate i·s \ (ix). ' ~pp licable'. p~r S~. Mtr. 1f~r FSI = 1 ?nd th~t ~or hipher ~SI, land ~alu~ a~d tate wi II increase. :Since \ the ~aid n9te gives cl~mty and w9uld avoid ~mb1gul1ty, the proposed note is appro1/ed. However, reference tb the word 'l~nd value' is ~eleted, for the reasons ~tated \earlierr If th {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}e land value \ and .r~te will increase fo~ higher FSl,'1 the rJIBPT is advised to \seek the approval 10f this Autha,rity for such1 higher rate 1with d~e just,ification. The \propo;,ed no~e is ~odifie~ suita~ly. · · \ ↩
I I ' I I ' ' ' 'महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ११ 1
I taxes (GST , Municipal Taxes, etc.), Penalties .I Interest. etc! and that the
I I I I I I ' '.
..l_ I I I I
,+.s. Balasubramanian ·
,
Member (Finance) I _ I _ I I I
- (xi). Glause j 13 (q of thf amei7ded ~and Pblicy Guideliriies, 2014 stibulate~ that the 1 rates will be revised once in every five years by this Authority. Since the rental is being prescribed with effect from 01 Oytober accorqingly, 1a note is being prescritied in ~he Retlt Schtbdule that the annual lease rentals shall remarn in force for a period of.five years thereon, which is approved. 10. , , hi the result, · and for the reasons given above and based on a collective Gova~di for ~he application of mind, this Authority ap1=1roves the Schedul~ of le~se re!jlt for l~nd at peridd 01 Octobe~ 2017 ~o 30 $eptember 2d22 which is attached as Annex.I ' ' ↩
भाग दोन---६१-२अ१२ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ 1
,
, • 1
1 Annex.
~CHE~ULE\ OF $TE t-oR ~LOT ~F L~No A~ GO~AN01 (RR 1oNE:, 1001~71) ', I
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I
I I
I
I
I
I
I I I
'
| I Sr. No. I | I I ~rZone |
| , 1 | 2 |
| 1 | ' 100/47' I I ! |
I
I
I I
I
I
Sr. I No. ~rZone \ 'Plot ~o.
I I I
\ : ( lr1 t.) \ I
\
I I I
I
;
I
I 3
I
I
1 100/47' Pt of land at rovanr
I I I I
' ! I I
I I
I
I I I I ! I ' '
I
I
I I I I I
I,
I
I
I
I I
I, \
'1 I ' ' I I '
'
'
'
'
I
I ' : l : :
'
I I I
I . I
I I I I
I I I I 1.
I
,
'
,
Above rate is sJbject tp increase@ 4% pJa. First sucl1 increase wi I be effective fron101.10.201s 1
1
:
:
I I I
'
I I I I I
I : : I I '
!Tor hig~er FS:I, rate \
\ ' . I Rat~ furni~hed apove i$ applicable per Sq.: Mtr. for FSI 1= 1. will increase subject to V,e ap~roval of TAMP. \
I
!
: : . I \ : , !
Above rate is exclusivk of a)I Taxes (GST, Municipal: Taxes, etc.), Pen~lties, 3.
' Interest. etc. Same are separately payable by les~ees, al> may be applicablel
.
I
I,
' ' '
I I I
' ,
I : I I , ,
. I I
'·4.
annual leas~ rental, shall ·:remair) in for:ce for a peribd of five ye~rs fr~rn 01 1
1
,
The Octo"er 20~ 7 to 3,0 September 2022. 1
I
I
I I
I
I •••••- 'महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ १३ I SUM ARY OFT EAR UME TS MADE I THI CAS DURING T E JOI THE RIN
EFORE TH AUT ORITY. . · · · · I
. .
I_ TAMIP/46/21020-MBPT Propo~al re~eived ltrom the M~mbai IPort l"rust (~BPTi
seekin.g approval of Schedule of Rates ·for Land at
~ovan~:U of MBPT ror the peri9d 01 ctober 201r to 30
September 2022. '
1
he jqint hearing.I
I
I I ' I I **0*** I I I I I In view of the outbreak of COVID-19 and in 'pursuance1of the Ministry Shipping (,V,OS) letteir No. ] 11053/30/2020-~oorct dated 1~ April 2020 to hbld of I virtual meetings, a joint t)earing on the case in reference was held on 17 November Video Cor,feren~ing. r'\t the jointIhearirg, MBPT tnade a brief POv¥er 20;20 through point presentation !of its: propbsal. ~he MBPT, and the users/ user organisations have made the submissipns during 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I I ' I
Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT)
I ' I I I
(i). The Bombay Doc:i;k Labour Board (BDLB) had purcpaseq land [of ab¢ut I 69,84~.84 sq. mlrs. (~pprox.) at Gova~di in lthe year 1965. After the merger of BDLB with MBPT in the year 2015, the 1land i:s with MBPT.
a buildings F3re standing the~eon and being used as MBPT emlptoye~s quarters.
.
. ; . i ; i I ' i I ' I I
1
I
I Welfare, 9ovt. qf India. I I I I
1
(ii), I
I
1
' : We lvill rJ11ocat~ the iempl~s/ m~squJ].
I
I -·-I I I
- (ii~. the Valuation of the :Govandi land has been done by applying 5 Land:Policy gui9etines. The1 mark!et value of fhe lalhd factor;, as p~r the ~s assessed by the ,Valuer at ' f .155800/- per sq.m. has been recommended by the ~.AC and ap prov~d by re Bly from the Ministry. • Prima facie '+'e have noiobjec:ltion to the propdsed r~te. Wie have a 9oncetn since te1j11plesi / mo!sque ~re ldcatecf in tile said land. [MBPT ↩
{Publishe~ in Part -111 Section 4 -of the Gazette of India, Extraorc:una"') I I TARIFF AUTHORITY FOR MAJOR PORTS '
G.NQ. 165 New Delhi, 12 April 12021
NC>TIFICATIIC>N
,-.s. Balasubramanian , Member (Finance)महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ १५
Tariff Authority for Major Ports
Case No. TAMP/26/2020-MBPT
Applicant
The Mumbai Port Trust
QUORUM
(i). Shri. T.S. Balasubramanian, Member (Finance) (ii). Shri. Sunil Kumar Singh, Member (Economic)
ORDER (Passed on this 16th day of March, 2021)
This case relates to a proposal filed by the Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) seeking approval of Schedule of Lease Rentals in respect of 9 Vacant Plots at various places in Mumbai to be allotted by E-Tender-cum-Auction method at Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT).
2.1 . The main points made by the MBPT in its proposal dated 22 July 2020 are summarized below:
(i). Background
(a). MBPT owns about 882 Ha of land in Mumbai City. These land fall under the jurisdiction of A, B, C, M, G-North, E, F-North and F-South wards. The said land stretches from Colaba to Wadala, Mahim, Worli, Govandi, etc. and is divided into 15 administrative units for management of these estates. Additionally, about 28.09 Ha of land at Titwala is owned by MBPT. The landed estates are divided into 2 main categories, viz. (i) lettable land and (ii) non-lettable land. Non-lettable land includes areas occupied by offices of Mumbai Port Trust, Port Trust quarters, Port Trust hospital, etc. The lettable category includes areas let out as long term leases, 15 monthly leases, monthly tenancies and licenses.
(b ). The land policy guidelines for Major Ports issued by the Ministry of Shipping (MoS) in 2010 do not have the sanction of Cabinet and these guidelines could not be implemented. The Ministry of Finance vide OM dated 25.06.2010 & 02.11.2010 with regard to the sale/ lease/ license of land in possession and control of Govt./ Govt. controlled entities directed 'to ensure that express approval of the Finance Ministry is obtained for any sale/grant/assignment/allocation or disposal in any form of Government Assets. The above subject has been further communicated through Cabinet Secretariat's 0.0. letter dated 21.03.2011 which specifically refers to the need for specific approval of Cabinet in each case of sale or long term lease of land belonging to Govt./ Govt. controlled statutory authorities.
(ii). Policy Guidelines issued by MOS / GOI
(a). The Ministry, with the approval of the Cabinet, issued Land Policy guidelines for Land Management by Major Ports 2014 (PGLM), which was applicable for all Ports except for the land relating to the township areas of Kandla, Mumbai and Kolkata Ports, for which it was stated that separate policy will be formulated . The amended policy guidelines were issued in 2015, which were not applicable to Township areas of MBPT.
१६ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४(r ). i The ·Minisiry viC,e cl~rification C\rcular, (Lan~ Mapage~ent) No.1 'Of 14.oJ.201 a and Clarification I No.2 of 09 1.03.2019 and dated 29.04.20·19 issued clarification circular on various issues of1 PGLM 2014/15 extending
/ I
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
I
I I I I I I I I I
..
i. State Government's ready ,,eckoner of land v,'afues 1in the Iarea, 1 if 1 available for similar dlassificationl activities. : 1 1 1 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
by I the Port. I I I I I I I ' I I ' I I I I I I I I I (b)
I the I highest of I the factors 1
- No.4 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} of 20~ 9 on {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} Policy Guideline~ on ~and Management' 2015 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} (PG~M 2015) have directed Board to ensure that optimum value is realized by 1 licensing/le~sing iPort uand though ' Tender-cum-auction methodology for 30 years lease in ·terms of PGLM 2015. I. I I ' I I l 1 '. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}. I I I I (a). Accordingly, Board vide TR 2o0 of 2020 accorded approval to invite public offers by inviting online' tenders in respect of 12 vacant plots on lease for I 30 yelars in lterms· of PGLM 2015 arid above clarifications. Out of which 09 vacant plots are being taken up in the 1st phase. (e). Total 09 vacant plots are earmarked for allotment through the process ,of e-tendering--cum-e-auction method , for leases of l↩
, I I I ' I ' I ' I 1
1
1
' Reserve P~ice in ',terms I of the', annuf!I lease renf'1 would be lafest \ SoR ', determined in accbrdance witH Para ' 13(a) '. and 1 3 (c) and , woul
I I I
I I I I
I I
I I. I I
(c) •
'
1 'every 15 years by T'AMP. "· 1
I I I
I
'
' I ·, I
I I I I
I ' I
I I . I I . . . I 1
I
I
I
I
~
I
I
,
1 ValiUe (F~V) and Sch~dule of Rates (SO ) for t~e MBf'T plots. \ : l : i : I I
I I 1
I I I '(iv). '
'
I
1 ,
I
I
i
Rec~mme 2020: 1.
I
: i i I ' I ' I
I
I
'
I
' I . I
~ each1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I
I
I
I
I I
I . 1.
.
I I ' 1- ' 1.
1
:
Advisor (~.lanning) in re.spect \of eac~ plot. \ : \ : 1
I I I I I I, '
I
I
I
I
I I I 1.
·, (b}. '
, '
', I ' I ·, I
II • 1,. I '1 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I
I
' I ' I ' I
I
'
I
I I I I I I I
I
I
I
I
I {d}.
I
I
1 I
I
' I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
·
I , I , I , 1,
,
I
I
\
I
I
I
I
I
- i consultatiodi with -~take ~older* withir,, 45 c(ays o'r rece)pt of the propo'sal. T~e Port Trust8oard1 will fix a rate of a~nual eiscalat1pn woul~ not b~ less1than ~%. SoR woqld be refixeq once\in ',which {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} (b).1 In :accor~ance :with ~e above g~idelin~s (Para 13 ;of PGLM 2015} and , above referred clari~cations, Register~d Valuers were ~mpaneled for val\uation: of plqts. Th~ emp~neled\ valuers submitted I their !:_and ~aluati¢n Reports. ! Thes• Valuation Reports were 'Placed befor~ the tand Allotmert Committee (LAC) he~ded by the ~Y- Ctiairma~ and comprising qf Esta~e Marager, Financial A~visor ~ ChiErf _Accqunts (pfficer; Chief, Engi~eer a~d Traffic Manager as members con~t1tute~ to recomm~nd the FairI Market ndatio.ns of1. LAC :appr~ved by the : Board vide TR 61 & !301 ~f I The 1. Land ',Allot1ent Commit~ee, after perusal ~f valyation ~eport~. deliberate~ I case of vacant ploi and r~commended as urider: ' · . \ (a}. ': LAC has \approyed the FM~ of th~ land( base(j on the vali.Jation I report; I, and, the market values in r~spec~ of these 0~ vacaht plots hav~ bee~ co~pute~ as per the \ present FSl1and 1:and u~e peimissi~le un~er th~ by the present oip Regulatiorls and ': for thJ perm'issible' activifies as ', given Rates per{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} Sq. Mtr. (in t.} for FSI ·= 1.0Q haveLbeen ,workep out (as on\ 01.qa.2020) @ \6% return ~n FMV of ~ach riot. :rhes~ rate~ shalll, increase by 4% ~very October. ; {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} Rat~ will lbe proportiqnally increased in! case : the permissible WSI is i plot by MBPT SPA/Planning increased {{^{{FOOTNOTE 11}}}}as may be 'applicable f~r any Authority's :new qc Regulations. I I : : . : ' I ' l ' Upfrc;mt Pr~mium ifor 3Q years, will be calct;ilated ~s per: applioable G-Sec {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} \ rate prevailing at ~he ti"1e of i~viting ~ender( T~e ~bov~ !recomlmendations I of LAC, FMV of the plot and SOR. to 1nv1te :pubhci offer ', throu~h e- ! 1. auction/e-t~nder in respect of ~9 vacant pldts to lease f9r 30 years on the I \ basis of Re~erve Price b\idding!were approv~d by the Board of Truste'.,es of ' ', Port iof Mumbai iVide TR No.261 'dated ', 14.01.2020! and \301 qated \ · 25.02.2020.: Out tjf which, one plot i.e. RR {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} 1925 ,is under reservation for ' , school as per DP 1991 (Para 3 :of TR ~61 of 14.01 L2020), Hence, sairie is 1 not conside~ed in the 1st Phasei {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} I I I (v).' Propos,al I I ↩
भाग दोन---६१-३१८ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ TA~P's awroval lis reqJested \o the ~chedyle of Rjates retcomm~nded Iby theILAC as per Para 4 above and approved by the Board vide TR 261 of 14.01.2020 and TR 301 of 25.2.2020, in respect of 09 vacant plots. Copies of TR 260 Bf 261 ~ated 14.0n .2020 and 301 dated 25.d2.2020 alongl with Schedule of Rbtes are furnished alongwith proposal. These rates will be applicable to sei,lf-occupied premises by lessTes of \\lon-H1yme OfCUpatipn lettings in MBPT.1 I I I (vi). Justification
I
(i).
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} The proposal is formulated in terms of the l.!.and Policy Guidelines for tand Marage"'lent 20115. I I I I I I I
(ii). Under section 4-9 of MPT Act, 19EI>3 antj para 13 (cl of P~LM-2P15, TAMP's approva.l to thJ SOR is sought for the period from 01.08.2020 for self-occupied premises and used for purely Non-home occ:upation of i vacant plots. I I I I I I I I 2.. 2. The MBPT has furnished the Schedule of Rates for vacan~ plots ~vith eff~ct fror1n 01.08.2CD20 as lgiven below: I I I I I I I
Sch~dule qf Rate~ for v~cant plots with effect from 01.08.2020
1
| Is1. . No. · , (1) | I RR 1 Zone I I (2) | I I I Plot No. I I I I (3) | Ffir Matket V~lue per Sq. Mtr. for FSI 1.00 I (Inf) I (4) | Rat~ for F,Sl 1.0~ per S~. Mtr. p.m. w.e.f. 01.08.2020 (To be esc:alatecl by 4% 1 ' I ev~ry odtober)i(ln f ) |
| (5) | ||||
| 1 I | 1 14/101 | R12023 lnduftrial I 1- Us · · | 'I ,24,400.00 (L.and) 10,200.00 (Structure) | (La~d) - 62~.oo I I (Structure) - 51.00 |
| 2 I | 14/101 I I | RR No. 1823 (FCI)- I Industrial 'Use | 1,24,400.00 I I I | 62roo I I I I |
| 3 4 | 14/101 114/101 | Plot No. 25 - Industrial I I Use I 107 - Industrial use | 1,24,400.00 (~.and) 10,1200.00 (Structure) 1 1,24,400.00 | I I ' (LantJ) - 62.2.00 ' , {Structure) - 5~ .00 622.00 |
| 5 I | 11/86 I I | RR No. 1 !~84 - I I Industrial µse | 1,3p,ooo.oo I | 6sp.oo I I I |
| 6 I | 3/35 I I | RR No. 742- Commercial use: I | 1,84, 131.58 I I I | 920.66 I I I I I |
| 7 | Titwala | Survey No.21 and 166 I -Green Zone | 2,760.00 I I I | 1:3.80 I ' I I I |
| I I 1 8 | titwala Titwal~ I 12/22 | ey No.21 arid 166 Su - Residential/ Industrial Sur1vey No.21 an(f 166 1 -Road/Public utilities RR,No. 1304- I I Commercial use | I 22,249.00 I 8,000.00 2,0~,624.Q0 I | 111.25 I I I 40.00 I 1,033.12 I I I |
| 9 I | 2/22 I I | RR 1768 I (Pldt B) - Commercial use | 2,06,624.00 (Land} 61,115.001 (Structure) | (~and) r 1,033.12 I (Structure) - 305.58 |
I I
Area, ~ubject to miriimum 6f FSI Iमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ १९ I 2.
3.
I
,f>.bove rates ~re no~ appliqable tq Way Leave 1/ Special Way Lea,Je charges and sa1e are calculated based on atfove rates as per MBPT regulations. I I I Above rates are exclusive 1of all Taxes (GST, Municipal Taxes, elf.), service Qharge~, f!>en~lti~s. ,n,erest. .• etc. '. Same are beparately pbyablJ by lessees, as may be ~pphcable. These fates are applicable 1for Nop-Hom~ Occ~pationf. I I I I I These rates are applicable to respective plots for E-Tender-cum-E-Auctioh only.
.4. 5.
2.3.
1 1 (\:i) (6). (c).
(~).
•
'
fo~~rdeq to M~PT as feedback imformation. The M~PT h~s not1 resporded 'ill the jcase fas {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
| SI. Ne>. | Information/ clarification sought by TAMP I ! ' ' | Response of MBPT I I I I I I I |
| (i). I I (iii) I (iii). I I I | 1 for Ttle reason fbr seeking approval the rentals mtrospe!ctively from 01 proposed August '2020 ' to l:)e explained 1 with 1 the significance of date of 01 August 2020. Ttie Ann~xures jformi~g part pf the JcR no. j260 and 261 lboth dated 14 January 20 O to be fur.nished. I I I I I I I In respect of the lands at RR - 2023, RR - 18f3, Pix no. f• and(lot 1· 1071 the Valuer ha arriv d at e ma ket v lue of the land at f.1,20,479/- por sq.m. in his Reporf of Septemb~r 2019. The'1 LAC ih its Reports has however, decided to consider the market value of the lamd at ~R - 2023 ~t t1 ,21f ,400/7 per sq.m. This is repported to be the Value of the land arrived based on the SOR a~provefi by TR1 no. 1112 dat.ed 201.os.2019 for the p riod to for the Ready 01.10.2017 30.09.2022 | TAMP 1 Propdsal was ~ent tb on Hxce, 22.07K2020. I ipprolal wis I soug t from 01.08. 020 j Annedures fo TR~ Nosf260 and 261 both ated 14.01 .2 20 are furnished. [Annexures . relate , to tt,e sta~emen\s I showino vacant plots]. I I 1 ' I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ' I I I I I I I I I I |
भाग दोन---६१-३अ२० महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४
| I (a) . I (b) I I I | !Reckd,ner Zpne 11/101 ~t ~,1,15,00P/- pet sq.m with 4% escalation per anlilum as on 01 In ~his regard, · the M~PT td ctob~r 201 19. IO clarifv# furnish the followino: ' . ' ' he dpcumef)tary ~viden(i:e in support! of th~ 1T !market value' of the lland al: ,1, 15,000/- Given that the Valuer has specifically ~eterm jned the Valur of the land :at RR ~ 2023 1 for ih his Valuation Report, 1 reasoh consideration · of alternati\re approach I to bi I I ~xplained. : ! ' i i I i I I 1 I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I | ' · I \ Copy of I valUfltiOn I Report daled 27 .04.201 $ for ,115,000/- is tJrnished. By :valuation report dated 27 .09.20'19, valJers ~ad ~umis~ed value I of f120,479/~ per ' sq.mtr. for RR 2023 fall~ in R;R Zof)e 14/~01. LAC whi1h con$idered the said val~e for the period 01.10.2019 to 30.09.2020. By TR No.112 d*ed 20.08.2Q19, Bbard tlad approved value of , 115,000 per sq.mtr. as pn 011_110.20F wit!'. 4% 1 incre~_se 1 everjy annum for plot$ falling in RR Zone 14/101 for industrial use. While forniulatinQ proposal lfor l,R Zdne 14/101 for TAMP's approval, position was as under : ' , Therefore, in accordance with PGL.M ' Guid~lines, I the ' high, st value of ,124,384 was taken into consideratiorn. | ||||
| I Period | As Per I TR 112 of 2019 1 | As 1 per valuation 1 reijort dated 27.09.2019 | ||||
| 01.~ 0.20117 to 30.09.20118 | ~-11s,oop ' I I | I I | ||||
| · 01 .~0.2018 to 30,09.2019 | t119,60b I | |||||
| 01.10.2019 to I b 30.09.2021 | f124,384 | f120,479; I | ||||
| (c). I | To fur~ish a_ copy of the ,TR nq. 112 1 1 20.08.2019 alon!l with all Annexures. , | dated : Cop~ of TR j No.112 date~ 20.0fi.2019 , , and annexures thereto are furnished. | ||||
| (iv}. I | Likewise, in respect .of the . land at RR - 9nd RR - 17~8, the 1Valuer has c1rrived at the ' market value of the land at ~1.90,717/- sq.m. ir,1 his Report e>f June: 2018. 1 ifs Report ha$ howJver, decided to consider the market value of the land! at RR - 1304 at f ~,06,624/- per1 sq.m. 1This is, repo~ed to be the · Value of the land arrived based on the SOR approve1d by TR no. 150 of 2019 as on 011.10.2()17 for the !Ready iReckoher zdne 2/ 22 at f1,91,036/- per sq.m with 4% escalation p19r annum a¥ on q1 October 2P,19. this hn mgard, the MBPT I clarify/ furnish the to followino: The dod:umen1ary e~idence in support d,f the market value of the land at t1 ,91,036/-. | 1304 , per, The LfC in , , Copy I of valuation rpport fur~ .191,036 Is attached. | ||||
l .. L. . l
L L
Lमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ २१
| b) I | iven the iValue ha~ spefificall~ that .i tll\e Value of the Land at RR ..: determined 1304 in his Valuati?,n Re~ort, t~e remron fo~ donsid~ration \ of aiternat~ apptoach i to b~ Jxplained. . . . . . , ' i ' 1 1 | M/si Patw rdha Con ltant Pvt. td. 1u by their eport ~ated 20.05. 019 . ad furnjshed ~ate of it191,036 for RR Zone 2/2~. By rR Not 150 dated 24.09.2©19 has 1approved the rate of ~-1;1 ,03~Las incre se e"fry on Q1 .10.2017 Jith 4o/J annum. Plot be1ring RR N. 304 also falls 1 in RR Zone 2/22J Shri Avinash Pen~se, a111other waluer ion MBPT panel had furnish.ad th~ rate ff ,19p,717 eer sq . . mtr. as on 01 .1?.2017 for ~R 1 No.1304. Henc , in accordance with PGLr,A guidelines, the lhighes,t rate I of t191,036 was taken intb consideration. After considering 4% xnual incre~se as on 01.10.2018 and 1.10.~019, r,te for tt1e period 01.10.201 to 30.09.2020 1 work d out to ,20~,624 er s .lmtr. | |
| (v) | of 2q19 e TR 1no. 15 s. The ma~et v~lue of \',2,06 \624 p~r sq. rtr. is i After considering urther as on 01.10.2019 as seen from the' LAC · on Rjeport fpr RR [No 13p4 an~ RR Np 176~ .. The j. 01.1 Q.2020 i to 30.09.2021 works out 1to arket plues nd r~tes of rent t9 be uA(1ated 1 1a a . of O 1. August 2020, the d.ate from whiyh the i MBPT hi:ls sought approval 1to the ;sched~le of 1 1 1 1 Rates. ln,l respef~ of~e are~ at RiR No.142, a~d as P•f the re eport ~ated ?4 Fe~ruary ~020, thr. Ma1 | Cop~ of T~ No.150 dated 24.09.20119 and annexures thereto a e furn'shed. , % in. rease}is 1 01.10.2020, rate tor the penod 1 1 1 , .214,889 per sq.rntr. I , : I I I 1 1 1 • , • After ~onsid~ring fi,irther4% increase.as on 01.10.2020, rate fbr the pem\>d 01.1q .. 2020 [.to 30,?9,2011 WOf~S out Ito ,191,;497 per sq.~tr. 1 1 1 ' ' 1 I I I I I I · 1 • ! j ' I I I I | |
| (vi} I (vii~ I | In respect of the area at RR - 1768, the Valuer's Report does1 not reflect the market value of the structure I at f .611, 115/l per sq.m. Thus doctumentf.ry ev\dence in sugport of the 1 ma.rket v lue o'i_the st~cturei at f .6~, 115/t per s .m., to e furnished. · . y MBPT in; the The notel no. 2 proposed proposed I Rent I SchecJule lacks clarity. The MBPT to ~xamipe the i said ~ate a~d pro~ose cha,nges ir the ~aid nqte so ,s to remove tany ambi uit . | , Copy , of . . valuation ~eport datep is attached. :02.12.~019 ~ Refe~ence tp 'the method is at Sl.No.4 on page no.4 1 1 1 1 of the t,1aluation report] I i. i i ,Note i$ amended as - "T ese r tes ar not applicable to Way Leave/ Special I I I ""'ay Leave Oharges" I I I i i | |
- t191,036 was taken intb consideration. After considering 4% xnual incre~se as on 01.10.2018 and 1.10.~019, r,te for tt1e period 01.10.201 to 30.09.2020 work d out to ,20~,624 er s .lmtr. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} ↩
(viii) he nptes p escriqing annual scalatibn on Note is amended as - "these ates a e 1 he rentals and the validity of the proposed valid upto ~10.09.20 22 w\th 4% 'increafe
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
,
I
1· I '
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 The f BPT r,ihile furnishi~g the ladditio'nal infmrmatid,n/ clarlficatio~ vide '1ts ab+e-
| SI. No. I i I (1) '1 . I i 1 2 I 3 I I | RR lzone I 1 I I I \ (2) ~41101 : t,101: 41101 I I | Pio~ No. 1 I I I ' I I I (3) RR No. 18t3 (FCI} - Industrial Use . RR 2023 ~ lndusfrial I 1. Use'. Plot1 No. 2j- I I Industrial se | i Ser sqJ I mtr. per month ~or FSI (In~-) I I I I 1.00 Jwith 1% escalatio.t I I in e erv October) (In~- I I I (5) I I (4) I I I ' I I 647.00 I 1 1 ,29,376.00 I I I I 1,29,376.Q0 (Land} 647.0~ (LanGi) I I 53.00 (Structure) 10,sba.oo ('Struct~re) I I ', 647.00 (Land) : _ 1,29p76.00 {Land) i I I 10,608.00 (Structure) $3.oo | |
| 4 | '4/101 ' | 107 '- Industrial use | , 647.Q0 i 1,29,376.00 i | |
| i 5 I | ' 11/86 i RR No. 1984- I | I I Industrial ube | I I · 676.~0 1 ;35,20~.oo I I : i | |
| 1 6 I | ,3/35 | I RR No. 74f- i 1 I Commercial use | I I ' ' 957.00 1 j91,497 .00 I I I I I I I I | |
| 7 I | Titwa1a · Survey No.21 and I | I 166 !,. Gree~ Zone: | I 14.0p ' : rs10.qo I I I I I 1. I I I | |
| I I I I a I | Titwala I Tjtwala I Surv~y No.r and j I 2/22 ' | Survey No.21 and I 166 J. Resi~ential/ 1 1 I lndu!;trial 166 ,Road/ ublic i utilities 1 I RR No.13~ - I Comtnercia use I | 23,139.00 , 116.010 I I I I I ' I I I I I I I ' 42.0(i) I ' ~.320.00 I ' I I I ' I I i i i ; I I : 1,074.~0 2, ~4,889 '. 00 I I | |
| ~ I I | 2/22 ' I | 1 I RR 1i768 (Plot 18) - Commertcial I use I ' I I I | I 1 '074.00 (Land) 2,l4,899ioo ' I I I I ' 318.00 (Structure) l(Land)1 I I ' ~,560.qo I I I I I tructur,a) I : ' |
I I I
1. ' The~e rates ate valid upto ~0.09.2~22 wi~h 4% iilcreasf every Octoqer. Finst such 4% inctease will be due on 01.10. 021 I I I '. I 1 • 2. I
- Trese rites ar~ applif8ble f~r Non~Home lOccup;ations.l ↩
5. I , 1_ ~ l Iमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ २३ I I I I
,
I I I I I ~ I I I I I I, I I 6. 1 Thes~ rate~ are applicab to refpecti~ plots\for E-tender~cum-E-Auction only. I I ' ' ' ' ' '
I I I I I 1 i A joirit hearing on ';the case in r~ferende was
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 1held oh 17 ~ovem~er 20~0 thro~gh 5J 1 Vjdeo donferencing. 1At the joint hearin~. MBPT ma~e a ~rief pdwer point presentapon of its p~oposa1. The fv1BPT iand the users/ use~ orgaf1isatioris have madd their ~ubmi~sions ~uring the jo,nt hearing: 1
1· 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I I I I
1 1to co~sultati~n in tt)is case are availab,e on ~cords 1 The Rroceetitings r~lating
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 1 at 6.1 1 1 · excerpt of the comment~ rec~ived from tt,e use\s I u~er th~ offi~ of this ALlthorityl An organisations c:ind arguments made by tpe co~ceme~ parties will :be se~t separately to them.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} be ma
1
pe av~ilable at our website1http://fariffau~hority.~ov.in. , •
n,ese d1tails v.jill also 1
1
.
'
'
, • I I I I 1. 1. i.
7.' With ~eferen1ce to totality i of inf9rmatiqn coll~cted during the pr(?cessing of this case, the following position emerges: I
' ' I I ' ' '
I I I I I
I I I I '
I ' I : (l}. The Mumbai Port Ttust (MBPT) ik reported to bwn vast areas of land in the City ,of , ,Mumbai, stretching from 901aba 1to Wadala, Mahim, \Worli, povadpi, and Titwala. 1 1 , ,The MBPT has earma~~d 09 \ vacaryt plot$ (located ini the different Real:Jy 1e-auct\on to the Public/ Private/ GovemrpenU ASU Sector. Accordirgty, t~e MB~T 1
'Reckoner Zones) f1ing-cum- has come up with a, proposal for fixation of lease re~tals in1 respect of the said i 9 metho~. The 1proposial of the jvacant Plots to be allotted '. bY E-Tender-•cum-Auction 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} port h9s the ~pprov~I of its ;Board of Truf;tees. 1 1 1 1
I '· ' ' ' l I I I (ii~.
I
the M~PT h~s filed its proposal, in July 2020. The said Pfoposa, alon~with tt)e information/ ciarification furnished by MBPT during th~ processing •of the \case, js ?onsid(jlred in 1this analysis. 1 1 ', , , 1
1 ',
I
I
'
'
I I I
I I I, 1, I
(iii). this Authority is m~ndate9 to fo,low th~ Land Policy Guidelines ·• issueq by the $overn1r,ent from tirme to time for ithe purpose ~f determining lease: rentals for the lands belongirilg to tHe Port 1Trusts~ The Ministrr. of Sh)pping in the ~overdment of India has an~ouncet:f Lan9 Policy Guid~lines for Major Ports, 20'.14 in ;January 2014 which h~s com~ into ,ffect from 2 .!January 2014'. Subsequently, the Ministry qf Shipping has issued am~nded 4and Policy Guidelines, 2014 und~r Sec~ion 111
of the MPT Act, 1963 for impleme~tation ~ith e~ect frQm 17 .July 2015. Thus, the 1 proposal for fixing ~cale of Rate~ (SOR) for allotment MBPT has, come up ;with a of land ', in re~pect of 9 Vacant Plots f~llowing E-Tender-dum-Au ction rpetho~. 1 b ased on the provisions of the Land Policy Guic:lelines 2014,' as amended in Jul¥ 2p15, at;id read along1 with the various Clarification Circ~lars i1sued ~Y the ~inistry of Ports, ShiRping ~nd Waterways (MOPSW) [erstwhile Ministry of Shipping (MOS)],
1 from time to time. , , •. . \ I I 1
',
' ' '
I
I I I II
I ~I II (iv)lr
I
1 Heads; of Departments of Finance, Estate and1 I
I
· headJd by the Dy .. Chairman qf the Port and the ,
A$ per dause 13(a) read with claus.e 11.2(e) of the Lani:1 Policy Guid~. lines 014, 3i L.~nd Allptmen~ Committee (LAC) constituled by the Poi1 Trus1: Board consi ting o~ Deputy ~hairrnian of fre Po~t. and Ttaffic s~all determine the m~rket Vfilue ofi land as per the methodology prescribed in \claus4 13(a)j Acco~dingly,i the MBPT h~s repqrted about constitution of a Land Allotment Committee 1(LAC) 1 er mei:nbers. Heads of Departments of Fit,ance,\ Traffiq and tstate being the oth The LAC so corstitut~d is seen to have Submitted separate Reports determining th~ market value of each of tlil1 e 9 plcpts of land proposed 1to be d.Uotted~ ' '
, I I I I '7'
I I I I ;
I
1
i (v). i (a). Para 13(a) of the ~and pblicy d~delinr s of ~uly 2915 prescribes the i n:iethodology for determination of rnarke value I of thel land ~ased c:m the : five factors a!s prescribed thereih. In terms 1of the1 said para ?f the
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
, · ' I I I
I I I I I
' ' '२४ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ amended land policy guidelines of 2014, the Land Allotment Committee 1 may normally take into I account the highest of Ithe factors mentidned therein, viz. (i). State Government re1ady reckoner of land values in I the area if available for similar cl~ssificaition/ ~ctiviti~s. (ii).I High~st rate of I actual relevant tra~sactions registered in the last three years in the Port's vicinity with an appropriate annual escalation rate to be approved the Port 1 Trust I Board~ (iii). Highest accepted tender-cum-auction tate of Port land for similar transactions, updateq on the basis of the annual escalation rate approved bv the Port Trust Bo1ard, (iv). Ra•e arri'{ed at Iby an I approIved I I '[ I I I r 1 valuer appointed for the purpose by the Port and (v). Any other relevant factor as may be identified by the . Port. The amended Land Policy 1 guidelines of 2014 ialso stipulates that iin case the L.!AC is hot choosing Ithe highest factor, the reasons for the same have to be rncorded.
I I I I ' I I I I ' I (b}. · To determine the market value of the various plots of land based on the five factors as prescribed in the amended .Land Policy. Guidelines, 1the 1 MBPli is seen to have ap,pointed a Valuer. The Valuer has subImitted I his Report for each of the plot of land, which has been considered by 1the LAC, while determining the market value of the lanq for e9ch of ti,e Plots.
I I I I I I 7 • (
• L I I I ' I I I
(vi). Based on the value of the land 'as suggested by the Valuer for each of the 9 v;acant plots, 1the LAC has recommended the Lease rentals fot eachI of the 9 vacant plots separately, based on which the MBPT has proposed a Schedule of lease rentals for 9 vacant I plots. IThe ahalysis in respect c;>f eacl,l plot pf Ian~ is discussed below: .
(a). 1Ready Reckoner Zone 14/101 - comprisimg of Plot no. 2023, 1823
(FCI), 25 and 107 which are all proposed to be pµt for ,ndus~rial U~e-
1 I I I I I T
1
1
I I I I I 'I' "1
(i). In connection with the Valuation pertaining to the Ready Reckoner 1 Zone 14/101 as per 'various methods Ias stipulatetl in the Guidelines, the valuation report of September 2019, has indicalted the value o;f the land asI per t~e Star np Du~y Re9dy Rei:;kone~ of 2019-20 at ~42,200/- per sq.m. and the depreciated cost I of construction at f 10181.80 per, sq.m. , (i.e. f 2.68 crores being the 1 depreciated cost iof coristructibn for i a built up area of 2631 ~82 sq.m.). The Valuer has stated that there are neither any tender cum auction of the port land for similflr tra11sactioris norI any sale I actions has occurr~d in the past 3 years in the vicinity. The trans Valuer has also: determined the market value of the land 1 considering1 the existing infrastr1uctureI facilities such as water fr6nt area, basin area, future use and uniqueness of location at t 1,20,479/- per sq.m. and the dApreci!:tted cqst of cpnstru~tion at t 3818.18 per sq.m {i.e. t 1.01 crores being the depreciated cost of construction for a built up area of 2631.82 sq.m.).
I
I
- mark19t valye of t~e land at Rf3ady ~eckoijer Zone 14i101 at f 1,24,400/- per sq.m. This is reported to be the Value of the land arrived based on the SOR approv,ed by, TR no. 112 dated 20.08.2019 for the {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} period 01.10.2017 to 30.09.2022 for ttle Real:iy Reckoner Zone 14/101 at , , 1,15,000/- per sq.m with 4% 1escalj3tion pIer annµm as pn 01 Pctob~r 2019. Since the escalated market value of~ 1,24,400/- pet sq.m after considering 4% annual ↩
(ii). However, the LAC in its Report has decided to consider theमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ २५ escalation is seen to be more than the market value of land as I deterrnined 1 the \(aluer, the LAC has recommended , the market value of the land at Ready Reckoner Zone 14/101 at f 1,24,400/ per sq.m.
{iii). It is noteworthy that ttrie MBPT while fl!Jmishihg the additional information/ clarification' in January '2021 has fu'rther updated the market value of land by 4% so as to arrive at the updated market value of the land at t ~ 1,29,376/- per sq.m. as on 01 October 2020. This has now been considered as the market value for the Plot nos. 2023, 11823 {FCI), 25 and 107, falling within the Ready Reckoner Zone 14/101.
I I I I I
{iv). I I
- clarification :in January 2021 has further updated the market value of structure by 4% so as to arrive at the updated market value of the land at, 10608/- per sq.m . as on 01 October 2020. This has now l:Jieen cbnsidered as the ri'larket value of the structures ih the Plot nos. 2023 and 25, falling within the Ready Reckoner :Zone 14/101. {v). Clause 13{b) of the guidelines stipulates {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} that Reserwe Price in terms of annual lease rent would be arrived, as· a percentage of latest market value of land determined based on the five factors in accordance with para 13{a) and that the psrcentage shbuld not be ·Iess than 6% which is to ibe fixed by the Port Trust Board. Accordingly, the lease rental for the' Plot nos. 2023, 1823 {FCI), 25 and 107, fallin~1 within the Ready Reckoner Zone 14/101, has been arrivedl by MBPT at 6% of the market valuE! of th1e land at f 1,29,376/- per sq.m which works out to f 647/- per sq.m per month. Likewise, the lease rental for the structures in the Plot nos. 2023 and 25, falling within the Ready Reckoner Zone 14/101 has been arrived by MBPT at 6% of the depreciated cost of the structure at f 1,29,376/-{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} per sq.m which works out to ~ 53/- per sq.m per month. {b). REtady Rtecko11er Zo,ne 11/86 - comprising of Plot no. 1984,, which is proposed to be put for Industrial Use - {i). In connection with the Valuation pertaining to the Ready Reckoner Zone 11 /86 as per various methods as stipulated in · the Guidelines, the valuation report of December 2019, ha$ indicated the value of the land as per the Stamp Duty Ready Reckoner of 2019-20 at f 27,200/- per sq.m. The {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}Value,r has stated {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} that there are neither any tender cum auction of the port land for similar transactions nor any salei transactions has occurred in the past 3 years in the vicinity. The Valuer has also determined the market value of the land c:::onsidering the existing infrastructure facilities ↩
भाग दोन---६१-४२६ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ uch a~ wate~ front ciirea, br3sin a~ea, fu,ure use and junique;ness 1
s of location at ~1.30,0b0/- per sq.m.
(ii)( "J[he LAC in itsl Report has decided to consider ihe highest mbrket value of the land at ,1,30,000/- p:er sq.m. for the plot of land at ~eady recko~er Zon~ 11/8f· ; i I I I (iii).
I
1
. 1
I
I
-
1 I I I I I
1
I
1 1 1 I
I
महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ २७J I I I I I . I I dccordJnce Wijth par~ 13(a) ~nd th,3 t the percen~age s~ould n{>t be 1$ss thah 6% which is to be fixed b¥ the Port TrJst Board.
~ccordi~gly, ~e leasi rental for th~ Plot ~o. 19~ famnb withih the Ready Reckoner Zone 11/St;>, has ~een arrived li>Y MBF?T at 611/4 of I I I
I ,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
wh'ich is' proposed 'o be
I
I I I I
I I I I
I I I
I
l!:I
· L I I I I I I I. I. I. I. I
,
•
• ' i i
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
aoqot- p~r sq.rrp, by ~elying i on th~ Not~ form~ng pa~ of t~e has pow b~en co~sidere~ as the market val~Je for ~he Su~ey nq.
. .L I I I . I I I
.,.
I I I
I I I
- Valuer's report which indicates that the prevailing I rate of TOR ,in the vicinit~ i~ ~ 4900/- p:er sq.ri1., which fluct~ates depends on t~e mar)↩
I I I \ less Tan 6\ whic1 is to 9e fixei by th, Port ~rust Bfard. \ \ भाग दोन---६१-४अ२८ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ Accordingly, the lease rental for the residential/ industrial use ihas been al-rived tiy MBPT at 6% of the marl
(e). Ready Reckoner Zone 2/22 - comprising of Plot no. 1304 and 1768
(Plot B) which is proposed to be put for Commercial Use - .
(i). In connection with the Valuation pertaining to the1 Ready Reckoner Zone 2/22 as per vari'ous methods as stipulated in the Guidelines, the valuation report of June. 2018, .has indicated the value of the land as per the Stamp Duty Ready Reckoner of 2018-19 at ,:1,01 ,300/- per sq.m. The Valuer has stated that there are neither any tender cum auction of the port land for sinnilar transactions nor any sale transactions has occurred in' the past 3 years in . the vicinity. The Valuer has also determined the market value of the land considering the existing1 infrastructure facilities at t 1,90,717/ per sq.m.
(ii). However, the LAC in its Report has decided to consider the market value of the land at Ready R,eckoner Zone 2/22 at t 2,06,624 pet sq.m. :This is reported to be the Value of the land as arrivE?d based on the SOR approved by TR no. 150 of 2019 as on O1.10.2017 for the Ready Reck(l)ner Zone 2/22 at , 1,91,0:-36/ per sq.m with 4% escalation per annum as on 01 October 20119. Since the escalated market value of , 1,91,036/- per sq.m after considering 4% annual escalation is seen to be more than the market value of land as determined the Valuer, the LAC has recommended the market value of the land at Ready Reckoner Zone 2/22 at f 1,91,036/- per sq.m.
(iii). It' is noteworthy that the MBPT while furnishing the additional information/ clarification in January 2021 has further updated the market value of land by 4% so as to arrive at the updated market value of the land at f 2, 14,889/- per sq.m. as on 01 October 2020. This has now been considered as the market value for the Plot no. 1304 and 1768 (Plot B), fallin~1 within the Ready Reckoner Zone 2/22.
(iv). Olause 13(b) of the guidelines stipulates that Reserve Price in teirms of annual lease rent would be arrived, as 1a percentage' of latest market value of land determined based on the five1factors in accordance with para 13(a) and that the percenta~Je should not be less than 6% which is to be fixed by the Port Trust Board.
Accordingly, the~ lease rental for the Plot no. 1304 and 1768 (Riot B) falling within the Re:ady Reckoner Zone 12/22, has been arrived b¥ MBPT at 6% of the market value of the land at ., 2, 141889/- per sq.m which works out to, 1074/- per sq.m per month.
महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ २९M· 1 As r~gards Ithe Structurei at Plt no. [1768 f lot 8) withih the I
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I m.
I
I I
I ' I
| Ready Stamp Depreci,ted duty I cbst of Reckonfr I I 'Zone cpnstruc~ion readyl recko?e a~ on \ I I r rate , I o~.10.2020 I (~ Per (intrr I I ' . ) sq. m s~.mtr.) I 1 I I 2019-20 | Rate per sq. rlitr. Hjghest r~te Hiphest Rate arrived ~t by a~ Market I - 1 I vall!le as ac;cepted , approved valuer Per mfnth o(actual 1 I i I I Tender- (per sq. mtr.), relevant per~LAC I I I I cutn- Land , tr, nsactidns struc;ture (pe, I in'the las( 3 sq.mtr) au'ction I rate of I La~d yiars 'tructure I I I I I I ' I port land , I I I I I I NIL 129,376 120,479 3818.18 INIL : 647 \ 53 I I NIL 1NIL I, I | 676 : 135,200 130,000 NIL NIL I I I 1, I | |||||||
| 14/101 i I 10,608 42,2P0 | |||||||||
| I NIL 11/86 l I 27,200 (plot No.1984) , I I | |||||||||
| 1 3/35 i 78,4p0 I I NIL I I folot No,742) I I NIL I l'itwala 6,900 I I I I (Survey No. I 21 and 166) I I I I (Residel"\tial/ I industrial I I I NILi , NIL Green 2< ne ' Roads/ Public 1 utilities | I NIL NIL I 1 . I I | I ' NIL NIL I NIL I I I I I NIL NIL I I | ~IL I I NIL NIL I | 1 I i i , NIL 957 i 184,1312 191,497 NIL I I I I I I 116 NIL! 231139 NIL 22,2~9 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I . 1 I 2,870 2,760 I NIL 14 NIL1 42 NIL NIL NIL1 8,f20 I ' I I I | |||||
| 2/22 (plot no. 1:304 and I ' 1!68) I I | I I NIL \ 101,300 ' I I I I I ' I I I I | I I NIL I I I I I I | NIL ' ' I | I 190,717 I I I I I | 61,115 : For Land 1074 3181 I I 214(889 I I I Fbr I structure I I I I I I 63,560 I |
' I I I I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I I \
, 1 I I
I {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
- has further u{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}pdated {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} the market v~lue of land by 4 % so as to arrive : I at th~ updated market v~lue of lthe sti·ucture {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} at , 6l3,560~ per , sq.m. ,as on 01 OctC!lber 2020. As {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}stipulated in Clause {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}13(b) of the . guidelines, 6% of tt;1e ma~↩
1३० महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ Iy, thel lease l rental, has ~een arrived pY M~PT at ' 6% of the 1
Boa~d. AcCfOrding market value.
, , , , , , , I
I
I
I
1
J ' I Icvm).
modified bihLAC fS diSCIJSSed,
I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I
' : i i i i J I I I I I ' (x). I I I
I and "t the IJ"arket1value ff the lrnd.
I
[Howe'l'er, the MBPT has ~ropos~d the ~alidity ',upto 3b.9.2022 i.e. bnly tor 2 years, I
j. j ..
I I j.
I j .. j ..
महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ३१ ' I I I\
I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I
that the MBPT has not 1envisa\ged le\vy of ~ny Way leave/ Special yv_ay le~ve charg~s in the said plots :of land. The judgment of the pof1 in thi~ rega~d is relied upon. However, if ry'IBPT ~mvisa~es anj Way leave/ ~pecia\ Way ~eave 1n the ~aid ', 9 vac~nt plots in future, the MB T is advised to seek the aJl)proval of this Authdrity follo>Ajing Land Policy ,for Way leave/ Special Way L :ave ~ith dufr justification !Guidelines, 2014. \ · 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I
. , 1 1 appro\ved b~ this tr,uthority is ej,cclusiv~ of a~y tax~s and
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
(x"v). The MBPT has also proposed a mote to 1the effect tha~ the rates are exclusive of1all \Taxes (GST, Municipal Taxes, etp.), Pe~altiesJ Interest. etc.: and that the same are 1 by lessees, ~s may1 be applicabl$. In th,is regard, it iii to sttte separately pilyable 1 that th~ tariff 1 statutory duties. ,The taxes and statutory duties are to be levied. by the Port ~t the applicable fates er the ,ariff SCf. approved bf this J;\uthori,y. In v,ew of \this pcpsition, : the nqte as proposed tl>y the rort is approv:ed. ; I I I I I I I
' .
' I I (xy). I I
' ' I I I
The M$PT has also \propo~ed a riote to ~he effkct tha~ the rates ar~ appli6able for tjJon-Home Occupations. As brot!ight o(Jt earli'~r. th~ vario1-1s plo\s of l~nds are reported to be allotted for ¢0mm4rcial and industrial uses. A.s such the propos~d note is approved. I I
'
I I I I
'
'
'
I I I I I ' {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
' I I I I I
1 1 \ . , , 1 1 1 r- . I I
' ' I I I I
j I
, , I
Ill I
1 Member {Fi~nce) ·
I
I
I,३२ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ Annex. I
I I ' I I I I
I
Sc~eduie of Rates (SOR) for 1the g' plot~.
I I I
| I I I I I '. RR Zone ~I. o. I I I I | I I I I I Rate Per Sq! Mtr I ' I I I I I I I Pet Month I I I I I Plot No. I As On 01.10.2020 1 I I I I I : ~In') : I 1 ' I I I I I I | ||
| (2)1 1 (1) | 1 I I I I (4) I (3) I I I I | ||
| · 14/101 11 | I I I I 647.00 I RR No: 1823 (FCI) -l Industrial Use | ||
| ,2 I 14t1q1 | i I , 647.90 (Land) i i IRR 20~3 - lndustriali. Use I I I ,53.00 1(Structure) I I I I I | ||
| I I . 14/101 I ? | I I I , 647.00 (Land) . i Industrial Usa riot No. 25 - i I 53.00 (Stricture)! | ||
| 1 4 | · 14/101 | I I I I I 647.00 I 107 - Industrial use I | |
| ,5 ,6 7 I I ·B I 9 | 11/815 1 I 3/3~ Titwala | I I I I I 676.00 ~R No. 1 1984 r lndu$trial u~e I I I I I I 957.00 RR No.1742- \Commercial wse I I 14.QQ I I SurvevNo.21 :and 166-Green Zone I | |
| I Titwala | ' , i \ I 116.00 Survey No.21 1and H 6 - Residential/ lnd~strial i | ||
| 1 Titwala 2/221 I I i 2/221 | 42.00 Survey No.21 and 1E 6 -Road/ Puolic utilities , I RR No.I1304 , Commercial [use 1014.oo I I I I ' i I I I 1074.b0 (Land) RR 1768 (Plot B)- Commercial use I 1 318.Q0 (Stnilcture)i I I | ||
I I I
I I I I I I
I
I I Notes.1 1 : I ' I I I I I I I ·. I I I \
' I I
1
Iमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ३३ ' I I ' ' I I I I I s~MARY dF THE coiMME Ts Ece1vEd FRdM T E P01RT USERS , USE ORGANISAT ONS 'AND ARGf MENTS MADS IN THIS OASE DUR NG I
1 1
1,
, II I THE J~INT ~EA~ING _EFORE T~E AUTH RI • '.
I
I
I
'
I I I I I
II
II
II
II
II I ',
1 Ill
Ill I : :, '1 : ', : II +··· ',, ',,
A su'mma~ of t,he ctjmmer' ts repeived fro'11 sor11e of ~he u~ers / user
1
,
I,
1,
\
,
,
1 1
| 1 1 \ Comments of Users orr user organitations I, I I, ' I I I I ' I 1 , 1 |
| 1 1 I , Pt. Yashodep Eduieational Charitable Society/ T~ust Our Trust named ~- Yas~odeo Educational Charitable llrust is ready, to take the land on lease to eistablish worlt:f-clas$ Bhar~t Rat~a At~I Bihari Vid~apeetll. Our' previc,us ?PPlication d2,tted 21,-11.2014 is ~!ready in your possession. 1 Unfo1unately, you!have rtot fent the details of the existing plots. Would be in 1terestJd for ready-made j::>remis,es becapse we want :to v,there Medic~! Hospital & ,Other 11nfrastructure is rea~rny aV13ilable 1, Medical, Engineering, M~nagerpent etc. colleges, ,preferably in the vicinity ',of 1 Mumb~i. Willibe interested for attachment with your h:ospital,locatep at Wfidala c:,nd other 1 1 1 ' 1 1 ! , I 1 I ' ' . Jeevao Jvot Cancer Relief & Care Trust 1 1 It is an Non-profit, Non-Government org~nizatipn sinqe 37 years old trus~. 1 I i I I I I I I I I i I I I I I I . . ' Requesting to1, allot u~ any abandoned plot at nominal ·and affordable cost!/ price~ Sine~. we are , running on ponatiq>ns and blessings ?f the :cured \patienb, monthly rental ~f f. 10ooq1- per ', mont~ can ~e given. I~ this ~ngoin9 pan~emic there is decrtease In 1 , ' donations and. the amount of work is increased; , 1 1 |
| , Sr. ,no , 1. | 1 1 \ , Comments of Users orr user organitations I, I I I I I ' I 1 1 , Pt. Yashodep Eduieational Charitable Society/ T~ust |
| 1 .\, 2. | Our Trust named ~- Yas~odeo Educational Charitable llrust is ready, to take the land on lease to eistablish worlt:f-clas$ Bhar~t Rat~a At~I Bihari Vid~apeetll. Our' previc,us ?PPlication d2,tted 21,-11.2014 is ~!ready in your possession. 1 Unfo1unately, you!have rtot fent the details of the existing plots. Would be in 1terestJd for ready-made j::>remis,es v,there Medic~! Hospital & ,Other 11nfrastructure is rea~rny aV13ilable Medical, Engineering, M~nagerpent etc. colleges, ,preferably in the vicinity ',of ~et up 1 1 Mumb~i. Willibe interested for attachment with your h:ospital,locatep at Wfidala c:,nd other 1 1 1 ' ! places., I Jeevao Jvot Cancer Relief & Care Trust |
| I I | It is an Non-profit, Non-Government org~nizatipn sinqe 37 years old trus~. i i I I I I I I i I I ' I I I I Requesting to1, allot u~ any abandoned plot at nominal ·and affordable cost!/ price~ Sine~. we are , running on ponatiq>ns and blessings ?f the :cured \patienb, monthly rental ~f f. 10ooq1- per ', mont~ can ~e given. donations and. the amount of work is increased; , |
I I
I I !
I I ' ' '
·
I I 2. , . _1 Ip vieyt of the out~reak 1
of cqv10 -r 19 and in ~ursu~nc~ pt the IIMinistry 1
1
, '
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I,
[
i i
'. 1.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I
I I I I I I
I I I i i I I I
1
1 1
1 Mumbai Port!Trust (MBPT) I,
I
. ' I I I
I I
I I
' ' I I I ' I I ' (i). 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I I I
I
'
I I I,
(ii). ' R~gistejred Value~s we\re e~:npanrled for v~luation at plots. Th~ e~panErled 'l'alue~ submitted their Larid Valuation Reportsl The Land A!lotm~nt C9mmi,tee, after perus~I of 1
va1u1tion ~eports, has
I
- I I, I I i I ' ', ,TAM~/26/~020~MBPT : '; Mumbai Port i,rust (MBPT) se~king, app~oval rcf Schedule', of ~eas~ Re~tals ! in r~speqt of 9 , Vac~nt Pl',ots at various places in Mumb~i to t;,e I allotied ~Y E-tend~r-cu~-Auction~ met'1od 13t Murtjbai Rort Trust fMBPT). I , , , o~gani~ation$ are piven\ belo'.W: {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} · of $h1pp1~g (f\j1OS) \letter No. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}1105~/30/2020-CJ;oord. dated 16 April 2020 to hold s, a jqint hyaring on the case in rt. fere1ce wias held on h 7 Ndvemtler Confrrenoing. At the ljoint ltlearing, MIBPT made a brief power virtual m~eting 2020 thrqugh Video {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} point presentation of its propo~al. The MBPT ,and the users/ user brgan~satiohs havt made th~ sub~issiors during the joint hearing. I, I ' I' , earmarked for allotment throug~ the ~roce~s of e- for . lea~es pf {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}9nd ~o tHe Reaqy tenderi~g-curn-e-c3/uctiop m~thodI P~blic/fi>rivate/Go~./PSU Sector. These plots are falling i,n five R~cko11er zones. 1 1 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} l' ' I I ↩
भाग दोन---६१-५३४ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ deliberated on each case of vacant plot and recommended the market value of the land based on the valuation report in respect of each of these 09 vacant plots. Market values have been computed as per the present FSI and land use permissible under the present DC Regulations and for the permissible activities as given by the Advisor (Planning) in respect of each plot.
(iii). The recommendation of the LAC has been approved by the Board of Trustees of MBPT.
(iv). The MBPT in its presentation has indicated through Maps, the location of each of the nine plots. Plot wise details are also shown.
ITM University
(i). We need time to give our comments.
[Member (F): You can submit your comments within 10 days.]
Amit Infra Logic India P. Ltd
(i). We also need time to give our comments.
[Member (F): You can submit your comments within 10 days.]
Youth Welfare Centre
(i). We want a copy of powerpoint presentation.
[MBPT agrees to share the copy with YWC]. -महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ३५ (Published in Part -111 Section 4 of th◄e Gazette of India, Extraordinary) I Ta rli f f JA.ulthc!:>ri-ty f<>r 1 1V1aj<>r Pb r t.s I I .
I I
In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 49 of the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 (38 of 1963), the Tariff Authority for MaJor Ports hereby disJ;>oses c;>f the qpplical ion rec;:eived 1 from ' MumlJai Port Trust (MBPT) seeking amendment to the Order No. T AMP/26/2020-MBPT dated 16 March 2021 passed by this Authority approving the Schedule of Lease Rentals in respect 1 of 9 Vacant, Plots at varie>us places in Mumbai to be allotted by E-Tender-cum-Auction metfuod at MBPT, as in the Order appended hereto.
'· T.S. Balasubraman
, ian
Member (Finance) भाग दोन---६१-५अ३६ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ I I
. : Ta Jiff ~uth+.rit~ for MajAr P~rts \ "I Case No. TAMP/26/2020-MBPT . I
I - - - I Applicant
The, Mum~al Po~ Tru~t
(i}. (ii), I
I QUORUM I I I I I I Shri. T.Sl Balasubramanian, Mem9er (Fi;nce) i SHri. Sunil Kumar Sinl)h, Mehlber (Econo ic} i
I
I I I 'I' I I
I I I ~R IDE~ I I
(Pa~sed on thi~ 5th dart of Septemljer, 2021)
I I
I
1 I l1his ca~e relates to J.an applicatidn datJd 02 !ugust ~021 receiv~d from Mu~bai 16 March
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I ' I ' I . ', I ', I i I I j I . .
3. . I~ this 9ackdr~p, the MBPT vide lits lett~r No.FNOEA-U13(20)/Gen/164 dated 2 1 AugJst 202¼ has requested to ,amend certain para_s i.e. ,Para 7. (xi) a~ well as Not~ 1 of ,tnnex~re 1 and fara 7(xii) o~ the order Nb. T AN1P/26/~020-r~1BPT ~ated ~ 6 Match 2021. Tre sulfmissiqns i mad~ by t~e MBPT in its application dated 2 1 August 2021 and 1 the feasons for proposed
| 1 | |||
| Sr. No. | 1 Existing para ' 1 1 1 | Proposed amendment I ' I I | Reason for amendment 1 I I I |
| a. | : 1 Para 7 (xi) of the Order | 1 , 1 1 | 1 ' 1 ' - |
| "The MBPT is seen to have I proposed a note tc> the Sffect tt1at 1 the lease rentals ', are valid upto .30.09 2022 , withi4% ,increafe 1 . every October an that first suF~ I increase will be e ective from 01 i October 202[1."· In this regard, it', is here to I mention that Irelevant .Clause 13 (c) ·of the Lar;id Polipy 'Guidelines of 2014, stipulates tHat 'the Port Trust Board will fix a rate f annual e~calation whi~h would Io ot b1;3 less1 than , 2% ~nd also 1n mentions that the SOR would be re:-fixep once in 5 y~ars by TAMf>. the I MBPT has Accordingly, 1 propo~ed 4% annyal esfalatiop. le~se re~t be~~g .l\lso, ~ince _ihe for the penod approved 1! beginning 011 Octoper 2020, t~e said fe~se slllall be1 subjebt to itis on first annual escalation 011 ¢)ctober 202n, in 1 line With the 1 !Land Policy I Guidelines.' 2014. | Tj1e Ml3PT seen to ip have pn;ipose9_ a not~ the effect ' that the lease rentals I are Yalid Iupto 3GJ.09.2Q22 1 with increase every Oc\ober ariid first such that increasel will tle effective . _ fr<;>m 01 pctobEt,r 2021 1 i 1 1 1 · 1n this regard, it is rejevant Ihere fa melhtion th~t Clause 1l(c) ofl the Land Policy GUidelinjs of 1ctarified I 2d14stipL1ates that the Pdrt Trust Boatd will fix a ra~e of 9nnual 1escal~tion w~ich Wlj>uld npt be less than 2% and wduld beI re-fixed once in 5 year~ by, TAr-,1P. Acpordin~ly, ltl.e M'PT has oroo9sed 4% anr:1ual | 1n terms ofl Para 113(c) et 1 pf I PGLM, th'~ app~·oval • TAMP is necessary for the 1 I fixatitjn of latest ~OR. A 1 4% 1 Writ Petition filed tiy MbflT . challenging TAM~s I I notifidation I was pendi, \9 I I befor~ the Hon'ble High since, · 200(1). ICourt 1 i Subs~quently, after deliberations with th1e I Ministry, and the I TAMi,0 ! officials, lthe I TAMP thf.t the SO~ pplicable ~o Township 1a areas of MbPT from 01.10.'2012 to be lnotifieij by T.AJMP a/id he~ce thb also Writ ' Pe\ition , wa~ mentions! that I the SOR Withdr~wn fr1m Higt'I Cou1 In terms of by MbPT. clause1 13 of PGL!M, the SOR ~ill bel for 51 yearsl. Therefore, revision of |
- Port{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}Trust 1(MBPT) seeking amendment toI the 0Irder No. TAMP/26/2020-MBPT dated 2021 passrd by ~his A~thorit¥, apprqving tj'le Sc~edule {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}of Le.se Rentals in resJect of J9 Vaclant Plot1 at va~ious P\aces ir Mun,bai to ~e-allo~ted b~ E-Te.rlder-c~m-Audtion method at MBl!>T. \ 2. J_ lti may ~e rerialled ~hat this Authority vide its Order No. 'TAMP/26/20~0-MBIPT date~ 16 o/)arch 12021 1has disposed the Iproposal received from MBPT 1 seekihg approval .for Plots at vari~us places inj Mumlfai to ~e allotted Schedule of Lease Rentals in respect of 9 'Vacant 1 by ErTender-cum~Auction me.hod al MBPT, The said order ~as been notified in the ~azette of lndial on 12{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} April 2021 vi(je Gazette No. 165. I ↩
_Iमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ३७
| I ,___~1 __ 1 __ 1 ______ 1 -~1 | Hpwev:[, t111e ~BPT I has 1 proposed the validity • upto 30.9.2022 i.e. only for 2 ~ears, 1 which i~ changed to 30.09~2025. . begipning Accordingly, the Note prescribed I changled to the effe;ct." is 1 I I 1 ___ _ I __ I __ ~' _ | esc11ation. I Also, sinje the lease rent being approved is for the periqd I 01 10ctob~r 2020, the said lease shall I be subjec~ ' to 1 its first annual escalation on 01 October 2021, in line with the Land I Polidy I The Guidelines, 2014. MB~_T hasj propqsed th,e valicllty upto 30.9.2022 i.e. only for 2 years. Accqrdingl½ No~e the prescribed is changed to I the effect. ___.. __ · _1 __ - - - j the | S(l)R for the r?_eriod ~rom 01.10.2017 to 30.09.2022 isdto be ~otifieq by T1MP. A cordingly, prbposals for · approval of SOR, for the lettings i~ Township Auea , fo~ above period has t!>een m~oted. The n?.tified SOR .plots •Was for 9 v~cant prepared based I on re~omm~ndatior,s of L.and · Allotment Committee formed as per Para 113 of PQLM 2015 an~ approved by the Board vide TR No 261 & 301 of 202Q for 1. yeairs' period from |
| b. t- - --+-- - -~---. . ... __ _. . _ _. _ ________ - ' - - - - ' - -1 | Note 1 in Annexure (SOR) : | 01.10.2017 to 30.09.2022. | |
| · I · | "Tre lease re~tal ~h,11 remain in I The I lease· force for a period of five years effective : from 1 October 2020 to 39 September! 202~ subject @ increase p.a every 4% 09tober. First ;such~% increase 1 will be due on 01.10.2b21: I I ' | rent11 shall remain in force for a period effective from 11>t to I October 2b20 3(jh io September 2022 subject to inFreas~ @ 4% P-t'!· ever}j' October. ~irst such increase will be due , 4% on01.10.20~1. I | Th-~reforet, the 1validitr. of the SOR for the subject 09 . va~.ant J:?lots ~as ~een decided I to be upto 30.09.2022 to bring the uniformit~ in Sof peri~ of 1 • • MbPT. |
| c. | Para 7(xii) of the Order | 1 1 1 , | I I I I |
| I I | "The MBPT hasl proposed another note to the effect that the rent will be1 worked_ out ~n the ~ases of the Actual Built-up area, subject to minimum of FS'I 1.00. Since the sajd note gives: clarit~ and *ould avoid ambiguit~. the proposed note is ;1pprovrd. Howevrr, rate will increase for 'higher FSI, th~ MBPT is advised to seek the approval pt this !Authority for !such higher rate with due justification.▪ I I , I I | The MBPT as proposed another note to the effect that I the tent be fill worked out on the basis of the AGtual Built-LI(? ' area, I subjedt to minimum Since the said ,·Fsl 11.00. if I note gives I claritly an~ would avoid ambiguity, I the proposed note i~ for I approved. IHoweJer, higher FSI, 1 the MbPT is I advisfd to calculafe renf propo'rtionately per as applicable higher FSI at · the rat~ ~ame I SOR' approved by the TAMP. I | The SOR has been calculated taking into acdount F~I 1.00, which is a base unit. However, for an~ increased p~rmiss/ble FSI as per D.C. RegulatioAs of MCGM and MbfT, SPA, rert will I be calculated proportionately as per J;iermis$ible ~SI. I ThE;1re is no need to seek approval of the TAMP : for increase ip FSI which will be ' in accordance with applicable D.C . . Regulatiorls. Hbnce this clause needs to be ~hewn I in amfrnded I as I italics. |
I
- .Authority vide its 0rder No. TAMP/26/2020-MBPT dated 16 March l2021 !ilas ~pproved thj Schedule o~ Leas~ Rentals in rrspectl of 9 Vacant I Plots at various places in M mbai belonging to MBPT and to be allotted by MBPT through E- Tendei·-cum-Auction. · I I I I ↩
- 1 I {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}With rr.f~rence to t~e subrnissiohs ma{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}e by MBPT vide. it$ letterl dated: {{^{{FOOTNOTE 2}}}} August 2021, the following pos1t1on emerges: · · · (i). lsasedl on a{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}proposal fil~d by !Mumb~i Port Trust (MBPT) in !July Jo20, ihis ↩
i" its p~oposa\, the fv1BPT h~d proposed anote ~o the ~. ffect th_. at thJ_ lease ~. entals · increase will bE: effe~tive fr9m 01 Qctobeli 2021. i_ In this 1
~,ire val1d upto 30.09.2022 twith 4P/o incr~ase every October and that first such _ re~ar9, refer~nce is; drawn tp para \no. 7 (~•) of ttie Order dated 16 March 2~21, wh)ch 1s r~produced below:
I I I I I I I
,
;
,
• •~The MBPT is seen fo hav~ f!ropose~ _a !note tcp the effect t~at the \lease ('entals are valid uptd 30. 09, 2022 :with 4% mcr~ase every dctoberi and that first such ihcrease will be effective from 01 qctober~021. 1
I I . I : : I I I I ' : :
I
I I I I
,
,
,
, • 1
·
I I I •
,
I I . I I ! : I I I I ' I .
I I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
•
'
'
'
,[
I I I
I
J -
I I I I I ' I I I ' ' ' I I I I I I J -
J - J - J -
- ·{{^{{FOOTNOTE 12}}}} to {{^{{FOOTNOTE 30}}}} Sep ember 1{{^{{FOOTNOTE 2011}}}} ,s well {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}as the quinq{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}Jennia! perio~ from p1 Octo.ber 20·17 to 30 Sept mber 2022. Thus, to have 'unifo~ity in $OR pEiod, tht. e MBf11T is se~n to have proposed valicHty u~to 30 ; September 2022 1 res ect of1 the Scltaedule I of Lease R~ntals for 9 Vacant , Plots •at various p aces i Mumbai. Pr~scripti9n of a\ common vali~ity pefiod forl all th~ land parcels 1would {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}enabl~ the port to file. a compreher1sive prpposal 1for revision of lease irentals, for th~ estatE;S of MBPT (which has nev~r materializec1 incase of MBPT till dat~). for the period be>jond 3<;) Sept~mber 12022. Based 'on the reasci,ning g)ven by the Rort an~ to ha~ uniformity iff'I the tariff vaUclity period, this Authority is ,inclined to pr~scribe the vali~ity upto 30 Septe~1ber 2b22. As such the '1ote nq. 1 fo(ming part of i the . Sc~edule pf Rates (SQR) for the 9 plpts as ~pprO\jed vide Order date9 16 M~rch 202,1 is modified.. · I 1 1 1 I (""") I Ill • In i~ propbsal, the MBfl>T had also propos~d another note to tl1e effect that I the rent {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} will t,e worked out on the basis of the Actual B~ilt-up 1area, ~ubject to minimum of FSI 1,00. lri this r~gard, reference is ~rawn tp para I no. 7 (xii) of ithe Ord~r date:p 16 March 2021, wllich is ~eprodJced below: 1 1 1 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} "The MBP'r has propos~d another ndte to the effe~t that :the reht will be worked out bn the basis dfthe Actual B {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}uilt-up area, subject to minimum or FSI 1r00. Siqce the said note gives clarity and wou{d avoid am1iguity, j the propose'r:J note, is approved. flowev~r, if rate wil/: incre~e for 1nigher iFSI, tne MBPT is advised to seek the approval of this Authorfty for ~uch higher rate with ,due justification." ↩
I -महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ३९ I I I I I I I I I
I
I I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
the riginal 1 propcpsal of MBRT of I July 2020), 1
I
I I
FSI i$ incr1ased ps m~ be applicsble for any plot b{{^{{FOOTNOTE *}}}} MB~T SPr Planning \ I
1 1
I I I
I I I I I I
I
I
• 1 1 1 I I I . . I I I . I I . .
I I I I I ·
"
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I, I, I, I I 1 I I I I II : I I I I I I I I
I
I I I 1.
I .
- same SOR rate approve? by th~TAMr- It is 1notewprthy that thS LAC ih its Report I (which formed p rt of has I recommend~d that the rc:1te will e proportionally indreaseciJ in case the permissible 1 \ Auth9rity's 'lew oq Regulationsl 1 : I I I I I , Given that ttie bas~ leas~ rent ~s app~oved t,y this 1'\utho~ity vide the Qrder d~ted : 16 March 2021 will remain intact and would be cj,nly proportic~nately incre:!ised .based on the FSI, this Authority is inclined to approve the ~roposfl of Mf3PT i'l this :regard . : . \ \ \ \ I ! I I 5. t. In the result, and for the reaions ~ive a~ove, find blj:lsed cpn the l colledtive application of m ind, thjs Authprity ail>proveb to re lace tpe exi~ting nqte no: 11 and l,2 forming part of the Schedule of _Rates (SOR) for the 9 vacfant pl · ts as approved vide Order dated 16 Mfrch 2~21 , with the followintnote~: I I I I I I I I 1 : . " , {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} .\ he lekse rehtal shall -remain in force for a period pt two I years 1. effect{{^{{FOOTNOTE 11}}}}v. e frol)Tl. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} I pctob'r_r {{^{{FOOTNOTE 202}}}}q. to {{^{{FOOTNOTE 30}}}} i s_ eptelln. ber {{^{{FOOTNOTE 2}}}}b{{^{{FOOTNOTE 22}}}} sJbject tb incre,{{^{{FOOTNOTE 3}}}}se @ 1{{^{{FOOTNOTE 4}}}}% p.f{{^{{FOOTNOTE 3}}}} every October. I I I first st,ich 4 ~ increase willl be due on O1 .1 O .2d21 *ent wj(I be worked lout or\ the brsis of1Actual BuilHJp Area, sulJject to 1minimum of FSI ~.00. In the e~entufany increase_d permissiblEi FSI as per D.C. RE:rgulatiq.rns of MCt-M anq MBPT, the tent will be pir.oportidl.natelyl. calcufated as per ~pplicaple Higher -SI at ,he sarre SOR rate as approved by the tr AMP! {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} • l R) 1 1 T1he MaPT is advis~ci to m 1ake sJitable bhanges in the Schedule of Rates (SO 5.2. for the 9 vacant plots as approved v1de Ord~·¾r date~ 16 ~arch 2021. 1 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} , T.S. Balasubr·amanian , Member (Finance) , ↩
( Published in Part - Ill Section 4 of the Gazette of India:, Extraordinary) T ,AR.IFfF Al.)THORITV FOR MAJOR. 1 PORTS
G.No. 535
New Delhi, 01 November 2021:
·N C>"TI F l·~~ '"TIC> N
महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ४१I I Applicant
QUORWM
(i). Shri. T.S. Balasubramanian, Member (Finance) (ii). 1 Shri. Sunil Kumar Singh, Member (E!conomic)
C>~D 1E~ 1
(Passed bn this 5 th day of October 2021)
1 1 1 This qase relq1tes to a proposal received frbm Murtnbai Pdrt Trust (MBPT) vide Its letter No.FA/OEA-U21(90)/Gen/229 dated 07 September 2021 seeking approval for fixation of Schedule of Rates (SOR) for way leave I special ,way leave fee;, of M£;1PT fo~ the PE:jriod trqm (1)1 .10.2017to30.09.2022. I I I I I
I I I I I I
i i i I i i i I I I I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
: 1 I
I
I
I
l
I i i i I i j
- 4. This Authority desires that the following Wair leave Schedule for MBPT prescribing 8cheduh~ of W<3Y leave char9es for. the 17 Readr Reckl)ner Zqnes for Carg0 Operii3ted a rjd Reckoner Zones for Non Cargo Operated Pipelines of MBPT associated pipelines arid for 31 Ready fqr the P¥riod 01 1 Octob~r 2017 imay be notified without waiting for notification of the Speaking Order: ↩
भाग दोन---६१-६४२ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ "
SCHEDULE OF WAY LEAVE CHARGES OF MUMBAI PORT TRUST FOR THE PERIOD FROM 01.10.2017 TO 30.09.2022
(i). Special Way Leave rates as on 01.10.2017 for Cargo Operated pipelines etc.
| Sr.No 1 2 | Division/ Village Name Colaba Fort | R RZone No. 1/3 1/3A 1/6 1/6A 2/9 2/12 2/13 2/22 2/23 | Rate per Sq. meter per month applicable for over - ground pipeline / cable as on 1.10.2017 (to be charged for FSl=1) (inf.) 1,400.00 1,196.50 983.00 943.00 750.00 1,149.00 915.50 506.50 485.00 |
| 2/34 | 492.50 | ||
| 3 | Princess Dock | 3/35 | 392.00 |
| 3/358 | 389.50 | ||
| 3/36 | 282.00 | ||
| 3/36A | 492.50 | ||
| 4 | Malabar Hill | 7/64 | 1287.50 |
| 7/66 | 1960.50 | ||
| 5 | Mazgaon | 10/78A | 258.00 |
| 10/788 | 187.50 | ||
| 10/79 | 348.50 | ||
| 10/79A | 140.50 | ||
| 10/80 | 135.50 | ||
| 6 | Parel Sewri | 11/84 11/84A | 475.50 282.00 |
| 11/85 | 156.50 | ||
| 11/85A 11/86 | 196.00 131.00 | ||
| 7 | Worli | 13/97 | 567.50 |
| 8 | Dadar Naigaum | 14/101 14/101A | 201.00 326.00 |
| 9 | Matunga | 16/110 | 453.50 |
| 10 11 | Mahim Mahul | 17/116 17/119 90/419 | 608.50 493.00 97.00 |
I
I
\ R R Z'.ne No.\ ~ate pl
I
:I Divisilon/ vm;~ge Nare
Sri.No I
I
Sq. mieter per 1
\
I
| I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I | on 1.10.20 7 (to lle charged · for FSl=1) (In?.) I I I I | ||
| I I I M/436 I ~mbap~da I 1 \ 2 : : : | : .226.00 : ! | ||
| Govandi/Deon~r D 100/471: I I I | I I 53loo I | ||
| I ~9/463 : (povandl/Borla 1 I I 114 | I I 282.00 | ||
| I ' Titwala ! 26/81 1S I I I I (Kdmc) I I I I I I I I I I I I | I 111i-2s I I I I | ||
| Kanhoji Angre 1 16 I I I I I | 2~.50 I | ||
| I I I Jawahar Dweep '1, 901419 I I I 1r I I I | I 971..00 I I I |
month ap licable for over - grund preline f cable 1as on 1.10.20 7 (to lle charged
I I I I I !
I I I I ve rates are ,exclusive of all Taxes (GST( Taxes, etc.),\ Servide Cha/ges, :
1.
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} Abo Pen~lties, and lnt,'erest etc. Sam~ are separately paya~le by l~sseesl as m~y be applicable. · . · · · · · , 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I 2. The I Special Way l_eave fi,3e for
. •
•
· ,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I 3.
computation inst~ad of 1 mt~. In tile event of fa11yre of achieve ¥1rnmum Guar~ntee T~rough~ut (MG:f), the µser shoWld combensate the pott by paying ad
.
5.
6.
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1= . .
qua!Jtity. 1 l 1 1 · I : I ' Oth~r aspelts related to right of Way permission will l be deAlt with1 as perl the extant Land Policy Guidelines. · Way, Leave/ISpecia~ Way 4'ave fee, whe*er demanded or not, $hall be:paid b~ the lessees/ ten~nts/ lidensees\on or before t~e 15th d,ay of each mortth succeeding that for Which Way Leave / Special Way Leave fee is ~ue. The iNay lea~e formulae will be as lunder. 1 Wayleave fee per lmonth bn !and Length of pipeline X (Exte~nal dia including insulation +6po mm) X rate\
,
\
1 I applicable
. : , 1000
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I · I ' I
Way eave fee per month on trestle= .
l (Suqject to minimum width' of 1 meter} !
1 Lengfh of pipeline X Exter al dia includin insula ion X ~ate applicable \
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
\
• 00 .
I I
7.
e by 4o/~ every jOctober. First ~uch 4% incre~se will\ be
1
1
•
I
'
1
i 8.
i
1
•
[ 1
.
I 9.
110.
Way leave f~es will increas effected frorf1 1.10.2b18. I 1 For ttle purpose of Right of way leaie charges, the area occupied by pipelines other than ~hose 011 trestl~ shall be calculf ted based on ~e width (subject to minimurt) of 1 me~r) and: length pf those pipeli~es. 1 Charges for way leave for oGcupation of air:space, underground, seabed and below seab~d will be 50% ~f the above rates. License fee for water ared would \be 50%1of the liQense fe'e of abt!Jtting land. Thel way le~ve fee for the service bhall be based 'on the full rates. i · : · , 1 l I I Interest will not be applicabl:e on th~ differ¢ntial a~~as due to revision till raising! of demahd notic:e. If the party fails to pay as per the demand/ invoice within 3 months from the receipt of d~mand notice ~ invoice, inter~st will be applipable at 18% per 1
annu~, as per existing policy or as rpay be decideq by Board froni time to time. 1.
1
भाग दोन---६१-६अ४४ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ '
I I I j I
(ii~. $pecial IWay L~ave rates as lon 01;10.2011 for nt\n-cargo oper:ated pipeline etc.
| Sr. No. I A | Ready IRecko'ner Zon,e I I I B | I Unit No. Divisjon I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I C D , i | Ra~e per Sq. meter per month applicable for over ground !pipeline / - cable as on 1.10.2017 (to be charged for Fs1J1) (in {.) I i G | |
| 1. ') ~-- | ' , 1ft/101 I 90/419 (PirPau} | I I Dadiar- Naigaum Unit 1 Unit 1, 14 Mahul I . i I I i I | 201.00 ·, 97.00 I ' I | |
| 3. 4. | I 10/79 10/80 | I Unit 2, 6,7 Mazgaon Unit 4,7,8,9, 13 Mazgaon | ~148.50 135.50 | |
| !:;i. | I 2/13 | I I I Unit9,1,1,1s I Fort i | I 915.50 I | |
| 6. 7. 8 9. 10. 1'1 . 1;!. | 2i22 17/119, I H/116 14/101A 1 11/86 | Unit 11. Fort Mahim lJnit 14 I I Unit 14 1 Mahlm ~Jnit-1 Dadctr-Naigaum | 506.50 I I 493.00 608.50 326.00 | |
| I Unit-1,5,, 13 Pare! -Sewr1ee I I I | 1131.00 I | |||
| 11/85A 1 11/85 | I Unit-3 PareI-Sewn~e Unit-4 ,513 Parel -Sewree | 196.00 156.50 | ||
| q _ | I 11/84 | I I Pare! -Sewr:ee l.ilnit-2 | I 475.50 | |
| 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. I 19. | 111/84A 10179A 10/78A 10/78B 3/36 I 3/~16 3/35 | Pare! -Sewr,ee Unit-2 Mazgaon Divi Unit-3 i I IJnit-6,8 1 Mazgaon Mazgaon Unit-8 I I Unit-9, 14 1 Elphiston,McJllet Bul]lder Unit -14 Ferry Wharf Princess Dock. Unit-9,10,14 SD /Sunder | 282.00 i 1~0.50 i 2!58.00 187.50 I I | |
| 282.00 3El2.00 | ||||
| 201. 21. 22. 23:. 24 . I | I I 3/35B 2/2'.3 2/9 I 2/112 ; 1/6A 1/6A 1/6A | I , I 1 Princes Doc!< Unit-9 10 Unit-9 , 11 , 15 Mody Bay ,fort,lndira Dock 1 Fort Unit-11 i ' ' Unit-12 , 1 Wellington Estate, Apollo Bunder,Fort i Unit-14,1[2 Jamsadji Burlder,Colaba Sassoon DocM inside), Colaba Uhit-12 &14 Unit-12 Aoollo Estate | I 389.50 . 485.00 | |
| I I 7q0.00 | ||||
| 1,149.00 | ||||
| I i 943.00 I 943.00 | ||||
| 943.00 I | ||||
| 25i 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 1 31 . I | I 1/31 I 1 /3,A. 1/4 I 100/471 99/463 26/81 (Thape -Ka'lyan RR) Jawahar I De~p ( Island} & land under recl,~matiom | 1 . I Apolld Estate, Colaba Unit-12 I Colaba Unit-12 1,196.50 I Unit-15 I Pilot81,mder.Colaba • I I I Unit-5 Govan.di/Deohar 53:3.00 Govandi/Borla Unit-5 282.00 I I I I jTitwata I I 11 '1.25 U~it-5 Nearest Zone 90/419 Unit-12, 14 i groo I I I I I I I I I ' I I I I I i ' I | 1 4010.00 | |
(All t~e rates for /anp valu7s has oeen roynded tp the nearest l - 10/-)'महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ४५ I I I I I I I I I I ' N~tes:
1. 1
, ' '
Above rates an~ exclu,ive of !all Taxes (GST, Taxes, etc_!), Service Charges, Penalties, and lriterest Ttc. Sarr,e are separatby payfble byllesseef, as m~y be applicable. 1
I 2. 1 The Special Way Leav~ fee for Optica'1 Fiber able J.,ill be Jpplicable as p~r the
'
1
3.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} above r~tes but. takin~ the W/dth supject to a minimum of half i a met, r for computat on inst ad of 1 mtr. Other as ects re ated to ~ight of Way permission will be dealt with as per the extant Laind Policy Guidelines. ', I I I I I 1
~ day of each m?nth sufceedin~ that Wiay Lea'le/ Spetial Way Leave lree, whether demandetl or no~. shall ~e paid by the lessees/ tenants/,licensees on o~ before:the 151
I
for which lway L~ave / sr.ecial Way Lea~e fee i$ due. : I I I 5. I The way l1eave f6rmulae will be bs under.
i ; : .l I I I
Wp.y Leave fee per montr on la~d = j i i
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I
1 1000' .
Length of pipeline X External tlia includin insulation +600 mm X rate applicable I I I I
(S~1bject td minimum width of 1 meter) I I I ' I I I I
Way Leave fee p~r month on tre~tle =
I I I
• j I I
L~ngth o~ pipelin~X External dia includ insu ation ~ rate applicable
300
I I I I I I I ·, . I I 6.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
W~y leav~ fees Will increase by .ti% every October. First such ij% inctease wlll be effected frpm 1.10.2018.
.I 1 1
8.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1
9.
7. 1 For the p.~rpose qt Right btway l~ave ch1rges , t'e area pccupi~d by pipelines mther than those on trestle shall be ca1Ju1ated based on the width (subject to minimum of 1 ~,eter) ard lengih of those pipelines. ' ·. I I I I Chr.rges f9r way l~ave for1 occupation of air space, underground( sea bee! and below seabed will be 50% of the above rates . License fee for water ar~a woul~ be 50~% of the license fee of +butting! land. The way leave f~e for th~ service shall ~e basecf on the full rates. I I I I I Interest will not b~ applic$ble on lhe differential ~reas d ue to r~vision ~ill raising of derhand n6tice. 1t ;the pa~y fails to pay as per th~ dema~d I invojice with~n 3 months frot'n the rJceipt of demand notice I invoice, interest will be applicable at 18% per an1um as per exi~ting pol,cy or a~ may be decided by B~ard from time ~o time.I I I I I I I I I I
"
jand 5. 1 I The Speall;ing Orcler passed by l this A~thority lwill be I intimat~d seprrately com1Jl1unicated to the MBPT and th1e relevant tenahts/ lessees in due coJrse of tJme.
I I I I
I I I , ( T.IS. Balasubramanian
Mrmber ~FinancT) I
I I४६ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ (Published in Part - Ill Section 4 of the Gazette of India, Extraotdinary) I T.(\RIFff AUTHO~ITY IFORI MAJOR PORtrS
G.No. 552
New Delhi,
12 November 2021
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 49 of the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 (38 of 1963)', the Tariff Authority for Major Ports hereby disposes of the proposal received from Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) for fixation of Schedule of Rates and revision of rent I compensation for the period 01 October 2017 to 30 September 2022 for non-home occupations in Township Areas of MBPT, as in the Order appended Hereto. : ' ' ' ' ' ' '
, :T.S. Balasubramanian Member (Finance)महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ४७ 1 Applicant (i). hhri. T.S. Bala~ubra~anian, MembJr (Fina~ce) ' (ii). Shri. Sunil Kumar Singh, Member (Economic)
1
E Ft ,
I I I, 0 ~ D
(Passed on this 1st day c~f November 2021)
I ' I I I I I I I I I I I
I This case relates to a proposal received ftom M4mbai Rort Trust (MBPT) vide its letter No'. FA/OEA-L38(21 }/Gen/166 'dated 03 Aug~Jst 2021 for fixation of Schedule of Rates and r~vision 9f renV Icompe~sationI for thel period 101 Octbber 2911 to 3p September 2022 fo1 non-h9me
, , , . , , occupations in Townsh'p Areas of MBPT.
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
I I ' I I I . I I I I I I ~ .
" I
| I Sr. , No. A 1. 2. | I I Ready I m .vision I, I Unit ~o. Rec:koner ' ' ' ione II C I I I B I D I ' 14/101 90/419 I | ' Dadar~ Naigaum Unit 1 Ur,iit 1 I I .Mahul I | ~ate pef Sq. M,tr. per ~onth j , @ 6% return per an um as on 01.10.17 ' I ( in,~.) I I ' I GI 575.00 ' I I 270.P0 I | |
| 3. ' 4. I 5. 6. 7. | I 10/79 ' 10/80 I I 2/13 I 2/22 . 17/119, 17/116 | I Mazaaon Unit 2 6 7 Mazgaon Unit 4,7,8,9, 13 I I [Fort Urlit 9,11,115 I 1 ,Fort Unit 11 ' ! Mahim Unit 14 | \ 856.pS 938.50 I I I 1262(48 ' 955.18 ' ' 950.00 | |
I
I
I
I
- 21 I 1The prf>posal pf MBP~ is based on t~e am~nded L~nd Policy Guif:lelinesf 2015. trhe proposal was taken on consultation with the relevan~ users/,tenants/ lessees. Many comments were received ' from tt,e tenants/ lessees. The MBPT has responded to the comments of the tenants/ lefsees. A joint hearin{IJ on thf case in reference ~as hel9 on 03 1 September 2Q21 thr~ugh Vicleo Cpnferencing. At the joint heaqng, the 1MBPT and the! tenants/ lessees have made their submissions. As decided during the Joint Hearing, the MBPT was requested to host the power point presentation ini its website ~nd ha~ invit1:1d the {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}commE1nts of I tenants/ lessees/ u~ers onl the pbwer pbint pr esentation. M$ny co111ments:were received from the tenahts/ lessees. The MBPT has responded to the comments of the tenants/ lessees. I :proces sing of 3., ~ith r~ferenc~ to the totalitJ of inf~rmatio~ collected during the ;the ca1se and based on a collective application of mind, this Authority has passed a spea'king Order disposing of the [ propo~al filedIby the IMBPT lfor fixation of Schedule of R~tes and revision of rent/ cqmpens~tion fo:r the period frc;,m 01 dctober 12017 to! 30 Septembet 2022 tbr non-home occupatibns in Township Areas of MBPT. , 4. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} I ;rhis Authority desires! that the following Rent Sche~ule for: MBPT prescribing Lease rentals for the 07 Ready Reckoner Zones for non-home occupations in 1iownship Areas of MBPT fof the p9riod 01 10ctober 2017 [to 30 ~eptemtier 2022 may be notifi+d with~ut waifing for notifica(ion of !the Speaking Order: , , , , . , , , · , ↩
I४८ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ~ : I : I : I : I : I : I 1. The le1ase rent is subject to an increcise@ 4% p.a . .,.nd thatlfirst su1h incre~se sha\ll be effective
',
,
1
' 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
may be applic13ble. 1 I ', , ' I 1 I
' 1
. I . I . I ;
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} II
I I I I
,, II I I I I
I I I ' I , I ' I , I
: I ', I ': I I: I ', '1
I I
I
I , I , I
T.43. Balasubrarr1ania1n ·
,
. I
I
. I -
I _
I _ _ I _
_ I _ _ I _
I_महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ४९ (Published in Part -111 Section 4 of the Gazette of India, Extraordinary) TARIFF AUTHORITY FOR MAJOR PORTS
New Delhi, 12 November 2021
G.No. 553
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 49 of the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 (38 of 1963), the Tariff Authority for Major Ports hereby disposes of the proposal received from Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) for fixation of Schedule of Rate for the period 01.10.2017 to 30.09.2022 for Land/ Water area leased to Mazagaon Dock Shipbuilders Limited - RR Zone 10/80 (Mazagaon Division), as in the Order appended hereto.
,
T.S. Balasubramanian
Member (Finance) भाग दोन---६१-७५० महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४
Tariff Aµthprity fo lr M~jol'i Po'rts
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
Mumbai Rort Tr~st
Applicant
aqoRUM I
I
I I
Balasupraman 1
(i). ( •• ) I
Shri. T.S. SHri. Suni, Kumat Singh, Memb r (Ecorli
ian, Metrber (Fiinance) omic) :
II. I
I
I Q R 1D g R II '
1 1 (Pas~ed on this 1st day of November 2021)
I
I I I I I I I I I I 1 1 This case relate$ to a proposal received from !Mumbai Port trust (MBPT) Jide its letter No. FA/OEA-U21(88)/U-8/~52 dated 16 ·September 2021 see~ing a9proval for fixafion of Schedule of Rate$ for t~e period 01.1 10.2011 l to 30.©9.2022 for Land/ Water area leafed to Mazagaon Dock Shipbuilders Limited - RR Zone 10/SO l(Mazgaon Division). ! 1
2. I I The proposal of MBPT isl based im the Policy GiJidelinJs of La~d Man~geme~t 2015 (PQLM 2015). The propdsal was taken Ion consultation with the relevant users/ tenants/ lessees. The users have responded. The ~18PT h~s respq>nded t9 the comment$ of the ~sers. 1joint hearing on the case in reference ~as held on 11 Octot\er 202~ through Videp Confyrencin$. At th~ joint hearing, the MBP11 and the users 1have made thsir subniissions. .
1
inform~tion col)ected ~uring t he pro~essing 3. I . With refe~ence td the totblity of iof the case and based oh a collective ~pplicatkm of mind, this Authority has passed a speaking Order disposing ~f the J:?roposal filed t;>y the rv1BPT ror fixation of iSched1.,1fe of ~ates f10.2017 .to 30.019 .2022 ;for Lanp I Watrr area i leased to Mazagaon pock S~ipbuilders Limited - RR Zone 10/80 (Mazgaon Division).
I I I I ' I I I ' I I I 4. I , Th js Authqrity de~ires that the foljowing ~ent Sqhedule for MBfilT prescribing II.ease rentclils for the period 01 October 2017 to 30 September 2022. for Land / Water ariea leased to Mazpgaon [j)ock SIJipbuilders Limiited - RR Zone [10/80 (Mazgaon Division), m~y be notified Without waitirg for ~otificatipn of the Spea~ing Orper: I ' I I I ' I u
I
| SR NO. I | RR ZONE I | I I I i i Pt.OT Nd I I I I I | |
| 1 I 1. ' ' I I I I | 2 10/810 I I I I I | I I : I 3 1 Plot be;tg , I · I i) No. 5 (Code no. ~08016 0) I 1 1 ii) Expahsion Phase in Ne>rth Yard II (code no. 1 1 I ~s.101 .201- ~ , 2oao·,642) i , 1 water area iii) Exte~sion o I Slipw y in S0uth Y~rd (code no. I , 20801650) I I i~) Addi~fnal water area for E,qension !of Slipway I 1 ' 1 I ( cod no. 2080165~) i | |
Notef
The SoR mentione~ above would increaje by 4 • % ann~ally e~ry Oc~ober and would be 1.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} 1 validl till 30.q9.2022 1 I I ,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
2t Actual quantum o~ Rent will be I worked out oh the base reht and factor as may be recor,nmend1
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
ad by t~e com1ittee appointe~ for th'. purpor of ap,plicabil'.ty of F~I. !
- 1 1 Case No. TAMP/51I2021-MBPT {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} I I I I I I ' I I I I I I ↩
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
3. T axe:p, service charges, penalties, :interest rates are not included in the above rates. . 4. Rate ~or allo~ment ot water bodies ls appli1able atl 50 % df the SC:>R rates for a~utting l~nd 5. 1 Differential Arrears, liabilities and other dues/charges for a period from 1, 10.2017 to 30.09_.2022 will be calculated based on above rates. , , : '
6. i These rates ~re apFllicable to only the fourl Expire~ Leasds of MOL as brought out abo{e. 7. Interest woufd be chargeable beyond permissible period as per Board's.policy from time to
'
] time. . b 1
8. 1 Whether demanded lor not, ~ent/corhpensat.ion/licerse feelfor a m nth would have to be paid by the tenants/lessees/licensees/occupants on or before the 15th day of each 1succeeding
I I month. ]
I
" 5. The Speaking Order passed by this Authority will be intimated separately 'and I commricate? to thel MBPT and thi releva11t tenaqts/ lessees in 1ue course of time. I
I
,
T.,S. Balasubramanian
Mimber ~Financr) ¥ भाग दोन---६१-७अ५२ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ (Published in Part - Ill Section 4 of the Gazette of India, Extraordinary) TARIFF AUTHORITY FOR MAJOR PORTS
12 November 2021
G.No. 554
New Delhi,
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 49 of the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 (38 of 1963), the Tariff Authority for Major Ports hereby disposes of the proposal received from Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) for fixation of Schedule of Rates and revision of rent I compensation in respect of 19 Ready Reckoner Zones for the period 01 October 2017 to 30 September 2022 for non-home occupations in Township Areas of MBPT, as in the Order appended hereto.
r T.S. Balasubramanian
,
Member (Financetमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ५३
Tari1ff A~th ajo1\r Port~
', ..,C_a_se ____________ ,.............,.......,.-=--......,.B __ P __ T 1
I
I
1 Mumli>ai Porl Trust!
, • - • 1
At>plicarlt
' I I I I '
I I '
I I
i
, i I ' oyoRUM I I I ' I I
1 (i). Shri. ,T.S. B
(ii). Shri. Sunil ~umar $ingh, rv,embe~ (Economic) i
1
I
I I ' I I
•
I
1
\
'.
, 1 (Passfd on tMis 01 st day of November 20~1) i
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 1
I I
I I
I I
I I I I I I , 1 This' case relates tb a proposal received from Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) vide its l~tter 1 No. FNOEA-L.138(21I)/Gen/tS dated 22 Septemlt,er 2021 for fixation ot Schedule of ~ates ard revi ion of rent/ compensation in re pect o~ 19 Ready Rfckonet Zone{ for th~ period 01 October 2017 t 30 1
,
I ' I I . I I I ', I I ' I I
1 amended Land Policy Guidelines, '2015. The ISeptember 2022 for hon-ho e occ:upatio!is in Township Areas of MBF:T. i 1 .2. 1 I The propos',al of ~~p'. is IIbased ,on the 1 propos 1al was Itaken on consultation with the relevant ur,ers/ tenants/ jessee~. Many comments v.,ere 1receiv~d from the tenants/ lessees. The M$PT ha~ respo ded td the comment~ of the:tenants/ lessees. IThe MIBPT ha13 respqnded t? the comments of th~ tenan s/ lessees. 1 1 1 1 . . . . . I ' ~- '. 1 With lreference to tt11e total\1Y of informati~n coll~cted d~ring th~ pro~ssing df the c~se
1 ~nd based on~ colle~tive applicatidn of mind, this Authotity has ipassed a speaking Order dibposing of the proposal filed by t.he MBf. T for rxation 1.of Sche. dule q.f Rate~and revision of rent1Icompe insatio~ in l;espec~ of 19 feady Recko[jler Zon~s for the period frorm 01 0 tober 2017 tol 30 Septemb~r 2022 for
1 non-hoine occµpations in TownshipIAreas of MBPT. 1 1 1 1
.
' I I
I I I I I I t- I ', This Authori~y desi,es that the following I Rent ~chedul~ for tv1BPT p'rescriblng Le~se
1
I
,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 , 1 1 I ' ~entals ~or the 119 Ready Reckoner Zones for nod-home occupations in Township Areas of MBPT ,for 2011 to 30 Septemb~r 2022 may be notified without wait)ng for potificafion ofttle the period 01 qctober I Speaking Ordiar: I ' 1 ' I I I I I I
' I I
I I ",' I I I, I I I l ' I 1 I I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I I S.bhedule of R~tes fo( the p,riod of.10.20:17 to 3~.09.2!il22
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 for Non-Home Occupation for FSI = 1.0? •
| Sr. Nq | I I I I I I I I I 4nit R~ Zone I ~ ' I I I I I I | I I I ' , I Divisi"n I I I I I Dad-1r-Naigaum I | 'Rate per Sq. Mtr. per f110nth ~6% return per1 .-nnum p on 01.10.17 1 1 I l (in ~.) ' I s·,1s.20 I I | |
| 1 I | I I 14/101A ND-Unit 1 I I | |||
| 2 I, 11/86 ND/Cit>/ Sunders Uniti.1, 5,13 1 Parel~Sewree | I | 1, 601.00 I | ||
| I I 1 11/85A ND- UInit 3 3 1 | I Parel Sewree | I 8~2.25 | ||
| 11/65 ND/CC!)/ Sunders Unitr4, 513 • ParelrSewre~ 4 | I . | I I 842.25 | ||
| 11/$4 ND- Uhit2 I 5 I I I 6 I ND- Unit 2 11/E/4A 10/79A I 7 ND- Unit 3 8 I 1 10/7!8A CD - lJnit-6 81 | ParefLSewree I I Parel~Sewree I i I Mazoaon I I Mazoaon I Maza~on | 1. 856.55 856.55 1 . ' . I 9'17.95 I i 8 1.20 I 811 .20 | ||
| I I , CD-Unit8 9 1017\8B | ||||
| I I SD- U,nit 9 10 3/36 11 1 , SD/Buhders • Unit 9, 1i0, 14 3/3~ I 1 12 ' SD - Unit 9 10 3/3518 SD/Buners Unit 9, 11, rtS 13 2/23 | I Princess Dock I Prince~ss Doell. | I 8ei1.20 I I 8$1.20 | ||
| ' , 1 Princess DocR , Fort i i | 948.20 i 10$7.50 | |||
| SD - Unit 11 14 I 2/9 ', I I I SD- Unit 12 15 1 2/121 , SD/Bumders Ulilit 12, 14 1/6A 16 | I Fort I 1 I Fort I ! Colaba | 1057.50 14$3.20 I I 14~i3.20 |
I I I ' I
I
I
I
I. I
I I
I
I I I I
- 1 I I I ' I ,!PRDER {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} I I . . . . ↩
ate per q. Mtr. per
I Divisibn
I I Unit
mcj>nth @6f/o returl) per on 01.1r.17 arinum a~
Sr. No
(111 ~-
17 18 19 SD - Unit 1
I
Notes:
-
1 I I I I I I I I I I 1. IThe leabe rent is subjec~ to an i~crease@ 4% p,a. and that first such inctease sHall be effective from 01 I
I
I
October 2018.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
2. 3 . 4 .
5. 6. 7 .
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
,
,
,
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
'.
'.
' 5. ' The Speaking Order passed by this Authority will bE,! intimcited separately; and communicated to the MBPT 1 and the relevant tenants/ lessEies in dtJe course oftirne.
I
I
I
I I
,
Balasubramanian
I T.S.
I Membtr (Finapce) I
I
Iमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ५५ I: \
' ~ I I I (Publlished fin Par11 - Ill Seiction 4 of the Gazette of I dia, E,i;traord'~nary) 1 TARI F ~UTHORlty FhR MAJ R PORTS 1
I I I "r-"
I ' I
12 November 20a1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I ' I
I
I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 • 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I I ·, I I I I I I ' I I
plots !for the 1iperiod 01 .10.io12 to 30.09 2017 and 7 pl'ots for 1the period 01.10.2017 to 30
I
I I In exercis;e of th~ powers conf rred by Secthim 49 Of the Major Port Trusts Act, 11963 (38 o'f 1963) 1 , the T~.1riff Aut~ority for Majof Ports pereby1 disp?~Fs of th~ prop~sal recle_ive~ from M4mbai Port Jrust (NABPT) for fixation of $chedu e of R~tes anti rev1s1pn of rent/ compenscht1on m!respeclt of 7 .09.2022 for let oJt land f~r non home o~upati?n falli~g under varioys RR Zones of MBPT( as in t~e Order apperded heret?. · \ 1 I 1 , I I
1
I
I
I I I
...,. I I I ,
T.;:". Balasubramanian
,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I I
- {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} N6TIFICATI N Member {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}(Finance) {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} ↩
I५६ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४
Tariff Authority for Major Ports
I I I Cast No. TfMP/5w2021-$BPT \ \ [
ClUORUM
I
(i). (ii).
Shri. T.S. Balasubramanian, Member (Finance) Sti. SuT Kumy Singhl, Membler (Eccromic) I
I
ORDER
I I (Pared 01 this 01.st day of November 2021)
This casie relates to a proposal received from Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) vide its letter Nq. FA/OE,:A-L/38(21 )/G~n/271 ~ated 2~ Septerpber 2og1 for fi~ation o, Sche~ule of F,.ates a~d revisipn of rent/ compensation in respect of 7 plots for the period 01.10.2012 to 30.09.2017 and 7 plots for the period 01.10.2017 to 30.09.2022 for let out land for non home occupation falling under various RR zores of ~BPT. I I I I I I I I I I I I 2. . . Tre proposal of MBPT is based on the amended La~d Policy Guid~lines, 4015. T~e prtjposal VfBS tak,n on cr,nsultation wit~ the r~evant ~sers/ tenants/ ,lessees. Many comments we're redeived from the tenantsY lessees. The MBPT has responded to the comments of the tenants/ lessees.
3. I With refe'rence tb the totality of jnformal:ion colli.ected dLring th~ proceksing o1 the caie . the· propos'al fifed by the ~11BPT for fixation of ScJiedule pf Rate~ and re,vision qf rent 1
and based on a collective application of mind, this Authority has passed a speaking Order disposing of co.mpe~sation ,n respect ofl7 plotslfor thd periodlo1 .10.io12 tol.30.09 .2017 and 7 plots for ttlie peridd 01.1(!>.2017 to 30.09.2022 for let out land for non home occupation falling under various RR Zones of MBPT.
4. I I T~is Aut~ority dJsires t~at the tollowin~ Rent bchedule for MBPT prescribi;,g Lea~e rentals Lease rentals in respect of 7 plots for the period 01 .10.2012 to' 30 09.2017 and 7 plots for the per\od 01.[0.2017I to 30.09.2022 for let,out land falling for non home occupation ulhder various RR Zorjes:
" I
A. Schedule of Rates for the oeriod from 01.10.2012 to 30.09.2017 for Non-Home Occuoatlons
| Rentals per sqm RR Description as per Ready Sr. Unit I per mllnth for1FSI Reckoner zone No. 1.00 ~-) 1 I I | ||||
| 1 I 2 I | I Lady Jamshetji Road-Portion Unit-14 (Mc1him 17/116 betwE!en city l~ht Cinjma jun~lion to i59.00 1 Bunder) I I I I Mahim hurch unction. Cuff parade Portion towards North of Unit-14 (Pilot Sunder) 1/5 Dr. Homibh,bha Ro~d and .,i\~st 1r70.oo P~rtion of rakash ethe M rQ I I I I I I | |||
| 2/13 3 Unit-15 I I I | P D Mello Rc>ad (Frere Road)from ~29.00 General Post Office tq Bound~ry of I I No11 of A ward I | |||
| I I I I Unit-12 & 14 {Fish 4 : based :occupa~ons of ;1f6A 1 Sassoon Dock) , Bundel,s Unit-14 (Fish ~36 I 5 I based occupations of | On East Sea, on West Shahid Bhagat 596.11 Singh Road, on South Homi Bhabha I I Roaci on North divisi~n boundary. I · (Refer Note No.9) All pqrtion of B Ward on Eastside of 5f5.49 • P.q' Mello ~oad uptp sea shpre I I I (Victoria Dock & Prlncess Dock). | |||
I
I
I I
I
I
I I I Ferry Wharff I I I I I I
Lan:d/Jetty) I I I
I I I I
I
I
I I 1 Sunders Unit-14
, An po]n of ~Ward Oil Easlsk!e of
611 3/36
I j (Fish based:
I
I
I
, (Viet ria Dock & Princess Dock).
I I hart - PT Structure)
' I I
1
I , (9/419
I ~84.28 1 I I I ccupatibns of Ferry 1 P.D' ello Rpad upto sea shore I I I I 7 - 1 1 JD '.Island I, Existing land at J~ Island I ', 117.22 '1 I I I I
I I I I
of Mahul) '
' I I
I I
'
',
I I I I I I ·, I i i
I ' I i,
lfhe lea~e rent is subjec~ to an imcrease '@ 4% p.a. and that firs~ such increase hall be effective from o·
1
'
~OTES: I 1. I I bctober;2013. • 1 1
I ' l I I , . 1 1 ' 1
:
2. The lea~e rentalis may remain i~ force tqr a peri{,d of five years thereon. I 1 3. Actual quantum bf Rent ';will be worked qut on the base ~enl and factor a~ may b~ recommende by the c;ommitt~e appointed fo~ the purpose of applicat:lility of FSI. , . 1 1 4. 9pecial \Nay Leave char19es are 1calculafed base,d on abrve rate~. as per;.MBPT r.egulations. I 5. 1axes, service charges, tpenaltiels , inter~st rates .are not ,ncluded in the a.bove rates. \ : 6. Rate for allotme~t of wat~r bodids is applicable at 50% df the SOR rates: · i 7. ~ifferentlal Arreals, llabil1t1es an~ other 9ues/charges fo~a perio~ from 0~ .10.2012 to 30,9.2017 ,are
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
~lculat~ baseq on abo\/e rates:. I \ ! . : 1 1 8. T•hese ra es are appticab:le for Non-Hom~ Occupations and Special Way'Leave . 1
1 9. The appl cable ~CGM c:ses wi
1
·,
tenants apd licen~es for ss tham 1 year 1
11 be billed separately orr and above t~e SOR rates fo~I monthly 1 1 I 1 , 10. rLese rates are l'IOt appli able toloccupa~ions given on n minal rents to ~ublic bodies anti for public ,. , • ,.J
, I I
I
amenilfe,,.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
, 1 1 • I 1
11. Interest would b~charge~ble beyond per~issibla period as per aoard's dolicy trqm time to time. ,
,fee for a monti-l would have to' be paid by the '
I I
I
'
I 1 12. Whether demanaied or not, rent/', compe~sation/ \license 1 tenants/ lessees/ l(icensees/ occupants on or be~re the 1tth day pf each succeeding morllth. I I ' I I 8., Schedple of ~ates f~r the period f~om 01.~ 0.201 t to 30. 9.2022 for no~ Home Occu~ation. ',
| 1 1 Sr. INo. | 1 , RR 7 i-one | U~ ·•t " Unit-1~ & 14 (Fish ba ed occupations of Sasso~n 1 1 Dock} 1 I I 1 · Unit-1 (Fish b1ased ' 1 occupa.tions of'.Jamsh1dji I Bunde~) , I : I ' I I ' ;Sunder Unit-1 L:. (Fish l?ased ,occupa ·ens of t-erry Wharf- tt Land/J 1 Bunders Unit-14 (Fish ased pccupa~ons of Ferry W arf - T Structure 1 Unit-12 , 1 ;JD Island I | 1 I . I Rentals per s~m J.. th fo1 I D~scnptlon as per Rea y ... 1 1 k per mon r 1 , .1 r1.ec oner FSI .oo I On East Sea, '.On West Shahid\ 7 5.'38 Bhag~t Singh Road, on South1 Homi ~habha oad or,1 North . 1R divisior boundary. (Refer Note 1 : No.9 I Shahid 1 On Ea~t ~ea, on West 871 .91 1 Bhagat Singh Road, Ol[I South 1 : Homi Bhabha Road o~ North I division boundary. (REifer Note 1 ' No.9 I | |
| 1 | 11/6A \ , | |||
| 4 4, 5 | 1/6A 3/36 -1 I | |||
| I 712.34 : All po ,.on of B \Ward o~ Eastside of '. P.D' Mdlo Roa~ upto sea sho'J. . ! Victoria Dock ~ Princ~ss Doc All porti,on of B 'fvard o~ Eastsi~e of 832.53 I 1 P.D' Mello Roacl upto sea shore '. Victori Dock & Prince s Dock: . :existin land at JD Island | ||||
| 71 | Unit-12 , I D lslan~ JD lslanl:I | j Reclaimed land:adjoini g to JD 123.40· 1 1 1 l lsland aratha Mandir at JD I land 242.13" | ||
:
\
:
,
1
:
1
, 1 1 ,
I inst~ad of 01.10.2017 1 1 Nord: i , · I 1
11
i be effective frojn 01
';
\ • The lease rent is subject to ~n incre~se@ 41% p.a. and that first sucn. incre'fe shall1 1 October201~. \ i '. I 1 ', 1 1
2~ The lease reptals may remain in force for a Aeriod oi five years thereon. 1 1 31 Actual quantum of Rent will be workfd out Cjn the base rent1and factor as rt1ay be recomm~nded by the committee aRpointed for the purposei of applicability 1,Jf FSI . I 1
1 1
1
I
, I
I ' I I I I I I
I , I ' I I I
भाग दोन---६१-८५८ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ' I I I {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
01fferenti<11l Arrears, liabiliUes and other ~ues/chalrges for a period from 01 .10.2017 to 30.9.202* are
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
, 1
calculated based bn abovl;! rates . i 1 1
8. These rates are a,pplicable for Non-Home Occupatjons an~ Specia\ Way Leave. ' 1 I 9. T\1e applicable Mc;GM cesses will ipe billed separately overiand abqve the SOR rates for mdrthly teryants
' a,pd licens,es for le,ss than r., year I ' I I I ' '
10. Tl'lese rates are not applibable to: occupa~ions gi~en on nominal rents to 1public lfodies ard for pµblic
,
' 1 I
, amenities.I I
1 1
11. Interest would be ?hargeable beyond permissible period as 1per Board's poliby from time tot me. 12. Whether demanded or not. rent/ compen1tion/ license fee for a iponth wpuld hate to be: paid b~ the tenants/ le15sees/ l!censee~/ occup?nts on 'l'r before the 1 Stlil day of each succeeding month i i
I I ' I I I
,, I I
I I
'
I I I
I I I
I I I
1 · The Speaking Order passed ! by thib Authbrity will be intimate/j sepa1rately and 5. 1 communicated to the MBPT and the relevant terants/ lessees :in due tourse pf time .:
' I
I . ' I I
I
I
I I I I I
, I I
I
I I I ' I I I
Balasubrarrianiah
T.$.
fV1ember 1(Finance) I I .
L - L - '- -
I I
L -
l_
\_महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ५९
·. TARIRF A~THdRITY1 FOR MAJOR PORTS i
II
',
',
I
j
I
I I
I I I :. ( Pub Ii shed i~ Part -1 II Section 4 ~~ the Giette of India, ~xtraoldinaryl ' ', I ', ',
1
,
1,
G.No. 556
': Ne~ Delhi, ':
. 12 No~ember 1
2021
1 I
'
I
I
I I
I
I I f .... I I ' ' I : \ ~0T1F1 A•:•o~ \ , : \
I
I
I
I I I
I I
1
1
1,
,
',,
,
1 ! , ,
, 1
I
' II J : : II
I
,
' I I r.s. I alasf' bra~ani~n I I
I
I ' .
I I I I ' '
६० महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४Tiriff1Au horj"ity for ~ajor Piorts
C se No. TAMP/5412021 MBPT 1 1 1
1
Applicant
rumb~i Port Trust
I ,
QUORUM
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 1 1
, r
1
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{i). 1Shri. T.S. Balasubramlanian, Member (Finance) (ii). 'Shri. Sunil Kumar SinQh, Member (Eqonomic:) · I ' I I I r
', !
1
I This else relates to a1 propos
· I I I I
~ -
1
1 1 1
'
I ' I I I I
| RR Sr. Zone ~o. I | Unit I I I I I | Description as per Ready Reckoner 1 1 ! I ' , ~ I I I I I I | \Rentals per ~qm. per 1 month ~or FSI 1 .00 as I on I 01 ,10,2012 I ~-) I I | |
| ' 141/101 1 I | 1 ' I | ~II the P9rtion on 1 East of Harbour Railway Une. | I I 120.00 | |
| 2 16/110 I | 1 I I I I | North, East & Sc;>uth bot,indary o{ Divisio~, on West Harbour Railway Line (Part) and boundary 1 1 1 ' of the Di~ision. | i 259.0i I i I I I | |
| 11/86 3 I I I i | . 1, Sunders I I I I | Portion towards ~ast of H~rbour Ure, On South )1charya ponde Marg (KirtJ Edwartl Road) iupto Sewri Railway Station. on East sea, on North boundary of ward 1and on West Harpour Rai way I1 I I.Jine. All the oortidn surroJnded. | : I I 69.00i I I I I I I I I | |
| 11/84 4 | I I 21 I I I I | On East i Barister Nath Pal Marg,, T. Jeevraj Marg, Rafi Ahmed Kidwai Marg, o.n West G.D. ~mbedkal-- Marg, bn Norttl Jerbai Wadla Marg. 1 All the portion surtounded .l ' | I ' 332.Sd , , I I I I I I | |
| 11/85A 5 I | 3 ' I I | On East B. P. T. railway line, on West Harbour r~ilway line, on Sputh Divtsion bo~ndary {First Avenue Road). , , , , | I 103.00, I I I ' I | |
| 6 , 11/85 I | 4,5,Bunders I I I I | On East Division boundary, from Sewri Station t~ward squth Hindustan Level Connpan(s East S\de Roa~, on W~st B.P.T. Railway Lme1 on South Division boundary. | I s6.so I I I I I I I |
- o R 0 {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} e R . (~assed on this ~1 st day pf Nov,mber 2:21) I ~ 1 al received from Mumbai Port Trust seeking approval for of rent/ compensati~n for fhe period 01 .~0.2012 to tlxation pt Schipdule qf Rate~ and ~evision 30.09.2~17 and 01.10.2017 to'.30.09. 022 for;residential and1mixed used occupations. 1 1 received from the tenants/ lessees. The MBPT has responded to the comments of the tenan,s/ lessees. J The prpposal of MBPf is based on tjhe amended L~nd Polley Guidelines,l 2015. the ~roposal was t9ken on{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} consultation Yt(ith the relevant users/ I tenants/ lessees. Many comments Were l , I With referen~ to the totality of information cc,llected lcturing the proqessing bf the case ~nd bas~d on a 1collective application of mind, ,this Authority has passed a speaking Order disposing of the proposal filed by the MBPT for fixation of Schedule of Rates anctJ· evision of renti! comp~nsatio~ in respect cpf 26 R~ zones for th~ period {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}01 .10.~012 to 30.09.2h17 an 27 RR zones ~or residential and r11ixed U$ed occlllpations. i i I i f {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} MBPT 1 4. [ frhis A~thority ~esires' that th~ following Rerlt Sche~lule tor l prescribing Le~se rentals Lease rentals in respect of 26 RR zorles for the period 01.10.2012 to 30.09.2017 and 27 RR ' ~ones for the period 01.i10.201 "( to 30.~9.202~ for res if ential ~nd mixed use1 occupations: I I "I A. Schecluleofrates for the period from 01.10.2012 to 30.09.2017 for residentia and mixed used o ccupatjons. I I I I I I I ↩
| .fr, ,0. t I I I I 8 I 1 (I | I 1 Unit pescription as per Rea~y Reckoner \ Rentals', per qm. , per 1 I 11 S 1, \ ', I, ' month for FSI 1.00 as on I 1 , , p1.10.2c112 1 1 1 I I II, ', I I I I ft.) II I 1 I I ' I I 10/79 I 10/V9 A I, I I 10~80 10/788 I | 2 ,6 On Eastdivision bounda\)' {porti_9.n of Ha;rbour I . 168.00 i 1 ~ailway t1ne and G.D. Ampedkar ll{larg) on West I I I I central rc.iilway line, division boun9ary, on North I, division boundary, Dattaram Laud Marg, on 1 , , South Saint Sava malimarb. I I I, 8 I On East i B.P.T. ailway Mne, on West cEmtral 83.5d I I railway harbour line, on North Division boun'r dary I I portion f all U\Pto First, Avenu1 Road, trangutar' 1 I I 1 t~e land. , , I ' 4,7 ,8 ,9, (East Oilfield On Wes~ B.P.T. 1 Railwa~, Line I 84.50 Freeway) ' on East sea ori South ~ijabhai l~ulji I Bunde:s I Rathod M,arg (Wa~i Sunder Road) and on ~orth sl,.P.T. Railway line and first Avenue Road. All 1 I 1 ' the portiori Surrounded. I 8 '1 1 On East B.P.T. ~ailway lil/',e, on West Ce'rtral 107.SQ I, railway harbour line, on south Jeenabai Rathod I I M~rg (W~di Sunder Road) trangular portion of I I 1 I I, , I ',. all the lanq!. ' I I I | ||
| 11'1, I | 3/35 2/W I I 2/9 I | I ' 134.00 1, 8,Docks AO portionl of B Ward on Easlside of P.D' Mello I R,,:,ad upt9 sea sh~>re (Vict~ria Doc~ & Prin~ess I I 1 I Dock). 1 ' I I I I 244,50 ' Area Between North Boundary bf B Ward 1 O I, (~amchanpra Bhatt Marg,201~), Sciuth I B Ward 1 (Lokmanya ~ilak Boundary I of I Marg ,2013), Centre.II Railway Line and P.D'Mello I I I I I Road. ' I land 1 Indira Do~k towards East: of 1265.00 I ~. 11 , 1~ I 1 Portion I, , , Docks P.D'Mello Road upto sea and froiil G.P.O: lo 1 North boundary of Ward. , , I I I , I I 11 S~hid Bhagat Singh Marg from Regal Cin~ma 1 466.50 , I I I I, to General :Post Office. i | ||
| 15 | 2/22 | 11 Ballard Est.ate part.. Portiotn towar,ps Eas!J of l i i.273.50 I Shahid Bhagat Singh Marg om Mint to Gen'rral Po~t Office, upto indira Doc Portion and Dmck ' • railway and portion IJpto division boundary. I i | ||
| 16 | 2/12 | ; 667.50 I Madam C ,ma Ro d betwf en Regal Cine("l'la I 12 I, i I i I ' an~ Gatew, y of India. | ||
| I, 17 18 | 1/6 1/6A, | 12, Sunders I 534 .00 Colaba porion: Ea~t portio~ of Prakash Pelhe Mafg and Jrgannath Bhosc3ile Marg · .. and Sowth portion of MF'dam Cama Road, except portion of ' Sub-zone 1/3 above. I 1 494.50 12 I on ', East Sea, on West Shfihid Bhfgat Singh I I Ro&d, on s1puth Homi Bhabha Roatjl on Notth I, I I division boundarv. (Refer Note No.91 , | ||
| 19 20 | 1 , 12 from po1aba to SM hid Bh~gat Sin~ h Marg I I 1 ' Regal Cine111a , , | |||
| 90/419 | ! 1 i All the properties of Mahul villaoe 68.50 : | |||
| 21 22 23 24 25 26 | 96/43p I , 26/81 1 i 17/11~ I i 17 /116 1 , 1/5 2113 I | I 1 All t~e prope rties of Aanik village, ex9ept Bhakti 115.00 ' 1 I , I i Par~ Complex \ , 5 Zone 2A. Di'Vision M~nda (34)(A) Manda West - f4 ,50 I I All oroperties on West of Central Rail\vav Linel on Fouth $itladevi 'i Temple Road, i on Eaist I 14 Western Railway line and on North and West I Mahim Creek. All thelportion surrounded. I . 1 1 , , I 359.00 I Mahlm Sunder I 14 I, 14 Pilot' Sunder {Sea Cadet\ 1070.00 1 I 1 ! 629.00 PD'Mello Ro.ad I 15 | ||
NOTES:
1. The lease rent is subject to an increase @ 4% p.a. and that first such increase shall be effective from 01 October 2013.
2. The lease rentals may remain in force for a period of five years thereon. 3. Actual quantum of Rent will be worked out on the base rent and factor as may be recommended by the committee appointed for the purpose of applicability of FSI.
4. Taxes , service charges , penalties, interest rates are not included in the above rates. 5. Above rates are not applicable for letout structures constructed/ owned by MBPT i.e. P.T. Structures. 6. Rate for allotment of water bodies is applicable at 50% of the SOR rates. 7. Differential Arrears, liabilities and other dues/charges for a period from 01 .10.2012 to 30 .9.2017 are calculated based on above rates.
8. These rates are applicable for Home and Mixed (Home and Non-Home) Occupations. 9. Estate lands of Old Sassoon Dock, Ferry Wharf and Jawahar Dweep are excluded from the above rates .
10. These rates are not applicable to occupations given on nominal rents to public bodies and for public amenities.
11 . Interest would be chargeable beyond permissible period as per Board's policy from time to time. 12. Whether demanded or not, renU compensation/ license fee for a month would have to be paid by the tenants/ lessees/ licensees/ occupants on or before the 15th day of each succeeding month.
8. Schedule of Rates for the period from 01.10.2017 to 30.09.2022 for Home and Mixed
(Home+Non-home) Occupations
| Sr. No. | RR Zone | Unit | Description as per Ready Reckoner | Rentals per Sqm. per month for FSI as on 1.00 01.10.2017 ~-) |
| 1 | 14/101 | ND-Unit 1 | Dadar-Naigaum | 575.00 |
| 2 | 14/101A | ND- Unit 1 | Dadar-Naigaum | 578.20 |
| 3 | 11/86 | ND/CD/ Sunders Unit 1 5,13 | Parel-Sewree | 601 .00 |
| 4 | 11/85A | ND- Unit 3 | Parel-Sewree | 892.23 |
| 5 6 | 11/85 11/84 | ND/CD/ Sunders Unit 4, 5,13 ND- Unit 2 | . Parel-Sewree Parel-Sewree | 842.25 856.55 |
| 7 | 11/84A | ND-Unit2 | Parel-Sewree | 856.55 |
| 8 | 10/80 | ND/CD/ SD/Sunders Unit 4,7,8,9,13 | Mazgaon | 938.50 |
| 9 | 10/79 | ND/CD- Unit 2, 6,7 | Mazgaon | 856.55 |
| 10 | 10179A | ND- Unit 3 | Mazaaon | 927.92 |
| 11 | 10178A | CD - Unit-6, 8 | Mazaaon | 851.20 |
| 12 | 10/788 | CD- Unit 8 | Mazgaon | 851 .20 |
| 13 | 3/36 | SD - Unit 9 | Princess Dock | 851 .20 |
| 14 | 3/35 | SD/Sunders - Unit 9, 10, 14 | Princess Dock | 851 .20 |
| 15 | 3/35B | SD - Unit 9, 10 | Princess Dock | 948.20 |
| 16 | 2/22 | SD- Unit 11 | Fort | 955.18 |
| 17 | 2/23 | SD/Buners Unit 9 11 , 15 | Fort | 1057.50 |
| 18 | 2/13 | SO/Sunders Unit 9, 11 , 15 | Fort | 1262.48 |
| 19 | 2/9 | SD - Unit 11 | Fort | 1057.50 |
| 20 | 2/12 | SD - Unit 12 | Fort | 1453.20 |
| 21 | 1/6A | SD/Sunders Unit 12 14 | Colaba | 1453.20 |
| 22 | 1/4 | Sunders Unit-14 | Colaba (Pilot Sunder) | 1453.20 |
| 23 | 1/3 | SD - Unit 12 | Colaba | 1453.20 |
| 24 | 1/3A | SD - Unit 12 | Colaba | 1658.00 |
| 25 | 17 /1 19 | BD - Unit 14 | Mahim | 950.00 |
| 26 | 17/116 | BO - Unit 14 | Mahim | 950.00 |
| 27 | 90/419 Pir Pau | ND· Unit 1 | Mahul | 269.10 |
NOTES:
1. The lease rent is subject to an increase @ 4% p.a. and that first such increase shall be effective from 01 October 2018.
2. The lease rentals may remain in force for a period of five years thereon .
महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ६३1 1
~iuded in the abo~e rates ~
F· Act~al qua~tum of~ent will be wor~ed out pn the tjase rent and fattor as ray be rcomm,nded by the ~- ~~1e:'.tt:;J~~~~!~~~~ ;~t~~~s~tt;:eit~~~:::~ ~~i~1
5. Above rates are not applicable for l~tout str~ctures construc~ed I owped by ¥BPT i.f P.T. ~ructures. 6. Rat~ for allqtment dfwater bodies is applicable at 5~0/o ofth~ SOR rates. , , , ; 1. Diff~rential ~rrearsi liabilities and bther dues/charges for a period from d1.10.2017 to 36 .9.2022 are calculated based on above rates.
,
. Th~se rateSI are applicable for Hom~ and Mixed (Htjme and INon-Hohle) Oc6upations. l I f
1
•
. Estfte land, of Old ~assoon Dock, ferry Wharf and Jawahar Dwee~ are ex61uded ftom the bove rates. 0. These rates are not applicable to occupations given on nominal rents to public bodies and for public 1 amE;nities. , ~ I I _ I . I • _ I 1. _I I 'I 1. Interest wo~ld be c argeablr beyon~ perm1,s1ble p~nod as per Boar:d's pohqy from time to time. I 12. Whether demande or not, rent/ compensation/ license fee for a month would have to be paid by the tenants/ lesres/ licrnsees/ occupa~ts on or before the 15t1 day of ,ach suqceeding month.I ',
1
' I I I I I " I I I I I i
5. i . i Thi;l Spe~king Order ~assed \ty thi~ Auth~rity wi:I be i~ti11:1ate~ sepa\rately knd communicated to ttie MBPT and the relevant tenants/ lessees 1n due course of time.
I
I I I I
I
I
६४ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४(Puhlishe~ in Pa~ -111 S~ction h of th~. Gazette of l~dia, E~traor)nary) • TARIFF AUTl-jORlfY FbR MAJOR P9RT~ , \ • '·: '·;, .\ ~ew D~lhi, i \ \ 1i\ Nov~mber ¾021 G.No.557
II
1,
'
I 1,
I J
. :, ',, I,
I '\ ·. ', ',,
I
• NOTIFICATIQN : : :
ase
1 i I ln:\exerc~e of thl powers conferred bt SecliOn 49 o the M~jor Port Trus~ Act, 1963 (38 ~' f 1963), the T~riff Authority fbr Major Ports hereby!disposes of th~ prop$al received from Mumbai Port Trust {MBPT) 'for incorporati~n of n~w section for ~rescrip~ion rel$tes to talculation of base rentals as o. 1.10.2012 ati··.d 1.1d:.2017 for the quinquepnial piiod 1!10.201Z to 3m9.20H and 1\10.2017 to 30.912022 riespecUvely fd.r the Port St1ucture, {PT tructu~s) for! non-h~me oicupati~nsl Home occupations1 in To"".n_ship treas tjf MBP1, on c~se to se basis in the respective ~chedule of Le rent~ls of M~PT, a$ m the :Order append~d her~to. ·• : : ':
'
'
I
'
I I
II,
II
',
' ' 'T.~. Ba.lasubrart1ania\n
,
1
1
Member (finance} ',
1
I
' I
1.
महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ६५Ta r i f f Authority f,or Majei>r Po r ts
I I I Case No. T.AMP/55/2021-MBPT I
Mumbai Rort Trust
Applicant
I
QUORUM
{i). 1 St11ri. T.S. Balasubramanian, Member ~Finance) (ii). Shri. Sunil Kumar Singh, Member (Economic)
I C ) R D 1E R
(Passed on this 1 !,t day of November 2021 )
I I I ' I I I
i
:
: I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I ' d
I I I I I I I I I I I I I (i)
The base lease rentals as on 1.10. 2012 for the for the Port Trust (PT) Structures will be anrived based on the following formula : 1
, I I I I
I I I 1 Lease ~entals as on 1.10.2012 per sqm per month: Approved Lease Rentals applicable for the zone per sqm per month+ (6% X (80% of Cost of PT structure as given in the TABLE -1A b,ased on the type of the building/structure x Percentage value after depreciation as qiven in T ABLE-;A of bafed 1on age 'Of the Building and type 1of building) I 12j. 1 1
भाग दोन---६१-९६६ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ TABLE-1A Cost of new construction as per types of construction (based on Stamp Duty Ready Reckoner, Mumbai 2012)
| Sr. No | Type of Construction Cost per Sq.Mtr(Built-up) in As on 2012 t. | |
| A) | R.C.C. Construction 17500 R.C.C. slabs, Brick wall made and plastered with cement mortar inside the wall, tiles flooring | |
| B) | Other Pukka Construction 14000 Load bearing Structure, R.C .C slab, Brick. wall plastered with cement, Kaccha or cement flooring | |
| C) | SemilHalf Pukka Construction 9000 Load bearing structure, wall made of brick or stone with mud, Shah bad floor mud or other type of flooring and construction other than slab | |
| D) | Kaccha Construction 6000 Mud wall with bricks, Mud Gilav, with roof of clay tiles/asbestos or tin |
TABLE-2A Depreciation rates of old buildings (Asper Stamp Duty Ready Reckoner, Mumbai, 2012)
| Completed Age of building in Years Value in Percent after Depreciation Pukka RCC Structures/ Other Pukka Structures | ||
| Half or Semi-Pukka Structures | ||
| 0 to 2 years. 100% | 100% | |
| Above 2 and uoto 5 Years 95% | 95% | |
| 90% Above 5 and uoto 10 Years | 85% | |
| Above 10 and upto 20 Years 80% | 75% | |
| Above 20 and uoto 30 Years 70% 60% Above 30 and uoto 40 Years | 60% 45% | |
| Above 40 and uoto 50 Years 50% | 30% | |
| Above 50 and upto 60 Years 40% | 20% | |
| Above 60 Years 30% | 15% |
1. Lease Rentals for let out structures constructed/ owned by MBPT i.e. P.T. Structures will be calculate based on the above rates by using this formula • Approved Lease Rentals applicable of the zone + 6% X (80% of Depreciated cost of PT structure based on age of the Building and type of building)f12 "
2. Type of construction and percentage of depreciation based on age of structure will be considered for calculation of PT structure rentals as given in Table-1 and Table 2 respectively
3. The lease rent is subject to an increase @ 4% p.a. and that first such increase shall be effective from 01 October 2012.
4. The annual lease rentals may remain in force for a period of five years thereon 5. Rent will be worked out on the basis of actual Built- Up Area, subject to minimum of FSI 1.00. 6. Above rates are exclusive of all Taxes (GST, Municipal Taxes, etc.), Service Charges, Penalties, and Interest etc. Same are separately payable by lessees/ tenants/ licensees, as may be applicable.
7. The rates are applicable for non -Home Occupations. 8. Differential Arrears, liabilities and other dues/charges for a period from 01 .10.2012 to 30.9.2017 are calculated based on above rates
9. These rates are applicable for Non-Home, Home and Mixed (Home and Non-Home) occupations in PT Structures.
1O. The rates are applicable to all the Expired Leases, Monthly Tenancies. Fifteen Monthly Leases and Licenses falling in the respective Ready Reckoner Zones.
11 . Estate lands of Old Sassoon Dock, Ferry Wharf and Jawahar Dweep are excluded. 12. These rates are not applicable to occupations given on nominal rents to public bodies and for public amenities.
महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ६७13. Interest would be chargeable beyond pe~missible period as per Board's policy fromi time to time. 1 14. I Whether demanded or not, rent/ compensation/ license fee for a month would have to be paid by the itenants, lessees/ licensees/ occupants ot'l or befote the 15th day of each succeeding month.
8. Calculation of base rentals as on 1.10.2017 for the Port structures (Pli structures) f(l)r non home occupations/ home occupations in township areas of MBPT.
(i). The base lease rentals as on 1.10. 2017 for the for the Port Trust (PT} Structures will be arrived based on the following formula :
Lease Rentals as on 1.10.2017 per sqm per' month= Approved Lease Rentals applicable for the zone per sqm per month + ( 6% X (80% of Cost of PT structure as given in the TABLE -1B based on the type of the building/structure x Percentage valµe afte1 depreciation as given in TABLE-28 of based1on age of the Building and type of building) 1 12) .
TABLE-1B ,
| Sr. No | Type of Construction | Cost per Sq.Mtr(Built-up) in |
| As on 2017 t. | ||
| A) | R.C.C. Construction RC.C. slabs, Brick wall made and plastered with cement mortar inside the wall, tiles floorina | 27500 |
| B) | Other Pukka Construction Load bearing Structure, R.C.C slab, Brick wall or plastered with cement, Kaccha cement flooring | 23375 |
| C) D) | Semi/Half Pukka Construction Load bearing structure. wall made of brick or stone with mud, S11ahbad floor mud or other type of floorina and construction other than slab | 16500 |
| Kaccha Construction Mud wall with bricks. Mud Gilav, with roof of clay tiles/asbestos or tin | 9625 |
TABLE ·28 1
Depreciation rates of o/d:buildings
| Completed Age of building in Years | Value in -Percent after Depreciation | |
| RCC Pukka Structures/ Other Pukka Structures | Semi- 0~ Half Pukka Structures | |
| Oto 2 years. ' | 100% | 100% |
| I 95% Above 2 and upto 5 Years | I 95% | |
| 1 Above 5 and upto 10 ¥ears 90% | I 85% | |
| Above 10 and upto 20 Years 80% | 75% | |
| Above 20 and uoto 30 Years , 70% | 60% | |
| Above 30 and upto 40 Years 60% | 45% | |
| Above 40 and upto 50 Years 50% | 30% | |
| Above 50 and uoto 60 Years 40% Above 60 Years 30% | 20% 15% | |
Notes: 1. Lease Rentals for let out structures constructed/ owned by MBPT i.e. P.T. Structures will be calculate based on the above rates by using this formula "1 Approved Lease Rentals applicable of the zone + 6% X (80% of Depreciated cost of PT structure based on age of the Building and type of b1,1ilding)Jr 2 •
2. Type of construction and percentage of:depreciation based on age of structure ' will be 'considered for calculation of PT structure rentals as given in Table-1 and Table 2 irespectively६८ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ 1 be effective frlm 01 3. The !ase re~t is sutiject to ~n increlse @ 1°/o p.a. ~nd that! first su~h incre1se shai
1
1
1
1
,
1
',
\
1
1 ,
Octo er2oq. 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
, I {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1
1
1
1
,
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1
1
,
,
,
,
,
1,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
i Structures. ' \ I ', . I I I •. I 1
1
falling ',in the respective Ready!Reckoner Zones. ; ; : I II ', 1
,
,
•
,
'
'
,
• 1 '. amenities. 1,
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 '
'
I
I I
' I I '
I I
' I I
1
1
:
:
:
•
\ 1 1 The MBPT is adyised td incorp9rate above pr~scripti9ns in the respective Schedu~ of 5. 1 Rates for h~me an~ non h?me ocpupatior for th~ period from on . 10.20~210 30.09.20'17 and ~1 .10.2P17 to 30.9.202~ approved by this Authority. , : 1
1
:
I
' I I ', ' \ I ', ' II II ' 11
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 The Spe~king ~rder passed·:by thi~ Authbrity will be intimate~ sep~rately ~nd 1
municated to the MBRT and the relevant te111ants/ l~ssees In due course bf timeJ ' I
' I I
I I I I I
' I I I I I, I
I I
I
'
II
I I I I I ' I I I I ' ' I • I I 1
,
T.S. Balasubraniania'1 1 Member {Finan~) \
- Estate, lands of Old S~ssoon Oock, Ferry Whart and J9wahar Dweep are exclu~ed. i : : 12. Thes~:.rates ,re not ~pplica~le to occupatiops give~ on nolninat rents to ~ublic bbdies aryd for public , 13. : tntere~t would Pe char~eable oeyond ~ermissi~le period as pe(> Board'~ policy fyom time to time. \ 14. · •. Wheth~r ~em~nded or, not, renV comp,nsation( licenseifee for a month w~uld h,ve to b~ paid by the ten~nts/ : lessee~/ hcens~es/ oc~upants on or b~ore the! 15th day of each succee~mg mo~th. : 6. {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}} com ↩
I I I I I I I Iमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ६९ (Published in Part -111 Section 4 of the Gazette of India, Extraordinary) TARIFF AUTHORITY FOR MAJOR PORTS
G.No. 558
12 November 2021
New Delhi,
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 49 of the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 (38 of 1963), the Tariff Authority for Major Ports hereby disposes of the proposal received from Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) for fixation of Schedule of Rates for way leave/ special way leave fees of MBPT Trestle i.e. Old Pir Pau (OPP), First Chemical Berth (FCB) and Second Chemical Berth (SCB) for the period from 01 .10.2012 to 30.09.2017 and 01.10.2017 to 30.09.2022, as in the Order appended hereto.
'.T.S. Balasubramanian
,
Member (Finance)
भाग दोन---६१-१०७० महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ · Ta 1
Au1hotity l-ror i
MaJor Ports
1
, 1 1 Ca~e No. ,TAMPl59/202~ -MBPT'
1
·. AppliGant M~mbai rort T~ ust
1
I I
I
, . Balasµbramanian, Member (Finance)
0
1 -
(i ).\ (ii). I I I
'
1_
', Shri. T.S 1 shri. Sunil Kumar Singh, Mernber (Etnomi(j;) I I I I I . , I I I . , , , C> DE r .-... . 1 i \ \ (P,assed on this 1st day "f November 2:021) 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
' I
' I I I i I I
, , T1.his caJ.e relates to a propos~I recei~ed frorr Mumtpai Port':Trust (:MBPT}1
1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
vide it~ letter dat~d 14 October 2021 seeking approval for fixation of Schedule ofl Rates Jor way leave ✓ speci~I way leawe fees1of MBF:'T Tre~tle i.e. Pld PirPau (QPP), F)rst Chemical EBerth (FCB} arid Second Chemical Berth (SCB) for the perio'd from '01.10.?012 to 30.09.2017 and 01.10.2017 to 30.09.2022~. :.
I I I
I ' I 1
1
I
'
I
I I I \ T~e proposal o~ MBP~, is basbd on the amJnded Lland Pdlicy Guideline~, 201~. The 2. \1 proposal was take'n on consultation witM_ the relevant users/ t,nants/ ';lessee$. User~/ User1 organi~ation hav¢ mad~ their ~ubmis~ions during the proc~eding \of the pase. lfhe MBPT ha,s resp~>nded to the comments of user~/ user$ organizations. ; I
'
I
I I I,
I ' I I I
0
ith refe~ence t~ the to~ality of information cdllected\during '.the prdcessing of the 1,case 3. i . \ W and based ~n a co)lective :applidtion of mind, this Autl'lority has pass.ed a s~eakin~ Order1 the p.ropos9I filed 9Y the MBPT f0r fixation of S~hedul~of Rates for way leave / spacial way leave', fees of MBPT Trestle i.~. Old Pir Pau (OPP), first C~emical Berth {f CB) ar,d SeC9nd Chemical Berth (SCB) for the perid,d from l,01 .10.2012 to,30.09.2017 and 01 .1 .2017 to 30.09.2022 , 1 1 I I
'
'
I I I I I I ' I I I ' I I I ' ; i I 4. ·, This Authprity d→sires that thei followihg War leave Schedule for,MBPT 1 prescrbing Schedule of; way leave charges of MBPT Trestle i.e. 61d Pir fau {OfP), First Chemical Berth (FCB) and 9econd1 Chemi:cal -~e~h ~SC!3) fa'. _t~e perib~ fro~ 01.101.2012 to _30.0Q.2017 and 01 l10.201\.7 to 30.09.2012 !lnay be.notified w1tho1i1t wa,tn[lg for n:otIficat11;>n of tt,:e Spea1kmg O~der: ' 1
' '
\ · I I
I I I I I I
' ' " i i i I ' I I II
0
PIR P~U
SCHEDUL~ OF ~AY LEjAVE C
;fARG~S FO~ THE PIPELINES L~ID'ON \TRES~LE AT
1 (i). ' Special Way Leave rates for the pipelines: laid ~n TreJtle at J>ir Paµ for ~he pe~iod {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I
| I I i i Period I I I I ' I I I I I I \ I I I I \ ' 01.1-0.2012 1to 30.09.201~ | Rate per sq m./month tpr Rate per lq m./month for 30(1) 300 1 mm dia pipeline la,id mm 1 1dia pi eline taid at :OId Pir 1 First Chemica( at ' Second Chemical Pau I Jetty ! & I I Berth I Befih I I I I I ' f. I ! : I ,. I N.A, 182.87 I |
| I 01.10.2013 to 30.Q9.2014 1. 01. H>.2014\to 30.0.9.2019 01.10 .2015~0 30.09.2016, 01.10.2016 1tO 30.013.2017: | ' I I ' I \ N.A! 190.19 I I I , I I 230 .64 , 1971.79 I I I 239.87 : 205.71 ' |
| I I I , M9.60, \ i 213l93 |
I I
I
I
Li (ii).
e peri d
I I I I I I I I I I 1 Special Way leav~ rates for the pip~lines ~aid o" Trestle at P,ir Pau 1
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1 01.10.2017t 30.091 2022 I · 1
for tn 1 I ! 1 I
I, Rate per sq m./month for 300 ' Rate ' per sq m./mqnth tor 1 mm dia pipeline laid at Old Pir \ 300 Tm dia pipeline laid
I Pau JJetty & First Chemical at 1Secon,~ Cf,1emical , Berth 1
I I lमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ७१ 22.49 259.44 31.39 1269.81 40.65 1280.6d 50.27 · 291.83 260.28 I 303.5 .
Notes: I I I 1. bove rates ar~ exclusive of a!l Taxe~ (GST, raxes,~tc.}, S~rvice Charge~.' Penalties,
,
I and Interest etc. Same: are seJ!>aratelY! payable by le sees, ~s may ~e applicable. , · i 1
· I I I
2! The Special Way Leave fee for Optica,I Fiber Cable w~ill be a~plicabf~· as per the abpve
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} . . I I I I
I r~tes bu, taking I the width subj~ct to a minimu,m of h If a me er for c mputa~ion.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
3 !he rat~ indicated in the table is for 300 mm extem,1 dia oj pipeline and tpe rate Fill iAcrease proporrionately for pipelines bf high~r dia. I ; : I I , · I I I 1
I
4. The way leave ee for the loop' length of the pipeline on tres~le will 9e charQed at 60%
I I or the rate applicable fdr the way leave fee onl trestle.I
I I I ' I I I I I
I s. 1 T~e above rates would be the SoR for the pipelines/rriarine IQad~ng_ 9rm~ prjsently lrid on trestl, and tq-m the reserve! rate for grant of way l~ave perm1ss1ohs in f~ure.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} I I I I I I
I
6. In the event of failure 9f achieve Minimum Guarantee Thr9ughpu~ {MGT), the user smould compensate the, port by payingi additi~nal wharf agei chargeis for the shortfall qtiJantity. i ' I I I I
Of her aspects related t6 Right bf Way 'permis~ion wil~ be de,lt with\as per the ext~nt
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
Land Policy Guidelines. 1
8. I w,ay Leaye/ Spacial Way Leavb fee, Jhether\deman~ed or hot, sh~II be paid by t~e lessees/ tenants/ licensees on br bef~te the 15th day of each month succeeding that
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} for which Way L~ave / 9pecial Way Leave fee lis due. I I I 1
,
The formwla for dalculatibn of way leave fee orl trestle 1is as follows:
I 9. I
1
·
;
•
\
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
w :ay Lea~e fee pbr sqm lper mohth = 1 Length of pipelin~ X (Exliernal dia inc1u6ing insulation) X rate 'applicable
1
'
,
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I I '
• l 300 mm I I I 1
I 10.1
effected from 1.1?.2013.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I I
Way leave fees will inciease b 4% e~ery O~tober. hrst sJch 4% 'increase will be I ' . I I I I 11. The rate applicable for loop length of pip'eline laid on trestle wil be taken at 60% of way I
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
I •
I I I I ' I I' {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
;
:
1
II
I I I I
1
,
!l.
{{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}}
1
- demand notice. If the p~rty fail$ to pay as perihe derpand / jnvoice !Within 3 montHs I I frorln the rJceipt of deman~ notice, I invoice, inter st will ~e appliq:able a~ 18% per annum I I as per existing policy or as may be decided by oard from time to time. , The Speaking otder p~ssed ~y this !Authority will {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1}}}}be intimated 'separately antl sees in due co~rse of~ime. 5. comr1nunicated to the MBPf and the relevant tenants/ les I • I I I I T.s.' Balcisubtama1nian 1 1ember {Financ;:e) ↩
भाग दोन---६१-१०अ७२ महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ry)
(Published in Part - Ill Section 4 of the Gazette of In~, Extr~rdina I 1AR1fF Af,JTHc;>Rll)' FdlR MfJo~ POrTs I
I
' 12 November 2021
I I I
N~wDel~i. I
I NgTIF~CArTIOIN
I I I I
I I I I . I I I I I I I I I
- (38 dt 1963)\ the Ta iff Aut ority f~~ Major Ports hereby disposeslof the propos~I received froni Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) or fixat on of Schedule of Rates (SOR) and revision of rent/ comRensatiqn for th1e periop 01 .19.2012 to 30.09.2017 (12 Zones) and l01.10.2017 to G0.09.2022 (09 Zones) for let 1out Ian~ fallin~ under1various Ready Reckoner Zones, as In the drder appended hereto. I T.SJ Balasubram~nian\ , I I Member (Fihance)l ↩
I I I I I Iमहाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ७३
Tariff Authority for Major Ports
Case No. TAMP/60/2021-MBPT
Mumbai Port Trust
Applicant
QUORUM
(i). Shri. T .S. Balasubramanian, Member (Finance)
(ii). Shri. Sunil Kumar Singh, Member (Economic)
ORDER
(Passed on this 01 st day of November 2021)
This case relates to a proposal received from Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) vide its letter dated 13 October 2021 received from the Mumbai Port Trust (MBPT) for fixation of Schedule of Rates (SOR) and revision of rent/ compensation for the period 01 .10.2012 to 30.09.2017 (12 Zones) and 01.10.2017 to 30.09.2022 (09 Zones) for let out land falling under various Ready Reckoner Zones.
2. The proposal of MBPT is based on the amended Land Policy Guidelines, 2015. The proposal was taken on consultation with the relevant users/ tenants/ lessees. Many comments were received from the tenants/ lessees. The MBPT has responded to the comments of the tenants/ lessees.
3. With reference to the totality of information collected during the processing of the case and based on a collective application of mind, this Authority has passed a speaking Order disposing of the proposal filed by the MBPT for fixation of Schedule of Rates (SOR) and revision of rent / compensation for the period 01 .10.2012 to 30.09.2017 (12 Zones) and 01 .10.2017 to 30.09.2022 (09 Zones) for let out land falling under various Ready Reckoner Zones .
4. This Authority desires that the following Rent Schedule for MBPT prescribing Lease rentals Lease rentals in respect of 12 RR Zones for the period 01 .10.2012 to 30.09.2017 and 9 RR Zones for the period 01 .10.2017 to 30.09.2022 for let out land falling for non home occupation under various RR Zones:
"
A. Schedule of Rates for the period from 01.10.2012 to 30.09.2017 for Non-Home Occupations
| Sr. No. 1 | RR Zone 11/84A | Unit 2 | Description as per Ready Reckoner On East Rafi Ahmad Kidwai Marg, on West T.Jeevraj Road upto P.Sawant Chowk on North Acharya Daunde Marg(King Edward Road) tranqular portion of all the land. | Rentals per sqm per month for FSI 1.00 (f .) 200.00 |
| 2 | 11/848 | 2 | Rafi Ahmed Kidwai Marg and Harbour railway line, narrow strip portion of land | 241 .00 |
| 3 | 11 /84E | 2 | Portion in between on East Harbour Railway line and on West Sewri Cross Road | 291 .00 |
| 4 | 7/64 | 12 | On west side Central Portion of Khamballa Hill having vertical slope on East side Javji Dadaji Marg (Tardeo Road) from Nana Chowk to Hajl Ali Chowk on North Haji Ali Chowk and on South August Kranti Marg. All Portion surrounded by these Roads. | 655.00 |
| 5 | 10/78A | 8 | On West Shivdas champsi Marg and Dr. Mascrenas Road, on East BPT Railway line, on North Sant Savtamali Marg and on South | 175.00 |
| 3/ SB 6 9 | I I 7166 112 | Jijabh i Mulji R,athod M rg. All t)'le porti n 1 •·urroun ed. : , 23 .00 West, South an East ~irision bOundary pn 120p.00 I North, August Kranti Marg and.Pandita, Ramabai Mar . All the ortion s rround d. | ||
| 8j I | I 1(4 , 14 | Onavy Nagar ortion apd cola 33~.00 t~ards ~outh of r. Hom1 Bhabh Road Navy Nagar, Tata Institute 9f Fund9mental ; 1 esearch and C laba Pd.int | ||
| 10 11, 12: | 13/97 13 15/ 05 11 I Only T£wnship 2/34 i Areas xcludingJ Custom ond are'as 3/36A | toward West S smira Road , O East and 322.00 ' South ward boLindary and on N?rth Worli Gaothan Bo nda , ' I 1).11 the pr perties Iof Salt an Division except 170.00 ' ' Zone No. 15/105A , 308.00 Lokmany Tilak Marg pa from Pt1ule Mar et ' . I to P.IJ'Mello howk , , | ||
| Lokmanya Tilak Marg on East side ;of PD M llo Ie I Road I |
NOTES: ' : ' : ' I
I . I '. I I 1 · The I lease re.nt is sul>ject to ~n increJse@ 4°~ p.a. a~I d that fifst such :increas(f shall be effecti\re from 01
I, , , , . , , , , I Octdber201(3. I 2. The '.lease re'ntals may remain in force for a p~riod of ;ve yeaf\5 there~. i ' i : , i · Actual quan~m of Rent will be work~d out ol'.) the ba e rent ,1nd fact r as may be recommenqed by the I committee appointed for the purpose !of appli~:ability o, FSI. , , ,
, ' I I I , . , {{^{{FOOTNOTE 1 }}}} B. s chedul~ of R~,tes for,1 the period frqm 01.10.2017 ~o 30.09.2022 for non Home: Occurlation. ; I ' I I I I I '1 '.
| L Un t I 11 ! 11 11 1' 2 ' 14 12 | I I I I I Oe~criplion as per 1Ready Reckon1r ' ' I I I Anik I I I I Salt Pan I Matunoa I I Parel-Sewree I I I I I Worli I I MalbarHill | 1 Rentals per sf m er month for SI 1p ,1.00 , . m 2$9.00 i ; ; 289.00 ' I 578.00 8S7.oo I 568.00 1288.00 |
| 1~ 1~ 1 | I I I Malbar Hill I i ! Colaba ! Karania | 1691.00 I I 1658.00 I I 57.00 |
| I Sr. 1 No. | L I RR Un I 11 e'.one ! |
| I 1 | 11 96/436 |
| 12 | 11 15/105 |
| , 3 14 15 · 6 I 7 18 ' 9 | 16/110 1' 2 ' 11/84E 14 13/97 7/64 12 17/66 1~ 1~ i 1/6 Karania 1 |
I I I I I
I i I I I I I I I I I
The lease rentals may lremain in force ~or a per/od offivb years thereon.: ! : , :
2. I
3.
I
4. I 5. '
I
I I I I I I I I ! I
महाराष्ट्र शासन राजपत्र असाधारण भाग दोन, एप्रिल २८, २०२२/वैशाख ८, शके १९४४ ७५6. Rate for allotment of water bodies is applicable at 50% of the SOR rates. 7. Differential Arrears, liabilities and other dues/charges for a period from 01 .10.2017 to 30.9.2022 are calculated based on above rates.
8. The applicable MCGM cesses will be billed separately over and above the SOR rates for monthly tenants and licenses for less than 1 year
9. These rates are not applicable to occupations given on nominal rents to public bodies and for public amenities.
10. Interest would l;>e chargeable beyond permissible period as per Board's policy from time to time. 11. Whether demanded or not, rent/ compensation/ license fee for a month would have to be paid by the tenants/ lessees/ licensees/ occupants on or before the 15th day of each succeeding month. ,, 5. The Speaking Order passed by this Authority will be intimated separately and communicated to the MBPT and the relevant tenants/ lessees in due course of time.
Mumbai,
T. S. BALASUBRAMANIAN, dated 28th April 2022. Member (Finance).
SMT. P. M. DABHOLKAR,
The Financial Advisor and Chief Accounts Officer.
ON BEHALF OF GOVERNMENT PRINTING, STATIONERY AND PUBLICATION, PRINTED AND PUBLISHED BY DIRECTOR, RUPENDRA DINESH MORE, PRINTED AT GOVERNMENT CENTRAL PRESS, 21-A, NETAJI SUBHASH ROAD, CHARNI ROAD, MUMBAI 400 004 AND PUBLISHEDAT DIRECTORATE OF GOVERNMENT PRINTING, STATIONERY AND PUBLICATIONS, 21-A, NETAJI SUBHASH ROAD, CHARNI ROAD,MUMBAI 400 004. EDITOR : DIRECTOR, RUPENDRA DINESH MORE.